Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partners sleeping on maternity ward?

420 replies

Jaaxe · 11/10/2022 21:40

I’m due a csection in December, it’s not my first csection so I know birth recovery especially csection isn’t a walk in the park with a newborn and that having your partner in the hospital is helpful and good for bonding but aibu to think partners shouldn't be allowed to stay overnight to sleep in the bays alongside all the other female patients overnight? A side room is fine with me but a bay with other female patients at their most vulnerable, no thanks. I think the flexible visiting during the day is great but having partners camped next to your bed with just a curtain between is a no from me. Aibu?

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 13/10/2022 16:40

most men don’t really know how to support women in really stressful circumstances

That seems like a sweeping generalisation and not something that I recognise from my own life experience whatsoever.

Blossomtoes · 13/10/2022 16:36

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 16:32

A week of being looked after was bloody lovely. Most second timers didn’t want to go home.

😂

The difference being that you said you got looked after. Most women on Maternity wards don’t have that luxury 😂

Precisely. Which is the point I’ve been making all along. Maternity services have deteriorated beyond all recognition in 40 odd years.

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 16:32

A week of being looked after was bloody lovely. Most second timers didn’t want to go home.

😂

The difference being that you said you got looked after. Most women on Maternity wards don’t have that luxury 😂

Blossomtoes · 13/10/2022 16:28

And I doubt any woman would want to spend 10 days in a maternity ward even if they had the choice

A week of being looked after was bloody lovely. Most second timers didn’t want to go home. .

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 15:07

Although I went home fairly soon (for those days) if the care was better, I would now think that 10 days minimum would be really good.

In my Trust you can go home as early as 6 hours after birth. Most women are discharged within 24-36 hours.

There is absolutely no way a ward can allow for 10 days stay when they need beds forest other women. It just wouldn’t happen.

And I doubt any woman would want to spend 10 days in a maternity ward even if they had the choice.

Goldbar · 13/10/2022 15:05

As pp have highlighted, a large part of the problem of course is that many wards (even some built fairly recently) are still designed for a different era of patient care.... i.e. most care, including personal care, being provided by midwives/nurses, babies being whipped away overnight to a nursery so mothers can sleep and fathers kicked out after (fairly short) visiting hours. You can see that in the design of many bays where cots are crammed in between the beds and fathers keep disturbing their partners' neighbours' curtains because there isn't enough space even for chairs really. And the staff have trouble getting round them to access patients and patients don't really even have space to get out of bed to go to the toilet when visitors are there. Regardless of the debate as to whether men should be allowed to stay on maternity wards, I think some hospitals need to acknowledge that actually they don't have the space or facilities to enable this safely or with dignity. And that's something women could then take into account when deciding where to give birth.

Confusion101 · 13/10/2022 14:57

I would now think that 10 days minimum would be really good.

@Ramblingnamechanger 10 days in hospital??? I mean a properly staffed 3 days would be a great start! I would absolutely crack up for 10 days (assuming everything went OK obviously). They were going to let me out on day 2 and changed their minds and I was devastated!

Ramblingnamechanger · 13/10/2022 14:51

This thread is a real eye opener to someone who had a baby 45 years ago. I am deeply shocked by the state maternity services are in. I can see why some women might think having a partner there to prop up the system would help but really most men don’t really know how to support women in really stressful circumstances, even if they aren’t actively dangerous to their partners or other women on the ward.. women must keep campaigning to improve staffing and services to ensure that we and the babies are safe. Just bunging a few men in does not do that. I was very glad that I had a little peace and quiet for a couple of days to recover from a forceps delivery.women deserve proper recovery time. Although I went home fairly soon (for those days) if the care was better, I would now think that 10 days minimum would be really good.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/10/2022 14:07

Goldbar · 13/10/2022 13:00

There are two things which are awful here.

The first is having to do without adequate support after having a baby when you're weak and vulnerable.

The second is the gross invasion of privacy which comes from being essentially on a 'mixed' sex ward, separated only by a flimsy curtain, and expected to put up with intimate examinations, vaginal bleeding, catheters and all that in the presence of men who aren't medical staff and often behave quite inconsiderately. This wouldn't be tolerated in any other context.

People weigh these issues in different ways, but recognising the other side of the issue would probably go a long way towards addressing the problem. For example, women having intimate procedures should feel comfortable insisting that all men leave the room during them (or medical staff should make this request on their behalf).

Absolutely this.

And a potential solution to both sides of this issue is a recognition of the inadequacy of maternity care leading right back to the year dot, or the situation in the interwar years in which the UK had amongst the highest maternal mortality rates in the developed world.

There are conversations to this day about women's health concerns being minimized or dismissed, when similar concerns in men are far more likely to be taken seriously. This is the key issue, combined with the inadequacy of existing postnatal care, not the stepping-in of relatives to fill in the shortfalls in that care.

In any other area of medicine, this is what people would be kicking up a stink about.

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 13/10/2022 13:32

Perfectly reasonable for men not to stay. When I had my son, at an NHS hospital, I got so lucky though as the only place available was a private room 🎉 It was so nice and chilled out.

Goldbar · 13/10/2022 13:27

Women need to feel comfortable refusing to be examined or treated in the presence of men. A curtain is not sufficient privacy.

We'd never expect a women having a smear test or hysteroscopy to be happy having it in a hospital waiting-room with a curtain pulled round, would we? Why does this standard of care therefore become acceptable on maternity wards?

Blossomtoes · 13/10/2022 13:18

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 12:17

I don’t think a dad only being allowed to see his new baby for a few hours a day and being separated from them (and his partner) for a whole week is a good thing at all.

You’re focusing on the wrong thing. The point is that maternity services should be good enough that women are properly supported without essentially turning maternity wards into mixed sex wards. Men on maternity wards is much more inappropriate than men in public loos.

OoooohMatron · 13/10/2022 13:15

OnlyHams · 12/10/2022 21:09

@OoooohMatron

im not dismissing anyone, if you’re so sensitive you can pay for a side room

I'm not sensitive and my days of maternity wards are over thank god but that doesn't stop me seeing thing from other women's POV. My DH is a top bloke and a great dad but do I think it's fair that random women who have just given birth have to listen to him snore all night? No I bloody don't. I think the best solution would be to split wards into partners and no partners, I know which I'd have chosen.

Goldbar · 13/10/2022 13:00

There are two things which are awful here.

The first is having to do without adequate support after having a baby when you're weak and vulnerable.

The second is the gross invasion of privacy which comes from being essentially on a 'mixed' sex ward, separated only by a flimsy curtain, and expected to put up with intimate examinations, vaginal bleeding, catheters and all that in the presence of men who aren't medical staff and often behave quite inconsiderately. This wouldn't be tolerated in any other context.

People weigh these issues in different ways, but recognising the other side of the issue would probably go a long way towards addressing the problem. For example, women having intimate procedures should feel comfortable insisting that all men leave the room during them (or medical staff should make this request on their behalf).

Loics · 13/10/2022 12:54

JackieDaws · 13/10/2022 10:48

Jesus, a thread full of panderers insisting that other women recognise how super special their partner is. On a maternity ward. Couldn't imagine being so clingy and needy that I had to force a partner to hang around a maternity ward.

Or, a thread with the odd person who either hasn't read the posts, or is lacking reading comprehension skills.
Most of us don't have to force our partner to want to be around us either. 😉

pocketvenuss · 13/10/2022 12:38

JackieDaws · 13/10/2022 10:48

Jesus, a thread full of panderers insisting that other women recognise how super special their partner is. On a maternity ward. Couldn't imagine being so clingy and needy that I had to force a partner to hang around a maternity ward.

Jesus did you even read what @KittyKel wrote? What sort of woman hating person are you?

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 12:19

These are exceptions to what should be the rule. Once, just once, women are in a situation which should entitle them to be put first, considering the strain and trauma their bodies have just experienced for all of 40 weeks.

And this is what happens when women have their partners stay overnight.

They are putting their needs first by making sure they, and the baby do not suffer due to no support overnight on and understaffed unit.

I think it’s awful that women are expected to martyr themselves and be expected to just put up with shit hospital care at the detriment to themselves.

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 12:17

Blossomtoes · 13/10/2022 11:25

It was a good thing. New mothers and their babies were properly looked after. How could anyone not think it was a good thing when they hear the horror stories about the absolute shitshow maternity services are now?

I don’t think a dad only being allowed to see his new baby for a few hours a day and being separated from them (and his partner) for a whole week is a good thing at all.

Blossomtoes · 13/10/2022 11:25

CrushingAndClueless · 13/10/2022 04:11

Time was when a baby spent its first week on a maternity ward and its father was there for a few hours a day. That was when maternity services were adequately staffed. As they should be now.

You say this like it’s a good thing?!

It was a good thing. New mothers and their babies were properly looked after. How could anyone not think it was a good thing when they hear the horror stories about the absolute shitshow maternity services are now?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/10/2022 11:24

I posted my above PP too soon. Yes, there need to be exceptions to any rule, such as when a baby is desperately ill and in any other circumstances worried parents would expect to be with their child.

These are exceptions to what should be the rule. Once, just once, women are in a situation which should entitle them to be put first, considering the strain and trauma their bodies have just experienced for all of 40 weeks.

Yet, apparently, no. People are not bewailing the appalling, often substandard maternity care that in other areas of medicine would rightly cause a scandal. They are, yet again, expecting the women to concede, put up, and shut up.

This is not good enough. And I say this as a woman who experienced a high-risk pregnancy after numerous miscarriages, followed by a traumatic birth, EMCS and nearly losing our one cherished DC in labour. Men were not allowed to remain on the wards overnight in this instance (DC is 8), and I was grateful for the peace on that ward and the chance to recover and get BF established, without stressful overcrowding or being on edge because of the presence of men.

@KittyKel - sorry your experiences were so awful. I hope your DC has made a good recovery.

MooseBreath · 13/10/2022 11:22

@MarieIVanArkleStinks It's not different though. I'm due to give birth this month. If everything is straightforward and I can handle myself and the baby, I will absolutely send DH home, as he doesn't need to be there and I wouldn't want to impose on the other patients. But if I'm struggling to take care of the baby and the staffing levels are as poor as they were last time I had a baby, I will absolutely be having DH stay to help. I will not risk my own and my baby's safety because someone else might be uncomfortable.

The NHS maternity services are not fit for purpose. Men shouldn't be on wards overnight, but surely you can see why they are currently necessary?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/10/2022 11:17

KittyKel · 13/10/2022 09:57

‘The mother is the patient’ what about the baby??

Yes I wasn’t in a great state, I had surgery and catheter etc but nothing compared to my baby who was in a really bad way, losing temperature, not feeding, having seizures, and we were still on the main ward. I genuinely thought she might die. We got transferred to NICU but not until the next day.

The risk of DH disturbing someone by snoring in that circumstance was pretty low. He was as worried as I was.

Different circumstances entirely.

KittyKel · 13/10/2022 10:53

Actually I don’t read it as a thread full of clingy and needy panderers, I read it as a thread of how much the NHS is on its knees that some women need extra support from their partners as it’s not provided anymore due to overstretched and under funded resources.

Sorry I was so clingy that I couldn’t look after my child who was disabled from her birth injuries in the hours after a traumatic birth. First time mum, baby seriously ill, no help from staff. I’ll be less needy next time.

JackieDaws · 13/10/2022 10:48

Jesus, a thread full of panderers insisting that other women recognise how super special their partner is. On a maternity ward. Couldn't imagine being so clingy and needy that I had to force a partner to hang around a maternity ward.

RedHerring24 · 13/10/2022 10:47

My DH stayed in hospital with me from the moment i was admitted for induction until the time I was discharged. This was last year so during Covid.
The ward had 4 bays and all curtains were drawn so completely private.
I had a horrible delivery and everything became an emergency so my recovery was pretty bad and with lack of midwives in the ward i was often left struggling.
If DH hadnt have been able to stay it would have been so much harder than necessary.

I understand why people feel uncomfortable with men being on that ward but to be honest, I couldnt have cared less as far as I was concerned all 4 women in the same room had been through a similar thing and their partners were all suppprtive.

If you dont want to be around other men on wards, ask to pay for a private room on the NHS or book the birth at a private hospital.