Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can someone explain in laymans terms what is happening with the BOE/pension funds on Friday?

398 replies

Silverin · 11/10/2022 21:38

There seems to be a lot of panicked talk in the financial media about pension funds potentially collapsing and the BOE needing to step in to help them but this support being stopped on Friday.

As a layperson, I would like to understand what is going on - what are gilts, what did the BOE do/not do and what are the risks to pension funds that could cause a collapse on Friday?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
AuntSalli · 12/10/2022 10:36

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:25

Sorry if I missed it, but is there an answer to this? Thanks

Now is actually the best time to invest in your pension I’ve actually suggested doubling down on your contributions you’re buying cheap

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:32

Statistcally thank you

so private pensions might be affected pretty badly. I'd imagine some people will pass on waiting for compensation.

I have never prioritised my pension because I felt immediate access savings were more important but I suppose the government will screw those up too.

my uncle was with Equitable life and didn't get anything back but I think he was confused and possibly didn't fill in the forms.

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 10:31

DB is different, falls under the PPF

Monkey2001 · 12/10/2022 10:31

1jan2020 · 11/10/2022 23:04

Or should I wait longer to see if the market calms down?

If you are offered an affordable fix which means you can stay in your home for the next 5 years, but if interest rates went up more you may not be able to stay, you need to take a view on whether you prefer

  • the certainty that you are OK, but may be paying more than you had to, or
  • want to take the risk that if rates jump up you will be in trouble, but if they stabilise you will be better off
Both decisions are valid and you should choose based on your appetite for risk and what the consequences would be for you personally if you chose the risky option.
ClaudineClare · 12/10/2022 10:30

ClaudineClare · 12/10/2022 10:28

"If something happened to pension provider overseeing your money, you would generally be able to claim compensation from the FSCS.

The FSCS aims to make sure you get back 100% of any loss"

www.moneyhelper.org.uk/en/pensions-and-retirement/pensions-basics/how-safe-is-your-pension

Actually I am not sure whether that is for DC pensions rather than DB, sorry.

ClaudineClare · 12/10/2022 10:28

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:25

Sorry if I missed it, but is there an answer to this? Thanks

"If something happened to pension provider overseeing your money, you would generally be able to claim compensation from the FSCS.

The FSCS aims to make sure you get back 100% of any loss"

www.moneyhelper.org.uk/en/pensions-and-retirement/pensions-basics/how-safe-is-your-pension

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 10:28

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:25

Sorry if I missed it, but is there an answer to this? Thanks

There is a pension protection fund which provides a backstop in the even of scheme failure, but it doesn't generally give the full value and it may not be big enough if lots fail in which case it depends what the govt do

Andypandy799 · 12/10/2022 10:27

@Pearmain sorry that comment was meant for you

It’s a very good video but references the holocaust I assume as it’s a couple of years ago since I watched it but it opens your eyes to who controls money and inflation etc and who’s making the money

Legalhelpifpossibleplease · 12/10/2022 10:27

Thankyou to the great explanations on here. My brain is still aching though as I only understand some of it.

Genuine question which may help further. Can someone explain simply in football terms please?

EmmaH2022 · 12/10/2022 10:25

miceonabranch · 11/10/2022 23:07

Will pensions that are currently paying out continue to do so?

Sorry if I missed it, but is there an answer to this? Thanks

Legalhelpifpossibleplease · 12/10/2022 10:24

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 09:07

It's probably DC - so it's basically a pot of money which you have invested in various things. Have a look at your statement or online portal and it should tell you what you are invested in- probably a fund name, or more than one, if you have an online account you should be able to see fund value too. If you can't find info on what the fund is invested in then shout, I'm sure one of us on here will be able to explain

Many thanks. I shall take a look.

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 10:24

I think it's less about the actual monetary value of the debt and more about what their decisions signal. Borrowing isn't inherently bad, but borrowing to fund tax cuts in an economy already heading for recession with spiralling inflation contradicts most economic rationale and has spooked the markets.

Pearmain · 12/10/2022 10:23

A previous poster mentioned that the IMF have said that our government have to sort this out or it could go global - what are the chances of the IMF or other external group/ power intervening in this to stop the havoc spreading to other economies?

Andypandy799 · 12/10/2022 10:23

It’s a very good video but references the holocaust I assume as it’s a couple of years ago since I watched it but it opens your eyes to who controls money and inflation etc and who’s making the money

filetoffanny · 12/10/2022 10:23

I gave a DB pension and a Career Average (currently paying into) pension with TPS (both very small).

I'm 59 and I was about to pay some (quite a bit) of money into an AVC (Prudential) to boost my retirement income. Would this now be unwise?

TokyoSushi · 12/10/2022 10:22

Bookclub99 · 11/10/2022 23:30

This is what is happening:

A Gilt is debt issued by the UK. When the Treasury needs to borrow money, it issues a Gilt (effectively an IOU note) to investors. For example, if the Treasury issued a £100 4% coupon 5-year Gilt, it would receive £100 from an investor and give them in exchange an IOU note in which it promised to repay the investor £100 in 5 years time and in the meantime pay them £4 of interest each year. The investor doesn't have to hold the IOU note until the Treasury repays the debt at the end of 5 years. It can sell the IOU note to other investors or buy more IOU notes from yet more investors if it wants to.

For reasons I won't go into here (because it will take ages to explain) defined benefit (aka final salary) pension schemes need to invest the money they will ultimately use to fund their members' pension payments in Gilts. Lots and lots of Gilts. So many, in fact, that they borrowed money to buy those Gilts. For example, if a pension scheme had £100, it went and borrowed an extra £200 and invested £300 in Gilts. Borrowing money to invest in something magnifies gains and losses. In the example given above, if you had invested just the original £100 and your Gilt investment lost 20% of its value you would have lost £20, leaving you with £80. However, if you borrowed £200 and invested £300, then you would have lost £60, leaving you with just £40 once you had paid back the £200 you borrowed.

For yet more reasons I won't go into (because I lack the skill to explain this in layman's terms), when interest rates rise, the price of Gilts falls.

The Bank of England sets interest rates and uses them to control inflation by increasing them when inflation threatens. Because of a mix of Brexit, Covid shutdowns in China and Russia's invasion of Ukraine, there have been supply shortages of certain things (e.g., oil/gas because of the Ukraine thing). This has led to inflation because when things are in short supply their prices increase.The Bank of England has raised interest rates to combat this inflation. This led to the price of Gilts falling. A lot.

Then old Truss/Kwarteng come along and announced a load of tax cuts. Tax cuts are inflationary because people have more money to spend, further driving up the price of those things in short supply.

This meant the Bank of England had to raise interest rates even more. The price of Gilts fell further. A lot further.

Now back to those pension schemes. They are making huge losses on their Gilt holdings. Because they borrowed money to invest in those Gilts, their losses have been magnified, and the people who lent them the money are now demanding they pay it back, so the pension schemes are having to sell Gilts to repay the money, further driving down the price of Gilts... it's a vicious cycle.

To help the pension schemes, the Bank of England offered to step in and buy Gilts. By buying Gilts, the Bank of England drives their price higher, thereby stemming the pension schemes' losses and arresting that vicious cycle. However, the Bank of England really doesn't want to do this. The reason why is because the Bank of England has to print money to buy the Gilts. Money printing is inflationary... so will ultimately drive interest rates higher (to control the inflation), which will force the price of Gilts lower, so the Bank of England has to print more money to buy more Gilts to save the pension schemes... and so on. Another doom loop. That is why the Bank of England put a time limit on buying Gilts - they wanted to do just enough to buy the pension schemes some time to stablise themselves - then stop to avoid the doom loop scenario. That time limit expires this Friday.

People thought the Bank of England might extend the time limit because the pension schemes are still in a huge mess, however the governor has just said that won't happen (presumably because he wants to avoid the doom loop scenario). So now everyone is shitting themselves.

It's all horribly messy. I don't know how this will be fixed, but the only realistic options are: 1) the Bank of England capitulates and starts buying Gilts again (this isn't a good answer because of the doom loop issue), or 2) Truss/Kwarteng reverse all their stupid tax cuts and resign.

If neither of those two things happens some pension schemes may make irrecoverable losses which would mean they wouldn't have enough money to fulfil the promises they made to their members. The only way to fix this would be for the pension scheme employer to put money into the scheme (some won't have enough), for the government to put money into failing schemes (i.e., a bailout) and/or the pension schemes break their promises to their members and don't pay them as much money as they said they would when the members retire - likely a combo of the three.

Not RTFT but this is a fantastic explanation, Thanks so much @Bookclub99 !

GasPanic · 12/10/2022 10:20

Alexandra2001 · 12/10/2022 09:23

Thats completely false.

Gilt were stable and considered a "safe" bet, that changed when inflation/interest rates went up BUT even then, still ok.

Truss then decided to borrow to fund tax cuts, that caused Govt Gilts to effectively become worthless (as no developed economy does this) hence the BoE stepped in to buy them as no one else would.

Yields are over 5% , this creates even further problems, as Govt now needs to borrow even more to fund increased borrowing interest rates (yields) but investors don't want to lend to the UK, no other G7 comes close to having effective interest rates like the UK's.

Pension funds were doing just fine pre the mini fuck up .... investing in Bonds and Gilts is what pension funds have been doing for decades.

This is a crisis solely caused by Truss and she has been called out on this by former chancellors, international investors and the IMF.

Rees Mogg now calling Gilts a ^high risk" investment FFS.

The problem is when you try to lay it all on Truss it makes no sense.

The reason the pension funds are in this position is because they didn't just buy gilts. They bought them, then went through some financial wizardry in order to work them harder. I don't don't know for sure why they did this, but I suspect it has something to do with a) pension fund managers making bigger bonuses and b) funds trying to offer better value for their customers. How much of each I have no clue.

If you want to blame the government, sure there is some culpability. One is how they regulate the pension funds. However, it's hard to lay this blame on Truss since she's only been in power a few weeks. the other is how Truss spooked the markets by basically going for tax cuts without properly explaining and budgeting. This you can surely blame Truss for.

But the situation is a lot more nuanced than "everything is all Truss's fault". This is the problem with doing politically biased analysis. It doesn't get to the root of the problem so that blame can be laid at the door of the chosen one.

An interesting question to ask is, if the UK has debts of £2.5 trillion, why did announcing Truss's budget which borrows a mere £45 billion spook the markets so ?

Once you answer this question, you begin to realise that Truss's budget was merely a trigger for the markets to act on what has been the UK building itself into a long term unsustainable position regarding debt.

It also tells you something about the past and the future.

For example the following questions :

If the markets view our current debt position as bad, how would they view it now without "Tory austerity" during the 2010's ?

If the markets view the government debt rising by £45 billion a year as bad, how is any government going to raise future increases in spending through borrowing (irrespective of whether that spending is spent on tax cuts for the rich or benefits for the poor) and what consequences does that have for the manifestos of future governments ?

Phineyj · 12/10/2022 10:16

This is a great book for anyone wanting to grasp the basics. I recommend the paper version not Kindle (even if it's a secondhand copy) as the colour graphics are very helpful.

"How Money Works: The Facts Visually Explained (How Things Work) eBook : DK: Amazon.co.uk: Books" www.amazon.co.uk/How-Money-Works-Visually-Explained-ebook/dp/B0799FTV8G/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?crid=1VCTUX7LAVGN0&keywords=how+money+works+dk&qid=1665566019&qu=eyJxc2MiOiIxLjU1IiwicXNhIjoiMS4xOCIsInFzcCI6IjEuMjUifQ%3D%3D&sprefix=how+money+%2Caps%2C117&sr=8-1

MarshaBradyo · 12/10/2022 10:15

edwinbear · 12/10/2022 10:07

What I don't understand is the logic behind DB pensions. How can they guarantee a level of return in 20-30 years time? that's impossible to achieve. If if was that easy, why don't we all have a DB pension

Typically, they will buy 'linkers' or inflation linked gilts. So instead of buying gilts that pay a flat interest rate of say, 2%, they buy gilts that pay an inflation linked return. Essentially, the BoE have to get tough with the pension funds now, they were told they had a two week window to sort themselves out, the BOE have been in the market, daily, offering to buy up to £5bn. Yesterday they offered to buy £5bn 'normal' gilts and £5bn linkers, but the pension funds aren't taking up the offer. There have been some day in the last 10 days when the BoE have bought none - not because they don't want to, but the pension funds aren't selling. This is why Bailey needs to reiterate to them, it's a limited offer.

Thanks for this. Your finance posts are useful. What do you think will happen?

Just generally - financially / politically etc (no pressure just out of interest)

Fenella123 · 12/10/2022 10:12

I should add, in my personal experience, defined contribution ("stakeholder"/"personal") pensions let you choose what your pot is invested in.
Typically the default fund is a "lifestyle" one which moves to more gilts and bonds (as a pot %) than shares as you get closer to retirement.

That's kind of a throwback to when you had to buy an annuity with the pot when you retired. You don't now, you can pretty much just keep it all invested and sell bits when you want money to live on.

More or less you can choose what your DC pension pot is invested in, the same way you choose what your stocks and shares ISA is invested in.

A book that was recommended to me is Tim Hayle's "Smarter Investing", which goes through the different classes of asset, how they are related, how much they go up and down in price, how much they grow or produce money, and therefore how you might divide your own pot between them depending on your attitude to risk.

StatisticallyChallenged · 12/10/2022 10:12

edwinbear · 12/10/2022 10:07

What I don't understand is the logic behind DB pensions. How can they guarantee a level of return in 20-30 years time? that's impossible to achieve. If if was that easy, why don't we all have a DB pension

Typically, they will buy 'linkers' or inflation linked gilts. So instead of buying gilts that pay a flat interest rate of say, 2%, they buy gilts that pay an inflation linked return. Essentially, the BoE have to get tough with the pension funds now, they were told they had a two week window to sort themselves out, the BOE have been in the market, daily, offering to buy up to £5bn. Yesterday they offered to buy £5bn 'normal' gilts and £5bn linkers, but the pension funds aren't taking up the offer. There have been some day in the last 10 days when the BoE have bought none - not because they don't want to, but the pension funds aren't selling. This is why Bailey needs to reiterate to them, it's a limited offer.

Part of the issue is that the pension scheme might not actually have the gilts in hand to sell, I'd guess. They have exposure to gilt prices and interest rates via other instruments but don't necessarily have the assets to sell

Faciadipasta · 12/10/2022 10:08

Just responding to a previous PP to say pension fund managers are not 'spivs'!
They use conservative investment strategies which is why they are invested heavily in gilts which until LT and KK came along were considered VERY low risk. US govt bonds btw were considered 'risk free' in the past. I'm not sure they are now though.
They have no option other than to leverage their investments because a lot of people take out more than they pay into their pot. That money has to come from somewhere.
Agree that pensions are basically a massive pyramid scheme 😳

edwinbear · 12/10/2022 10:07

What I don't understand is the logic behind DB pensions. How can they guarantee a level of return in 20-30 years time? that's impossible to achieve. If if was that easy, why don't we all have a DB pension

Typically, they will buy 'linkers' or inflation linked gilts. So instead of buying gilts that pay a flat interest rate of say, 2%, they buy gilts that pay an inflation linked return. Essentially, the BoE have to get tough with the pension funds now, they were told they had a two week window to sort themselves out, the BOE have been in the market, daily, offering to buy up to £5bn. Yesterday they offered to buy £5bn 'normal' gilts and £5bn linkers, but the pension funds aren't taking up the offer. There have been some day in the last 10 days when the BoE have bought none - not because they don't want to, but the pension funds aren't selling. This is why Bailey needs to reiterate to them, it's a limited offer.

the80sweregreat · 12/10/2022 10:07

Dh had a letter saying his one was doing well , which surprised him
Not sure how , although this was last month!
My fear is it all drying up completely everywhere

Fenella123 · 12/10/2022 10:02

ClaudineClare · 12/10/2022 09:12

The teacher's pension is unlikely to go bust though, as public sector pensions are funded by the taxpayer? Is that correct? I guess the government could run out of money to pay public sector pensions, but that would be even ore catastrophic.

You're right sorry, TPS is "unfunded" and backed by the government. So it's not directly part of this.

Looking around for a better example, the railways pension scheme is still around.

Swipe left for the next trending thread