Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s nothing wrong with quiet children?

157 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 18:38

Just had my parents evening for DD (9).

I was told “She’s very quiet” and they want her to speak up and raise her hand more. Very much spoke about ‘being quiet’ like it’s a bad thing.

It pisses me off because what exactly is wrong with not being some ostentatious gobshite of a child? She is far from shy - she will stick up for herself, place her own order in a restaurant etc. but she isn’t loud and doesn’t say things unless there’s a need to say them. There are a lot of overconfident kids in her class and she doesn’t wanna be like that. She’s been the same since she was a toddler. She’s very aloof and much more one to stand back and observe rather than pile on. She doesn’t get it from me, I’m an extrovert, but I’d never expect her to be the same as me so I encourage her to go the flow.

AIBU to get really pissed off when people describe quiet people in a negative way, like it’s a flaw?

I did say i don’t see what wrong with being quiet it’s who she is and I don’t think she needs to change, the teacher practically recoiled in horror 🙄

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 12/10/2022 11:18

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 12/10/2022 07:38

Why would she ‘sit back and ignore my daughter’? Are you saying I should be glad the teacher isn’t a really shit teacher?

I’m saying you should be glad she’s taking an interest in your child’s specific personality and noticing where she needs support in class. She has noted that she’s a quiet girl who can’t or won’t join class discussion, and is thinking about how to support her with that.

And no, you didn’t say all other children were ostentatious gobshites, but you suggested she was better quiet than an ostentatious gobshites, ignoring the massive gap between those two descriptions, populated by children who can be quiet at silent work time and can participate in class discussion.

I know it feels weird to accept hearing something that feels like a flaw about your child but that’s the point of parent teacher meetings. I guarantee she will not have sat in front of one parent and said ‘oh Jess? No she’s perfect. She shouldn’t work on anything, perfect in every way, no further learning required.’ If she did she wouldn’t be a very good teacher.

FrenchPlatypus · 12/10/2022 08:52

Interesting @Untitledsquatboulder , not to derail but my quiet but calmly confident dd would like to be a Zoologist. Do you like your job?

Untitledsquatboulder · 12/10/2022 08:10

In many careers you can be highly successful without having any knowledge of art, or science or geography. The point of school is to teach a wide range of skills and knowledge to equip children for whichever career they choose. You have no idea of whether the OPS dd will need to participate in group discussions in later life and neither does the OP. I've ended up in a job where I do it all the time and I'm a zoologist, a career I embarked on because I like animals and didn't particularly want to speak to anybody.

Vulpine · 12/10/2022 08:03

Out of my kids friends I much prefer the ones who chat

Gruffling · 12/10/2022 08:01

For me, this is just another reason why class sizes of 30 are failing many children.

In what situation is an adult expected to participate in a discussion of 30 people? In many careers you can be highly successful without ever having to participate in large group discussions.

Untitledsquatboulder · 12/10/2022 07:56

Why do you think being "loud and a gobshite" would be considered a good thing? Have you ever heard a teacher say that?

The teacher is feeding back to you that your dd contributes very little to class discussions. If you want to make her reticence to open her mouth a virtue, go for it. If you want to characterise children who do occasionally open their mouths, give an opinion, express an idea, get enthused about a lesson as "gobshites" that says far more about you than either the teacher or them.

sashh · 12/10/2022 07:51

From a teacher point of view it's easy to overlook the quiet ones, it's can also be an issue with children too shy to ask for help.

One way I have used it 'traffic lights' either with the whole class or just the odd quiet student.

For the whole class I get them to make a sort of toblerone shape with green, yellow and red sides (also written on in case of colour blindness).

If I'm seeing green then the students are fine and understand what's happening, yellow they need more explanation and red for 'help'.

It can be done more covertly with coloured pens.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 12/10/2022 07:38

Kanaloa · 11/10/2022 23:09

And it seems pretty clear the teacher wasn’t looking to insult your daughter - but a teacher will notice and seek to support a child who doesn’t or can’t join in class discussions confidently. If anything it is good thing - she could just as easily sit back and ignore your daughter.

Why would she ‘sit back and ignore my daughter’? Are you saying I should be glad the teacher isn’t a really shit teacher?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 12/10/2022 07:37

Kanaloa · 11/10/2022 23:07

I mean you’ve got upset with the teacher suggesting your child is quiet. If you don’t like her being labeled as ‘quiet’ for not participating in class discussion it’s hardly surprising that people are pointing out it’s worse to be referring to the children who do participate as ‘ostentatious gobshites.’

Oh FGS I didn’t say that any non-quiet children are ostentatious gobshites. My point was that being described as ‘quiet’ is clearly a criticism to many, and if she was loud and a gobshite, it would be considered a good thing and I don’t know why.

OP posts:
FreudayNight · 11/10/2022 23:42

bellabasset · 11/10/2022 23:24

I'd say that a being quiet, being thoughtful and more considered before expressing opinions might not be a bad thing.

That’s just a passive aggressive control mechanism isn’t it?

It’s the #BeKind friendly version of “Better to be thought a fool, than open one’s mouth and leave no doubt.” More considered is obviously being weaponised, and that’s not for the kids benefit is it?
Don’t forget we’re talking about children, many of whom learn best using the socratic method… a form of teacher guided more consideration if you will.

Was your comment meant in the mean spirited and nasty way it’s being perceived as?

CaptainBarbosa · 11/10/2022 23:28

I wish my child were "quiet", he's got ADHD and natters/talks non stop ..like you can tell he just likes making noise, sometimes it not been words, just random sounds like going "bop, bop,bop" over and over again 😂

I don't see an issue at all with being quiet, we all couldn't be loud the world would be a deafening place!

Mariposista · 11/10/2022 23:25

There are two kinds of quiet child. One is the kid who prefers to be a listener rather than muscle in with what is going on, but is still actively engaged, and the other is the one gawping out the window, in their own world, disengaged. Provided your kid falls into the first camp, she is absolutely fine!

bellabasset · 11/10/2022 23:24

I'd say that a being quiet, being thoughtful and more considered before expressing opinions might not be a bad thing.

FreudayNight · 11/10/2022 23:23

Kite22 · 11/10/2022 23:19

But being nervous and anxious is not the same as being quiet and observational.

I agree. I was replying to a pp who was saying pupils shouldn't be asked to do things if they aren't comfortable with some aspect of it.

That’s such a bad idea. Basically telling people that “comfort” is the most important thing? And that being asked to go outside their comfort zone is unreasonable.
Daft!

XenoBitch · 11/10/2022 23:20

I was a very quiet and anxious child. My anxiety got me out of giving presentations throughout school, college and uni etc.
Now, in my 40s, I can not find the courage to stand up in front of anyone. I cant even get up for a piss in front of the people in the support groups I attend.
Maybe, if my teachers and parents had made the effort with me, I would not be a useless wreck now.

Kite22 · 11/10/2022 23:19

But being nervous and anxious is not the same as being quiet and observational.

I agree. I was replying to a pp who was saying pupils shouldn't be asked to do things if they aren't comfortable with some aspect of it.

PinkRiceKrispies · 11/10/2022 23:19

Also used to get this all the time as a child and still now as an adult.
It's always made me feel like I am lacking somehow and not as good as louder and more confident people. 😔

FreudayNight · 11/10/2022 23:18

Putting aside the unnecessary hostility to kids that do speak up, I do think that there is something quite cheeky about simultaneously not wanted to participate/contribute in classes whilst feeling entitled to criticize those who do.

How about having a little think about how that might come across to other people.

TLKlover · 11/10/2022 23:16

Why my brain put younger instead of quieter...I'll never know! Sorry about that.

MostTacticalNameChange · 11/10/2022 23:15

This touched a nerve...I was an A* student but throughout secondary, college and uni I was criticised for being quiet.

One teacher even told my parents I was arrogant because I didn't engage with her class ( I had consistent A grades in her class for my work but she would verbally shred anyone who didn't answer perfectly so I protected myself by never volunteering to answer).

I have always been naturally shy but the compound shame I have been made to feel for being that way makes me really angry now I'm pushing middle age. I was always good, well behaved, compliant and well qualified but still made to feel like a useless shit because I wasn't a hands-up leader.

I think it's inseparable from sex too. Women in work have the worst of all worlds...you're a shy, retiring wallflower who needs to grow a backbone and when you do you're an obnoxious bitch who should know her place.

TLKlover · 11/10/2022 23:14

I was a quiet (not shy) child, as one teacher very firmly pointed out to my mum in high school.

I spoke when needed & my parents were often told, 'we can see she has a lot to offer, we'd like to see more of that'. However, I still only spoke when asked a question or whether I had a particular interest in a subject.

Now I have a lot more confidence & work in a role where I need to speak alot!

My daughter's are the same, often told 'how polite they are but quiet. They wish they could hear more from them.'

They are both happy at school & know when they can speak up to show their knowledge/interest in a subject and I think based on their personalities ( similar but different too - does that make sense?), they will do fab in whatever they choose to do!

Try not to worry OP, teachers want the best for all their children and based on experience of having two go through primary school, they will just want to make sure that your child is not going to lose out being a smaller voice within a crowd.

Quieter children can get lost in the midst of louder children but good teachers will draw the skills of younger children out.

Kanaloa · 11/10/2022 23:09

And it seems pretty clear the teacher wasn’t looking to insult your daughter - but a teacher will notice and seek to support a child who doesn’t or can’t join in class discussions confidently. If anything it is good thing - she could just as easily sit back and ignore your daughter.

Kanaloa · 11/10/2022 23:07

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 22:45

FWIW, my DS is definitely an ostentatious gobshite 🤣 not sure why people are getting so upset with that term.

I mean you’ve got upset with the teacher suggesting your child is quiet. If you don’t like her being labeled as ‘quiet’ for not participating in class discussion it’s hardly surprising that people are pointing out it’s worse to be referring to the children who do participate as ‘ostentatious gobshites.’

Thinkingblonde · 11/10/2022 23:06

I was a quiet child, I’m a quiet softly spoken woman now.
I hated having to speak out in class, never put my hand up voluntarily.
I was quiet so as not to draw attention to myself. I stammered you see, I still do although nowhere near as bad as back then.
One of my daughters is like me but without the stammer. So is her 7 year daughter. She’s not particularly quiet at home but she can be shy around people she doesn’t know, she does eventually engage with them once she’s weighed them up.
Being quiet hasn’t done either of us any harm or held us back. We can make ourselves heard or get our point across as well as any one else.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 23:04

Being quiet doesn’t mean you always have anxiety either. The notion that you must be riddled with anxiety all of the time and be shit at life if you’re an introvert really is insulting

Completely agree. And I say this as an extrovert (and self confessed gobshite), introverts are really sold down the river and pegged with all sorts of things, it is bloody insulting

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread