Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angler blocking footpath, I know I was unreasonable, but would this annoy you/what would you have done??

115 replies

Patienceisntvirtuous · 11/10/2022 20:07

I realise this might need a diagram! I was out running with my dog today. There's a footpath off the main road which leads to a dam. People fish on it. The footpath has a fence either side of it right up until the dam, give or take about 4 feet of land comprising of grass and another footpath (between the end of the dam and the fence). An angler was sitting at the dam, with his fishing rod to his left propped up on some apparatus completely blocking the four feet of land which I was to run across, right next to the fence. No way around it without going for a swim. It was poised about a foot and a half high.

I stepped over it and my dog jumped over it. Dog is huge, didn't touch the rod just cleared it. I didn't take a flying leap, I stepped over it carefully. Then continued my run-but he shouted after me that I shouldn't step over it, he'd have moved it (he hadn't said anything like this before I stepped over it). I shouted back that it was okay, and he responded that had I broken a section of his rod it would have cost me £250.

It's then when I was unreasonable, I shouted back that I wasn't waiting for him to move the rod, I've as much right to the path as him.

And he was blocking it which isn't great. Further up from the footpath would have been fine, no fence there and grassy areas surrounding so I could have just avoided.

I imagine he'll spend half his day repeatedly moving his rod, sitting in the spot he was right opposite where the footpath emerges, It's a regularly used-route.

Would you have hung about while he moved it (again he never said 'hang on I'll move my rod')?
I had no reason to think he would, and I wouldn't have asked either because I didn't know it was possible without a lot of faffing about. It wouldn't have been an especially quick thing to do, a long fishing rod with various elements and garments attached to it.

Anyway no harm done but I perhaps shouldn't have argued back with him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cutthelawn · 20/10/2022 10:11

*"i am a man too btw and have received lots of intimidating and rude comments by strangers men over the years. It doesn't give you any protection."

Fixed it for you cutoff. Why don't you start a campaign against these men instead of NAMALTing on a site where 99% of users are women*

you are missing the point, my point was that these MEN target males just as much as females. Look at the stats actually-most violence is man on man,.

Patienceisntvirtuous · 19/10/2022 21:21

reigatecastle · 19/10/2022 11:49

I regularly run/walk along canal towpaths and I've never had an angler behave like this. They always move their rods. I've never had to ask. If they didn't, I would step over them. Not sure how you can damage something by stepping over it anyway.

Well, quite! I'd have had to have been particularly clumsy to touch the rod as I stepped over it and even if I had, I doubt I'd have broken the bloody thing. They're designed to be transported/bent/thrown about in water after all.

Agree about the NAMALTing, @phishy

OP posts:
reigatecastle · 19/10/2022 11:49

I regularly run/walk along canal towpaths and I've never had an angler behave like this. They always move their rods. I've never had to ask. If they didn't, I would step over them. Not sure how you can damage something by stepping over it anyway.

phishy · 19/10/2022 11:41

"i am a man too btw and have received lots of intimidating and rude comments by strangers men over the years. It doesn't give you any protection."

Fixed it for you cutoff. Why don't you start a campaign against these men instead of NAMALTing on a site where 99% of users are women?

cutthelawn · 19/10/2022 11:09

*The comment is not tainting all men, it's tainting men who are confrontational to strangers in public places.

I'm a man and I feel the "he wouldn't say that to a man" comment that appears on many threads here is nearly always justified.

This forum has been an eye-opener for me, with regard to the various comments women have to endure from complete strangers. Not just from men, but also from other women, also from old people of both sexes. Some women have even had comments from teachers, nurses, postmen and delivery drivers that I could just not imagine being on the receiving end of.

I've gone through decades of adult life and cannot remember strangers on public transport or supermarkets or anywhere else getting shirty with me. Just being a man guarantees me a level of respect and politeness that some women apparently have to live without*

i am a man too btw and have received lots of intimidating and rude comments by strangers over the years. It doesn't give you any protection.

cutthelawn · 19/10/2022 11:06

Just being a man guarantees me a level of respect and politeness that some women apparently have to live without

such bollox.

BuryingAcorns · 18/10/2022 12:13

PauliesWalnuts · 11/10/2022 20:18

On my canal cycle commute there isn’t an angler who doesn’t think the canal should be just for anglers. Try riding down on a bike - I couldn’t believe the huffing and puffing going on. One weekend I rode 30 miles in the other direction up to Yorkshire and didn’t realise there was an angling competition going on. By the time I got to Hebden Bridge I felt like the most hated woman alive.

On the canal near where I used to live, cyclists felt they owned it. I was almost pushed into the water several times and often forced into the nettles by cyclists (always men) who bolted at high speed along the towpath and expected the peasants to leap and clear their path.

SirChenjins · 18/10/2022 12:02

I think you'd have quite a successful career in duck drawing - human drawing, not so much...

Patienceisntvirtuous · 17/10/2022 23:05

Thank you, I am satisfied now. Perhaps I should pursue a new career involving drawing ducks 🤓

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 17/10/2022 20:18

Patienceisntvirtuous · 17/10/2022 20:04

I am not one to continue any thread of mine that has depleted in interest but I have to admit I'd like at least one person to appreciate my wonderful diagram 😂

I appreciated it!! 😀

PuttingDownRoots · 17/10/2022 20:06

Patienceisntvirtuous · 17/10/2022 20:04

I am not one to continue any thread of mine that has depleted in interest but I have to admit I'd like at least one person to appreciate my wonderful diagram 😂

The duck is magnificent

Patienceisntvirtuous · 17/10/2022 20:04

I am not one to continue any thread of mine that has depleted in interest but I have to admit I'd like at least one person to appreciate my wonderful diagram 😂

OP posts:
Patienceisntvirtuous · 12/10/2022 18:37

@Discovereads voila (above) sorry, it wasn't something I felt I could explain well.
@RedSkyAtKnight Grin

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing that's so true. I read about (and joined) an 'experiment' some women were doing while walking down narrow paths or corridors. They'd see a man approach, not veer from their walking direction, and wait to see when the man veered to the side so they didn't collide. Very few of them did until the last minute! They just expect that the woman will be the one to apply the inconvenience to themselves.

Definitely a public footpath

@QuebecBagnet what
an idiot! If it was so well disguised and the same colour of the path he can hardly blame someone for not noticing it!

@Nat6999 maybe he didn't see me until the last minute but if that were me (not that I'd ever block a path, period) I'd have said straight away 'Hang on, let me move this out of your way' or such. He obviously DID see me if he'd anticipated that he'd move his rod.

@TimeforZeroes selfish fish bastard Grin this thread has amused me!

@Hearthnhome your DP sounds like one of the considerate, unselfish ones.

@Rosehugger they do have to pay (there are signs up indicating this)but it is in a public place.

@SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain sadly I agree. He really didn't seem to expect me to say anything back to him! I'm forever steering my dog away from bait buckets.

@TheOrigRights yes, It's that isn't it. I'd have had to stop for a minute or more had I waited for him to move it, and he had other equipment attached to it or around it, and I suspect he'd not have been happy at doing that either. I've no idea why he picked this particular spot-I know angling has a lot of complicated 'rules' around where you're most likely to catch, perhaps that was a particularly good spot.

@luckylavender yes I could have asked him. I'd not have thought he'd have sat where he was expecting every person who wanted to pass to ask him to move his rod. It's quite a busy walkway, so perhaps I subconsciously thought he expected people to step over it rather than inconvenience him each time.
@CustardySergeant really? I'll bet my Dad's on it :)

@getoff that's a refreshing post. I've had more than my fair share of such encounters you've mentioned!

@HairyMcLarie that's so inconsiderate!

@Kanaloa I do agree with that :(

@thehideandseeking I think you're definitely right. He wasn't so mindful of what was going on around him, surely had he been preparing to move it he wouldn't have been still sitting down!

@Tara336 common thing then! I must say this hasn't happened to me before although thinking about it I have usually just managed to maneuver
myself around the anglers on the dam-but this is the first one where I couldn't have done without actually getting into the dam, or climbing over a fence (impossible with Dog).

@Harrystylestutu that's hilarious! I know some anglers and I am sure they're more considerate than the one I encountered.

@RincewindsHat good point!

@YouSirNeighMmmm that's how I feel too. He wasn't even thinking about anyone else when he decided to place himself there. Expecting that he's important enough for others to have to change their behavior for him. And yes @JennyForeigner , he thought something like 'I'm going here, if anyone wants to get past they'll have to wait while I shift my stuff'. I didn't. Silly me. :)

OP posts:
Patienceisntvirtuous · 12/10/2022 18:02

Hope this helps! Very crude but I never was the best at using 'paint'. There was only a couple of inch gap between the fishing rod and the fence, I couldn't have fit down there to pass.

Angler blocking footpath, I know I was unreasonable, but would this annoy you/what would you have done??
OP posts:
JennyForeigner · 12/10/2022 15:44

PauliesWalnuts · 11/10/2022 20:40

The problem is that they can see you coming from a couple of hundred meters away in my case yet don’t make a move to lift the rod until you are right up to them and have to stop and ask. Of course he’s going to he to move the rod - there is nowhere else for me to go.

It's a power play isn't it? You have to wait on his convenience. Not playing within the aggressors rules - as the OP didn't - is experienced as aggression.

SirChenjins · 12/10/2022 15:39

tulips27 · 12/10/2022 09:55

@SirChenjins You're not "instructed by a ding ding of their bell", the bell is to inform you that the cyclist is approaching. I'm sure you'd have a lot to say if a cyclist approached without ringing their bell, wouldn't you?

Saying that you would laugh at an attack on a cyclist just exposes the true nature of your personality.

In which case, the correct behaviour on a canal path is that the cyclist should use the bell, slow down, and then give me and other slower path users time to move in if we can - and not use it as a ‘get out of my way, because like fuck am I going to slow down as I approach you at speed’ signal.

Those kind of cyclists are a-holes and the true nature of my personality cares not a jot. I don’t cycle like that when I’m on a shared path, there’s no need for any cyclist to behave that way.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 12/10/2022 14:18

GabriellaMontez · 11/10/2022 20:15

Hmm I wonder if he'd have said this to a man? No. Not a chance.

I think that men can be arsey and unreasonable to other men and not just to women. Some men are bigger arseholes to other men than they are to women, even if only because they are sexist pigs.

Anyone who blocks a public footpath and then expects people to ask / wait whilst he moves it is a completely entitled prick.

It is my honest opinion that anything in the "pick it up and throw it out of the way" (into the water) to "jumping over it" range would be reasonable.

If someone is blocking a path as they manoevre their wheelchair or try to stop their pushchair-bound toddler from chocking then you wait patiently and politely. If someone blocks it for no reason then they are basically saying that they don;t respect other people, so why should you respect them.

RincewindsHat · 12/10/2022 13:47

You weren't unreasonable and next time some joker shouts at you like that, remind them that if they don't have liability insurance that covers deliberately causing hazards on a public right of way they could potentially be forced to pay out a significant sum of money if they injure anyone with their actions...

W0tnow · 12/10/2022 13:41

I read these threads and think surely, SURELY, no one will think YABU. But here we are.

Harrystylestutu · 12/10/2022 13:35

My Dh said that's bad fishing etiquette and you should be aware of what's around you at all times.

then he told me canal fishermen are the worst for a load of reasons and something about when he accidentally hooked a canoeist and had to reel him in and cut his top to free the hook Confused. I almost wish I didn't ask 😂

PassThePringles · 12/10/2022 12:59

I'd have done the same as you. Imo he should have been the one to look out for people coming so he can move his gear in advance. Sounds like a him issue, not a you issue. Don't give it a second thought.

Snowpatrolsnowpatrol · 12/10/2022 12:47

VeniVidiWeeWee · 11/10/2022 20:35

He said he would have moved his tackle. Very rude, and risky, to step over probably a £1,000 piece of kit.

He was rude to block the path.
He was rude not to move his rod when he saw someone approaching. He should have been looking out for someone at all times if he was going to move his rod every time. Its his responsibility to move obstructions he made.
There would be absolutely no way in hell I'd pay anything towards his equipment if I broke it if while jumping over it as the OP did.

Sux2buthen · 12/10/2022 12:33

Iateallthechocolate · 11/10/2022 21:29

I always want to push them in. I never have of course, but I can't see a man fishing from the bank without wanting to. Anyway I don't think you did anything wrong at all. Just because he didn't like it doesn't mean it was wrong

That's so coincidenctal, when I see a woman running I always want to push her over.

Not really, obviously. That would be a Dickish thing to think

Tara336 · 12/10/2022 12:18

I used to live directly next to a river, during fishing season it became a real pain as the fisherman would block the narrow footpath with all their equipment and place the rods completely across the path when they fiddling with them. I started by politely asking to pass especially when I had DD in her pram and my Ddog with me but found that they were not friendly or helpful and I'd be glared at or ignored. They would also get really pissy with DDog when he trotted past on his walk and would show an interest in what they were doing, he wasn't bounding around or jumping or their stuff just sniffing at the stuff they were blocking the footpath with. While they might have paid to be there it didn't give them ownership of the place.

miceonabranch · 12/10/2022 12:12

Silly man. He should count himself lucky that you didn't do any harm. I'm overweight and have dyspraxia. I'd definitely have tripped over and squashed his precious tackle 😄