Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how the kids of very overprotective parents turned out?

142 replies

Uncleebz · 13/10/2022 09:25

To be honest I can see the pros and cons (don’t have kids myself) of insulating your children from risk. However, my friend has a son who’s 14 and the rules he has are insane (eg not allowed to go anywhere on his own with friends unless accompanied by an adult). It got me thinking do you know any adults who were very overprotected as a kid (or are you one) how did it work out for them? What are they like now as adults?

OP posts:
Meadowbreeze · 13/10/2022 16:41

Some of these stories are abuse, not overprotective parents 😔

ParsleyTL · 13/10/2022 16:41

Allthegoodnamestakken · 13/10/2022 09:49

Perhaps not as extreme over protectiveness as some of these stories but I grew up with pretty over protective parents, not allowed out without an adult, not allowed to parties even after turning 18 (still at school). Was driven to and picked up from anywhere I was allowed to go including my weekend job, school etc.
I moved out for university and went wild for 2 years, I had no clue how to drink appropriately because i'd never been allowed so much as a sip in a controlled environment. I let boys treat me terribly because i'd never been allowed to meet them, have a boyfriend in an innocent teenage way etc. so I had no boundaries. I thankfully pulled myself together and passed my degree by 3rd year. I have lived abroad in various countries since graduating, and I think part of the desire to do that was to figure out who I am without having to fit in my parents box.
I am pretty risk adverse but not to an extreme level so I think I have managed to shake that off but one thing I still struggle with is standing up for myself. I am so keen to avoid confrontation of any type I am a complete doormat. Luckily DH is the opposite and not afraid to point out when people are taking advantage.

I could have written almost all of this post!

But, my parents were not at all protective - from age 13 I could stay out as long as I wanted, sleepover where I wanted (no checks 👀), was drinking in the park and smoking dodgy fags by age 15, sleeping with random strangers met at parties by age 17. But, the rest of my life turned out the same as this post.

So I don’t think we should give too much credit to our childhoods for how we turn out 😬

sourcreampringle · 13/10/2022 16:41

Yep there was always one or two people at uni who just went a bit wild, didn’t know their limits with alcohol and had no prior experience with being independent at all which is all a bad recipe!

of course it’s a balancing act but it’s silly to treat a 17-year-old like a small child, be really strict, track their every move if you know they are months away from living independently at uni. Parents job is to help them prepare for that.

MarigoldPetals · 13/10/2022 16:40

OP you do realise that everyone is different? You can’t generalise.

mathanxiety · 13/10/2022 16:39

The two I knew (brother and sister in the same family) never went through the important business of making friends as teens, and never had deep, lasting friendships as adults. It really hobbled them in later life as you can imagine.

They were really only comfortable with other people in highly structured environments, never opened up about problems or feelings. The sister married her first boyfriend, who looked good on paper but turned out to be abusive, and she put up with it for years before a neighbour called police and brought matters to a head. The brother joined the submarine service.

Meadowbreeze · 13/10/2022 16:38

I don't know anyone who was brought up like this but DDs 14 year old best friend is being raised like this. She's riddled with anxiety and whatever the therapist suggests, doesn't get implemented as the mum won't let her. Sadly the friendship is sizzling out as she's not allowed to do anything unless closely supervised by an adult. I'm not about to do that to DD.

Snowpatrolsnowpatrol · 13/10/2022 16:37

It’s a balancing act isn’t it.

If more people would insist on keeping their teens under supervision, we’d have fewer gangs and the social issues.

mynameischloe · 13/10/2022 16:34

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 13/10/2022 09:31

My parents were overbearing, hyper-strict helicopter types. At 16 I went right off the rails before moving out. Spent years living abroad and around the country, and even now I live 4 hours away from my DM because I can't be around her. Such a claustrophobic upbringing did me a lot of damage mentally.

Same.

Pamparam · 13/10/2022 15:22

Yet another who went off the rails a bit as a later teen and got very skilled at lying to my parents. I couldn't wait to get away at 18 and basically didn't speak to my parents for months on end. I calmed down after university and have carried some risk aversion (I think this is inherited rather than instilled) but I am not that close to my parents now. I'm determined to find a happy medium with my kids.

Bllueblazerblack · 13/10/2022 15:16

My MIL is like this and DP doesn't get on with her. Him and his sibling grew up terrified of the world (SIL would take MIL to job interviews with her, couldn't watch her own DC have jabs as she'd sob). SIL children just the same. MIL makes comments about DS eating dangerously 🙄. I had talked about DS walking and how I'll take him to run around. MIL was horrified and kept telling me that DS will fall over. I acknowledged that he would but that he'd learn to get back up. Now if he does fall over unless he's hurt himself, he won't cry. If he does cry, a quick cuddle and he's fine.

HypaHypa · 13/10/2022 15:12

I could have written a lot of these. Especially the one about where the mum was waiting outside looking in. She even used to come and sit inside my dancing class and then critique my performance on the way home. I had no autonomy and was frequently told, 'you can't do that.' Every bit of independence from what clothes I wore to what music I listened to was hard won. I went to university not knowing how to cook, shop, use a washing machine or catch a bus. She even came along to the 1st day and got kicked out.

I did rebel against her rules and expectations but I do feel that I am able to assess risks. Unlike my brother who is in piles of debt, addiction and completely unable to function without my parents.

MadWorId · 13/10/2022 15:09

I let boys treat me terribly because i'd never been allowed to meet them, have a boyfriend in an innocent teenage way etc. so I had no boundaries

This really resonates.

Fallingasleepanywhere · 13/10/2022 15:08

As someone with an overbearing mother it really ruins your life.
Having to be in at 6 at night at age 15 was awful.
I had no friends because I didn't know how to make them.
Something that's still very prevelent today.

I think not being allowed to make mistakes and not being allowed to make decisions makes adult life very hard.

The final straw for me was at 18 I went out with my bf,and came back to my DM incandescent with rage.
Because I went out without her permission.

She slapped me across the face but that was the last straw.
I just done my own thing from then on.

IlIlI · 13/10/2022 15:03

I know a few who I've known since secondary school. Turned out fine generally, apart from 1 who is really anxious all the time, went from controlling parents to controlling abusive men, and worked out very late how to pay bills etc as parent used to control bank accounts to "help" as a teen and just never stopped, well til I kept dropping hints about how nice it would be for her to control her own wages.

It's the whole nature vs nurture thing isn't it? Being raised a certain way doesn't guarantee anything. I know people who had the opposite of controlling parents who still ended up similarly to the one I mentioned above.

TeddyisMydog · 13/10/2022 15:03

My mum only allowed me to sleep in my own bed when I turned 14. Alcohol was a no go, boys not allowed in the house at all
I went off the rails, got blazing drunk every single night, took a lot of drugs, ended up in an abusive relationship as I thought that someone who was over protective was the right quality, ended up becoming a teen mum.

I'm in my late 20s now, I'm riddled with anxiety. Don't have a successful career, I'm not close to my parents at all which saddens me

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 13/10/2022 14:58

One very strict and controlling parent (mum) and one very laid back parent. I rebelled at 15 and the laid back parent actively helped/covered up (they lived together). Lots of unsuitable relationships, drinking far too much, some drugs. Calmed down in my 20s after a traumatic incident saw me hospitalised and later diagnosed with ptsd.

Still suffer from anxiety in new situations but am a mostly functioning adult who has travelled considerably, has multiple degrees, a job and a family.

Strugglingtodomybest · 13/10/2022 14:57

The most overbearing parent I know/knew was DH's uncle. He's dead now, but his two sons, both in their 50s, still live at home with their mum.

The most overbearing parent from my DC's peer group currently has one DD who has gone NC with her, one who is planning to move away as soon as she can, and one who is selling weed.

legophoenix · 13/10/2022 14:50

I hear you. People quite possibly look at my DD and decide I have been over protective, whereas I have parented the child I got given, and actually spent quite a lot of time trying to get her to do more and be more adventurous.

Yep this is my experience too. It's actually exhausting how much I have tried to get DS to be more independent. Yet I still get accused of being overprotective (always by busybodys who know nothing of our situation).

dizzydizzydizzy · 13/10/2022 14:50

Friend's (friend is v controlling) DD went to farthest away uni (to get away from parents) and discovered booze in a big way and regularly gets v drunk. She also spends money like water. My DD went to nearby uni. She has tried alcohol but doesn't particularly like it and sticks to soft drinks and budgets carefully.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 14:44

Certainly NOT unkind.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 14:43

I should say in the families I knew, the parents weren't exactly strict, and certainly unkind. It was just that they lived a certain way and their kids followed their lead in living very cautiously.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 14:40

I knew a few kids like this - it was rare in 1980s Dublin, and we looked on those families as oddballs, but actually they have done well in life. They definitely missed out on fun and adventures, but they also missed out on some mistakes the rest of us made. They generally married young (happily) to similarly cautious/safe types, and remain close to their families.

honeylulu · 13/10/2022 14:34

Personality has a huge bearing. My parents were very strict. I went off the rails in my teens and didn't pull myself together until my early 20s. It was an unhappy time. I didn't really enjoy my rebellion but was trying to find out who I was as there was no autonomy at home. It was just "you will do as you are told".

My younger sister was good as gold. She's a naturally anxious person and was happy to be sheltered and spend all her time with our mum.

I did OK in the end. Good career, married, kids etc. My sister is terrified of life. Prefers to stay home, despite being very academic at school has not really had a career. Won't drive outside her town.

We might have ended up like that anyway but I do think with more balanced parenting I would have skipped much of my unhappy rebellion and my sister might have been encouraged to venture outside her comfort zone a bit more.

TeenDivided · 13/10/2022 14:32

Mummadeze · 13/10/2022 13:22

It really is a chicken and egg question. Is our DD anxious because we have been so protective towards her. Or are we that way because she is so anxious and in need of protection. Is she immature because we haven’t allowed her to grow up. Or do we treat her like a younger child because she acts like one. She is autistic so it is very hard to pick apart.

I hear you. People quite possibly look at my DD and decide I have been over protective, whereas I have parented the child I got given, and actually spent quite a lot of time trying to get her to do more and be more adventurous.

thecathaszerobrains · 13/10/2022 14:27

Growing up I had a friend like this. Her mother was completely OTT and had lots of 'rules' as well. Rules such as my friend was only allowed around to another friends house for homework, she had to ring her mum when she arrived, the mother would ring every hour to check on her. My friend was taken everywhere by her mum (including to school as a 6th former), wasn't allowed to ride a bike and even as a teenager wasn't allowed to use anything in the kitchen or make a cup of tea because it was dangerous. It was almost like her mother was scared of life.

I was the only 'approved' friend that my friend was allowed to be with unsupervised because my mum was deemed as respectable. It was at my house where my friend learned to do things like ride a bike, make a cup of tea, use knives and cook food, wear makeup, drink alcohol, use buses.....
I am forever grateful to my mum who's supplies of lies to my friends mum was never ending- 'yes friend's mum, they're upstairs doing their maths' when in reality we were actually in town.

As soon as she could, my friend moved out, went to uni, got a degree and a husband. She now lives thousands of miles away and is non contact with her mother or indeed the rest of her family.