Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how the kids of very overprotective parents turned out?

142 replies

Uncleebz · 13/10/2022 09:25

To be honest I can see the pros and cons (don’t have kids myself) of insulating your children from risk. However, my friend has a son who’s 14 and the rules he has are insane (eg not allowed to go anywhere on his own with friends unless accompanied by an adult). It got me thinking do you know any adults who were very overprotected as a kid (or are you one) how did it work out for them? What are they like now as adults?

OP posts:
legophoenix · 13/10/2022 14:22

MadWorId · 13/10/2022 13:58

My mother was ridiculously overprotective. I wasn't allowed to walk to school alone until I was in sixth form. I couldn't go into town with my friends on a Saturday afternoon until I was 17 and then only for two hours. When my friends started turning 18, if they invited me to their parties I was allowed to go for the start time and I had to leave an hour later. That way my mother could say I'd shown my face and that she'd allowed me to go when I complained that I wasn't allowed to do anything. She would wait outside the venue for me for the full hour after walking me there, and then she'd walk me home (this was only for places like our local community centre hall or someone's house if parents were present, I wasn't allowed to go to parties in clubs or anything). There was one venue in particular that lots of my friends had their 18th parties at and she would stand outside the main window and look in for the whole hour. In the end I was so embarrassed I stopped going, and the invitations dried up anyway. I was bullied for years at school for being a weirdo.

I wasn't allowed to go to the cinema with friends until I was 17 and she did the waiting outside thing for the whole film - at one point I went to the toilet and I could hear her talking to my brother outside (old fashioned local cinema with windows that opened onto the street). She often used to bring my younger brother with her to wait with her 'for company'. I wasn't allowed on school trips, to stay in for lunch at school for clubs, no school discos as I got older, no sleepovers.

Then she got a boyfriend and literally overnight my brother (three years younger than me) and I were left to our own devices. To say we made up for lost time is an understatement. We went from having our every move monitored to my mother not giving the tiniest shit about what we got up to. I went off the rails massively. I ended up with a drink problem, and got myself into some awful and very dangerous situations. I had had no guidance whatsoever as to how to 'adult'. Some of the things that happened to me still have repercussions decades later. It took me years to get my life on a slightly even keel.

I had to be so, so careful when DD was younger. So many times I had to stop myself from being overprotective myself, or going too far the other way to prove to myself I wasn't like my mother. Thankfully I had DH to guide me (his upbringing had its issues but his parents were never overprotective and were quite healthy in that respect). DD has turned out fine and there haven't been any issues but my god it was hard.

Funnily enough, when I was much older my mother completely denied she had been overprotective at all and claimed that I was a juvenile delinquent who she couldn't control, and all my issues were my own fault. She was so convincing that sometimes I doubted my own version of events. But other people I knew from back then, and relatives too, reminded me of what she was really like.

Wow. That sounds borderline terrifying. Glad to hear you go through it ok.

legophoenix · 13/10/2022 14:22

Mommabear20 · 13/10/2022 13:44

My SIL is a VERY helicopter parent, her DS is only 2, but is already very clingy to mum because he's never been allowed to be without her.

Not hugely unusual for a parent of a 2 yr old

VioletInsolence · 13/10/2022 14:21

I don’t think you can blame every personality trait on parents. Mine were somewhere in the middle but I’m an anxious mess because I’m autistic. I’d they’d been more involved (in a good way) that wouldn’t have been a bad thing. It’s about meeting a child’s needs.

I’m over-protective but my son is autistic so he’s quite happy for me to take him to college and collect him. I tell him that I’m an idiot and know he’s capable of doing things for himself. He doesn’t want to go out and doesn’t want to drink. I don’t really have rules because we don’t need them. He’s very good at self-regulation. I know I’m starting to irritate him a bit but I hope he appreciates that I’m a very honest, open person and there’s nothing he can’t talk to me about. I’d never try to control his life so I don’t think he has any reason to rebel.

MadWorId · 13/10/2022 13:58

My mother was ridiculously overprotective. I wasn't allowed to walk to school alone until I was in sixth form. I couldn't go into town with my friends on a Saturday afternoon until I was 17 and then only for two hours. When my friends started turning 18, if they invited me to their parties I was allowed to go for the start time and I had to leave an hour later. That way my mother could say I'd shown my face and that she'd allowed me to go when I complained that I wasn't allowed to do anything. She would wait outside the venue for me for the full hour after walking me there, and then she'd walk me home (this was only for places like our local community centre hall or someone's house if parents were present, I wasn't allowed to go to parties in clubs or anything). There was one venue in particular that lots of my friends had their 18th parties at and she would stand outside the main window and look in for the whole hour. In the end I was so embarrassed I stopped going, and the invitations dried up anyway. I was bullied for years at school for being a weirdo.

I wasn't allowed to go to the cinema with friends until I was 17 and she did the waiting outside thing for the whole film - at one point I went to the toilet and I could hear her talking to my brother outside (old fashioned local cinema with windows that opened onto the street). She often used to bring my younger brother with her to wait with her 'for company'. I wasn't allowed on school trips, to stay in for lunch at school for clubs, no school discos as I got older, no sleepovers.

Then she got a boyfriend and literally overnight my brother (three years younger than me) and I were left to our own devices. To say we made up for lost time is an understatement. We went from having our every move monitored to my mother not giving the tiniest shit about what we got up to. I went off the rails massively. I ended up with a drink problem, and got myself into some awful and very dangerous situations. I had had no guidance whatsoever as to how to 'adult'. Some of the things that happened to me still have repercussions decades later. It took me years to get my life on a slightly even keel.

I had to be so, so careful when DD was younger. So many times I had to stop myself from being overprotective myself, or going too far the other way to prove to myself I wasn't like my mother. Thankfully I had DH to guide me (his upbringing had its issues but his parents were never overprotective and were quite healthy in that respect). DD has turned out fine and there haven't been any issues but my god it was hard.

Funnily enough, when I was much older my mother completely denied she had been overprotective at all and claimed that I was a juvenile delinquent who she couldn't control, and all my issues were my own fault. She was so convincing that sometimes I doubted my own version of events. But other people I knew from back then, and relatives too, reminded me of what she was really like.

WrongWayApricot · 13/10/2022 13:55

Not great for me but could be a bad combination of mental health, ND and overprotective parenting. I was determined my kids would be brought up differently. That's not going so well since I gave birth to a lemming. Finding it really hard to find a good balance.

Mommabear20 · 13/10/2022 13:44

My SIL is a VERY helicopter parent, her DS is only 2, but is already very clingy to mum because he's never been allowed to be without her.

murmuration · 13/10/2022 13:35

Ugh, just lost a long post.

anyway, quick version: I turned out okay but have had to learn a lot of things late. Like how to take a bus/train, shop in a supermarket, etc. It’s mostly just embarrassing.

I wasn’t allowed to do anything but be at school and home. I tried once to get a job aged 15-16 but my parents found my applications and tore them up and I was never allowed out alone after that. I really resent my lack of life skills.

FarmhouseLiving22 · 13/10/2022 13:30

Yes - a few school friends had very strict or overbearing parents. One went down the "off the rails" route and kept lots of secrets from her parents (she could have ended up in serious trouble including prison or dead some of the things she did to "rebel"), one had crippling anxiety and wasn't very streetwise at all. She could barely cross a road on her own, and I remember once a proper weird guy coming over to her in town and asking her what her plans were for that night and she told him the exact itinerary!!! So we had to change what we were doing as we didn't want this weirdo following us.

I see it with my own kids now. The friends of there's which have overly protective parents who are extremely anxious etc have all sorts of problems with eating and making friends for example

antelopevalley · 13/10/2022 13:28

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/10/2022 13:12

Whereas my husband had neglectful parents and no rules growing up, he is not fine and has depression.

This is really important. Overprotectiveness has obvious drawbacks but there is less focus given to people with very relaxed and permissive parenting approaches and sometimes I think those can be even more dangerous.

I grew up in a town full of wealthy progressive liberals and there was a lot of very performative lax parenting: kids rarely had curfews, underage drinking and taking soft drugs was tolerated from the mid teenage years (or at least a blind eye was turned) and despite the fact this was an academic town with successful parents kids often weren't pushed academically and allowed to go off for years and "find themselves".

I saw an awful lot of my contemporaries go properly off the rails and in some cases develop serious problems with drugs and miss years of education which they never really got back. I can't be sure it was all attributable to this but I'm sure a much higher proportion of these kids "failed", given their demographics.

You do want your kids to learn to take some risks and to start to make their own decisions but if its communicated to children that they don't need to give any consideration to risk whatsoever they lose the sense of self-protection that they need to assess risks properly.

I have to say its made me a much stricter parent with my own daughter.

Like most things the middle way is the best. No one is arguing about allowing your kids to do whatever they want with no rules. That is neglect and sends the clear message you really do not care.
But children grow into adults. You need to slowly let them learn how to navigate the world alone.
I used to work in support staff at a university. Some of the 18-year-olds did not know how to take a train alone. Basic living skills were not always there.

antelopevalley · 13/10/2022 13:23

Protecting people does not decrease anxiety, it increases it.

Mummadeze · 13/10/2022 13:22

It really is a chicken and egg question. Is our DD anxious because we have been so protective towards her. Or are we that way because she is so anxious and in need of protection. Is she immature because we haven’t allowed her to grow up. Or do we treat her like a younger child because she acts like one. She is autistic so it is very hard to pick apart.

morningsareshit · 13/10/2022 13:21

I think that like many things a combination of factors come into play and a child's personality/ disposition is equally as important in how childhood and adulthood relate in an individual.
I do believe though in " generational trauma " and how it is almost impossible for people to be able to break a cycle and to not pass on learnt behaviour completely, to return to the state before an occurrence happened.
When a tragedy occurs in the family it's very difficult to stop it altering behaviour down the generations and sometimes this comes out in ways such as overprotective parenting.

RatherBeRiding · 13/10/2022 13:14

My parents were strict and controlling. I became a very good liar in my late teens and went off the rails a bit once I left home. Lots and lots of very unsuitable relationships etc. I also had no idea how to stand up for myself as I have never been allowed to question their decisions or advocate for myself, and for a long time was a doormat people pleaser.

It has taken me a long time to shake all this off but having my own children was a revelation - I have encouraged them from early childhood to be assertive, to think for themselves, to ask their opinions and explain to them why some things weren't possible rather than reverting to "because I say so", which was all I ever used to hear as a child.

Needless to say they turned out very differently to me - neither felt the need to go off the rails, we have a great relationship, they are confident and outgoing. I suppose my own parents gave me a great template of how NOT to parent in that I grew up determined to never, ever be like that with my own children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/10/2022 13:12

Whereas my husband had neglectful parents and no rules growing up, he is not fine and has depression.

This is really important. Overprotectiveness has obvious drawbacks but there is less focus given to people with very relaxed and permissive parenting approaches and sometimes I think those can be even more dangerous.

I grew up in a town full of wealthy progressive liberals and there was a lot of very performative lax parenting: kids rarely had curfews, underage drinking and taking soft drugs was tolerated from the mid teenage years (or at least a blind eye was turned) and despite the fact this was an academic town with successful parents kids often weren't pushed academically and allowed to go off for years and "find themselves".

I saw an awful lot of my contemporaries go properly off the rails and in some cases develop serious problems with drugs and miss years of education which they never really got back. I can't be sure it was all attributable to this but I'm sure a much higher proportion of these kids "failed", given their demographics.

You do want your kids to learn to take some risks and to start to make their own decisions but if its communicated to children that they don't need to give any consideration to risk whatsoever they lose the sense of self-protection that they need to assess risks properly.

I have to say its made me a much stricter parent with my own daughter.

ThisShipIsSinking · 13/10/2022 12:54

Very judgemental post , you have no idea as to why someone may appear over protective, why not just focus on yourself and mind your own business?

rhowton · 13/10/2022 12:50

My parents were "tell the truth and you can do it" parents and we had lots of freedom. We are close now as adults and see them frequently. My husband had to lie to do anything as even at 16 had to be home at 9pm, so would like about where he was doing and what he was going.

Strict/over protective parents make for sneaky kids IMO.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 13/10/2022 12:46

I have a friend who’s a partner in a consulting firm. A work contact of his was exactly like this - his wife actually studied and took every exam alongside their only son so she could coach him; he had little to no unsupervised independence, they basically chose his uni and course, etc.

The dad arranged summer work experience for the son (who was 18 or 19) at my friend’s company. He literally talked him down the street on the phone to the correct address, then rang my friend on a separate line to ask if he could please leave his meeting to go down and assist, as the boy was panicking because he couldn’t get into the building. I think the problem was a revolving door, and he’d never walked through one before.

Kid was completely NT, just utterly clueless and unable to rationalise situations or make even the simplest decisions for himself, because they’d barely ever allowed him out of their sight.

God alone knows what his outcomes have been but it’s difficult to imagine he’s a happy, functioning adult making his own way in the world.

berksandbeyond · 13/10/2022 11:53

I was one of those kids. I have anxiety and am desperate not to repeat history with my own daughter!

whatshouldIdo2022 · 13/10/2022 11:47

Crippling anxiety, which my mother has and instilled in me. Let her put me off things like going to uni, travelling, stayed near to her so she wouldn't have to worry about me. Went off the rails as a teenager and spent the next 15 years binge drinking to manage my anxiety, being exploited by older men and trashing my life being a drunken mess. None of which actually bothered my mum as she only likes to worry about what MIGHT happen not what is actually happening. Now she has turned her anxiety to my 2 year old and I get a constant dripdripdrip of 'do you really think she ought to be doing/eating/having that'. It gives me the absolute rage thinking what she made me miss out on and how my life could have turned out if she had instilled confidence not fear into me and hell will freeze over before I let her affect my daughter in the same way. She basically tries to control my choices so that they cause her minimal anxiety.

WireSkills · 13/10/2022 11:36

TeeBee · 13/10/2022 11:30

My son has a couple of friends with overprotective parents. One is refusing to go to uni as he doesn't think he can cope living away from home. The other is so heavily-regulated that if he comes over to hang out with his mates, his mother will text me to say he can only have one alcoholic drink and that if he wants more, I have to call her!! Like I'm sitting their monitoring a bunch of 18-year olds. Of course, he's the one in any situation who is getting smashed out of his skull while everyone else drinks generally in moderation.

Regarding anxiety, I do think that our children take our queue from us. If they see us scared about the world, they will think it's something to be scared of.

I was listening to the SMA podcast the other day and they made reference to the fact that it was the girls whose parents were too overprotective re boys (not allowing them in their house, etc) that were the ones that were shagging around, more than the ones whose parents allowed them to have their boyfriends over.

I remember when I was a teenager (16-17) and some of my mates were meeting up in a park to drink cheap WKD's and cider. They asked another of my friends to join them and she replied "nah, you're alright thanks - my Mum lets me have some decent alcohol at home, so there's no point in me freezing my tits off on a bench drinking that cheap shite"!

As the PP who is a social worker said, there's examples of each end of the scale no matter whether a parent is overprotective, or not protective enough.

Hearthnhome · 13/10/2022 11:34

My Mum was extremely over protective. Even checked on me in my sleep until left home at 19. She saw her brother die when he was a baby and had quite severe mental health problems. These things impacted how she acted quite a lot.

I had a quiet rebellion. My life is very different from the one she planned for me. I have no clue why, but it’s not impacted me hugely. I did move out young (19) and got my own place and made my own space. Once I moved out I put boundaries in place to stop communicating her risk assessments to me. I made my own decisions. For a while I did have to think very carefully about my thought processes.

With my kids, I am more a ‘give them the information and hope they make good choices’. I gave them as much autonomy as I could, for the age they were. Dd is 18 and it’s worked out so far. Ds is 12 and it’s working out.

Dbro hasn’t done so well. Wasn’t self sufficient at all. Struggles in any professional setting, often couldn’t make a decision at all as he spent so much time trying to work out what’s best. He ended up being a stay at home dad which seems to have improved the situation, though I think he is very overly cautious with his kids and I can see that it’s impacted the oldest one.

TeeBee · 13/10/2022 11:30

My son has a couple of friends with overprotective parents. One is refusing to go to uni as he doesn't think he can cope living away from home. The other is so heavily-regulated that if he comes over to hang out with his mates, his mother will text me to say he can only have one alcoholic drink and that if he wants more, I have to call her!! Like I'm sitting their monitoring a bunch of 18-year olds. Of course, he's the one in any situation who is getting smashed out of his skull while everyone else drinks generally in moderation.

Regarding anxiety, I do think that our children take our queue from us. If they see us scared about the world, they will think it's something to be scared of.

happy66 · 13/10/2022 11:25

My husbands family is like this. On the whole he is fine. But he is underneath quite an anxious and stressed person.

His brother who has high functioning autism has cut himself off from his parents. I couldn’t comment on the whole story as I have never met his brother.

SirBlobby · 13/10/2022 11:21

Hmmm. As a SOcial worker I've worked with both ends of the spectrum.

I've seen kids turn out wonderfully after having far too much freedom, and then turn out with many mental health/attachment issues.
I've seen kids turn out wonderfully under the care of very protective parents, and then the opposite have seen anxious/children with mh needs.

It's too simplistic a divide to make, depends on all other factors and experiences imo.

Apologies for all the grammar/typos! Phone is playing up 😖

sashh · 13/10/2022 11:21

It made me deceitful and resentful.

When you know the answer will be 'no' there is no point asking for permission, so just do it behind your parent's back.

I spent as much time away from my mother as possible.

I spent most of my VI form time wandering around town, had the odd trip to the next town along.

I didn't know how to deal with normal situations or what normal boundaries were.

But it made me independent. I've not moved abroad but I have lived in different parts of the country and I've travelled on my own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread