Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants to rent our house out and I don't

166 replies

inappickle · 13/10/2022 10:39

Really clashing with my husband about this and we just have such different opinions I’m not sure what to do. Financially we’re ok, he makes out it’s very doom and gloom and we do have a big mortgage but we earn £68k between us and I’m only working 3 days a week, we have an expensive car (£300 a month) and we don’t budget or skip on luxuries so we do have ways in which we could cut back, as well as extra earning potential if I was too go back full time if needed. We have a young child who has been in an expensive private nursery and another baby due soon.

My husband has an opportunity for us to live at his work, it’s secure employment and the accommodation is nice (nowhere near as nice as our current house) and in a nice area I will give it that we wouldn’t need to drive as much and would be walking distance to kids school etc. He is desperate to do so, it’ll cost us half the price of our mortgage inclusive of bills and he wants to live there and rent our house out. He says it’ll pay for our retirement and set us for life. I hate the idea of someone else living in my house, we designed it ourselves and it’s my home. I hate the idea of living somewhere that isn’t ours again. I hate the idea of living where he works so he never switches off. This is our family home we worked so hard to build and I don’t want to leave. He also talks about renting it out at what he could realistically get for it but it’s more than our mortgage and I feel like it’s just being part of the problem and ripping off people that need housing.

I want to enjoy our lives now, but he’s so set on sorting ourselves out ‘for life’ and that our retirement would be sorted we’d be able to travel and save up loads in the mean time and it all just seems too far fetched and at too big a cost

Who’s right here? Am I being too attached to the house and possibly missing a good opportunity or is he just getting caught up in this idea that being a private landlord will set him for life when it isn’t realistically that straightforward

OP posts:
CrustyFlake · 14/10/2022 03:31

I'd do it on a trial basis for 1 year. You'd possibly struggle to get tenants in for less than 1 year anyway.

However, that's just me. I like to save money so this would really appeal to me. You are not wrong for not wanting to do this. You just have different priorities. I hope you manage to find a compromise.

youlooklikeapenis · 14/10/2022 02:57

Not a chance I'd give up my home. Not a chance in hell.

TooHotToTangoToo · 13/10/2022 17:14

We had exactly the same situation as you, we did this, moved in and rented out home out, it also enabled us to buy a second home and rent that out too. It set us up financially for life tbh.

Darbs76 · 13/10/2022 17:14

It’s tempting. I’d ask him to do some homework, proper figures on how much you could make, what you’d need to spend out on etc and then see just how much per year you’re looking at saving. I can see your point, if you’re house proud and you’ve got your house just how you want it then I can see why you don’t want to rent it out. I’d want proper info before taking a decision

ninjafoodienovice · 13/10/2022 17:10

Sounds like a no-brainer to me. I'm with your DH on this one.

Sago1 · 13/10/2022 17:07

WhyCantNameLastMoreThanDay · 13/10/2022 17:04

Bet North Yorkshire an area of low wages loves that

Second homes destroy communities.

Our property is not in a rural area, it’s in a City.

WhyCantNameLastMoreThanDay · 13/10/2022 17:04

Sago1 · 13/10/2022 14:38

I can see both sides of the argument but a lot depends on how much equity you have in the house.
We have been landlords without any hitches, I find the better the area and property the better the tenant.
We met all our tenants first.
If I were in your position and the equity was enough I would sell the family home move into the company accomadation and buy a holiday let.
This means you can use it yourselves at quiet periods and get a better income than an ordinary let.
We have a 2 bed, 2 bath apartment in N.Yorkshire that gives a great income and is our bolthole too.

Bet North Yorkshire an area of low wages loves that

Second homes destroy communities.

mumda · 13/10/2022 15:19

Speak to an accountant.
Speak to a local letting agent. Work out costs for someone else managing it.
Read some landlord sites.
Get quotes for insurance, Electrical safety check, gas check, etc.

PaperDoves · 13/10/2022 14:57

What's the point of working toward things like having a nice home if you then give it up because it's cheaper to live somewhere else (assuming you can still afford it and put money into savings)? Many of us could live more cheaply by giving up the things that make life enjoyable, but that doesn't mean we should or must.

I would also question how much you'd actually profit from the rental after expenses and income tax. The landlords I know, despite having nice properties, make very little -- their investment is the property itself, not the rental income.

sortmylifeoutoctober2022 · 13/10/2022 14:45

I have not read all the replies. We rented out our UK home when we moved abroad and for us, it was a nightmare emotionally. However, it meant we didn't have to sell in a downturn (2007/2008) and when we did sell the house recouped over 100k so it worked out as financially sound. You may need to remortgage to allow BTL and the CGT allowance has also changed now for property lets that have been previously primary residential status. It is not as profitable anymore you really need to do your sums the 50% you are saving in the subsidised accommodation might be wiped out. Good luck.

Sago1 · 13/10/2022 14:38

I can see both sides of the argument but a lot depends on how much equity you have in the house.
We have been landlords without any hitches, I find the better the area and property the better the tenant.
We met all our tenants first.
If I were in your position and the equity was enough I would sell the family home move into the company accomadation and buy a holiday let.
This means you can use it yourselves at quiet periods and get a better income than an ordinary let.
We have a 2 bed, 2 bath apartment in N.Yorkshire that gives a great income and is our bolthole too.

Caterina99 · 13/10/2022 14:37

Is it possible to refuse the accommodation and be compensated for that with a higher salary? Or is it work accommodation or nothing?

I ask this as I work for a company that often provides housing as part of the job package, and we probably wouldn’t mind if someone didn’t want the house as we’d be able to rent it out. As long as they lived close enough to do the job. However we would then have to pay them more to make up for that (but they wouldn’t necessarily end up better off if you compared their net pay v the market rent)

Also as mentioned - consider the tax implications carefully

1AngelicFruitCake · 13/10/2022 14:33

inappickle · 13/10/2022 14:23

I get that we're in a frivolous situation at the moment without savings and with expensive cars, small amounts of debt etc. just in my head that's pretty normal after doing everything we've done in such rapid succession - baby, house, wedding, another baby within like 3 years. But I see it as something we'll come back from and if we manage to maintain a nice life during this time and still have occasional holidays and stuff that savings taking a backseat short term isn't the end of the world? Yes would agree though I choose happiness over money and perhaps don't think about these things the most sensible way

I think spending a lot on those things is probably normal but to continue to go on foreign holidays, eat out a lot etc is living in the moment, which is fine whilst everything Is going well but it’s a risk.

angelicabtton · 13/10/2022 14:30

I get the feeling that is unlikely to save you money and is quite risky. I would probably cut costs and overpay your own mortgage while living in your house. But maybe get him to do all the sums so you can see. It must depend to a certain extent on the actual value of your mortgage/rent difference and how it affects the tax you pay etc

Talia99 · 13/10/2022 14:28

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 14:04

Seen folks sell up and return 20 years later. They lost out enormously

But neither of the options involve not owning property. It’s either living in the property themselves or renting it out.

Therefore, the issue isn’t equity in the house - they will be gaining that regardless. The issue is whether they will have more money available each month. Various people have been trying to point out it’s not a matter of having 1/2 the mortgage (as rent + bills is half the mortgage) + house bills free to spend each months as once tax, costs and expenses are taken into account, there may be very little left over.

diddl · 13/10/2022 14:27

just in my head that's pretty normal after doing everything we've done in such rapid succession

Not necessarily as some people would for example have a less expensive wedding/cars to keep within their means.

Darkstar4855 · 13/10/2022 14:26

It’s not the end of the world if you stay fit and healthy or if you have income protection/critical illness cover. The issue comes if one of you is diagnosed with a serious health condition and can’t work, or you have an unexpectedly high bill etc. With kids involved it’s irresponsible not to have some form of backup plan if you can possibly afford to.

inappickle · 13/10/2022 14:23

I get that we're in a frivolous situation at the moment without savings and with expensive cars, small amounts of debt etc. just in my head that's pretty normal after doing everything we've done in such rapid succession - baby, house, wedding, another baby within like 3 years. But I see it as something we'll come back from and if we manage to maintain a nice life during this time and still have occasional holidays and stuff that savings taking a backseat short term isn't the end of the world? Yes would agree though I choose happiness over money and perhaps don't think about these things the most sensible way

OP posts:
Whistlesandbell · 13/10/2022 14:15

OP how much profit do you think you’d make per year from renting out your current house once you’ve subtracted tax, converting your mortgage to a buy to let mortgage or whatever it is that needs doing regarding the mortgage, minus the right insurance, gas checks etc etc?
Surely this is the case if the OP actually lives in her house, she doesn’t have to move out to achieve this?

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 14:04

Getoff · 13/10/2022 13:42

I don't think profit is actually the main benefit of keeping the house. Knowing you will own a house when he leaves the job is the big benefit. You avoid the risk that goes with being out of the property market.

Seen folks sell up and return 20 years later. They lost out enormously

Rafferty10 · 13/10/2022 14:02

Op this rang alarmbells for me when you said your Dh wants to be a LL for passive income...there is no such thing any more.Show him this thread.

I have just sold all but 1 of my BTL properties as they were not making a profit despite only 50% mortgages, due to the tax situation, and more and more regulation. A management agent will take a fairly big slice of your rent, then you have to pay tax on the rent, BEFORE paying your mortgage with only a 20% tax allowance. It may well tip you into higher rate tax payers which can wipe out any profit at all. It is perfectly possible to end up worse off with a whole load of risk.

It is now highly risky being a LL, if you get bad tenants who stop paying it could take up to a year to remove them, you would have to cover the mortgage, deal with the courts and then repair any damage. This is not worth the risk for anything but a big return and l would be surprised if anyone could get a good return in the current climate.

25 years ago it was MUCH easier and yes you could take a long term view and make a decent return, maybe this is what you Dh has heard.

Ask your DH to go and see a property tax expert with his figures and let them estimate your profit/loss accurately.

In your situation and as a LL of 30 years l would not do this, however l would cut back immediately and build up 6 months savings.

justasking111 · 13/10/2022 14:02

Floweryflora · 13/10/2022 13:37

Oh some of these stories, we were quids in on ours and we used an agency to manage it. I suspect it depends on the standard of your house, new boiler blown windows is usually due to age and poor maintenance.

The boiler was 8 years old ditto the windows

1AngelicFruitCake · 13/10/2022 13:58

Why will you be + £850? Is that the childcare? Don’t forget the cost of wraparound childcare and the costs change as they get older. At one point we were paying £750 in childcare but that’s been replaced with £135 wraparound care, £200 ish on clubs as well as school dinners for older child all additional things that come with their clubs, school events etc.

I work part time and we have savings. I don’t spend loads on myself and we don’t go abroad because we’re not building savings up. It sounds like you’re spending a lot day to day but think about building up savings.

Gerwurtztraminer · 13/10/2022 13:51

HeddaGarbled · 13/10/2022 13:34

This is just the age old money versus happiness argument. Your husband’s priority is money and yours is happiness. I’m sure there’s research that shows that, over a certain amount, more money doesn’t make you any happier. Maybe try and find something like that and show it to him.

I totally agree that's the dilemma. I vote happiness now and pulling the spending in a bit.

Also agree that renting one house out does not mean financial gain,as others have said, there are risks that outgoings on repairs and having it to a rentable standard can far exceed the market rent. My own flat now, if rented, wouldn't cover all the costs as I' did the maths when considering it a few years ago (when mortgage & service charges rates were lower).

It's far harder renting out your own loved family home than being a professional landlord. My ex and I rented our house out when we came to the UK for temporary work reasons. The first trip back to see it was a bit heartbreaking as although the tenant hadn't trashed the place the previous pretty garden was very unloved and whilst the house was still OK it was understandably far more bashed about than if we'd lived there taking care of it. It was hard to see that. It ended up being rented for 5 years. In that time, one tenant stole all the curtains, loads of appliances broke, another tenant was evicted with huge rent arrears and left drug paraphenalia to be cleared up, along with lots of damage to repair. If we had moved back in it would have needed a lot of work to get it back to what I'd have wanted.. As it was we divorced and sold it as 'with potential'. I still feel a bit sad about that house.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 13/10/2022 13:44

Floweryflora · 13/10/2022 13:04

That’s a mad thjng to write 🤣 if he loses his job either way they can’t pay the mortgage, at least this way they have savings to tide them over. Renting your house doesn’t mean you can’t get it back. You give notice lol

A landlord cannot end a tenancy agreement. Only a renter or a court can do that. A landlord can serve notice that they want the property back but only a court can order a tenant to leave a property.