Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take nephew out for the day?

286 replies

iz92 · 13/10/2022 12:00

Nephew is 15, y11, he hasn't done a full week at school this academic year with having one day off a week or attending one day and having the rest of the week off, he attended 4 days last week, had the Friday off and has so far had the whole of this week off, his parents don't seem to care, in their defence he did skip school Monday and Tuesday but yesterday he said he didn't want to go for no particular reason, and the same today. When he doesn't go he just stays in bed on his devices (which I wouldn't allow but I'm not his parent!).

Today, I'm going to take DD to a trampoline park, as she only attends nursery a few days a week and she's off today, his mum has asked if I can take him along as he'd enjoy it, I've said no as he should be at school and that'd be rewarding him for not attending and its half term soon so he can go then. BIL spoke to DH and DH has said I'm BU as I know nephew struggles with his anxiety which is probably why he isn't going, I disagree as yes I understand he has anxiety but I think he isn't going as he finds staying at home more fun.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Worklessplaymore · 26/12/2022 17:55

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 19/11/2022 17:27

So many extreme black and white responses on this thread. As a teacher I’ve had kids refuse school with genuine anxiety/MH problems and the parents have been distraught and tried everything etc. I feel for them as it must be stressful beyond belief. I’ve also had kids refuse school who want to play on devices all day and the parents CBA arguing. Both things can be true. None of us know which one OPs nephew is 🤷🏻‍♀️

^^. Totally this! I suppose the op has a better idea than most of us what causes the lad's anxiety, but even a close family member doesn't know everything that does on in a relative's home.

And remember, many teens are still recovering from the effects of lockdown when their lives were interrupted, which has made everything more difficult.

I don't think his parents should have put you in this position op, but in your shoes, I would be taking your nephew out, outside of school hours, and trying to be a bit of an ally.

Notimeforaname · 02/12/2022 23:30

I would have refused too.

I understand many people struggle with anxiety but it does no good to just let them choose the fun bits of life that give them no anxiety and then refuse to engage with the rest. That only fuels it.

SammyScrounge · 02/12/2022 23:19

After he has managed to meet a target, say two half days at school in a week. The target increases gradually. It works.

SammyScrounge · 02/12/2022 23:17

JennyForeigner2 · 13/10/2022 12:12

There’s nothing ignorant about not taking a truant to a trampoline park.

There’s quite a lot of ignorance in thinking that someone not attending school,should be taken out for treats like this.

Absolutely right. The treat should be given to the boy

BabyDriversMummy · 02/12/2022 22:02

Is he getting any formal/ professional help for his anxiety?

Or is he just spoiled and indulged?

My brother truanted (with my parents’ blessing) for the last two years of school.

He’s now 55. Still living off the Bank of Mum & Dad. Never learned to drive. Never held down a job for very long.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 19/11/2022 17:27

So many extreme black and white responses on this thread. As a teacher I’ve had kids refuse school with genuine anxiety/MH problems and the parents have been distraught and tried everything etc. I feel for them as it must be stressful beyond belief. I’ve also had kids refuse school who want to play on devices all day and the parents CBA arguing. Both things can be true. None of us know which one OPs nephew is 🤷🏻‍♀️

Poppinjay · 18/11/2022 16:42

Stompythedinosaur · 17/11/2022 15:25

I work in children's mental health, and have done lots of work with to teens with anxiety. I absolutely wouldn't have taken him to a fun activity when he should be in school. Anxiety is a horrible disorder, but let's not encourage non-attendance by providing secondary gains to being off.

Thank goodness there are more enlightened staff working at our local CAMHS who understand the benefits of providing children with activities that support wellbeing and self-esteem and how that contributes to their resilience and ability to get into school when it is meeting their needs.

sue20 · 18/11/2022 14:04

You are not BU. You could even at a stretch be picked up on why you have a school age child with you during school time eg if there was an accident.

A child’s anxiety issues can’t be dealt with by colluding with them - it’s a parental responsibility that he is not falling behind on social and educational development. Hopefully this issue is being dealt with by the school and their social welfare system. So whether it’s laziness or anxiety it’s a problem which needs proper address not taking them to the park!

Stompythedinosaur · 17/11/2022 15:25

I work in children's mental health, and have done lots of work with to teens with anxiety. I absolutely wouldn't have taken him to a fun activity when he should be in school. Anxiety is a horrible disorder, but let's not encourage non-attendance by providing secondary gains to being off.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 15:21

@Pinkdelight3 I asked a poster who had recent experience as we have had a look around and its not so easy to find it on the nhs or get the diagnosis

JudgeJ · 17/11/2022 12:14

Wayk · 13/10/2022 12:04

Anxiety is crippling, please offer support to the young man.

Anxiety or terminal laziness? People are so quick to assign labels as excuses. Personally I wouldn't be taking his, if he does have anxiety I wouldn't want the responsibility and if he doesn't then I would be adding to the parents' neglect.

Coolcreature · 16/11/2022 19:50

Im about to put my 10year old who has anxiety, to bed. I can guarantee I'll be there for at least 30minutes and a panic attack about going to school tomorrow, even though she's on half days. She hasn't done a full week for way over a month. I still take her places. I'm not going to punish her!

Kennykenkencat · 16/11/2022 19:21

CatchersAndDreams · 13/10/2022 12:08

Support isn't taking him to a trampoline park when not at school. Support would be taking him to a trampoline park after he managed a few weeks of full attendance.

Why are his parents just letting him stay in bed all day? If I was dealing with school refusal my dc would be up at the same time, chores, garden work, you name it they'd have to do it. Staying at home wouldn't be lying in bed all day on a device.

I think this is where you lack understanding about school refusal

Being up at the same time, chores, garden work, you name it they'd have to do it is a reward not a threat,

Personally I think I should have left school at 14. I really wanted to leave. I was made to stay and for the extra 2 years I was there I managed 0 qualifications, got more and more depressed. It took me years to recover and I think I really lost all hope for the future.
I would have loved doing gardening and chores instead of sitting in a classroom bored out of my mind waiting for 2 year to slowly tick by

zingally · 16/10/2022 12:07

I wouldn't have taken him either.

School refusal is a complicated issue, but "rewarding" it with a trip to a trampoline place probably isn't the answer either.

Also, I can't think of a single 15 yo who would find a trip to a trampoline place with a nursery age, opposite gender kid, an enticing prospect...

For all those saying OP should be more sympathetic. This isn't her problem to solve.

Pinkdelight3 · 16/10/2022 11:31

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 09:10

@TigerRag sorry to ask but how do you go about getting a diagnosis when older ?
My ds19 i have always had some feeling he may but never looked at when he was younger or taken notice off when I brought it up , he is now saying him self he also thinks he may be autistic but have no idea how we go about finding out as an adult

Not being facetious, but there's no reason to have no idea how to find something out today when you can google it. There's a wealth of info out there, from the official lines on the NHS website to private services, to people's personal stories and news articles and FAQs. Even searching on Mumsnet will pull up many threads on how best to go about it. We looked into it and now my son has his diagnosis and it's been very helpful. Have a read around and get the ball rolling.

KennAdams · 14/10/2022 11:50

Some absolute shit being spouted on this thread. Yanbu not to take him of you don't want to OP. You don't have to.

My daughter suffers from anxiety surrounding emetophobia. Some days she will not move if she feels sick. She will not eat or drink. Last week I had to try and physically force her to school all it did was upset us both and made me feel like the shittest mum.

I think we need to look at individual situations. A typical school environment will not be the best thing for some children. All our children are different hey we have such a blanket one size fits all approach to education.

And I'm laughing at people suggesting CAHMS. Good luck with that. My daughter struggles as mentioned above but apparently it's not within their mental health criteria.

It's really not as simple as forcing them to go or making them do chores from 7 in the morning as punishment for not being able to go. Oh to be THAT naive.

alotoftutus · 14/10/2022 11:29

I don't think you are being unreasonable for not taking him, although if you are concerned he stays in bed all day on screens then you had the opportunity to change that for a day and chose not to, so not sure that puts you in a strong position to judge.

It is clear you have no understanding of school refusal and anxiety in teenagers. Kids are suffering and killing themselves over these things. Judge less. It's not as easy as you seem to think it is.

I recommend telling his parents to join the Facebook group not fine in school. Perhaps you could also join to educate yourself and get more understanding about what your family are actually going through and the little support that is actually available in schools.

Fancylike · 14/10/2022 09:58

TigerRag · 14/10/2022 07:57

I was diagnosed as Autistic when I was 23. Does this mean my needs were any less valid the day before? There are certain things that are so difficult to diagnose as well. (I've been waiting for a proper diagnosis since I was 5 months old; I'm now 33 and no closer to an answer) Does that make my needs any less valid than my diagnosed medical conditions?

Were you telling people you were autistic before being diagnosed?
Did you decide you were autistic and then refuse to see a doctor or specialist ever to seek assistance?
Did you make demands on other people, saying it was because you had self diagnosed as autistic?

Self-diagnosing or identifying into a condition while refusing a medical professional’s assessment is vastly different to being diagnosed.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 14/10/2022 09:26

around here, you have to be actively psychotic or suicidal to see CAHMS and several referrals have all been refused saying "He doesn't meet the criteria".

Yep. First off apparently they tend to refuse anyone waiting for ASD assessment. And secondly they don't do anxiety.

I've heard some awful things about people trying to access CAMHS as I work for a mental health charity - sometimes suicidal, including with actual attempts, isn't enough.

I've been trying to get DS help since February, which was months before the school refusal started. I am furious that the only referral accepted was the ND Pathway (with 26 month waiting list), and all the rest were refused. Timely help and support could have prevented the school refusal, but nobody would do anything until it reached that point - and it didn't come out of nowhere, it was a very foreseeable outcome.

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 09:10

@TigerRag sorry to ask but how do you go about getting a diagnosis when older ?
My ds19 i have always had some feeling he may but never looked at when he was younger or taken notice off when I brought it up , he is now saying him self he also thinks he may be autistic but have no idea how we go about finding out as an adult

TigerRag · 14/10/2022 07:57

Fancylike · 13/10/2022 21:16

Erm, it’s absolutely less valid.
It’s gross to equate a real diagnosis with someone saying they feel anxious, don’t want to do any school work but it’s somehow not enough of an issue to see the GP for help. Statements like yours are why actually valid mental health issues aren’t taken seriously.

I was diagnosed as Autistic when I was 23. Does this mean my needs were any less valid the day before? There are certain things that are so difficult to diagnose as well. (I've been waiting for a proper diagnosis since I was 5 months old; I'm now 33 and no closer to an answer) Does that make my needs any less valid than my diagnosed medical conditions?

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 14/10/2022 07:51

@Jadebanditchillipepper I could have written your post and I identify with everything you say.

worriedatthistime · 14/10/2022 06:26

I think this post shows how shockingly bad our mental health provisions is for kids and how we have little alternatives than main stream school
I have a friend who dd refused school last two years primary it wad really hard them getting her in
She started secondary and they handled it very differently the school and she had a much better experience and she praised the school so much so it seems some schools are set up better than others and as usual a bit of a postcode lottery
With covid on top MH issues in kids is likely to be higher so we really need more funding so any kid that needs help gets that help and early on

NoYouSirName · 14/10/2022 00:16

budgiegirl exactly. Some people just don’t get it.

I’m lazy and failing my child? Ok. I’m driving in and out to and from school, have had endless time off work, have taken her to a private specialist that’s a two hour drive away… spend hours in meetings, facilitate just about anything that will help her a tiny bit… but ok, I am lazy because she has her phone 🤦‍♀️

NoYouSirName · 14/10/2022 00:13

CatchersAndDreams

why is my dd not doing school work at home? Because she isn’t well enough. Because adults who are off wirk for mental health reasons don’t get asked to work from home. Because she’s recovering from the huge amount that going into school takes out of her.

Why do I let her on tech?
Because she isn’t being punished. She has accessed some school work online. She is isolated and tech helps her maintain social contact. Because she is using the headspace app and mindfulness podcasts. Because she has the kindle app and is reading… mainly because she isn’t being punished for being ill, or having her life made more shitty than it already is. Hope this helps.