Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be concerned G.P has prescribed DH co-codamol for long term pain relief

139 replies

Hangingwithmygnomies · 11/10/2022 18:40

Obviously will start by saying I am clearly not a health professional but my DH has a problem with a couple of vertebrae in his neck, something akin to bulging disks. It's a chronic condition and basically he has been told that nothing can be done so it's just long term pain management. He was precribed amitriptyline but he felt they made him an angry person and didn't like it, so he spoke to the G.P and they've now precribed co-codamol. I feel really uneasy about it as whenever I've bought it for migraine, the pharmacist has told me not to take it for more than 3 days so didn't think it was suitable for long term relied. Also I had a friend who became fully addicted to codene after taking co-codamol for an injury and sadly the addiction over took her completely and she took her own life, so I am aware my opinion maybe clouded due to this and would welcome other perspectives to see if IABU or not

OP posts:
LeningradSymphony · 12/10/2022 09:23

Alliswells · 12/10/2022 08:45

@Cheeseandcrackers86 is not a real GP.
Real GP's don't pop up on forums offering advice and arguing with posters on Mumsnet. Real GPs don't be on Mumsnet entrenched in one particular view and being so dismissive of posters serious experiences of pain.

Giving advice without seeing and assessing someone is actually quite dangerous..... But hey GPs have been doing that for over two years because of Covid 🙄 so maybe they are a GP after all. But an unprofessional one.

GPs aren't pain specialists and pain is definitely a specialist area as it complex and debilitating.

They showed their hand when they tried to portray people with chronic pain as 'people who are trying to turn their doctor into their drug dealer and think doctors should hand out whatever they ask for'.

I'm very sorry that they're in so much pain that they feel the need to pretend to be a GP online to put their point across, but I feel more sorry for people who might read it and be really upset by their words. There's a reason MN make it clear at the top of the page that they haven't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here!

sashh · 12/10/2022 09:23

I was diagnosed with arthritis at 26, I'm about to turn 56. I am on an array of pills for this and other health issues.

The big difference, IMHO is that I cannot afford not become addicted because then I would have no pain relief.

If he needs pain relief then he needs it.

mauveskies · 12/10/2022 09:15

You can also tell the people who are pretending they are GPs...

Mangogogogo · 12/10/2022 09:06

You can definitely tell the people on here who’ve had chronic pain and those who havent

TopSec · 12/10/2022 09:02

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 11/10/2022 19:05

I'm a GP. YANBU to be concerned. We are trying to steer away from treating chronic pain with medications as they ultimately don't work well and come with their own risks of addiction, dependency and rarely fatal side effects especially if you end up on a cocktail of them that all mix together. I wouldn't be massively concerned about a bit of codeine but I would be explaining to DH that other methods such as distraction techniques and talking therapies are much more likely to provide more long term benefits. I'd be encouraging him to self refer to his local counselling service to access therapy. His current medications are low risk but I would want to be nipping the chronic pain in the bud and starting early finding alternative coping mechanisms to medicine. This is all ultimately your DH's decision though of course x

Not sure how this is going to help to be honest. My husband has been on co-codamol for years due to having to have 4 hip replacements on the same side due to MRSA contracted in the hospital (he was only 54). As a result, the last hip will never be as good as it should and has had a real bad affect on his lower back. He now has to walk with a stick. He has tried to do without but the pain deems it necessary to start again. He also has to take anti gastric tablets alongside the co-codamol and I think this is an important thing to note - make sure you get anti-gastric tablets if you are on co-codamol long term. No amount of talking will make this pain go away.

iloveeverykindofcat · 12/10/2022 08:51

@Cheeseandcrackers86 for another perspective I actually wish my GPs had worked with me on the source of my pain rather than keep prescribing codeine. I'm off it now with a lot of Pilates and some weight training. I still have some pain and take paracetamol etc but I prefer it to dependency. Which I had. Because mammals will get dependent on opiates if they take them long enough. Even my vet would only give a short course after my cats ankle fusion. That said people are different. OP Yanbu to be worried but its up to him and his doctor.

Alliswells · 12/10/2022 08:45

@Cheeseandcrackers86 is not a real GP.
Real GP's don't pop up on forums offering advice and arguing with posters on Mumsnet. Real GPs don't be on Mumsnet entrenched in one particular view and being so dismissive of posters serious experiences of pain.

Giving advice without seeing and assessing someone is actually quite dangerous..... But hey GPs have been doing that for over two years because of Covid 🙄 so maybe they are a GP after all. But an unprofessional one.

GPs aren't pain specialists and pain is definitely a specialist area as it complex and debilitating.

lovelilies · 12/10/2022 08:45

Haven't RTFT (got annoyed with the GP upthread!)
I have a pain condition and have been on cocodamol for 15 years. I'm a nurse. I have never taken over the prescribed dose and take 8 tablets daily pretty much.
I probably am dependent but certainly not addicted.

I think it largely depends on the individual just keep an eye on him x

NewHopeNow · 12/10/2022 08:39

@Cheeseandcrackers86 with zero respect that is absolute bullshit and I'm glad you're not my gp. Get a clue.

DaisyDreaming · 12/10/2022 08:27

Its good to avoid painkillers if you can but sometimes you need them. I’m on long term painkillers. Ones that are classed as addictive. Without them my life was miserable and no amount of mind over matter or meditation techniques could help. With them, I still have pain but I can live with it (along with stretching, heat packs and other things which help). They transform my life and give me a good quality of life. My body is currently dependant on them but I’ve never needed to increase my dose (I’ve been on the same dose for over a decade) and I don’t feel I have an emotional addiction or anything. Sometimes people need pain killers and shouldn’t be denied them just as some people have addictions. They shouldn’t be handed out like sweets but they rarely are.

PineCone74 · 12/10/2022 08:26

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 12/10/2022 05:03

So what exactly would you like your GP to say then? Because no decent GP us going to keep upping your pain meds until they're basically your drug dealer. So really the options are they look at it more holistically and talk to you about the things that have been shown to work (whether you accept that they work or not) or they tell you there's nothing they can do. So which would you prefer? It's crappy I know but what exactly do you expect them to offer when there is nothing else that works and nothing else that the guidelines recommend?

I would suggest a more empathetic response than your first post. I have not suggested that alternative therapies do not work, ( I acknowledged their potential clinical ‘correctness’ )but that simply telling a patient to try distraction and counselling needs to be done with awareness of how that is going to make the person feel. I do continue to question how practical a suggestion of counselling is given how difficult it can be to access. Your first post suggested a confidence in alternative therapies which came across, from a patient point of view, as having no understanding. I accept this might not have been your intention.

megletthesecond · 12/10/2022 07:02

Can't they do anything to help like physio, exercise, diet or a minor op? Long term pain relief should be a last resort. (Disclaimer, I can't tolerate codeine at all and just go around grumpy instead).

Sparklywolf · 12/10/2022 06:55

I've been on co-codamol for years now for a chronic pain condition, having tried multiple different options its the only one to work consistently. I would agree with earlier points on dependency v addiction. If I'm having a good day I will forget to take a dose, sometimes 2 until my pain levels rise and remind me. On a bad day it the only thing that enables me to get out of bed and do the bare minimum to keep everybody alive and safe.

Obviously long term painkillers are never the ideal but often they're still better than the alternative.

LeningradSymphony · 12/10/2022 06:50

Also: GPs aren’t pain specialists. Pain consultants are. There’s a reason pain patients should be referred to pain clinics for help instead of being treated solely by their GP in the first instance.

friendly reminder that anyone who pops up claiming to be a pain consultant might or might not be...

LeningradSymphony · 12/10/2022 06:48

Cheese and crackers reads like someone who has perhaps lost a loved one to addiction (as have I) or maybe experienced it themselves and is now desperately trying to inform others to stop it happening again. There’s absolutely no way they’re an actual GP with what they’re saying on here. I hope their Ignorance hasn’t upset anyone.

BaskingInTheSun · 12/10/2022 06:45

Also, your might want to take a look at the NICE gudelines again - there are options other than distraction techniques, talking therapies and opioids.

LeningradSymphony · 12/10/2022 06:44

Musti · 11/10/2022 21:45

I have found GPs tending to offer pain relief instead of treating the cause. I’ve just had surgery for something they suggested just taking pain relief for the rest of my life. I had to ask for a specialist referral, and I was looking into private.

A friend had to have private surgery after a c-section left her in agony as the nerves had knitted all wrong. She went from not being able to carry a bag and having to sit on a ring cushion to being able to lift weights heavier than her.

I don’t know anything about your husband’s condition but I would get a few different opinions from specialists, also look at acupuncture and other non drug methods of healing and pain relief. You lose nothing by researching and trying some other methods.

Gosh, I wish GPs I’ve worked with as a patient had that attitude. From the start of my pain to actually being given the first step painkillers on the pain ladder was six years. Six years of unmedicated pain while they tried to find the root cause. Lost jobs, relationships, went bankrupt. Because living with unmanaged pain was just unspeakably awful. I’m glad they tried to find the cause but I wish they had recognised and understood that you can’t go months, years, in agony day after day until the physical cause is ruled out or identified, you need help with the pain NOW.

BaskingInTheSun · 12/10/2022 06:43

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 12/10/2022 05:03

So what exactly would you like your GP to say then? Because no decent GP us going to keep upping your pain meds until they're basically your drug dealer. So really the options are they look at it more holistically and talk to you about the things that have been shown to work (whether you accept that they work or not) or they tell you there's nothing they can do. So which would you prefer? It's crappy I know but what exactly do you expect them to offer when there is nothing else that works and nothing else that the guidelines recommend?

To answer your question,I'd like the GP to refer me to a chronic pain management service, particularly if my GP is someone who thinks my chronic pain can be nipped in the bud.

I6344 · 12/10/2022 06:06

I've been on 30/500mg of cocodamol for six years and haven't had any adverse effects yet. That's not to say your DH won't so maybe just see how he gets on?

Toomanybooks22 · 12/10/2022 05:44

I'm sorry but as someone with chronic pain I find comments about alternative therapies to be incredibly problematic, somewhat lacking understanding of the impact chronic pain and borderline lacking empathy. I find it completely ridiculous to assume anyone can use "distraction" techniques to cope with chronic pain for any significant period of time (I've tried it whilst guided by pain management team).

I mean seriously it's all good saying in an ideal world we'd all do "mind over matter" but have you considered the amount of mental energy this takes on top of managing a semi-normal life? In addition are you aware of how long it takes to get access to talking therapies on the NHS? Even the dedicated pain management team I've been referred to doesn't offer any form counselling specifically and the best you get is a couple of group sessions about breathing / visualisation which at best can be said to have limitations if you're in pain whenever you're moving.

So yes whilst I limit it pain medication to what is absolutely necessary for me to move and concentrate and I plan my daily activities so I know when best to take it pain medication is absolutely necessary for me to work and have anything close to a normal life in my opinion at least for now whilst under 30.

I am worried about a move towards alternative therapies being a cost saving device packaged as what's best for patients but in reality severely underfunded and of limited benefit at best.

PlantDoctor · 12/10/2022 05:27

MIL was taking them and ended up with very very bad constipation, to the point where she needed fairly urgent medical care. She let the problem progress without saying/doing anything, so definitely not only the fault of the meds, but also that's what the Dr said caused it and it hasn't been a problem since switching to another med (unfortunately less effective for pain relief)

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 12/10/2022 05:03

PineCone74 · 11/10/2022 23:08

This may be clinically correct, but surely part of being a GP is to have the sensitivity towards patients to know how telling someone in constant agony to try distracting techniques and talking therapies is going to make them feel? And, as other people have said, how is anyone supposed to even access counselling these days without a very very long wait? I’d imagine the emotional and psychological impact of hearing this sort of advice from a GP to whom they have turned for help could be very negative indeed.

So what exactly would you like your GP to say then? Because no decent GP us going to keep upping your pain meds until they're basically your drug dealer. So really the options are they look at it more holistically and talk to you about the things that have been shown to work (whether you accept that they work or not) or they tell you there's nothing they can do. So which would you prefer? It's crappy I know but what exactly do you expect them to offer when there is nothing else that works and nothing else that the guidelines recommend?

katmeouws · 12/10/2022 00:48

Why not scrap the NHS and the Courts and replace them with MUMSNET boards? No need to got to your GP, just ask MUMSNET. Trial by jury, barristers on strike. Much simpler to just let MUMSNET be the judge (and jury), complete with a voting buttons Guilty/Not guilty.

StudentMumTo3 · 12/10/2022 00:39

Your DH really should ask his GP about input from a pain specialist, if that's possible.

I'm a chronic pain sufferer and co-codamol isn't usually considered an alternative to amitriptyline as they work in different ways for different types of pain.

And as for the so-called GP - what condescending arrogant nonsense from someone who clearly neither specialises in pain management nor lives with chronic pain.

Distraction works for relatively "low levels" of pain. Talking therapy can help with the psychological and emotional impact of living with chronic pain. Physio and Occupational therapy may help with physical aspects of living with chronic pain.

No amount of distraction or talking therapy is going to genuinely and effectively alleviate moderate to severe chronic pain by themselves. They have their place still, for some, but as part of a package of treatment not in place of all other options!

The last GP I saw like you (thankfully a while ago), ended up with a clear and firm communication from my pain specialist. I needed my meds & my outpatient clinic treatments!

MrsRuggles · 12/10/2022 00:08

Hi OP. I'm sorry to hear of your DH's pain. Within my own family there have been different experiences of co-codamol use. I've had occasion to need them for sciatica and gallstones and the other person had lots of back problems.

I used them fine, and yet the other person developed long term, lifelong even, problems with them.

Something that no-one seems to have mentioned is that the body develops a tolerance and the pain killing properties are lessened. The best course of action is to stop taking them for three or four days when this happens and then they will work again as the tolerance level drops. When first taking them, most people have a fair bit of nausea for the first few days and them the body gets used to them.

Some people try and increase the dose, which is where the problems really start. Some people are more predisposed to having addiction problems than others. Your GP should be keeping an eye on this. Hence why prescriptions are needed for this sort of medication.