Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd 'best' friend has upset her at school today

57 replies

auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 17:21

8 year old Dd came home from school today upset because her 'best' friend hasn't invited her to her birthday after school tea party today. Her friend told her that only her best 3 friends were invited and Dd wasn't one of them.
This has been confounded by the fact I arranged for this friend to come over last week for Dd's 8th birthday after school for tea and cake and a bit of a fuss. There was no party arranged for Dd because we were supposed to be going away for it, but for a number of reasons I moved the holiday to half term instead so thought having her 'best' friend over would make up for the cancelled trip somewhat.
I am really upset for my Dd because yet again, someone she thought of as a friend has upset her to the point she was crying in school over it.
Dd has been invited to this friend's bigger party on the weekend which is basically an all day event at a trampoline park. I really begrudge going to this party now, having to dedicate a whole weekend day there (when I have so many other things I could be doing) and having to buy this girl a gift and card, when she clearly has no real regard for my Dd as a friend. The mother has asked for Pusheen stuff as a gift too, so not cheap 🙄.
I know 8 year olds are fickle and still learning social skills, but this girl is very precocious and I feel her mum is not coming off well in this either for not returning the invite for an after school birthday tea (I am disappointed in mum too as I thought she was nice).
I just wish there was some way of helping my Dd with these unpleasant encounters. She is a very sensitive and anxious child, but doesn't struggle socially (although there is a pattern forming of her being unable to make close friends like her other peers). I worry that she will end up finding it difficult or withdrawing from making new friends because she will always expect to get hurt 😔.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SophieinParis · 05/07/2023 12:25

Wow..8 is not a socially unaware toddler. By 8, an NT child will have a clear understanding that exclusion is hurtful and that avoiding hurting others feelings is very important.
She isn’t under any obligation to invite your dd (although the mum should know better..and her tactless behaviour is no doubt why she has produced a similarly thoughtless child) but she is obliged to be subtle about the invite and thoughtful to her classmates, inc your daughter.

auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 22:35

Feelingconfused2020 · 11/10/2022 20:54

Given your DD'S party was last week I think the mum was rude and could easily have extended the tea party to include your DD even if she hadn't planned to originally.

If as you suggest your DD has had this happen before I would suggest that maybe you need to try and work out what's going on with her. How is she managing her friendships? Why does she perceive someone to be very close and they don't see her that way? Do you think she is picking friends based on how popular they seem to be? If, for example, she decided this girl was the best person to make friends with to be popular and made a beeline for her because she is popular it may explain why she is getting hurt as she is not choosing friends based on comparability. It's just a theory and I'm not suggesting she is doing it consciously. Maybe talk to her about how she chooses he friends and encourage her to find some new ones.

Definitely agree with just buying a smallish gift and check with DD if she actually still wants to go. She doesn't have to.

Interesting points about how she chooses friends. Firstly, there are a lot more boys than girls in her year and the girls formed friendships, usually in pairs, during nursery. My Dd did this with a girl who has since ‘dumped’ her, and for a long time my Dd has been a sort of floater for want of a better word, unable to break into already established friendship groups or pairs. This new friend started in Year 1 , so had no friends initially but she has always been encouraged by her mum to be friends with everyone, she is very precocious verbally which has helped her settle in well. Perhaps Dd has latched onto her because of her openness. I don’t think she tries to make friends with the ‘popular’ girls, I know who they are and she rarely mentions them. She has a male friend and another female friend who she says she often plays with, both Polish, but the parents keep to themselves or their siblings pick them up so I have never got to know the parents to invite these other friends around for play dates. I also work so am not always there for the school run.

I will definitely talk to her about who she chooses as friends, she has always seemed to be happy playing with anyone.

OP posts:
auberginepickle · 11/10/2022 21:56

Puffalicious · 11/10/2022 20:23

Oh do shut up! OP has a right to feel how she feels. I fucking hate that word entitled on here- it's so bloody overused and in all the wrong contexts (and don't start me on grabby 🤢).

It IS upsetting for OP's DD and, personally, I think it's unfeeling. Yes, she'll get used to unrequited feelings and build resilience, but it's hard and OP can see the upset.

Thanks Puffalicious,
A bit harsh to say I’m entitled I think. I’m upset for my Dd because I can empathise and put myself in her shoes having to hear those knock back words that are a big deal to a child of that age. My Dd feels big emotions, and if she regards someone as a friend she really invests and enthuses in that friendship.
Anyway, thanks for responding all, a lot of supportive comments and some not so supportive (which I was expecting). I am not dwelling on it further, or trying to make a big thing of it with Dd. She is well aware when someone is not being a good friend, and I can only encourage her to become more resilient to it. It is just so hard to see your child upset when they get knocked back by someone they thought was special to them🙁.
She still wants to go to the party on Saturday, I have no intention of spoiling it whatsoever. However, no Pusheen cat purchases will be made!

OP posts:
slashlover · 11/10/2022 21:12

Notanotherwindow · 11/10/2022 18:12

Get her a shit gift from poundland and if shes likely to say anything I'd be inclined to prime your DD to say that she only gets proper presents for close friends. But then I'm a petty cow.

Are you 8 years old too?

Feelingconfused2020 · 11/10/2022 20:54

Given your DD'S party was last week I think the mum was rude and could easily have extended the tea party to include your DD even if she hadn't planned to originally.

If as you suggest your DD has had this happen before I would suggest that maybe you need to try and work out what's going on with her. How is she managing her friendships? Why does she perceive someone to be very close and they don't see her that way? Do you think she is picking friends based on how popular they seem to be? If, for example, she decided this girl was the best person to make friends with to be popular and made a beeline for her because she is popular it may explain why she is getting hurt as she is not choosing friends based on comparability. It's just a theory and I'm not suggesting she is doing it consciously. Maybe talk to her about how she chooses he friends and encourage her to find some new ones.

Definitely agree with just buying a smallish gift and check with DD if she actually still wants to go. She doesn't have to.

stayathomer · 11/10/2022 20:34

I’m really not ‘forcing’ anything here
Sorry op I worded that wrong- it’s just easy to get as invested as the children, but 2 parents doing play dates just doesn’t always mean the children are as close as you think. Hope it all works out and your dad has fun at the big party. And the cheapskate comment seems crazy btw!!!

Puffalicious · 11/10/2022 20:23

Hesma · 11/10/2022 18:29

She been invited to the party… you are being very precious and entitled

Oh do shut up! OP has a right to feel how she feels. I fucking hate that word entitled on here- it's so bloody overused and in all the wrong contexts (and don't start me on grabby 🤢).

It IS upsetting for OP's DD and, personally, I think it's unfeeling. Yes, she'll get used to unrequited feelings and build resilience, but it's hard and OP can see the upset.

dottiedodah · 11/10/2022 20:14

Maybe she had invited the other girls already. Honestly this is little girls all over!one minute bestie next not .your dd is going to the weekend party.just relax and enjoy that.giving up time is all about being a parent. Just say to dd that sometimes you can't ask everyone

SilverGlitterBaubles · 11/10/2022 20:09

It is so hard to see your child upset by situations like this but the best thing you can do is lead by example and just brush it off. It is possible that these plans were made in advance of your DDs last minute birthday tea and as she was invited to the main party her DM thought no more of it. It is also possible that the birthday girl invited exactly who she wanted to her birthday tea. There does come a point where parents cannot dictate to their DCs who they should invite or play with based on what we think is the correct thing to do. DD once refused point blank to invite a girl who had been mean to her even though she had been to this girls party (the incident happened in between) and I really couldn't argue with her.

Lolreally · 11/10/2022 20:06

The mum has probably invited the children of people she wants free childcare from.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/10/2022 20:03

It sounds as if they will be spending more on the children per head at the trampoline park than you spent on the birthday party so I’m struggling to understand the attitude toward the gift.

You will not be doing your dd any favours if you give any old tat. If the birthday girl’s mum says something to her dd, perhaps even not maliciously eg surprise at the gift, yours could end up being picked on for it. My dd’s former bestie blanked her overnight for 6 months after something the parent said. Much better to let it go and get a nice gift. Something similar price range to what she got your dd.

As for the non invite, always teach your dd to treat herself well when upset and take her out somewhere nice for a treat. This is what I did with mine when she was not invited to this former besties party and devastated.

Do not listen to the mean girl attitude on this thread op. Your job is to pretend you haven’t even noticed.

As for the last minute, it was going to be a holiday thing, I’m really confused by that. Basically you didn’t intend to have anyone over and you did something really low key, correct? This tea is low key as well by the sound of it. The party is the main event.

SpidersAreShitheads · 11/10/2022 19:50

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 11/10/2022 17:33

I say this as gently as I can:

This is a really good opportunity for your DD to learn that just because someone is your best friend, it doesn't mean you are theirs.
And this is totally okay.

What if it were the other way around? What if your DD had a friend who considered her a very best friend but your DD didn't feel the same way? Would you force her to choose her over another, closer friend?

Encourage your DD to enjoy the friendship for what it is. Maybe encourage her also to join some clubs or groups where she'll meet other girls her age from different schools and other walks of life and make more friends so she isn't so reliant on one friendship.

This is a really good post OP.

I do get how you feel - I think one of the hardest things is watching your child trying to navigate the world, and getting hurt in the process. Of course it brings out your protective instincts , but in reality, this other girl hasn't done much wrong.

Having said that, as your DD clearly isn't one of her besties, like bollocks would I be buying her Pusheen stuff. As others said, a fiver in the card will suffice.

As she grows up, your DD will make new friends. I have a sensitive, anxious DD (who's autistic so really struggles with friendships) so I know how hard it is to look on sometimes.

gamerchick · 11/10/2022 19:45

She wants you to buy expensive gifts and do regular free childcare for her?

Putting this thing to one side, you've been well taken in imo.

myexisawanker · 11/10/2022 19:42

threecupsofteaminimum · 11/10/2022 19:35

I think you're reading way too much into,it. It happened to me at school, i soon found my own way, you should brush it off, protect her from negativity, don't show her you think it's a big deal or she'll start catastrophising and upset herself as well.

This. She will respond to your reaction.

It's tough but you've got years ahead of you of this. You need to avoid projecting your own stuff onto the situation

threecupsofteaminimum · 11/10/2022 19:35

I think you're reading way too much into,it. It happened to me at school, i soon found my own way, you should brush it off, protect her from negativity, don't show her you think it's a big deal or she'll start catastrophising and upset herself as well.

AllThatHoopla · 11/10/2022 19:34

The mother has asked for Pusheen stuff as a gift too, so not cheap 🙄.

Did you ask the mother what her daughter wanted? She has to say something!

MsTSwift · 11/10/2022 19:29

Oh god hang onto your hat op you have a few years of this ahead!

My advice fwiw is to try to model breezy nonchalance as they will take your lead. Build up her confidence and encourage a broad friendship group these intense “best friend” set ups can be poisonous. Listen to Taylor Swift “Best Day” and “Mean” she went through this!

I still in my heart of hearts foster a deep hatred for the mother who invited a group to an outing then all but two to a sleepover afterwards. Dd2 was one of the two girls collected. The birthday bitch spent the whole party crowing about the sleepover. Dd (a calm usually cheerful child) was sobbing when Dh and her arrived home and Dh was furious too. They was 6 years ago so seems I am still holding a grudge!

MRSE20 · 11/10/2022 19:29

I agree with the above comment. Children have different best friends constantly. Just because your DD see’s this girl as her bestie doesn’t mean the other one see’s her as this. Just the same as adults, I am someone’s closest best friend but I myself have other best friends who I see closer than her. Doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be friends or this is a bad thing.
I get the upset, my best friend at through primary and secondary school would have other best friends sometimes over me and it’s natural to feel jealous and left out especially at 8 years old.
She is invited to the main party, and I would say that speaks volumes on the facts they are still friends.

howshouldibehave · 11/10/2022 19:26

She sees your daughter as a friend, your daughter sees hers as her ‘best’ friend-therein lies the problem. The girl and her mum have done nothing wrong! She likes your daughter well enough to invite her to her party.

If she/you are really hurt by this and don’t want to ‘waste’ your weekend going to party, don’t go. Go and do all the other things you want to be doing instead. Is your daughter happy to do your weekend jobs instead of going to a party?

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 11/10/2022 19:23

My DD is 8, all the girls in the class are BFFs with each other depending on what day you ask them. The birthday girl could only have a very limited number of people round to her house, her not choosing your DD doesn't make her mean, or not a friend, it just means that she had to pick her top 3 of the moment and your DD wasn't in that list.

As an adult I would expect you to model a grown up attitude and explain that to your daughter. They are clearly still friend or she wouldn't have been invited to the bigger party. Deliberately choosing a crap present as a form of revenge is petty and won't help the situation. You should choose the same kind of present you would give to any other friend, in the budget level you would usually give.

Stevenage689 · 11/10/2022 19:21

Not all invitations are reciprocated. True at age 8 and as adults. Please don't make this a big deal for her.

outtheshowernow · 11/10/2022 19:19

Sorry I don't understand the problem really. She's been invited to the party ? Surely that's the main thing and not the tea. Stop making a fuss about it and be careful to not let this rub off on your daughter I would just be saying oh well the party will be so much fun

Darbs76 · 11/10/2022 19:17

When it’s your child it does hurt when they are upset. But kids are fickle as you say and when restricted to a few friends some kids will inevitably be left out. Your DD has been invited to this child’s party, she could have been left out completely. Try not to take it to heart, I can guarantee you in 5yrs time you’ll wonder why these things upset you so much (as do I now)

neverbeenskiing · 11/10/2022 19:17

She could equally think you were a cheapskate by not having a party but doing a "tea and a fuss"

This is comment is completely unecessary and a cheap shot imo. There is nothing to suggest that the girls Mum thinks this, but if she did it would make her incredibly judgemental and shallow.

cansu · 11/10/2022 19:08

Yes, it is hurtful, but I can guarantee this kind of thing will happen again. This is how many girls operate at this age. This is partly being a bit unkind but also lacking empathy and maturity.

Your biggest error would be to get sucked into making a big deal of this by sacking off the party or saying anything much about it. Your best bet would be to say something like 'Oh what a shame, maybe she could only invite three people. Anyway, shall we get some ... as a treat. I would also big up the great day at the weekend. You can be privately cross but being offended and upset won't help your dd and will make this into a bigger upset than it needs to be.

I am a teacher and have often seen this kind of thing. I will always remember a little girl in my year 6 class who was left out of a birthday trip to town, pizza and cinema by a queen bee type. She told me very matter of factly - 'my mum has talked to me about this and said that people can invite whoever they like. I know she is not being very nice though. Me and mum will do something fun instead'. She was brilliant and I remember thinking that her mum had really helped her to deal with it in the best way possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread