Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Let-to-buy mortgage refused - broker at fault?

36 replies

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 09:35

Realise you can’t be complacent with the financial situation as it is but I was confident I would secure a reasonable deal.

LTV is c 35%; I have no debts other than mortgage; Credit rating is high (999 on Experian); regular use of a credit card which is paid off monthly. Take home salary is over £2000.

Tenant has moved in - done through an agent, standard tenancy agreement, 18 months @ £1700 which easily covers mortgage and expenses.

I’m moving in with my partner so not buying another property and this apparently is the problem for many lenders. Broker selected Leek as according to her they are one of the few for whom this wouldn’t be a barrier and now - after 8 weeks of waiting - I’ve been told they won’t give me the 5 year fix I was originally offered because I’m not buying. Have offered a discounted tracker instead.

At no point have I been asked for any proof that I have a tenant despite the broker saying the lender’s concern is that I will be living in the property.

AIBU in thinking I’ve been massively let down by the broker and is there any point in contacting the building soc myself?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 12:13

Theonewiththecandles · 12/10/2022 12:09

I worked for years for a major high street mortgage lender. Let to buy has nothing to do with whether you release equity or not, it's simply moving out of a residential property and converting it into a rental property and buy another one
The area where you might have problems is the lender asking if you ever intend to live there again (which may very well be the case if you were to split up with your partner) and some will refuse if you state your intention is yes I intend to move back there.
However if you say no, because I doubt you intend to break up with your partner, it should all be good BUT it will come under regulated buy to let which can be more tricky as the standard buy to let (find a house, buy it with the sole intention of renting it out) isn't regulated, but accidental landlords (usually termed consumer buy to let) are regulated which is probably why they've offered a different rate because it's a different type of contract

Thanks candles, that’s really helpful. The question is - was the broker at fault for suggesting that a product with that lender? To me the point of going through a broker is so you don’t waste weeks applying for something for which you don’t meet the criteria. Assuming you van back up all your financials etc, which I have done

OP posts:
Theonewiththecandles · 12/10/2022 12:09

I worked for years for a major high street mortgage lender. Let to buy has nothing to do with whether you release equity or not, it's simply moving out of a residential property and converting it into a rental property and buy another one
The area where you might have problems is the lender asking if you ever intend to live there again (which may very well be the case if you were to split up with your partner) and some will refuse if you state your intention is yes I intend to move back there.
However if you say no, because I doubt you intend to break up with your partner, it should all be good BUT it will come under regulated buy to let which can be more tricky as the standard buy to let (find a house, buy it with the sole intention of renting it out) isn't regulated, but accidental landlords (usually termed consumer buy to let) are regulated which is probably why they've offered a different rate because it's a different type of contract

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 11:55

According to the broker the issue is that I’m moving but not taking on a mortgage so their concern is that I will actually be living in the property. Despite the fact I have a tenant - arranged through an agent - who has signed a tenancy agreement, paid a deposit, first month’s rent etc

OP posts:
NamelessNancy · 12/10/2022 11:46

I don't see why the fact you already own it should prevent a remortgage as BTL. When a property which was initially bought as a BTL is remortgaged with another lender it is already owned? Don't see how that's any different to your situation.

BirdIsland · 12/10/2022 11:36

You definitely need a BTL, I have a very similar situation save for I do have a mortgage on the house I live in too.

Be warned, some lenders are very strict about BTL criteria if you are looking for interest only. I remortgaged earlier this year with the bank I do all my banking with, so know me very well, I have perfect credit rating and they almost refused me a BTL mortgage on a piddly amount because I didn't have a 'repayment plan' - the plan of selling the house didn't count, and they would only acknowledge one third of the value of a S&S ISA. I eventually had to negotiate with them based on the monthly payment as against my monthly income (less than 5%!) and they relented.

My advice would be to get a better broker or just make the application yourself, but asap as rates are changing daily. It does seem like your broker just got it wrong.

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 11:35

No - but the BS are aware - basically they give you a grace period when you tell them that you’re remortgaging and they said it would be fine if there was an overlap.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 12/10/2022 11:26

So does the current mortgage you have actually allow you to have a tenant in your property ?

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 11:05

It’s just so gutting as they kept telling me it was just a slow process and interest rates have gone up twice since I started. Definitely going to complain but not sure it will change my situation given rates have gone up.

also worried about starting again with a new lender as having had one rejected will presumably harm my credit rating

OP posts:
NoseyNellie · 12/10/2022 10:56

Escalate your complaint with the brokerage - sounds like he’s given bad/wrong advice. Before going elsewhere I would see if a formal complaint to his boss sorts this

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2022 10:56

I was exactly the sane situation as you and found it difficult too. In the end, I found I could go with Birmingham Midshire. I found them myself but could only deal with them through a broker who was crap, but that's another matter. I got a 3 year fix with them. After the 3 years, went directly with NatWest, got a much better deal and the process was efficient and very quick. Got a 5 year fix deal.

Do your own research. Many brokers are really not the experts they claim to be.

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:54

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:44

Thanks to everyone who is replying! Really appreciate it!

i did some comparisons back at the beginning which is why I decided to remortgage as there were much better rates than those being offered by my current provider - Nationwide. There were also some restrictions around what would happen at the end of the term

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/10/2022 10:48

Let to Buy is when you're releasing funds from your residential property, which you will then let, to buy another. If you're not, then you're just either moving onto a Buy to Let rate or you are getting permission to let, which is normally a short term thing.

Your broker is wrong here, you should be moving onto a Buy to let rate.

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:47

OP just to say that I think I had a similar problem

Brokers seem to expect us, the customers, to know what product we want and what the industry calls it

I tried to explain wanting a let to buy, when I was really was planning on doing let to buy, and was greeted by bafflement with a few brokers. London & country seemed to know their stuff. But generally no one did.

you are trying to convert a residential mortgage to a buy to let though, I think. But it's frustrating that we are now expected to know what the banks would have given advice on in the past.

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:44

Well I told the broker the rental yield and also answered all the questions they asked about my income / expenditure. I enquired about a BTL - it was the broker who said let to buy - and confirmed this was correct when I queried it

Make a complaint then. Sounds like they applied for the wrong product and you would never have qualified for that rate.

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:44

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:40

I live in and own a property; decide to move in with partner so rent property out with no need to buy another property.

It’s not that unusual a situation. But most people doing this just get permission to let from their existing residential mortgage lender. It’s usually granted for a time-limited period e.g. 3 years and adds a couple of per cent to the mortgage rate. That still usually works out cheaper than a new BTL mortgage. And it’s usually the pragmatic choice because what if your new relationship goes tits up and you want t life back in - you can’t on a BTL mortgage. Or you want to sell the flat to buy a new property with your boyfriend in a few years. That’s why most mortgage companies do the permission to let thing, as it’s most pragmatic for most people.

I do think the issue might be in how the mortgages are being calculated - on a BTL yield basis or on a personal income-multiple basis. You should clarify that.

There’s loads of BTL mortgage comparison services if you Google - money supermarket etc. Stick your details in there and see what rates you are offered on a BTL basis.

Thanks to everyone who is replying! Really appreciate it!

OP posts:
Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:41

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:32

Sorry, on the 35% LTV. You’re saying you have a great deal of equity (e.g. flat worth £100K, mortgage needed 35K)? Is that right? Which obviously wouldn’t be an issue at all.

Well I told the broker the rental yield and also answered all the questions they asked about my income / expenditure. I enquired about a BTL - it was the broker who said let to buy - and confirmed this was correct when I queried it

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:40

I live in and own a property; decide to move in with partner so rent property out with no need to buy another property.

It’s not that unusual a situation. But most people doing this just get permission to let from their existing residential mortgage lender. It’s usually granted for a time-limited period e.g. 3 years and adds a couple of per cent to the mortgage rate. That still usually works out cheaper than a new BTL mortgage. And it’s usually the pragmatic choice because what if your new relationship goes tits up and you want t life back in - you can’t on a BTL mortgage. Or you want to sell the flat to buy a new property with your boyfriend in a few years. That’s why most mortgage companies do the permission to let thing, as it’s most pragmatic for most people.

I do think the issue might be in how the mortgages are being calculated - on a BTL yield basis or on a personal income-multiple basis. You should clarify that.

There’s loads of BTL mortgage comparison services if you Google - money supermarket etc. Stick your details in there and see what rates you are offered on a BTL basis.

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:34

Talia99 · 12/10/2022 10:29

Doesn’t 35% mean she’s paid off 65%? If so, that sounds pretty good after 15 years.

Yes - my mortgage is £155,000 against value £435 - 450,000. Rent is £1700 pcm so surely figures are good?

OP posts:
Shamoo · 12/10/2022 10:34

You need a buy to let. I did a let to buy when we moved because we remortgaged the old house to take equity for the new one, and then rented out the old one. That’s let to buy. Once we had moved, when it became time to remortgage the old house again (fix ended), it became a buy to let mortgage.

My friend has just rented out her place and moved into a rental, with a buy to let.

Talia99 · 12/10/2022 10:33

I have to agree, I can’t see how this is a let to buy, since you aren’t buying anything.

It sounds like a fairly standard buy to let where the issue is whether the rent and your other income covers the mortgage.

You may have grounds for a complaint against the broker. If I’m not wrong about the way the mortgages work (and I may be, I’m no expert), he’s gone for completely the wrong sort of mortgage.

I would assume a let to buy has better rates because there are two properties for security? The let property and the bought property?

NKFell · 12/10/2022 10:33

Angelicapickles1 · 12/10/2022 10:14

Yeah that's a btl mortgage you need as you are paying a mortgage to let it out. LtB you use the money from the mortgage to pay for another property but the amount borrowed is based on rental amounts and not salary like a standard mortgage.

I came to say this. So I'll just quote instead!

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:32

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:26

I think the issue might be that you want to use your income in the mortgage calculation (residential mortgage), rather than the rental yield (BTL).

You need to be clear what you’re asking the broker to do and why.

Presumably the rental yield on your flat is not high enough for a BTL mortgage? After 15 years I’m surprised you only have 35% LTV - that could be part of the problem.

Sorry, on the 35% LTV. You’re saying you have a great deal of equity (e.g. flat worth £100K, mortgage needed 35K)? Is that right? Which obviously wouldn’t be an issue at all.

Paintedocean · 12/10/2022 10:30

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 09:52

I can’t tell if it’s the broker at fault or you have miscommunicated somehow because you should never have been trying to get a let to buy mortgage.

thanks NoSquirrels - the broker was 100% clear about my situation, which surely can’t be that unusual…

I live in and own a property; decide to move in with partner so rent property out with no need to buy another property.

I queried it with the broker and they reassured me that let to buy was appropriate for my situation and that BTL wasn’t as I already owned the property.

hope you don’t mind me asking - do you have professional knowledge of this?

OP posts:
Talia99 · 12/10/2022 10:29

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:26

I think the issue might be that you want to use your income in the mortgage calculation (residential mortgage), rather than the rental yield (BTL).

You need to be clear what you’re asking the broker to do and why.

Presumably the rental yield on your flat is not high enough for a BTL mortgage? After 15 years I’m surprised you only have 35% LTV - that could be part of the problem.

Doesn’t 35% mean she’s paid off 65%? If so, that sounds pretty good after 15 years.

NoSquirrels · 12/10/2022 10:26

I think the issue might be that you want to use your income in the mortgage calculation (residential mortgage), rather than the rental yield (BTL).

You need to be clear what you’re asking the broker to do and why.

Presumably the rental yield on your flat is not high enough for a BTL mortgage? After 15 years I’m surprised you only have 35% LTV - that could be part of the problem.