Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how the kids of very overprotective parents turned out?

142 replies

Uncleebz · 13/10/2022 09:25

To be honest I can see the pros and cons (don’t have kids myself) of insulating your children from risk. However, my friend has a son who’s 14 and the rules he has are insane (eg not allowed to go anywhere on his own with friends unless accompanied by an adult). It got me thinking do you know any adults who were very overprotected as a kid (or are you one) how did it work out for them? What are they like now as adults?

OP posts:
Feelinglikeachange22 · 14/10/2022 07:40

I was over protected. I feel quite angry most of the time ans I think my physical skill sets are less than they would have been. I alao became very rebellious aged 14 and left home as soon as I could at 16.

I am trying to get the balance right with my own children. It's quite tricky.

caroleanboneparte · 14/10/2022 07:24

Mine weren't overprotective, they didn't care, were lax with safety but had very strict rules. 10.30 bedtime until I left home, no boyfriend in room as an adult, virtually no socialising.

I went on a huge partying spree at uni and had the time of my life!

Wasted the studying/learning opportunity.

Someone from school had an anxious DM. Think having to drink from plastic cups instead of glass. She's middle aged and has never been properly independent. Serial monogamist. Lived with mum til 30 ish. Then mum bought her house. She can only work p/time due to her own anxiety. Didn't learn to drive. Too scared to travel. Very small life. It's difficult to separate what if that is being genetically like her mum and what is learned behaviour.

Kitkatcatflap · 13/10/2022 21:24

School friend is over protective - and her children were kept on a tight leash, not allowed to go on playdates (you can't trust people), not allowed class parties, not allowed to go on school over night school trips (too far if anything happens). Never had sleepovers with friends.

Our friendship group were very 'you wait, they will rebel'. When they kick out they will be wild. I remember thinking how 'young' them seemed compared to their peers. The eldest went to a local university, so she could live at home and commute in. She has finished university, 24, an intern but still living at home. She is a delightful girl, she seems well balanced and is close to her parents. She doesn't seem resentful at all. She has a boyfriend and they have been on holiday and weekends away but he is not allowed to stay over. Her sister is still at school but her life is as strict as her sister's was - time will tell with her.

theresastormcoming · 13/10/2022 21:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

GeorgeorRuth · 13/10/2022 20:29

I was a 70s child brought up by a wonderful grandmother, but..she was a strange mix of contradictions. From 8 or 9 we walked the mile to school, rode bikes, played out. As I said on another thread I had the confidence to go to a cafe and buy a drink and cake.
The flip side was not allowed to use knives until I was well into adulthood , no concept of any danger from strangers. Struggled to assess risk, no climbing to the top of a climbing frame..we might fall.
I have only ever travelled on a train on my one once. I have no idea how to book a flight.
University wasn't even a discussion. I wouldn't have had the confidence anyway.
My social skills even now aren't that great. I'm either over the top or deeply unsure of myself.

Fallingasleepanywhere · 13/10/2022 20:05

murmuration · 13/10/2022 19:51

See, I was going to say the opposite. I remember talking with other kids in primary. By secondary we had a 20 minute lunch break where no one sat with the weird kid who never was allowed to do anything outside of school, and a 10 minute break which was barely enough time to make it to your locker and swap out books. One quarter I had an art class where I got to speak to other kids. I really liked it. But I wasn’t allowed to continue art as it wasn’t educational enough or something for my parents.

By secondary we had a 20 minute lunch break where no one sat with the weird kid who never was allowed to do anything outside of school,

That was/is me im still the weird kid deep down.

murmuration · 13/10/2022 19:53

murmuration · 13/10/2022 19:51

See, I was going to say the opposite. I remember talking with other kids in primary. By secondary we had a 20 minute lunch break where no one sat with the weird kid who never was allowed to do anything outside of school, and a 10 minute break which was barely enough time to make it to your locker and swap out books. One quarter I had an art class where I got to speak to other kids. I really liked it. But I wasn’t allowed to continue art as it wasn’t educational enough or something for my parents.

Fuck. It has literally just occurred to me that maybe they made me stop art because I got to talk to other kids for a whole hour?

murmuration · 13/10/2022 19:51

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 19:39

If my recollection of secondary school is correct, there are many social interactions where no adult is remotely present Grin

See, I was going to say the opposite. I remember talking with other kids in primary. By secondary we had a 20 minute lunch break where no one sat with the weird kid who never was allowed to do anything outside of school, and a 10 minute break which was barely enough time to make it to your locker and swap out books. One quarter I had an art class where I got to speak to other kids. I really liked it. But I wasn’t allowed to continue art as it wasn’t educational enough or something for my parents.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 19:39

If my recollection of secondary school is correct, there are many social interactions where no adult is remotely present Grin

antelopevalley · 13/10/2022 19:28

Being with kids when there are adults around ready to intervene is different from being with kids without that intervention.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 19:27

You miss social cues,making friends,keeping friends.Bounderies,how to read situations.

If a child is kept at home and not allowed go to school, this could happen. But if a child is going to school day in day out for at least 10 years, most will use the opportunity to do all the things above (barring neglect, abuse etc).

Fallingasleepanywhere · 13/10/2022 19:11

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 18:53

So I don’t think we should give too much credit to our childhoods for how we turn out 😬

I really agree with this. It is so easy to look back and attribute everything to parenting, but the truth is more complex. Barring extreme experiences, we are who we are, to a great extent.

I dont attribute everything to my dm being overprotective.
But theres no denying the harm it did either.
You miss social cues,making friends,keeping friends.
Bounderies,how to read situations.

Like its hard to know social situations when older if you didnt experience them when younger.

antelopevalley · 13/10/2022 19:09

AcrossthePond55 · 13/10/2022 17:37

My friend was very overprotective of her both her son and daughter, but especially her daughter. They're in their 30s now and her DS is absolutely fearless, confident, and has made and followed his own career path. Her DD is fearful, lacks confidence, and is stymied in her career because she feels that everything about her employment should be completely safe and risk free.

I think how a child turns out has more to do with their innate personality.

I think parenting can nurture or help children overcome personality traits. So someone naturally anxious can be made more anxious by parenting or taught how to manage anxiety.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/10/2022 18:53

So I don’t think we should give too much credit to our childhoods for how we turn out 😬

I really agree with this. It is so easy to look back and attribute everything to parenting, but the truth is more complex. Barring extreme experiences, we are who we are, to a great extent.

AssumingDirectControl · 13/10/2022 18:19

I was wrapped in cotton wool, never allowed out with friends even to the park over the road until I was around 15.

It messed me up socially. I simply had no social skills, which in turn led to bullying and self harm. I was actively suicidal in my early teens. I was too afraid to go to university although I had offers, I took a safe office job instead of the trainee lawyer position I was offered, and when I hit 18 I took stupid risks and slept with people in dodgy situations just to feel wanted and doing what I thought “normal” people did.

Now in middle age I’m emotionally healthy and settled, but it caused me massive issues for years.

AcrossthePond55 · 13/10/2022 17:37

My friend was very overprotective of her both her son and daughter, but especially her daughter. They're in their 30s now and her DS is absolutely fearless, confident, and has made and followed his own career path. Her DD is fearful, lacks confidence, and is stymied in her career because she feels that everything about her employment should be completely safe and risk free.

I think how a child turns out has more to do with their innate personality.

MadWorId · 13/10/2022 17:28

My mother constantly told me that I'd amount to nothing so I'd be better off just accepting I was a 'homebody'. I was told that ambition was unfeminine. That I would never hold down a job because I wasn't made that way. She said holidays weren't for the likes of me when I told her I wanted to travel when I was older, also cars weren't safe and only for rich stupid people. I've still never been on holiday or learned to drive.

She kept me and my brother home from school for weeks on end - the education officer was always knocking on the door. She told school we were sickly and had every bug going when there was absolutely nothing wrong with us. Again she denied this later and said she always sent us to school, if we skived it wasn't her fault - but she always walked us to school, right up until I was 16, so she knew full well we hadn't gone. She was often 'out walking' past school at hometime when I was in sixth form too. Imagine being 17 and your mum walking you home from school.

But I digress... I believe now that the whole 'you'll never have a job/husband/life' was a way of demeaning me and making me believe I was a lost cause, so I'd stay with her.

I do think it affected me more than I realised for a long time and definitely had far reaching consequences. I'm in my late 40s now and have no friends or family (mum and dad are both long dead and I've not had contact with any wider family for years. DB and I haven't spoken for years either and aren't likely to again). I was divorced twice by the age of 26 and all my relationships until I met DH were abusive in some way. As a PP said, I had no boundaries and didn't know what was normal. And I was always so ridiculously grateful that someone wanted me - it didn't matter if they treated me like shit.

RampantIvy · 13/10/2022 17:24

I sometimes wonder if some of the parents on a Facebook page I follow have been over protective. Their DC are at university and a fair few aren't coping at all, and neither are their student DC.

Downtown123 · 13/10/2022 17:16

A poor girl I know has left school with not one qualification (mainly because her mum liked her being at home) and works at the cafe her mum works at. Has hardly any social life as friends have stopped asking her to go out as it was always a no or she was embarrassed with her Mum or dad taking her and picking her up early. I think it’s abusive as this child has no idea of the real world because she has been so protected over everything. I also doubt she will ever move out and live her life as they all live with the mums parents. Very weird setup.

Glo1988 · 13/10/2022 17:15

I ended up incredibly anxious, overestimating risk, thought I couldn’t cope on my own. 6 months of therapy sorted it

Meadowbreeze · 13/10/2022 17:13

@CarefreeMe that's really interesting. I was the same. Me and my siblings were feral. I'm not too protective but I do want to know where DD14 is going, I don't like her walking around aimlessly after school etc. I prefer she doesn't carry cash and she isn't allowed her phone in bed. I feel like I was exposed to so much so soon and I want to protect her and make sure she has a childhood for as long as possible.
She does have a friend with super strict parents and that poor child is not allowed to do anything. Her parents have installed some nanny cam on her phone and they can see who texts her what etc. It's insane.

CarefreeMe · 13/10/2022 17:03

My parents were the opposite.
I literally had no rules and was basically feral.

Because of this I know how dangerous life (and men) can be and I will admit I am pretty overprotective of my own child now.

I am not strict but I do worry if she goes out with friends and I don’t know where she is etc but she is also autistic so she’s a very trusting and can be naive.

I am making a conscious effort to loosen the reins though now she is 14.

LightDrizzle · 13/10/2022 17:00

I wasn’t, but a friend and classmate of my daughter was. Lovely, lovely parents but so overprotective. I’ve known her since she was 5.
It’impossible to know if they are linked but despite getting a degree in a good subject, she struggles with working full time and has very poor (diagnosed) mental health problems.

FoxCorner · 13/10/2022 16:57

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 13/10/2022 09:44

My daughter has a friend with parents like this. Its exhausting trying to arrange things because the parents expect so much.

A sleep over at our house meant a 20 minute call with the girls Mum to discuss everything from if we smoke or intend to drink, to what our fire escape plans are. She also gives us a list of emergency numbers. Then the actual sleepover had her calling every hour and insisting on a long drawn out "good night" phone call with their daughter. Followed by a call to us detailing exactly what her daughters bedtime routine is.....they're 13!!

We ignored the "rules" and the girls ate too much sugar, stayed up too late, and had a blast

I think if you protect your kids from all risk and independence, you're just setting up kids to be anxious, naive adults. I see on here people who wont leave their children alone in the house at 13/14 years old for even a couple of hours!

Dd had a friend like this. The girl was nice but i found it such a relief when she moved and I didn't have to deal with the exhausting parents any more.

Fe345fleur · 13/10/2022 16:49

Long story short I no longer speak to them.