Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To talk to 29yo DD about her weight?

490 replies

singingamy · 13/10/2022 10:00

Hi all,

This is a bit of a tricky one so would appreciate any and all advice.

My DD is 29. In her teens she was quite chubby but never anything we were really concerned about and she was a size 14-16 by the time she was in college.

When she went away to uni she put on a lot of weight, and not long after that met her now hubby and settled in to life together which led to more weight as it does with a lot of people.

She had our granddaughter four years ago, and had quite a difficult pregnancy in large part due to her weight. She was 22 stone when she gave birth and comments from her GP and health visitors did get her making an effort to eat healthier and to try and exercise. That lasted a few months but then fell by the wayside.

Since then, she has gained a lot of weight and is now significantly bigger than she was after pregnancy. Lockdown obviously didn’t help and I was hoping that once all that had settled down and life was more normal again that she may start to tackle it but she just seems to be continuing to put on the weight.

It’s not a topic I’ve ever really discussed much with her. She is a grown woman and I respect everyone’s body is their own. However it is now at the point where I am getting really concerned and the impact of the weight is becoming obvious. Just getting out of the car and walking up the drive to our front door, or walking up the stairs for the loo, leaves her completely out of breath, for example. I’m obviously worried about her but also the impact on our granddaughter.

I know there’s probably two schools of thought on this, one that it’s none of my business and should stay out of it and one that I’m stupid because she’s my DD and I should’ve addressed this with her, so I know I cant really win either way. But as I said at the top – I’d appreciate any advice on this, whether to talk to her or not and what to say.

I guess if there’s an AIBU question it’s AIBU to be nervous to talk to her about it?

TIA x

OP posts:
hereyougoagain · 14/10/2022 12:16

@singingamy then she’s likely not in denial and aware of her size.

i guess I wouldn’t mention the weight but only approach it from the point of view of being out of breath etc, talk to her on whether she’d like to improve her fitness level?

singingamy · 14/10/2022 10:57

hereyougoagain · 14/10/2022 10:51

@singingamy maybe your solution is to take a few pictures of her with DGD and then share them with her and leave it at that for now?

DD doesn’t shy away from pics. She has loads on Facebook, most recently from DGD’s birthday in the summer and a night out with friends a few weeks ago

OP posts:
AltheaVestr1t · 14/10/2022 10:53

If OPs daughter had any other lifestyle based health risks - chain smoking, drugs, excessive alcohol, the advice would be to gently share her worries and support her daughter to improve however she can. I don't see why this is any different.

hereyougoagain · 14/10/2022 10:51

@singingamy maybe your solution is to take a few pictures of her with DGD and then share them with her and leave it at that for now?

hereyougoagain · 14/10/2022 10:48

@DoraSpenlow

The thing is, why was the lady avoiding having her picture taken? Because she KNEW she was fat!

if someone did tell her, esp while she was still in denial stage and she didn’t find out for herself, instead of being grateful to that person she’d likely be avoiding them forever after that conversation, esp if she wasn’t ready to do anything about it.

Also to look good in a random phone photo and not fat you normally need to be model skinny or have a very chiselled face. Most of my absolutely normal weight friends get upset by a random photo(not a curated selfie) because they say they look so fat in them.

Esp if you are the type who gains weight everywhere or on your face and not someone like Ashley Graham.

singingamy · 14/10/2022 10:44

Hello all - wow, so many posts! Obviously can’t reply to everything but I guess a few things I picked up on reading through…

SIL is maybe a stone or two overweight, but not especially big. DGD is, thankfully, a normal weight for her age. I’m fairly slim myself (size 12) and I like going out for walks etc.

I think DD’s problems with food are a few things. She’s a big snacker but it’s rarely healthy things. Her portion sizes are definitely an issue too - I’ve noticed that when shes here for dinner and will often get up and serve herself a fairly large portion of seconds.

I think I said before that you don’t know what’s going on in someone’s head, but she didn’t suffer with PND and has always been happy and bubbly. She has a big group of friends who she’s often out with. I know that doesn’t automatically mean everything is fine mentally, but more that she’s not the stereotypical depressed, doesn’t want to go out etc.

I almost said something to her last night when she came to pick DGD up. We were upstairs so she came straight in from the car and upstairs, and she was absolutely huffing and puffing, to the point she couldn’t get through a full sentence without getting her breath. I didn’t think it was a good idea doing it in front of DGD.

OP posts:
Crunchingleaf · 14/10/2022 10:42

It's very difficult to separate the 'shunned section of society' aspect off from the health aspect if you are over eating. Feeling shunned and unacceptable as a human being does not help with the looong process you need to undertake to be acceptably/ healthily thin either.

This isn’t about being ‘acceptably thin’.
Being overweight means that you are increasing your risk of health complications, however plenty of overweight people don’t get things like type 2 diabetes and are still pretty active etc. There comes a point in weight when you go deep into the obesity category that you are virtually guaranteed that it will cause health complications. The weight puts a huge strain on your body, your organs, your joints etc. It prevents you from living your life to its fullest and keeping up with your kids etc. If you love someone who has reached such a size you would definitely be worried about them from a health perspective.

Its a tough situation for OP to be in because she is rightfully worried about her DD health. The safest entry point into a conversation is probably asking the DD about what GP is saying about the breathing issues, because weight issues like this are often a symptom.

DoraSpenlow · 14/10/2022 09:55

OP, only you can know how your daughter will react to you mentioning your concerns about her health due to her weight.

Lots of people here saying, don't mention it, she knows she's fat.

A few months ago a new lady start at the gym. I don't know what her weight was but her face was so fat her eyes were like slits. She was coming three times a week and was having sessions with a PT. One day the PT was not there for some reason so the young woman was just doing her own thing. As I was the only other one there she came over to ask about a piece of equipment. I just asked if she was enjoying her sessions and she said she found them difficult but knew she needed to get a grip on things.

She told me (I didn't ask) that she had always avoided having her photo taken because she was so big but had recently been caught in the background of a photo at a party. She said that she was horrified to see just how fat she had got and was so disappointed that no one in her family or any of her friends had taken her to one side and given her a good talking to.

So, it seems you are wrong you do mention it and wrong if you don't.

The lady in question has now lost several stone and says she has never been happier.

Mardyface · 14/10/2022 09:32

MintyFreshOne · 14/10/2022 09:23

When you comment on their weight you are commenting on a concrete thing that they are

But it is the result of repeated actions or habits.

There are loads of risky habits that shorten life that people never comment on or might not even know about like driving, driving too fast, drinking, smoking, unprotected sex with lots of different people

And I would hope parents could talk to their children at any age about these irresponsible habits and behaviours.

It's just that society really hates a fat woman. That's where the over concern about health comes in because very often but not always people hide behind the 'health' line when what they really feel is fat people look disgusting

This is a concerned mother though and not just some fatphobic randomer.

But it is the result of repeated actions or habits. - outside onlookers assume they know exactly which actions or habits lead to someone being fat, but the truth is they don't know how much or what someone eats or exercises or how that compares to their own habits. But it's OK to comment anyway as if you do know somehow.

This is a concerned mother though and not just some fatphobic randomer. yes absolutely, but commenting in the context of all that - which is why it is a sensitive subject. Additionally as I said before mother daughter relationships are seldom simple, especially when it comes to food, eating, and weight. There are generational differences in attitude for one thing (but there are many other things too).

MintyFreshOne · 14/10/2022 09:23

When you comment on their weight you are commenting on a concrete thing that they are

But it is the result of repeated actions or habits.

There are loads of risky habits that shorten life that people never comment on or might not even know about like driving, driving too fast, drinking, smoking, unprotected sex with lots of different people

And I would hope parents could talk to their children at any age about these irresponsible habits and behaviours.

It's just that society really hates a fat woman. That's where the over concern about health comes in because very often but not always people hide behind the 'health' line when what they really feel is fat people look disgusting

This is a concerned mother though and not just some fatphobic randomer.

Mardyface · 14/10/2022 09:02

I think the difference is that when you comment on people's drug use, alcoholism, depressed demeanour etc you are commenting on what they are doing. When you comment on their weight you are commenting on a concrete thing that they are.

There are loads of risky habits that shorten life that people never comment on or might not even know about like driving, driving too fast, drinking, smoking, unprotected sex with lots of different people. Those habits (not the consequences of them) directly affect other people around the person doing them too whereas overeating tends to be a solitary self damaging thing. It's just that society really hates a fat woman. That's where the over concern about health comes in because very often but not always people hide behind the 'health' line when what they really feel is fat people look disgusting and getting shouty about health gives them the opportunity to express that. Really individuals' health is their own business.

It's very difficult to separate the 'shunned section of society' aspect off from the health aspect if you are over eating. Feeling shunned and unacceptable as a human being does not help with the looong process you need to undertake to be acceptably/ healthily thin either.

That's why it's a sensitive subject. I suspect too that if the op broaches this with her daughter she will damage their relationship (it find out that it was actually much more fragile than she imagined in the first place).

Tabbouleh · 14/10/2022 08:53

MintyFreshOne · 14/10/2022 08:46

I just don’t understand why PP think she shouldn’t share her concerns with her daughter. This will be a difficult conversation but her daughter is on the path to an early death if she doesn’t reverse course. She will regret forever if her DD dies or becomes disabled due to a preventable condition.

We would encourage conversations around alcoholism and drug abuse, I don’t see how this is different.

The difference is that most people don't consider morbid obesity comparable to alcoholism or drug addiction. I do, though. We aren't talking about a couple of stone excess weight here. Which I would overlook.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 14/10/2022 08:49

Nogreens · 13/10/2022 11:20

Where does this ' shut up don't mention it' thing end.

My husband is depressed. It is starting to affect family life and his work. He know he is depressed but does nothing about it. I want him to do something about it. Should I talk to him?
Answer: Shut up. He knows. You mentioning will only make him more depressed.

My daughter is turning yellow. It's very obvious people are commenting about it so she knows. Should I talk to her?
Answer: She has a mirror. What do you think talking to her about it is going to achieve.

My son is severely underweight. It affects his day to day life. He is always tired. Does not eat enough. Health issues are starting to arise. Should I talk to him?
Answer: Shut up. He knows.

What is the point of family if you can have difficult conversations. What other health related issues is this 'shut up, don't mention it ' pushed?

Somewhat different- a depressed person may be so low they don’t realise just how depressed they are and incapable of seeking help without assistance - eg someone waking them up and helping get them dressed and out of house and to a pre booked GP appointment(or A&E, if needs be)

MintyFreshOne · 14/10/2022 08:46

I just don’t understand why PP think she shouldn’t share her concerns with her daughter. This will be a difficult conversation but her daughter is on the path to an early death if she doesn’t reverse course. She will regret forever if her DD dies or becomes disabled due to a preventable condition.

We would encourage conversations around alcoholism and drug abuse, I don’t see how this is different.

Octomore · 14/10/2022 08:41

If a 26 stone woman in her 20s (so not old in the slightest, unlikely to have developed conditions that are more age related) is struggling to walk short distances, it is almost guaranteed to be weight related.

There is nothing else the OP mentions (e.g. asthma) that would cause it. And even if she does have asthma, the obesity would be making it harder to manage the condition (I have asthma and I'm a runner, certainly don't get out of breath walking around).

Occams razor - the simplest explanation is usually correct.

Walkaround · 13/10/2022 23:30

mistermagpie · 13/10/2022 21:49

I'm not disputing that at all, my point is that the OPs daughter knows this already. She's the one who is out of breath, she doesn't need her mum to tell her. If she is happy how she is (and we have no reason to think she's not) then I'm not sure what good is going to come of the OP telling her information she already knows. The likely outcome is that her daughter will feel bad about herself or guilty for worrying people or lots of other negative things about herself, none of which are conducive to her losing weight.

Sorry, I find that a weird attitude. Nobody even knows if the cause is definitely the obesity, ffs. Why on earth would you not express concern about an obvious health issue? Why just quietly watch those you love kill themselves by not seeking help for poor health? It’s completely abnormal to get out of breath just walking up a drive.

RubyTrees · 13/10/2022 22:05

She's the one who is out of breath, she doesn't need her mum to tell her.

You're right. But her 4 year old daughter needs her mum to be healthy.

mistermagpie · 13/10/2022 21:49

RubyTrees · 13/10/2022 21:46

mistermagpie OP has said that her 29 year old daughter can't walk a short distance without getting out of breath - this is not at all normal regardless of how happy and confident the daughter may feel.

I'm not disputing that at all, my point is that the OPs daughter knows this already. She's the one who is out of breath, she doesn't need her mum to tell her. If she is happy how she is (and we have no reason to think she's not) then I'm not sure what good is going to come of the OP telling her information she already knows. The likely outcome is that her daughter will feel bad about herself or guilty for worrying people or lots of other negative things about herself, none of which are conducive to her losing weight.

RubyTrees · 13/10/2022 21:46

mistermagpie OP has said that her 29 year old daughter can't walk a short distance without getting out of breath - this is not at all normal regardless of how happy and confident the daughter may feel.

CousinTime · 13/10/2022 20:15

JennyForeigner2 · 13/10/2022 14:40

Twice the size, eh?

Aye, of course they are.

WTAF?
The relative was a size 14, ended up like a 26. Why would you spend your time picking apart my life experience?

mistermagpie · 13/10/2022 20:13

'Weighing in' on the can fat people be healthy debate here - I'm currently wearing a pair of size 6 jeans (vanity sizing but still, I'm slim) and have eaten a packet of super noodles and a cheese string for my dinner tonight. I have the diet of a student or a toddler mainly and hardly eat anything healthy. I have friends much bigger than me who eat a really healthy diet, much better than mine, but people assume I'm healthy because I'm thinner. We are more than what we look like.

OP I really recommend Aubrey Gordon's book 'what we don't talk about when we talk about fat' for a bit of insight into the experience of fat people and just what your daughter might go through by living in her body. I found it and her podcast really enlightening.

My cousin is very like your daughter, in terms of having gained weight steadily through pregnancy and beyond and now being at a stage where she is very overweight. Sadly her relationship with her mother has been very damaged by the mother's helpful intervention about the issue and honestly, I'm not sure what's to be gained here. Your daughter knows she's overweight, of course she does, but she hasn't spoken to you about it and seems happy and confident in her body - so maybe she is? At best you might dent that confidence and at worst you might ruin your relationship by telling her something she knows and has chosen not to discuss with you. She won't lose weight because you want her to, that's for certain, so I don't see the point of pushing the issue.

Hadtocomment · 13/10/2022 20:02

OP, one thing I would say is that a private and potentially hurtful conversation done sensitively can be forgiven even if taken badly. However, a thread on Mumsnet about something so private (even anonymously) could be unforgivable. Such threads can also be taken up by tabloids. If that happened your relationship could be ruined forever. I'd ask this to be taken down if you are a serious genuine person asking about this. @singingamy

Eeksteek · 13/10/2022 18:45

It’s ‘A Thorough Examination’ with Dr Chris and Dr Xand.

Eeksteek · 13/10/2022 18:44

She knows. Back RIGHT off it. Accept her wholly and truly as she is, unless she asks for support.

I recommend Chris and Xand’s podcast. They’re twin doctors and Xand was overweight, but he just couldn’t do anything about it until Chris backed off. There was no space for him to make a decision without it being an admittance of ‘being wrong’. I can’t think of the name of it. It’s mostly about UPFs, but the relationship part of it was so key. When Xand was asked ‘how much of deciding to do something about your weight was me backing off about it?’ His answer was an immediate ‘ALL of it’. I’ll check for you.

You daughter has eyes. She KNOWS she is overweight. Obese people are not treated kindly in society. Don’t be part of that. Be her judgement free place to be fully herself. She may tackle it, she may not, but anything coming from you will not help. It will make it harder, and will impact on your relationship.

I’m not overweight. I’m a healthy BMI, but I do vary within that, and even occasionally slip a couple of pounds into overweight. My mother cannot help commenting on it. I find it so fucking annoying. I KNOW if I need to lose a few pounds and it’s usually because of massive stress or life difficulties. I don’t need my mother’s thinly-veiled, pointy judgemental comments about it to remind me, and to add to that stress. I’ll get to it when I can. I refuse to discuss weight, diet or health with at her all now. I shut it down, zero tolerance. I don’t need to hear her weight obsession. My daughter doesn’t need to hear it. (And she does have obsession. I have never had a conversation with her where it doesn’t come up) She still does it. I simply don’t say anything. She’s very puzzled about this isn’t helpful to tell me I’ve put on weight, and ask what I’m going to about it. Often in company. It’s bloody rude, and I bloody know, and I’ll get onto it when whatever shit has hit my personal fan passes. It’s often sleep related, so I’m probably a bit short tempered over it, being chronically sleep deprived at the time. Still, it’s horrible. I feel like it’s really judgemental, and it definitely makes me feel more distant from her than I’d like.

MintyFreshOne · 13/10/2022 18:20

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 13/10/2022 12:13

If I was your daughter, I would think "how dare she talk to me like this". I would probably never speak to you again.......................................

Really extreme reaction to a concerned mother