Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd 'best' friend has upset her at school today

57 replies

auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 17:21

8 year old Dd came home from school today upset because her 'best' friend hasn't invited her to her birthday after school tea party today. Her friend told her that only her best 3 friends were invited and Dd wasn't one of them.
This has been confounded by the fact I arranged for this friend to come over last week for Dd's 8th birthday after school for tea and cake and a bit of a fuss. There was no party arranged for Dd because we were supposed to be going away for it, but for a number of reasons I moved the holiday to half term instead so thought having her 'best' friend over would make up for the cancelled trip somewhat.
I am really upset for my Dd because yet again, someone she thought of as a friend has upset her to the point she was crying in school over it.
Dd has been invited to this friend's bigger party on the weekend which is basically an all day event at a trampoline park. I really begrudge going to this party now, having to dedicate a whole weekend day there (when I have so many other things I could be doing) and having to buy this girl a gift and card, when she clearly has no real regard for my Dd as a friend. The mother has asked for Pusheen stuff as a gift too, so not cheap 🙄.
I know 8 year olds are fickle and still learning social skills, but this girl is very precocious and I feel her mum is not coming off well in this either for not returning the invite for an after school birthday tea (I am disappointed in mum too as I thought she was nice).
I just wish there was some way of helping my Dd with these unpleasant encounters. She is a very sensitive and anxious child, but doesn't struggle socially (although there is a pattern forming of her being unable to make close friends like her other peers). I worry that she will end up finding it difficult or withdrawing from making new friends because she will always expect to get hurt 😔.

OP posts:
auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 18:59

stayathomer · 11/10/2022 18:54

please don’t try to force kids together, you can nudge them but after that it’s down to the children. You push and all that will happen is they’ll break apart in a spectacular way. And the other parent can’t make her daughter invite someone. I’ve seen mothers stop talking and then their children get back together but the mothers don’t and it’s so sad. She’s invited to the big day out, definitely definitely go!! And I’m so so sorry op, I’ve been where you are and it’s so hard. The only thing is remember they are so young and there will be downs but so many ups too.

I’m really not ‘forcing’ anything here. The girls have had a couple of play dates over the summer hols . The mum always expects us both to stay together with the girls whenever we meet up, so I have gotten to know the mum quite well now…enough to ask me if I would be available for regular free childcare at one point!

OP posts:
stayathomer · 11/10/2022 18:54

please don’t try to force kids together, you can nudge them but after that it’s down to the children. You push and all that will happen is they’ll break apart in a spectacular way. And the other parent can’t make her daughter invite someone. I’ve seen mothers stop talking and then their children get back together but the mothers don’t and it’s so sad. She’s invited to the big day out, definitely definitely go!! And I’m so so sorry op, I’ve been where you are and it’s so hard. The only thing is remember they are so young and there will be downs but so many ups too.

IamnotSethRogan · 11/10/2022 18:51

Kids sometimes say things not always in the best way, I've had something similar recently and you just have to take it with a pinch of salt as they can be very blunt.

Could be a variety of reasons why she's not invited to the child's house (and these trampoline parties are pretty bloody expensive so it makes sense to keep this thing small) for example the mum is friends with the other kids mums and wants a chat at the casual birthday tea.

Goldbar · 11/10/2022 18:47

I think you're taking this a little bit too personally. Imo the best thing to do would be to tell your DD she can't be invited to everything, remind her that she'll have the fun of the trampoline party and encourage her to diversify and be resilient in her friendships. Sometimes friendships evolve and sometimes friends let us down, but there's no point dwelling on it.

I wouldn't be buying an expensive gift though!

auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 18:44

Notanotherwindow · 11/10/2022 18:12

Get her a shit gift from poundland and if shes likely to say anything I'd be inclined to prime your DD to say that she only gets proper presents for close friends. But then I'm a petty cow.

Love this! Hahaha, I’m thinking a re-gift so I don’t even have to bother going Poundland 😂!

OP posts:
auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 18:40

To answer a few points made:
I can’t be regarded as a cheapskate for not organising a bigger party surely? I explained on here and to the mum that the tea was a last minute thing because of a cancelled holiday for DD’s birthday. It’s a little difficult to organise a big party at a few days notice.
The trampoline party is a half hour drive away and we are expected to stay.
No, Dd is not a first child. I have a 25 year old son from a previous relationship and didn’t experience this kind of thing with him growing up. Things seem so much more complicated now!
I guess it stings because I still remember certain so called friends saying hurtful things to me growing up, and I’m projecting my own hurtful experiences as a child onto this situation, so I know I am being a bit over sensitive here.
I do encourage her to make lots of friends, she goes to Brownies and makes friends at swimming lessons too. Her teachers always say what a ray of sunshine she is, that she has no issues socially and is popular in school (despite never being asked on play dates or to lots of parties like other kids in her class).
Dd has said that’s not how good friends are supposed to speak, and I agreed saying that, yes, her friend hasn’t explained things very nicely.

OP posts:
Mariposista · 11/10/2022 18:32

I feel very sorry for your daughter - I was her over 20 years ago and it feels gut wrenching. I had many sleepless nights worrying about friendships. Please don't worry about her. How she is at 8 is no way how she will be as a teenager, student and adult. I am 30+ now and have great friends. Girls are nasty and play the exclusion/best friends card all the time. Do something nice with her this evening to take her mind off it.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 11/10/2022 18:31

As heartbreaking as it is to see your child upset over something like this, the other family haven’t done anything wrong.

They reciprocated your invitation by inviting your dd to their party. That you only had an after school celebration with one friend for your dd is irrelevant to their plans.

Hesma · 11/10/2022 18:29

She been invited to the party… you are being very precious and entitled

Iguanainanigloo · 11/10/2022 18:28

At 8, their friendships can still be quite fickle and fluid, and I can guarantee if I ask my 8 year old who her best friends are from one week to the next, the names will be completely different each time! She has got a couple of children that she's closer to, as I'm good friends with the mums, so we'll often do stuff with all 3 of them together, including mini tea parties to celebrate the girls birthday, and get together ourselves separate to the "main party". Could it be this? That the mum is more friendly with those mums, so it's kind of a "party" for her dd, but also a get together with the other parents she's closest to? I understand it's upsetting seeing your child feeling left out, but it happens, and is a part of life we all have to unfortunately learn to live with and deal with. Actually an important life skill. Don't begrudge your daughter getting to go to the main party on the weekend, as I'm sure she's excited to go, and will have lots of fun. No need to emphasize and focus on the need for a "best friend" at that age, as someone is always going to get upset, and causes tensions when one of the children wants to spend time with someone else.

PoeticLicense · 11/10/2022 18:25

At eight years old a girl is old enough to know it is hurtful to say you are having a tea for your best friends when you were invited for a special birthday tea by yourself the previous week. YANBU at all.

phishy · 11/10/2022 18:25

Notanotherwindow · 11/10/2022 18:12

Get her a shit gift from poundland and if shes likely to say anything I'd be inclined to prime your DD to say that she only gets proper presents for close friends. But then I'm a petty cow.

Love this.

PoeticLicense · 11/10/2022 18:23

Around eight years old is quite a tough time for girls to navigate the minefield that is female friendship. I understand you being upset. The best thing for your DD is for you not to overthink it and to downplay the whole thing. I would ask your DD if she still wants to go to the trampoline party and, if she does, send her with a card and a £5 book or similar. Don't put too much thought into the present. If your DD doesn't want to go, I would just call off saying something vague like something has come up. The most important thing is your DD's self-esteem. I would be encouraging her to widen her friendship group to less precious/precocious girls who are perhaps more worthy of her affection.

Prinnny · 11/10/2022 18:16

YABU.

Shes invited to her friends main party but wasn’t chosen for tea tonight, like many other party invitees I imagine. Just because your child views this girl as her BFF it doesn’t make the relationship reciprocated or exclusive.

I would suggest you both work on your personal resilience.

Notanotherwindow · 11/10/2022 18:12

Get her a shit gift from poundland and if shes likely to say anything I'd be inclined to prime your DD to say that she only gets proper presents for close friends. But then I'm a petty cow.

phishy · 11/10/2022 18:05

Does dd even want to go to the trampoline park?

phishy · 11/10/2022 18:05

A £5 max one.

phishy · 11/10/2022 18:05

Don't get the Pusheen stuff. Get a book.

TrashyPanda · 11/10/2022 18:03

Why are you thinking you have to spend the day at the trampoline park?
Surely you will just drop her off?

Summerfun54321 · 11/10/2022 18:02

Don’t project your disappointment, try and be matter of fact that maybe she isn’t such a good friend which you understand is very disappointing for you DD, but discuss how to foster new friendships. Having 1 best friend isn’t always healthy.

SunneRising · 11/10/2022 17:58

Your DD invited friend to a birthday tea. Friend has returned the invitation by inviting your DD to her party. Both girls have a birthday social event. So I don't think the mum is rude. (She could equally think you were a cheapskate by not having a party but doing a "tea and a fuss".)

As others have said teach your DD how to navigate this but I think that whilst the other eight year old might not have handled it well, this is not unfair.

Royalbloo · 11/10/2022 17:55

Sounds like my childhood! But I'm trying to teach my DD resilience, so I would skim over it and not react, no matter how upset she was. Anyone is entitled to invite anyone else to their party, and if you're not invited, that's that. She can choose her friends on the basis of who is kind to her, which this isn't.

musingsinmidlife · 11/10/2022 17:54

Her friend has done nothing wrong. Your daughter and this girl are friends but based on their other friendships, this specific friendship is perceived differently by each of them. It sounds like maybe your daughter just has a couple close friends and this other girl maybe has a big network off friends and lots of close friends. That doesn't say anything bad about the girl or your daughter. Many people have been in that situation as personality, extroversion, social circles, etc all mean different kinds of friendships.

SerenaTee · 11/10/2022 17:49

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 11/10/2022 17:33

I say this as gently as I can:

This is a really good opportunity for your DD to learn that just because someone is your best friend, it doesn't mean you are theirs.
And this is totally okay.

What if it were the other way around? What if your DD had a friend who considered her a very best friend but your DD didn't feel the same way? Would you force her to choose her over another, closer friend?

Encourage your DD to enjoy the friendship for what it is. Maybe encourage her also to join some clubs or groups where she'll meet other girls her age from different schools and other walks of life and make more friends so she isn't so reliant on one friendship.

Totally this, the birthday girl wasn’t obliged to invite your DD just because your DD invited her to her birthday tea.

These are 8 year old kids, you’re taking it very personally - you were presumably happy enough to sacrifice a weekend day and buy a present for your DD to attend the trampoline party before, it seems a bit churlish to be annoyed at this now you’ve found out she has missed out on a smaller get together.

Strugglingtodomybest · 11/10/2022 17:45

This is a really good opportunity for your DD to learn that just because someone is your best friend, it doesn't mean you are theirs.
And this is totally okay.

I agree with this. Use this as a lesson in building resilience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread