Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP surgery appointments

37 replies

Peanut61 · 13/10/2022 09:57

AIBU to not understand why my GP insists on phone appointments.

I am getting so frustrated. I have a couple of issues today and need to see the GP. One of the issues involved a poorly child. And the other needs looking at in person as it’s a physical thing that has potential to turn bad, spoken to pharmacy and first treatment has failed.

call up at 8 on dot, sit in queue for ages. Explain myself in great detail to a non medical receptionist. They only do phone appointments first. So now at some point this afternoon a medical person will call.

im sorry but in my opinion this is a waste of time. They can’t examine a child with fever of unknown origin on phone. They can’t look at my physical issue either. Phone is great for some things but to have that blanket rule is such a waste in my opinion.

is it like this everywhere? Why are GPs insisting on phone appointments first? Does it really save time/money?

surely I’m my case, I’m wasting time and potentially the dr will miss things that could turn bad.

eg if I had a breast lump or a mole that was dodgy or potential tic bite. Would a phone appointment really help?

I should add my surgery is on special measures as it’s so poor! I am looking to change but do are lots. There’s very few doctors there now so it’s even harder to get an appointment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CoffeeWithCheese · 13/10/2022 20:20

Ours used to be good - but since Covid hit - oh my God. I had to get a repeat prescription reviewed recently - rang to book that up straight after I got the text that they'd issued a repeat but wanted to review before next time ...4 week wait for a telephone only appointment.

Telephone appointment day came - no call. Rang surgery the following morning first thing - oh they'll call at some point today - no call. Following day I repeat the same thing again - nada. By this point my repeat medication was running low and it's not stuff you're meant to stop cold-turkey.

Day after I ring the surgery again to a receptionist nearly in tears and I spend about 15 minutes listening to her offload onto me - they finally renewed the repeat for another month and booked in another telephone call with a pharmacist they've brought on to take the medication reviews over... in a fortnight.

I'm very calm and understanding and ever so polite (as seen by the receptionist offloading onto me!) but it was absolutely crazy - I was trying to do induction for a new job while hanging onto my mobile phone in case it rang for nearly a week! Not a great way to start a new job and make an impression!

browneyes77 · 13/10/2022 19:55

Pre Covid, we had f2f and we could book an appointment within a 2 week timeframe using the online booking system.

Worked well for those of us who work especially, as we could schedule appointments around our work hours and didn’t have to do the mad constant redial at 9am to get an appointment that had to be that day.

Once Covid hit they removed the online booking system and usual f2f and did phone only and you were only asked to attend the surgery for urgent issues or nurse appointments like smears/blood tests etc.

Nearly 3 years later, the online booking system still hasn’t been switched back on. You can’t book a f2f unless it’s for something like a blood test and have to wait for a GP phone call and then they’ll decide if they need to see you. It’s infuriating.

In fact the only thing they’ve changed is they’ve now installed a telephone queuing system so people aren’t having to redial 100+ times at 9am to get through 🙄🙄

BabyST · 13/10/2022 14:45

The way the GP and role of primary care have changed over the last number of years. A GP has now many options.

While I can see you’re point but again not knowing you, you are not medical. Trust the medical professionals. It is not always the case that you MUST be seen by a GP, Paramedic Paramedic Practitioner or Nurse Practitioner. They are very good at listening and can prescribe over the phone.

This is not taking away the fact that they are in Special Measures with he CQC. You can always go to a walk in centre or urgent treatment centre. Equally the NHS has Livi, you have 111 (I personally hate them) bare in mind they are a advice line and out of hours service

Wichit · 13/10/2022 13:33

It's long been a patchy bolt on though. They set their own contracts, systems, hours ... There's no consistency or planning to how they operate - usually a practice manager trying and failing to set up a usable appointment system while GPs berate them about not wanting their time wasted. They've always been a law unto themselves but since covid they really are just doing whatever the fuck they want. Loads of them don't even work full time.

If anything they're a good example of how terrible private contracts within public health can be.

Peanut61 · 13/10/2022 13:10

Well it seems pretty awful everywhere. We are also in a location that has had significant house building.

one estate in our village left a field empty for a new school. The council said it wasn’t needed. It’s still an empty field but won’t be long til they fill it with houses.

we can’t even find GPs to work in the existing surgery so no point building a new one.

too many people here, aging population. Honestly… I’m getting to point where think we should scrap nhs and pay for it differently. Which of course is what government want us to think.

OP posts:
Icantsee25 · 13/10/2022 12:52

My GP surgery is really good, you can book phone or f2f appointments a week in advance for routine things, or on the day for urgent. And they always seem to have appointments available when I have needed them.

However my previous surgery did phone first only, and would say "a doctor will call you sometime in the next 2 weeks" so you had to hope you wouldn't miss the call during an entire 2 week period, which was crazy and basically impossible. It's weird how GP surgeries have such different ways of working.

Garysmum · 13/10/2022 12:52

DistrictCommissioner · 13/10/2022 10:47

Yes - and what are the GPs supposed to do? It’s impossible to recruit GPs (where we are anyway), my town has gone from 4 surgeries to 3 in the last 4 years so you can imagine the strain on the surviving surgeries, the houses keep on getting built & our population (in general) needs more & more healthcare.

I don't think this is an issue for GPs though. It's one of those where we come back to NHS underfunding, Government being massively in debt so put up and shut up scenario.
Not sure better education in terms of both keeping healthy long term and what service to use and when will noticably impact the amount of GP care available. There are simply not enough GPs - some practices have multiples more of patients per GP than other practices.
I'd like to see housebuilders when building significant estates be forced to construct the GP premises (like they do for schools as a condition of planning once a development reaches a certain size). (Maybe they do this already so the point of build needs to be a lower threshold). How the funding is put in place to run the practice is beyond me. (I might be able to come with ideas but I don't know how the funding streams work).
Personally I'd pay a fee for my GP consultations BUT that just brings in deeper inequality in healthcare.

MissyB1 · 13/10/2022 12:48

Six week wait just for a phone appointment at our surgery - yes you read that right 6 weeks!

longtompot · 13/10/2022 12:40

Yanbu op. Ours does this and sometimes you want to see someone face to face and just can't. They have also now introduced a one condition per phone call, so if you have two things you'd like to ask about you have to make a separate app and decide which one is the most urgent. And what if the two things are linked, but it might take a while to find out with having the appointments a week or so apart?
I am sure in most circumstances it has saved gps time, but I wonder how many people have the phone call and then get called in anyway? Just seems to double the time taken with the gp at that point.
As for giving the call handler info, I just give very basic info ie gynae issue, or discuss hrt something like that, nothing too detailed.

Wichit · 13/10/2022 12:23

A big issue with phone "appointments" is that at our surgery they're not really appointments - you have to be available throughout the entire day. This is how it goes now:

  • I fill in an online form
  • I get a text to say that a clinician will review my contact in twenty eight days
  • five weeks later I get a phone call out of the blue, which I miss. Because I'm fucking working.
  • I then fill in an online form and the whole process starts again.

I've paid for private GP appointments a couple of times over the past six months just because I needed to get things sorted. And been referred to urgent care by 111 on one occasion. I don't really know what the point of being registered with a public health GP surgery is, now.

ChilliBandit · 13/10/2022 12:23

DistrictCommissioner · 13/10/2022 10:47

Yes - and what are the GPs supposed to do? It’s impossible to recruit GPs (where we are anyway), my town has gone from 4 surgeries to 3 in the last 4 years so you can imagine the strain on the surviving surgeries, the houses keep on getting built & our population (in general) needs more & more healthcare.

We are thinking of leaving our area and this is one of the issues, our surgery has about 30,000 patients and developers just build more and more flats. The schools are already oversubscribed. The government needs to invest heavily in infrastructure and training and incentivising more GPs and teachers etc.

Livpool · 13/10/2022 12:16

We also have to ring at 8 for a same-day appointment and while it can be difficult to get through - I always have done so I think my surgery is doing well to be fair

Livpool · 13/10/2022 12:14

My GP always sees children in person (in my experience) and I was seen yesterday for an exacerbation of my asthma. I have also had telephone appointments regarding an ongoing back issue.

I do think it is surgery-dependent

Freddiefan · 13/10/2022 10:48

We start phoning at 8.00, the phone starts to ring and then we get the message 'the waiting list is full' and then we get cut off!
I've done an e-consult with a photo and found that quite difficult but did get a phone call.
I'm horrified about what has just happened to a friend. She had dreadful stomach pains, went to A&E but after hours in agony was sent home with laxatives. To cut an awful story short, she ended up with three blockages being removed from her bowel and is in a dreadful state.

DistrictCommissioner · 13/10/2022 10:47

Garysmum · 13/10/2022 10:36

In my area there is no option to change practice. You will only be in catchment for one practice.
All the practices are bursting at the seams due to significant house building which has doubled the population in 20 years (may be less) and no more GPs surgeries have opened. There are a number of people even without a GP as surgeries have refused to take on more. What are these people supposed to do?

Yes - and what are the GPs supposed to do? It’s impossible to recruit GPs (where we are anyway), my town has gone from 4 surgeries to 3 in the last 4 years so you can imagine the strain on the surviving surgeries, the houses keep on getting built & our population (in general) needs more & more healthcare.

ChilliBandit · 13/10/2022 10:42

I do think telephone is fine for most things but I’ve had to write in advance to get the follow f2f without a telephone appt first

  • 2x post 28week antenatal appts (for some reason in my area 2 are done by GPs)
  • Pertussis jab
  • Stitches on my arm to be removed by practise nurse

The receptionist was insisting a phone appt first to tell a GP why an appt was needed. 🙄 luckily my GP is now basically back to pre covid service.

RedHerring24 · 13/10/2022 10:40

Our GP surgery is awful and getting appointment is like looking for a unicorn.
Ive been on hold for 2 hours before and told they cant book appointments in advance so have to call back the next day. Same thing happens again.
They only seem to offer phone appointments as well which are useless if you need to be examined.

I do think the more worrying this is the e-consult system.
We are directed to completing an online form now which is fine for anything basic like a repeat prescription etc.
But Ive filled these forms out for new conditions and just been prescribed medication without being seen. Same for DH where he had a skin problem. He uploaded a photo, was prescribed cream for it which made it worse and the same process has happened 3 times now.
Hes asked for a face to face appointment and been refused.

They also seem happy to prescribe for a baby over the phone which i feel is disgusting given they dont even know her weight for medication. Its borderline dangerous.

Its about time they reverted back to normal. All other industries have.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 13/10/2022 10:38

Garysmum · 13/10/2022 10:36

In my area there is no option to change practice. You will only be in catchment for one practice.
All the practices are bursting at the seams due to significant house building which has doubled the population in 20 years (may be less) and no more GPs surgeries have opened. There are a number of people even without a GP as surgeries have refused to take on more. What are these people supposed to do?

There are a number of people even without a GP as surgeries have refused to take on more. What are these people supposed to do?

Yeah it's the same here. We had to get the health board to 'force' us onto the list of a GP surgery who'd already turned us away when we attempted to register in the normal way.

EverydayImPuzzling · 13/10/2022 10:37

Mine did the telephone triage followed by F2F if necessary during height of covid but stopped about a year ago. They now offer you a choice between telephone or F2F for both urgent or routine appointments which is perfect. I’ve even gone in F2F for a mental health problem (as it was quite severe) but then have had all follow ups over the phone which saves us all time. I’m always told I can come in F2F if I prefer.

My GP surgery are fab and I’m so glad we now have the option as it works really well for staff and patients.

Garysmum · 13/10/2022 10:36

gingercat02 · 13/10/2022 10:30

I suspect you just have a crap GP practice. I work in primary care and it's really not like that locally.

My mum rang for an appointment on Tuesday last week, saw GP F2F on the Friday. Hospital appointment on Tuesday and phone call from GP on Wednesday to sort her medication.

She also has a 4 week review with the practice nurse to make sure she's happy with everything.

I've worked with GP's for 30 years and there have always been shit ones but people won't change practice to a better one

In my area there is no option to change practice. You will only be in catchment for one practice.
All the practices are bursting at the seams due to significant house building which has doubled the population in 20 years (may be less) and no more GPs surgeries have opened. There are a number of people even without a GP as surgeries have refused to take on more. What are these people supposed to do?

lanthanum · 13/10/2022 10:33

Our surgery has put out a message to say they are very short of doctors this week - covid is still doing the rounds. Those who are positive but not too unwell can do telephone appointments, and of course the fewer face-to-face appointments, the less risk of another doctor encountering covid. Some things can be dealt with remarkably easily over the phone, sometimes with the aid of a photograph. On a couple of occasions the doctor has wanted me/dd to go in so they could look properly, and it's been easier to sort a time for that because the phone appointments are more flexible.

With your examples:
Breast lump - whatever they think it is, the next step is probably referral to the breast clinic. Even if they're pretty sure it's something benign, they will send you, so seeing it will make practically no difference.
Suspect mole - I had one, they looked at a photo, didn't think it was a worry, but asked me to pop in for a couple of minutes so they could confirm.

Musicaltheatremum · 13/10/2022 10:33

My surgery is telephone only too and either morning or afternoon, no time given. I hate it. I'm a GP and went back to F2F last November. Much safer and quicker.

Sidisawetlettuce · 13/10/2022 10:31

Ours have started F2F appointments again but trying to get through at 8am is a nightmare. I think for some things, phone appointments are ideal but for the majority of cases, a GP needs to see you in person.

gingercat02 · 13/10/2022 10:30

I suspect you just have a crap GP practice. I work in primary care and it's really not like that locally.

My mum rang for an appointment on Tuesday last week, saw GP F2F on the Friday. Hospital appointment on Tuesday and phone call from GP on Wednesday to sort her medication.

She also has a 4 week review with the practice nurse to make sure she's happy with everything.

I've worked with GP's for 30 years and there have always been shit ones but people won't change practice to a better one

fastandthecurious1 · 13/10/2022 10:29

Oh and at the moment any respiratory issues unless very ongoing has to be a telephone a call firstly but once you have had that they will book you in person normally if you are struggling