Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s nothing wrong with quiet children?

157 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 18:38

Just had my parents evening for DD (9).

I was told “She’s very quiet” and they want her to speak up and raise her hand more. Very much spoke about ‘being quiet’ like it’s a bad thing.

It pisses me off because what exactly is wrong with not being some ostentatious gobshite of a child? She is far from shy - she will stick up for herself, place her own order in a restaurant etc. but she isn’t loud and doesn’t say things unless there’s a need to say them. There are a lot of overconfident kids in her class and she doesn’t wanna be like that. She’s been the same since she was a toddler. She’s very aloof and much more one to stand back and observe rather than pile on. She doesn’t get it from me, I’m an extrovert, but I’d never expect her to be the same as me so I encourage her to go the flow.

AIBU to get really pissed off when people describe quiet people in a negative way, like it’s a flaw?

I did say i don’t see what wrong with being quiet it’s who she is and I don’t think she needs to change, the teacher practically recoiled in horror 🙄

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/10/2022 22:33

I've always liked my own company and some people find it hard to accept, everyone should be constanty 'sharing' their feelings

My DD is so like this. She keeps her feelings between me and her dad. Theres been a whole lot of school activity for MH awareness week this week and she’s hated every moment. Having to write your feelings on a star and talk with peers about what makes you sad. She said it was ‘super cringey’ and she felt really uncomfortable doing it. She doesn’t wanna share her feelings to her class. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that, in fact I’m proud of her for knowing who she is and going with it no matter what.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/10/2022 22:31

Quincythequince · 12/10/2022 20:49

There was nothing remotely resembling humour in your post referring to children as such.Clearly I’m not the only one who bought that either.

Christ you’d think I’d personally called each of your children cunts the way everyone is over reacting to two fairly innocuous words.

I think a few people on this thread need to grow a thicker skin.

I love how this thread has gone on to analyse what the success chances of my 9yo in her future career and Uni life 🤣 good old MN! My whole point is why is seen as being ‘quiet’ a bad thing?!

My niece is even quieter than DD, properly shy and timid (not around loved ones) and it’s like when people say “Ooh aren’t you shy” to her. What makes people think they can do this?!

OP posts:
Kite22 · 13/10/2022 19:05

@Gruffling I haven't missed the point at all.
I am able to do this, because it was required of me as a child and as a teen, so it's something I have practised.
The OP's dd is 9. No-one has any idea of what she might do when she is older. I also doubt very much if any 9 yr old is going to retire having only done the job they joined straight from school, so if not needed in one job, it might be in another. Also, as a pp said, she will quite possibly need to partake in discussion groups at University if she goes, or might want to be part of a campaign group for something, or 101 other places where it is normal to speak in front of other people.
Making this a normal thing to do, when in front of a group of familiar people she spends all day with at school, is going to make it less daunting when she later needs to do it in front of people who are less familiar or even who are strangers.

JudgeJ · 13/10/2022 11:20

serenaisaknobhead · 11/10/2022 18:44

This was me when younger. My mum used to tell people I was a loner but really I enjoyed my own company.

Found my voice when I went to uni but I still like my own company.

She's fine. Ignore them.

I've always liked my own company and some people find it hard to accept, everyone should be constanty 'sharing' their feelings! When my OH died very suddenly at the start of lockdown it was, I think, my liking my own compny that got me through it. Acquaintances would ring up, very sorry that because of the lockdown they couldn't drop round to be with me, my mental thought was God bless covid!

Kanaloa · 13/10/2022 10:43

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/10/2022 10:02

A lot of posts saying not speaking in class isn't such a problem as long as child can contri6during group work. Groups in primary are normally about 6.

And yes, 30 kids per class. Not such a huge number and these are familiar children. So not quite in the same league as addressing the whole school. Speaking up in class is a reasonable aspiration for most children.

As for career change - which careers guarentee you'll never need to speak in front of 30 peers?

I mean surely you’d even struggle to get into careers that require a degree if you refuse to speak in group situations. Don’t know about every degree of course, but in mine seminar and workshop participation is mandatory, usually in groups of between 12 and 20, and you’d struggle if you refused to ever ask a question in a lecture which can have loads of people in it.

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/10/2022 10:02

contribute during

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/10/2022 10:02

A lot of posts saying not speaking in class isn't such a problem as long as child can contri6during group work. Groups in primary are normally about 6.

And yes, 30 kids per class. Not such a huge number and these are familiar children. So not quite in the same league as addressing the whole school. Speaking up in class is a reasonable aspiration for most children.

As for career change - which careers guarentee you'll never need to speak in front of 30 peers?

Gruffling · 13/10/2022 09:36

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/10/2022 08:35

@Gruffling what a stupid post. Not being able to voice your opinion in a group of more than 6 would be limiting in many careers and being introverted doesn't mean you can't do it anyway. Being an introvert doesn't mean you are only happy sitting in a corner by yourself.

Honestly, I've seen so many women's careers blighted because they just lack the self confidence to address a group its depressing. And it's also perfectly possible to overcome with practise for the vast majority of people.

Where did you get 6 from?

OP is talking about a child speaking out in a state school, where class sizes are 30.

And as for the women with the blighted careers - if they are really that introverted that this one aspect of their work is blighting their careers, then perhaps a career change is needed.

superplumb · 13/10/2022 09:19

Nowt wrong with being quiet my 6 year is a chatter box. There is a big diff between quiet and a gobshite though!!
Is your daughter shy? Maybe the teacher feels she lacks confidence and is trying to encourage her? I get that some people are very confident but dont shout it from the roof tops.

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/10/2022 08:35

@Gruffling what a stupid post. Not being able to voice your opinion in a group of more than 6 would be limiting in many careers and being introverted doesn't mean you can't do it anyway. Being an introvert doesn't mean you are only happy sitting in a corner by yourself.

Honestly, I've seen so many women's careers blighted because they just lack the self confidence to address a group its depressing. And it's also perfectly possible to overcome with practise for the vast majority of people.

Gruffling · 13/10/2022 08:27

Kite22 · 12/10/2022 22:58

In what situation is an adult expected to participate in a discussion of 30 people?

Well, just in the last month, for me

  • work
  • a meeting of something I volunteer with
  • a meeting of something else I volunteer with
  • a training course I was on
  • a Church meeting
  • a training course I was delivering.
I mean, that is just in the last 5 weeks.

Now, not everyone will have encountered as many, but when a child is at school, no-one knows what opportunities will offer themselves to them once they are adults. By encouraging that child to challenge themselves a little, the teacher could make the world of difference.

The other point is, it isn't a 'criticism' of the child.
A parents evening should always consist of

  • what the child does well
  • what the child could do better
That applies if the child is a mensa member or if they have learning difficulties or the whole range in between.

So you have the kind of job where you deliver training and you do lots of volunteering that requires you to attend and speak up at large meetings....ergo all children need these skills?

You missed my point entirely, that I know many introverted people in successful careers that are never required to do this.

Maybe your school should have focused on helping you to be more imaginative and creative so that you are able to envisage that everyone needs to be exactly like you.

mondaytosunday · 12/10/2022 23:20

I have a loud son and a quiet daughter. She's very self contained. She doesn't raise her hand much. But I can see from the teachers point of view - they want to make sure she is 'getting it'. Plus they may think she has something interesting to contribute. Part of grades are in class participation.
My son was loud and gobby. I got as much complaints about that as I do about my daughter being quiet.

mastertomsmum · 12/10/2022 23:05

Schools are often keen to label kids. The private school we were at for a while when relocating back to UK from abroad was really bad at this. They had some sort of ideal student - sporty, not too bright, able bodied, not sensitive and they also used to say he needed to ‘aim to be more compliant’. Honestly, who in their right minds wants a sheep. Vive La difference!

Kite22 · 12/10/2022 22:58

In what situation is an adult expected to participate in a discussion of 30 people?

Well, just in the last month, for me

  • work
  • a meeting of something I volunteer with
  • a meeting of something else I volunteer with
  • a training course I was on
  • a Church meeting
  • a training course I was delivering.
I mean, that is just in the last 5 weeks.

Now, not everyone will have encountered as many, but when a child is at school, no-one knows what opportunities will offer themselves to them once they are adults. By encouraging that child to challenge themselves a little, the teacher could make the world of difference.

The other point is, it isn't a 'criticism' of the child.
A parents evening should always consist of

  • what the child does well
  • what the child could do better
That applies if the child is a mensa member or if they have learning difficulties or the whole range in between.
Quincythequince · 12/10/2022 20:49

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/10/2022 22:54

Dear for pardon me for trying to inject a little humour 🙄 you used to be able to do this on MN.

That comment has really touched a nerve with some people

There was nothing remotely resembling humour in your post referring to children as such.Clearly I’m not the only one who bought that either.

Fairislefandango · 12/10/2022 19:10

Oh FGS I didn’t say that any non-quiet children are ostentatious gobshites. My point was that being described as ‘quiet’ is clearly a criticism to many, and if she was loud and a gobshite, it would be considered a good thing and I don’t know why.

But that's not true at all. Being loud and a gobshite is not considered a good thing by teachers. Participating and contributing are though. Not the same thing at all.

Why would she ‘sit back and ignore my daughter’? Are you saying I should be glad the teacher isn’t a really shit teacher?

The poster very obviously meant that the teacher could just ignore the fact that your daughter is quiet and allow her to just not contribute or respond. Do you think that would make her a shit teacher? What do you actually want the teacher to do then? You don't want her to comment to you that your daughter is quiet, or try to get her to be less quiet (because being quiet is a good thing) but you also don't want her to ignore your daughter's quietness?

OnlyHams · 12/10/2022 18:38

YABU

She isn’t just quiet

She isn’t participating in class enough, that’s the issue here

maybe you can take this for what it is, a teacher giving good feedback on how your child could improve in class.

itsgettingweird · 12/10/2022 18:03

Nothing wrong with being quiet if you have nothing to say.

But if the class is asked a question and she has nothing to say it's an indication she doesn't know the answers. Which is worrying.

Teachers will encourage children to put hands up and answer questions and will also tell the parents of the louder outgoing kids the same if they don't out their hand up to answer.

Being able to speak up is a good skill to have.

GCMM · 12/10/2022 14:02

I was a quiet child of a quiet parent. I am now the quiet parent of my own quiet child. We are all happy, well adjusted, successful people!

HauntedDishcloth · 12/10/2022 13:07

XenoBitch · 11/10/2022 23:20

I was a very quiet and anxious child. My anxiety got me out of giving presentations throughout school, college and uni etc.
Now, in my 40s, I can not find the courage to stand up in front of anyone. I cant even get up for a piss in front of the people in the support groups I attend.
Maybe, if my teachers and parents had made the effort with me, I would not be a useless wreck now.

Similar to me. But I was quiet because I'd been abused. No one went any further with me to check if there was something underlying. Not that I'm saying this is the case with the OP's DC of course, but maybe in some cases & perhaps there's a way to check it out so people don't end with decades of mental distress.

SparklyDiscoBall · 12/10/2022 11:58

My son is a quiet, gentle child and always has been. He is slowly building his confidence, and school and sport have both played important roles in doing that. But I always tell teachers at parents evening that he is who he is and I would never want to change that. He is very bright, has friends, and is a genuinely lovely kid. Being quiet doesn’t equal being a loner or that there’s something “wrong”.

Someone upthread said it’s the teacher’s job to make sure the louder children don’t dominate - exactly this. Yes the quieter children do need to learn the skills to speak up when it’s appropriate to do so, but the louder children need to learn the skills to shut up and know when it’s time to let others speak. That’s an equally important life lesson.

It sounds like your daughter is doing just fine.

FeelTheRush · 12/10/2022 11:52

There is nothing wrong with being quiet but being perceived as "very aloof" is potentially going to hinder socially as she goes to secondary

ThisShitsBananas · 12/10/2022 11:33

I’m a gobshite but have two very quiet children and it’s such a worry to me. I know deep down they are fine but I do suffer terribly with anxiety about them being desperately unhappy because the only time I myself am quiet is when I’m depressed.

badgermushrooms · 12/10/2022 11:27

I was a quiet child, partly because - I now realise - I needed help with social skills. Teachers complaining to my parents that I was quiet every parents evening did not provide that help, not least because they are also quiet people. In my case by secondary school they were asking me to speak more in class because I was a bookworm who often knew the answers but then completely failing to protect me from the bullying that was a direct consequence of sticking my head above the parapet. If I sound bitter it's because I am - stop treating quiet children like they're being difficult and start dealing with the reasons they're quiet!

That Susan Cain book changed my life. I wish it had existed when I was 13.

Untitledsquatboulder · 12/10/2022 11:25

@FrenchPlatypus love it, no regrets at all. But most zoologist aren't hands on with animals, we study them, survey them or (in my case) manage land for wildlife. So if she wants to be literally hands on then zoology may not be the right choice iyswim?