Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s nothing wrong with quiet children?

157 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 18:38

Just had my parents evening for DD (9).

I was told “She’s very quiet” and they want her to speak up and raise her hand more. Very much spoke about ‘being quiet’ like it’s a bad thing.

It pisses me off because what exactly is wrong with not being some ostentatious gobshite of a child? She is far from shy - she will stick up for herself, place her own order in a restaurant etc. but she isn’t loud and doesn’t say things unless there’s a need to say them. There are a lot of overconfident kids in her class and she doesn’t wanna be like that. She’s been the same since she was a toddler. She’s very aloof and much more one to stand back and observe rather than pile on. She doesn’t get it from me, I’m an extrovert, but I’d never expect her to be the same as me so I encourage her to go the flow.

AIBU to get really pissed off when people describe quiet people in a negative way, like it’s a flaw?

I did say i don’t see what wrong with being quiet it’s who she is and I don’t think she needs to change, the teacher practically recoiled in horror 🙄

OP posts:
Goldbar · 11/10/2022 20:01

It's quite difficult for teachers to teach a whole class full of very quiet children though. You do sort of rely on some of the children being happy and willing to contribute to get a good class discussion going. Otherwise, it is a bit like trying to get blood from a stone.

AloysiusBear · 11/10/2022 20:00

There's nothing wrong with being quiet.

However, it can hold a child back if they never contribute in any discussion at all - they can be assumed as either having nothing to say, or not making an effort to join in. Group tasks rely on shared effort and it can be a drag on peers if one person effectively refuses to participate.

It can also be a barrier to learning if a pupil cannot even speak up to a) say that they haven't understood b) ask a question they need the answer to c) ask for help.

Benjispruce4 · 11/10/2022 19:59

If a quiet child is nervous when they are asked a question or their name is pulled out, a teacher should know and adjust accordingly. I will ask but if I can see they are uncomfortable I will assist , get their friend or partner involved or come back to them. Gentle encouragement.

SpidersAreShitheads · 11/10/2022 19:57

I was a school governor for several years and one of the issues I raised was that a teacher said the class award scheme would only get awarded to children if they "weren't too quiet". It's absolutely ridiculous, and unfair.

I don't see why children HAVE to be comfortable raising their hand in class to be considered as performing well. It's ridiculous. And I say this as someone now who is very comfortable at speaking out myself, but was cripplingly shy in school.

The louder children would routinely be picked for this special award/prize scheme even if they weren't so great in other areas. Quieter children would be told they would be considered if they started speaking up more - even if they contributed actively and positively in smaller groups.

Giving parents the feedback about children being quieter/uncomfortable in larger groups is fine. But I don't see that it's a flaw, and I don't see that it's something that MUST be fixed. Not everyone fits the same personality mould.

Schools have many positive attributes, but this insistence that every child develops in the same way is really damaging. Children aren't bloody clones.

ILoveMonday · 11/10/2022 19:55

I don't think you're wrong - quietly confident is a real thing. I wonder what the teacher was really getting at though? Maybe she thinks her silence is holding her back (which I have seen) and I think it's worthwhile asking her teacher for clarification as to what the actual problem is. Maybe you could encourage your daughter in a positive way by telling her that her thoughts are valuable and the teacher would like to hear what she has to say sometimes.

cansu · 11/10/2022 19:54

BTW Some 'quiet' children hate cold calling or lolly sticks. They feel under pressure and stressed that they might be asked something they don't know. I have had parents ask me not to ask their kids questions unless they have raised their hand.

cansu · 11/10/2022 19:51

I am starting to think that the best approach to parents' evening is to say that everything is brilliant. The child is perfect and there are no concerns whatsoever nor any targets at all.

I guess then the parents will be on here saying. 'The teacher couldn't give us any feedback on what she needs to work on. It was rubbish.'

The number of people who have taken umbrage about an innocuous comment or observation. Clearly for some parents saying someone is quiet in class is the same as saying they are not clever or capable or in some way of suggesting they won't do well.

Cheekylittle88 · 11/10/2022 19:51

I’m a quiet person because I’m shy. I’m not quiet in front of my family but I was quiet in school and college. I wish my mum hadn’t just assumed that I was fine and had helped me to feel more confident when at school x

Beancounter1 · 11/10/2022 19:48

The teacher is BU for expecting/allowing 'hands-up'. Far better for the teacher to choose children to answer questions, either deliberately or randomly, and tailor the question to the ability of the child.
Teacher needs more training.

Blahdeebla · 11/10/2022 19:48

Some people speak because they have something to say, some people speak because they have to say something.

I totally agree with you OP, buy the teacher the book 'quiet' as a little gift 😀.

Sh05 · 11/10/2022 19:45

I used to get this all the time for both my boys, Ds 1 is now in university, studying software engineering and smashed all his A levels and GCSEs.
Ds2 is in year 10 and has had multiple stars of the week in multiple subjects already this year.
I always found that the more experienced teachers said their quietness wasn't a problem, it was always the more inexperienced teachers who bring up their quietness/ shyness.

cansu · 11/10/2022 19:43

No it isn't a bad thing but developing the confidence to participate in class is a good thing and will help her in the future. You are over reacting to a reasonable bit of feedback.

Untitledsquatboulder · 11/10/2022 19:42

Choconut · 11/10/2022 19:32

Society is not made for introverts. They are seen as something that must be fixed.

Being an introvert doesn't mean not participating in class.

And there's a lot of clear water between being an "ostentatious gobshite" Hmm and sitting there like a bump on a log.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 11/10/2022 19:42

I think the teacher needs to find a better way to include everyone in lessons and not rely on the same few who willingly put hands up for everything. I seems to remember DCs had a teacher who had a jar of lolly sticks with everyones names and she would randomly draw names for answers or to appoint a group leader etc. to avoid the same few being picked. Also if being quiet is the only negative thing the teacher can think to say your DD is not doing badly. But really the teacher should think of a better way to convey that she would like her to participate a bit more.

Choconut · 11/10/2022 19:37

I would also say that often the issue is with the teacher in making the classroom feel like a safe place to speak up. My DS is a gob shite in some classes and wouldn't say a word in others depending on how safe he feels speaking up in that particular class.

GlassDeli · 11/10/2022 19:36

It also depends what culture and period of history you're born in, as to what the societal ideal might be. In some eras and places, being discreet, meditative, sensitive, poetic, individually creative, thoughtful and calm are valued as qualities.

Darbs76 · 11/10/2022 19:35

Stereolab · 11/10/2022 19:16

Quiet - (the power of introverts in a world that can’t stop talking), by Susan Cain is a good book on this topic It includes a chapter for teachers.

This is an excellent book, my daughters dad read it and I keep meaning to read it as our daughter is an introvert. As both parents are extroverts we wanted to understand it a bit more so do recommend it

Gatehouse77 · 11/10/2022 19:33

I agree. We had this with DD1. Like you, I said to teachers how wonderful it that there’s a variety of personalities 😜
And you know what, when she was ready she learned what her own limits were and matured at her own rate.

Choconut · 11/10/2022 19:32

Society is not made for introverts. They are seen as something that must be fixed.

Manasprey · 11/10/2022 19:31

One of the many, many sticks to beat teachers in observations was when a kid wouldn't speak in a lesson. Having grown up with my mum's stories of being painfully shy, I always hated having to try and make them all talk. I get that not speaking doesn't mean not engaged.

I was that kid bouncing in her seat, desperate to answer.

luxxlisbon · 11/10/2022 19:31

It pisses me off because what exactly is wrong with not being some ostentatious gobshite of a child?

Sounds like you have already decided that being quiet is better. Not being overly quiet doesn’t mean the child has to be an ostentatious gobsite. You’re just being a dick now.

There is also a difference between a quiet child and one who is totally disengaged with group activities in class and won’t actively participate. It sounds like the teacher is just trying to broach the subject with you so you can both work on building her confidence in school more so she takes part.

Newmum110 · 11/10/2022 19:30

Had (and still have) the exact same with my child. Feeling like saying to teachers that they all can't be the class clown. Absolutely nothing wrong with being quite.

RedHelenB · 11/10/2022 19:27

YABU , she needs to answer questions in class. Just like the over enthusiastic ones need to give others a chance to join in.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 11/10/2022 19:26

It pisses me off because what exactly is wrong with not being some ostentatious gobshite of a child

There is a middle ground. That comment was unnecessarily nasty towards more vocal children.

I'd guess she knows what your DD is capable of and what she can offer to a conversation so wants to encourage your DD to talk up for that reason? Especially as you sat she isn't shy

BeanieTeen · 11/10/2022 19:25

I’m a teacher and was also a ‘quiet’ child. I definitely avoid that term, it really isn’t nice to be referred to in that way as a negative. There’s nothing wrong with being quiet - many children are quietly confident, but some are quiet just because they don’t feel able to speak or lack confidence. The hand up thing I would always encourage as I suppose it’s a confidence boost and an important aspect of whole class learning - it is a shame when children don’t feel secure enough to share their ideas. It’s always great to see someone come out of their shell in that way because you can see they actually feel very good about themselves when they’ve plucked up the courage to put their hand up!