Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants to rent our house out and I don't

166 replies

inappickle · 13/10/2022 10:39

Really clashing with my husband about this and we just have such different opinions I’m not sure what to do. Financially we’re ok, he makes out it’s very doom and gloom and we do have a big mortgage but we earn £68k between us and I’m only working 3 days a week, we have an expensive car (£300 a month) and we don’t budget or skip on luxuries so we do have ways in which we could cut back, as well as extra earning potential if I was too go back full time if needed. We have a young child who has been in an expensive private nursery and another baby due soon.

My husband has an opportunity for us to live at his work, it’s secure employment and the accommodation is nice (nowhere near as nice as our current house) and in a nice area I will give it that we wouldn’t need to drive as much and would be walking distance to kids school etc. He is desperate to do so, it’ll cost us half the price of our mortgage inclusive of bills and he wants to live there and rent our house out. He says it’ll pay for our retirement and set us for life. I hate the idea of someone else living in my house, we designed it ourselves and it’s my home. I hate the idea of living somewhere that isn’t ours again. I hate the idea of living where he works so he never switches off. This is our family home we worked so hard to build and I don’t want to leave. He also talks about renting it out at what he could realistically get for it but it’s more than our mortgage and I feel like it’s just being part of the problem and ripping off people that need housing.

I want to enjoy our lives now, but he’s so set on sorting ourselves out ‘for life’ and that our retirement would be sorted we’d be able to travel and save up loads in the mean time and it all just seems too far fetched and at too big a cost

Who’s right here? Am I being too attached to the house and possibly missing a good opportunity or is he just getting caught up in this idea that being a private landlord will set him for life when it isn’t realistically that straightforward

OP posts:
TimetoGoTed · 13/10/2022 13:43

I think you should get him to create a detailed spreadsheet showing all the numbers for a set period - say until your DC leave primary. (Some assumptions will need to be made re mortgage repayments).

Get him to factor in everything including:
-any investment you'd need to make to your mortgage company to convert your current mortgage to a BTL one
-cost of readying your property for tenants (EPC, updating lighting to meet safety regs, etc)

  • the annual cost of tax on your rental income
  • monthly fees to lettings agent and sign-up fees
  • new monthly outgoings at new home

Also get him to factor in any void periods.

If after that the bottom line looks promising and would make a genuine difference to your future stability then I'd consider it.

Getoff · 13/10/2022 13:42

Whistlesandbell · 13/10/2022 11:24

OP how much profit do you think you’d make per year from renting out your current house once you’ve subtracted tax, converting your mortgage to a buy to let mortgage or whatever it is that needs doing regarding the mortgage, minus the right insurance, gas checks etc etc?

I don't think profit is actually the main benefit of keeping the house. Knowing you will own a house when he leaves the job is the big benefit. You avoid the risk that goes with being out of the property market.

Scottishskifun · 13/10/2022 13:41

inappickle · 13/10/2022 10:49

School is only a 4 minute drive with easy parking so it's not a massive draw to me. To be honest a 15/20 min walk sounds worse than a 4 min drive especially when it's raining.

He's always harped on about being a landlord since I met him, he says it's a free pension and I've always disagreed and not liked the idea. This house being available cheap and bills inclusive has just set him off again and he's adamant it's the best option

Has he looked at what it will cost to get out of your current mortgage and switch to a buy to owt one which is often significantly higher?
You can't just start renting the property without the correct mortgage, any insurance you had would be invalid, he also needs to register with a proper deposit protection scheme, gain gas certs, check if it needs doors changing, have interlinked smoke alarm system etc.

It sounds like he thinks it's a magic bullet when reality these things cost a lot of money and very few landlords cover their costs for the first few years!

OneFootintheRave · 13/10/2022 13:38

Paq · 13/10/2022 10:47

Sorry, I've just seen the cost is half your mortgage. TBH I would still do it for the ability to walk to school.

Yep. Me too. You could make it really nice and agree to redecorate your own home when the tenants move out.

When you are young, it's so easy to see retirement as forever away. It's really not.

Sirius3030 · 13/10/2022 13:38

Fantastic opportunity. I’d take it in a heartbeat. Go for it!

Floweryflora · 13/10/2022 13:37

Oh some of these stories, we were quids in on ours and we used an agency to manage it. I suspect it depends on the standard of your house, new boiler blown windows is usually due to age and poor maintenance.

MaChienEstUnDick · 13/10/2022 13:35

I don't hate the idea, but I don't think it will generate nearly as much money as he thinks it's going to.

You have to pay rent, so half the house income goes towards rent.
You then have upfront costs - fire alarms, fire safety checks, potentially swapping out some furniture, potentially storage for some of your bits and pieces.
You've got wear and tear to cover.
You have to pay tax on 90% of the income - for me personally, that usually pushes me into another tax bracket, so that's worth checking very carefully.
You will need to change your mortgage to BTL which is usually a higher interest rate.
Repairs etc have to be done and done right away, you can't 'make do' like you would in your own house.
Insurance is very necessary and not worth skimping on!

And that's before you factor in the risks: what if you can't let it, what if your tenant defaults? Every day there's no rent coming in from your house, you're still paying rent on the work house...

That's not to say don't do it, but it's not going to be a cash cow that sets you up for the future...

HeddaGarbled · 13/10/2022 13:34

This is just the age old money versus happiness argument. Your husband’s priority is money and yours is happiness. I’m sure there’s research that shows that, over a certain amount, more money doesn’t make you any happier. Maybe try and find something like that and show it to him.

DottieGinger · 13/10/2022 13:33

I agree with your husband on this, but financial security and saving for the future is high priority for me.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/10/2022 13:32

I’m a landlord op. It sounds all great on paper. In reality, you’ll probably not see that much of a difference financially when you’ve paid the extra tax and on costs, which a number of people have mentioned - set up costs including gas / electricity checks, ongoing agency fees, EPC, insurance, potential increase in mortgage rate etc.

There is no way in earth I would rent out my house, which has been lovingly remodelled for the short term as we could lose far more than we would gain. Especially true with problem tenants and there are very few people, who will look after your home as well as you. I would perhaps do it for a decade as a minimum I could return with the mindset that I may have to replace the kitchen, bathrooms, floor coverings etc. Then you’d have to look how much all of that would cost to replace and you may well find yourselves at break even.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 13/10/2022 13:32

Discovereads · 13/10/2022 10:48

Why don’t you give it a trial run? Live at the work accommodation for a year and then decide from there if you want to stay or want to move back to your family home.

You can get tenants in and with 60days notice evict them at any time so long as they have been in the house for 6mos.

Even if you do like it and want to stay. It doesn’t have to be “forever” - you could agree to do it for 5yrs until the new baby starts school. It will put you ahead for retirement and suchlike. You would have more options. You could pay down the mortgage faster. You could save for DC Uni costs. You could have a private pension as you’re working PT.

It doesn’t have to be all or nothing.

Before giving advice which is going to affect someones life, you may want to do a bit of research.

TheLoupGarou · 13/10/2022 13:32

I would do this for a set period of time - say 5 years and with the aim of overpaying or paying off the mortgage on the house. Especially if it would set you up financially and mean you can stay part time while your kids are small if that's what you want.

gogohmm · 13/10/2022 13:29

I would go for it. If you can at least do it until the kids are out of childcare and you can go full time. I would check though if you can decorate the rental, that makes a difference

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 13:27

YerAWizardHarry · 13/10/2022 13:24

Myself and DP early similar (actually slightly more) our mortgage is £450 a month and we don’t have any cars on finance and we are absolutely shitting it still… if we had a way to take it another income like renting a house we 100% would

Could you afford all the new upgrades to make your home lettable though?

YerAWizardHarry · 13/10/2022 13:24

Myself and DP early similar (actually slightly more) our mortgage is £450 a month and we don’t have any cars on finance and we are absolutely shitting it still… if we had a way to take it another income like renting a house we 100% would

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 13:24

Annual boiler inspection.

Electrical inspection.

Carbon monoxide detectors
Wired in smoke detectors

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/10/2022 13:24

Floweryflora · 13/10/2022 13:04

That’s a mad thjng to write 🤣 if he loses his job either way they can’t pay the mortgage, at least this way they have savings to tide them over. Renting your house doesn’t mean you can’t get it back. You give notice lol

It is not. Just because a ll serves notice, the tenant doesn’t have to comply. Court and solicitor costs run into thousands. This can drag on for many months.

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 13:22

Tenant pays £600 pcm. Just had a new boiler installed £2320. Last year it was blown double glazed windows £1135 . There's always maintenance costs plus insurance. Leaking bath, sink, plumber call out another bill and we don't have a mortgage.

waffless · 13/10/2022 13:21

Two things to check is that the morgage may only allow you to rent for a year. Depending if you want to move to a BTL one. If you decide to move check the accommodation because it they can be very dull and impersonal. However, sounds like a great way to save money. You can tell him that you want to go for a period to seeing you like it. Like a year or two?

diddl · 13/10/2022 13:19

Realistically how much would you save by doing this compared to how much you could save by cutting back?

Could you really rent the house out for enough to make it worthwhile?

Plus cover the mortgage, bills etc if there's no tenant?

Would the work tenancy really be secure?

I'm kind of wondering why it has been offered to someone who already has their own home!

DPotter · 13/10/2022 13:18

Being a landlord isn't a free pension - far from it.

You would have to change your mortgage - not easy at the moment
You will need to pay for insurance, safety certificates, local council registrations
you will have to pay for the upkeep of the fabric of the house - boilers, windows, plumbing
if you are renting with furniture and domestic appliances, you will need to pay for replacements
you will have the hassle of tenants contacting you about repairs
and when you come to the point when you want to move back in to the house, you may have to go to court to enforce eviction.
Above a certain amount of rental income you will have to submit tax returns and pay tax - probably not a lot - but again your time, worry & effort

Many tenants complain bitterly about amateur and 'accidental' landlords and many amateur and 'accidental' landlords realise they got into something they have very little knowledge of and it can cost them dear in ££ and time.

Get your DH thinking through these points - I'm sure there are others. He needs to check out his legal responsibilities before booking to removers.

Homewardbound2022 · 13/10/2022 13:15

I am an accidental landlord and it's a pain.
Have a great tenant (doesn't want to buy the house) but it's the tax returns that do my head in. And I make up the shortfall between the rent and mortgage. This is not a money spinner!

Aprilx · 13/10/2022 13:11

If it is nice accommodation in an area you would like to live in, then I would absolutely do it. Sounds like a good financial idea to me.

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 13:10

inappickle · 13/10/2022 10:49

School is only a 4 minute drive with easy parking so it's not a massive draw to me. To be honest a 15/20 min walk sounds worse than a 4 min drive especially when it's raining.

He's always harped on about being a landlord since I met him, he says it's a free pension and I've always disagreed and not liked the idea. This house being available cheap and bills inclusive has just set him off again and he's adamant it's the best option

If he's in Wales or Scotland, rents are being frozen landlords expected to lower EPC rating on properties. Has he seen the new rules, you won't be able to raise rent or evict tenants. And don't think England won't follow. Small landlords are selling up. Overseas investors are buying up because local council can't touch them.

user1471538283 · 13/10/2022 13:10

I do understand how you feel OP. I never thought I could leave my favorite house but I did. I think about it sometimes but not often.

It has been quite rough as we moved and it was horrific and then we moved again and we will move again soon hopefully. But what it has taught me is that homes really are just bricks.

I would try it and see if you like it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread