Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how the kids of very overprotective parents turned out?

142 replies

Uncleebz · 13/10/2022 09:25

To be honest I can see the pros and cons (don’t have kids myself) of insulating your children from risk. However, my friend has a son who’s 14 and the rules he has are insane (eg not allowed to go anywhere on his own with friends unless accompanied by an adult). It got me thinking do you know any adults who were very overprotected as a kid (or are you one) how did it work out for them? What are they like now as adults?

OP posts:
GelatoQueen · 13/10/2022 11:21

It's really hard to be a parent and to get the balance right. I'm sure my DS thinks I'm too overprotective on some things (eg I refused to let him watch squid games at age 8 although his friends watched it) but I try really hard to give him his independence and help to navigate the world.

WireSkills · 13/10/2022 11:19

Pinpot · 13/10/2022 09:27

My friend was one of these. She's fine - very successful in her career, has high expectations of how she is treated etc. but she is really scared of a lot of things - and wildly overestimates risk in my opinion.

This. My SIL had a very over-protective mother who wouldn't let her do anything she deemed "risky", to the point of not being able to climb climbing frames, etc.

She is a wonderful, lovely person, but is terrified of so much. Frightened of going on a plane to the point that her children have never been abroad, won't go on any rides in fairs or theme parks and actively tells her own children not to go on them, etc, so she's in danger of passing on her anxiety to her own children. One of the kids is showing signs of anxiety and the other started out as a total daredevil but is now starting to change.

My BIL is not the same so tries to show that things are fine, but the kids seeing their Mum's fear is rubbing off on them. It's better when my SIL isn't around as BIL is able to encourage them to be a bit more adventurous (while still not dangerous).

Trademarker · 13/10/2022 11:17

I had overprotective parents who were strict due to religion. So no going out in my teens, went to university but would have to text when I got there/left for home. They weren't risk averse, but had lots of rules. I had a friend in school who's mum allowed her to smoke at home (we were about 14) and I thought she was the height of a cool parent.
I've turned out OK, so has my sibling and I'm pretty much the same with my dc as my parents were with me. I look back at the 'cool' parent now and think she was awful!

shumway · 13/10/2022 11:15

Similar story for me - anxiety, depression, social anxiety, eating disorders, low self esteem, no social skills, failure to be a proper adult.

ohthehorrorthehorror · 13/10/2022 11:11

Anxiety and depression, social anxiety, cripllingly low self esteem.
I went totally off the rails at uni and in my 20s, binge drinking, lots of one night stands.
I've never really fulfilled my early potential, and in my late 50s I'm finally having counselling to try and address my issues.
And an over protective parent turned me into a liar too.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 13/10/2022 11:08

I think it is important to let children take minor risks, and to cope within the problems which ensue if you get it wrong. I remember being warned not to go near the edge of ponds , but I was allowed out with my ten year old cousin when I was eight to play in Bushey Park, quite a wild environment in those years. Of course I thought I could reach the lily that was floating on the surface of the pool,big splash, cousin pulled me out dripping ( I found a water snail in my pocket when I got home so not without profit). I didn’t go near the edge next time.

A lady who worked for me had a daughter who was very protected, she was never allowed to wander around a park for example without adult company (supervision). She was horrified when I told her the lily story ‘ you could have drowned’ well, maybe but it was only three feet deep, I could swim and I didn’t drown.

Her daughter went on a gap year, of course one of those rather expensive highly organised social improvement trips. While she was there , she decided to go white water rafting with a very dodgy outfit. The raft overturned and she was tragically killed.

She had no ability to assess risk , because she had never been exposed to it.

ChagSameachDoreen · 13/10/2022 11:04

I went off the rails and took a lot of drugs in my early 20s. I then moved halfway across the world.

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 13/10/2022 11:03

I had a relative who, together with his wife, were incredibly rigid in how their children could behave e.g. clothes folded in a particular way by the children each day, beds were inspected every morning before s hook, how they sat at the table, how they slept ( yes, they policed that) what they ate. I always said they’d rebel, go wild at Uni or become school refusers. No, both got Firsts at Uni, great jobs where they moved up the ladder quickly. The son actually became a single dad to his very young daughter as his wife died when she was only 30/31. His sister had a great sense of humour, did leave her steady job and went off to become something a bit risky like a sky diving instructor but as far as I could see they were both really nice people. Of course, later they may have reverted to similar parenting.

antelopevalley · 13/10/2022 11:03

My nephew was one of these kids. Insane levels of protection. At 17 years old he climbed out of his parents window and couchsurfed with friends. He never went back to live at his parents.
I was really worried about him as he had zero experience of managing risk. But he seemed to have great friends who looked after him. He is fine now with his own children. His relationship with his parents exists but is shaky.

Rosehugger · 13/10/2022 11:02

My DM was a product of over-protective parents, and rules that didn't make sense. Having to be home earlier than others from parties (in her late teens) which meant she had to walk miles home alone in the dark instead of coming back with others. Not being able to take part in school productions or sports teams as she had to stay at home and do her chores. I think they were anxious parents with a dose of "not getting above your station" and "girls should not be doing...x, y or z". This was 1940s and 1950s. I'm sure WW2 added to that. Also she experienced her little brother, ten years younger, having much more relaxed rules applied to him.

She couldn't wait to get away from home and like lots of people of that generation married fairly young to get some freedom from parental control.

So then towards me she very much didn't want to be that sort of parent. She stood up for me against my DF in my teens when he otherwise could have been more controlling.

I still think they were a little overprotective, perhaps being an only child. Not in not letting me do things but perhaps over-emphasising the danger in things sometimes which caused anxiety.

I'm a fairly laid-back parent (I hope).

Ghostlight · 13/10/2022 10:54

My parents were incredibly strict and restrictive and had an endless list of rules like no music, no socialising, no internet, no extracurriculars that were not pre approved by them. They had very high expectations.
So I grew up learning from very young how to lie to my parents and how to play a character.
They had no reason to doubt that I was shy and quiet and studious and was incredibly well behaved, they are very proud of me.
They had no reason to be suspicious but I lied about everything.
I changed the contact details for my parents at school so it all went through a seperate phone and I forwarded the innocuous ones onto them. My parents believed that was the number for the school so all communications they had with school went through me.
My parents never knew who my actual friends were or what I got up to, they did not even know what A-levels I actually took. Everything was curated and neat.
I wasn't even naturally rebellious or wanting to be badly behaved. I still got good grades and never got into trouble, I just wanted normal things like being able to be in the school play or to walk home with friends or occasionaly have a fanta. But they were so over the top- all of my normal interactions had to be secret and difficult.

As an adult I think I am mostly normal because the life I kept hidden from my parents was really great and well rounded- I have always had good friends and I have a job I love, in a city I love, I have a wonderful husband and brilliant kids and its all good.
But they will never know about it and thats hard, especially as they think we have a good relationship and that they were good parents.
They only know about my husband and children because that is not something I was willing to hide, but that is probably the only real part of me that they have seen since I was around 8 years old.

spiderlight · 13/10/2022 10:54

In a nutshell - crippling anxiety, zero social skills and my entire life feels like the first five minutes of an episode of 'Casualty'.

VeridicalVagabond · 13/10/2022 10:53

Had a friend in high school who grew up with very religious overbearing parents, she wasn't allowed to do ANYTHING. She went completely wild in university, drink, drugs, risky sex. Multiple abortions (no judgement on those, but they were a symptom of her dangerous behaviour), multiple hospitalisations, overdoses, all sorts. Really went fully off the rails as soon as she had an inch of freedom.

At 22 she got off her tree on Mescaline at a house party and wandered into a road, got hit by a car. Complications of surgery after the accident left her permanently disabled.

She's 34 now and only just starting to put her life back together. She's a lovely woman, but a lot of damage was done by the 4-5 year period of rebellion.

She's a horror story, of course. Lots of them turn out ok. But I do think you're risking your child going completely wild by giving them absolutely no freedom to make mistakes when they're young.

ChlorineChris · 13/10/2022 10:32

Bootsandcat · 13/10/2022 10:08

I have the ‘typical’ strict Asian parents, very loving but strict. I’m fine, had a bit of a party phase in my 20s, moved overseas (still here) and have a very quiet life working in local government, living in a rural village with husband and two young kids.

Whereas my husband had neglectful parents and no rules growing up, he is not fine and has depression.

I think this is an important point.

Like everything, moderation and gradual transfer of responsibility are key.

My DPs were far more engaged and involved than a lot of my friends' parents but not in a restrictive way. They were interested, available to me and clearly wanted me to feel safe and supported. They cared enough to have the argument about where I was going and who with. It would have been easier to be permissive and just say yes to everything...I grew up completely secure in the knowledge that I was loved and had their back up whenever I needed it. I had a nest to fly from. They gradually gave me more freedom but never withdrew their interest.

DH grew up in a family where the adults were too busy or involved in their own work/life/worries/addictions to either know or care where he and siblings were, nor did they have the time or inclination to give lifts etc. It was not a happy upbringing and much of what he got up to with his peers while unsupervised was not fun but dangerous. He is far more anxious than me!

It's all about balance.

SleeplessInEngland · 13/10/2022 10:29

I wouldn't say my partner's parents were overprotective as such but they were really anxious in general and he's definitely inherited that. He often thinks everyone, eg tradesmen or colleagues, are out to get him. He knows it's silly but an entire childhood of having that mindset reinforced is really hard to break free of.

Quincythequince · 13/10/2022 10:18

Pinpot · 13/10/2022 09:27

My friend was one of these. She's fine - very successful in her career, has high expectations of how she is treated etc. but she is really scared of a lot of things - and wildly overestimates risk in my opinion.

So not really fine then.

ginnybag · 13/10/2022 10:17

Friends raised their kids like this - hobbies decided for them (usually those fitting an image and run by friends) and no other clubs or activities, no real trips anywhere, not allowed out to parties with friends past 10.30, even at 17/18 and with other adults present.

As was predicted, eldest went completely off the rails as soon as they got to Uni - drink, drugs, smoking, one night stands via tinder, the whole thing, all in the first few weeks, and it isn't improving years down the line. Youngest throws temper tantrums a lot, far past an acceptable age, because they can't cope at all with things that don't go their way, and are scared of their own shadow with no tolerance for anything slightly difficult. They've absolutely (also predictably) picked up loads of worrying social media trends, and high school has been a real shock.

It does kids no favours being kept like hothouse flowers. The world isn't kind, and they need gradual exposure to that to develop the strategies and ability to cope with it.

VoluptuaGoodshag · 13/10/2022 10:16

I have a friend who is extremely over protective of her daughter. She is nearly 18 and seems ok but I do wonder about her resilience when she finally leaves home. But not as much as I worry about the friend who is so over involved in her daughter's life that I wonder how she will cope when her daughter moves on.

legophoenix · 13/10/2022 10:15

On the flip side, a relative of mine had parents who just let him get on with things (basically neglected) and he's now a heroin addict/dealer who has had his child removed. He had no real direction or a feeling of belonging. There definitely needs to be a happy medium. Not easy to find what that is as a parent though!

legophoenix · 13/10/2022 10:11

AreYouAFeminist · 13/10/2022 10:04

I don't think you can blame a person's anxiousness on parenting style entirely.

You'll find people who suffer from anxiety and those who are overcautious had parents who had anxiety or were risk averse. It's a personality trait.

I was going to say this too.

Sometimes it's not the overprotectiveness that causes the anxiety.

It's perhaps the anxiety of the child that causes the parent to appear overprotective.

One of my kids has SEN and extreme anxiety. As his parent I know what things he can cope with and what he can't - I probably appear overprotective to outsiders who don't know our situation. But in his case it's not OVER protection, it's just protection against sensory overload, meltdown etc. Most of the time he's making the decision not to do something and I just back him up.

It makes me wonder if a lot of these anxious adults were in the same situation as kids. Sometimes it's nothing the parent has done wrong.

Bootsandcat · 13/10/2022 10:08

I have the ‘typical’ strict Asian parents, very loving but strict. I’m fine, had a bit of a party phase in my 20s, moved overseas (still here) and have a very quiet life working in local government, living in a rural village with husband and two young kids.

Whereas my husband had neglectful parents and no rules growing up, he is not fine and has depression.

SallyWD · 13/10/2022 10:08

My friend is insanely overprotective of her 14 year old DD. The girl can't walk anywhere on her own. My friend works at a school as a lunchtime supervisor. She's out of the house for 1.5 hours only. If her DD has an inset day she'll take her to work with her, despite the fact HER HUSBAND IS WORKING FROM HOME!! So the girl wouldn't even be left alone in the house (which I think is fine at 14), she'd just be unsupervised as her dad's working upstairs. I feel really sorry for the child. She never wants to do anything or go anywhere with friends - maybe that's just how she is. I can't help thinking it's because her mum's made her terrified of the world.

loveisanopensore · 13/10/2022 10:07

My Dad was ridiculously over protective. As I had two older brothers I could see the difference in the way I was treated.
I lied so much as a teenager, still at 40 tell my parents very little. Its not worth the hassle.

AreYouAFeminist · 13/10/2022 10:04

I don't think you can blame a person's anxiousness on parenting style entirely.

You'll find people who suffer from anxiety and those who are overcautious had parents who had anxiety or were risk averse. It's a personality trait.

MeowMeowPowerRangers · 13/10/2022 10:01

I'm overprotective of my son, he has autism and adhd though. He's growing up fine. Grin

I had to much freedom as a teen and completely went off the rails onto drugs and booze.
Was an addict for a long time (now clean and sober!) so to much freedom can be a bad thing as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread