Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not buy things for grandchild?

160 replies

medvedgosha · 11/10/2022 15:46

DS and his gf are students, they're expecting a baby in a couple of months. They have clothes for baby etc but DS has asked if we can buy a pram and a cot.

I've said no as I'm currently paying their rent for them, but AIBU?

OP posts:
Userno46477473636274 · 12/10/2022 06:44

I mean this all depends if you can afford it. Their baby is their responsibility so no, you are not obliged to. Your title is misleading, there's a difference between buying a cot and a pram and buying a few outfits or smaller things. I'm sure you would buy something smaller and less expensive though??

it sounds like you're already being her pjs enough paying rent.

you can buy prams and cots second hand on Facebook, sometimes for free, just tell them to make sure the mattress for cot is new.

speakout · 12/10/2022 06:42

Flitter123 · 11/10/2022 16:58

There’s loads of second hand baby stuff around. If you’re not too fussy about what you want you can get it for virtually nothing.

I agree. Second hand baby stuff is very inexpensive. You could buy a new mattress for the cot.
I have had two kids and never owned a cot or a pram.

PinkSyCo · 12/10/2022 06:37

JenniferBarkley · 11/10/2022 18:05

We were professionals in our 30s with a comfortable income when we had DC1, and my parents bought the buggy and DH's bought the cot. They are quite common gifts from grandparents.

If you can afford it and you would have been paying rent anyway then I would.

If you can't afford it or the rent payments are been because of the baby, then I wouldn't.

Well that’s very nice that your parents were able to afford to buy 2 big items for you isn’t it? I’m wondering though if you demanded them? Because if my dd had demanded anything off of me they would have got nothing, especially if I was paying their rent too!

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/10/2022 06:20

CJsGoldfish · 12/10/2022 05:08

You do realise that despite contraception sometimes it happens anyway? Or are you pretending to not be aware of this?
You do know that that's`the convenient fallback for those who didn't bother with contraception right? Those who knew it wasn't the best time but went ahead ahead anyway. 😂
Most of the 'oops' babies fall in to that category 🤷‍♀️
Note: Most. There is a very minor percentage of true contraception failures.

Love that because OP’s son and their partner are being slammed for not being responsible because they can’t ‘afford’ a baby as OP is paying rent. Do you apply that logic to every person in this country who is living in social housing or receiving benefits in order to feed/clothe/house their kids?
I'd feel the same about anyone who can't pay their own rent or expenses tbh 🤷‍♀️

Actually you're wrong. There was a great NYT article with graphs for all the methods and the failure rates. There are many children born while using contraception. Those failure rates are often with perfect use, for one year. Well unless you only have sex for one year, the cumulative risk is quite large.

The NYT article is worth a look. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/09/14/sunday-review/unplanned-pregnancies.html

ilovepuppies2019 · 12/10/2022 06:01

I'm surprised at the number of posters who think you should only say no if you can't afford it. You can say no simply because this is not your responsibility and you're already shouldering a lot the responsibility by paying their rent. I think my Mum would have laughed and told me that my baby was my responsibility. Having a child when you can't afford essential living expenses is irresponsible. The solution is not the expect the GPs to pay but to step up and provide for the child. They will need job. If necessary, they might need to delay Uni for a year to save up money for the baby. This is the reality of having a child, they need to get used to it. I would require that they both have jobs before I purchased any items for the baby. They will be studying, working or parenting round the clock with very little free time but that's what they signed up for. If they're not willing to put in the work to care for their own child then they need to question if they're ready to be parents and explore other options.

sashh · 12/10/2022 05:37

OP they should look to claim benefits, they might not get anything now but once the baby arrives they can claim Universal Credit.

maddening · 12/10/2022 05:30

Get on fb marketplace- so much available for good prices.

HowVeryBizarre · 12/10/2022 05:10

I think asking directly for two “high ticket items” is very cheeky, especially as you are paying their rent. We bought the cot for our grandchild, DIL’s very wealthy parents had bought them a very expensive pram, they certainly didn’t ask us (or the other GPs) for anything but I did want to also buy something they would need so I said what our budget was for the cot to save any awkwardness around expectations and they chose one. As other people have said you can get a lot of great stuff second hand so if you can afford it I would look there and see what you are willing/able to contribute. Any hint of turning up their noses at second hand though and they would be on their own.

CJsGoldfish · 12/10/2022 05:08

You do realise that despite contraception sometimes it happens anyway? Or are you pretending to not be aware of this?
You do know that that's`the convenient fallback for those who didn't bother with contraception right? Those who knew it wasn't the best time but went ahead ahead anyway. 😂
Most of the 'oops' babies fall in to that category 🤷‍♀️
Note: Most. There is a very minor percentage of true contraception failures.

Love that because OP’s son and their partner are being slammed for not being responsible because they can’t ‘afford’ a baby as OP is paying rent. Do you apply that logic to every person in this country who is living in social housing or receiving benefits in order to feed/clothe/house their kids?
I'd feel the same about anyone who can't pay their own rent or expenses tbh 🤷‍♀️

BlackberryCat · 12/10/2022 05:06

Are you the OP where they are living with you and the GF has a child from a previous relationship?

If so, you know they are CF and the only way to sort this is to be firm with them.

If not, I'm sorry, I agree it depends if you can afford it or not, but I agree that there are loads of baby stuff going cheap on Facebook etc.

Tigofigo · 12/10/2022 05:00

We could have afforded new, but got a second hand cot bed & buggy system for free. Bit old but absolutely fine. A relative bought a new cot mattress as a gift. I bought a second hand sling and Moses basket (again got a new mattress) for very little.

Tell them to get on Gumtree or FB, or do you have a local Nextdoor group?

Marmee53 · 12/10/2022 04:54

It's ultimately your choice.

Me and hubby bought a used pushchair from eBay for our first since we couldn't justify spending the amount it costs for a brand new one. (And I'd like to think we are financially stable)

They could do the same.

MK85 · 12/10/2022 04:50

Not to sound harsh, but I think you need to have a sit down and have a discussion with them and make the understand the value of money and providing for this child is their responsibility. Your son is an adult who is going to become a father. He needs to take some responsibility for his actions. Why dosent he at least try to get a part time job to suit around his studying? Why are two students creating a child if they can't even afford their rent ? How are they going to pay for the basics, food , nappies , future child care ? Assumingly things are that financially different that they can't even afford condoms

Trez1510 · 12/10/2022 04:47

Depends entirely whether or not you can afford to do so, and then do the same for any other children you have.

As others have said, it's traditional for one set of GPs to buy one, and the other set the other. No mention of GF's parents. Does she have any?

If you want to make a point, set them a budget that will cover decent, secondhand items and challenge them to see what they can get!

greenteafiend · 12/10/2022 04:26

I think it's great for GPs to help out, but paying rent is already doing quite a lot. If the OP has money to spare, it would be better off going into a saving fund or investments for the child's future, not a brand new pram and cot; a young couple raising a baby on limited income needs to get into the habit of shopping around for second hand things. My local freecycle FB page has things like this posted regularly, and a low income couple can probably get most of the things they need from such sources if they are smart.

GUARDIAN1 · 12/10/2022 04:14

If buying either or both would put you in financial hardship I'd tell them that paying for these woulf mean their rent wouldn't be paid. Even if you can afford, I would offer to buy the cot but suggest either second hand pram or look on Freecycle for one. They need to live in the real world and take responsibility. They're going to be parents and much as it's nice to be able to help out where you can, the baby is not your responsibility. What about the other grandparents? Are they going to help out too?

DifficultBloodyWoman · 12/10/2022 03:36

I disagree with asking anyone, even parents, to buy specific items. Presents should be offered, not requested.

And asking a person who is already shelling out for rent to but not one but two high priced items?

Your DS needs a gentle reminder of manners. I might be tempted to say ‘you mean instead of paying your rent, sure, no problem!’ But I don’t know if I would actually go that far.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 12/10/2022 03:29

PickAnyName · 11/10/2022 21:47

I'd splash out and buy a xylophone and a set of drums for the little one. It's so important that they are able to play and express their creativity as they grow.

You are evil and I respect that.

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/10/2022 02:12

Blueeyedgirl21 · 11/10/2022 22:34

Love that because OP’s son and their partner are being slammed for not being responsible because they can’t ‘afford’ a baby as OP is paying rent. Do you apply that logic to every person in this country who is living in social housing or receiving benefits in order to feed/clothe/house their kids?

Social housing isn't free.

Musti · 11/10/2022 22:36

If you can afford it, yes, if not, no.

Plenty of cheap prams and cots around. I got an expensive travel system for my first. Barely used as it was complicated. Quickly bought a £20 stroller and for my second bought a basic travel system from mothercare for under £200 and used it for 3 kids.

I bought a basic cot from ikea (I liked the simplicity and again, it did 3 kids). My eldest never slept in a cot.

Just had a look on Facebook . Lots of lovely prams and cots for sale really well priced

Blueeyedgirl21 · 11/10/2022 22:34

Love that because OP’s son and their partner are being slammed for not being responsible because they can’t ‘afford’ a baby as OP is paying rent. Do you apply that logic to every person in this country who is living in social housing or receiving benefits in order to feed/clothe/house their kids?

monkeyupsidedown · 11/10/2022 22:33

You're not unreasonable but I'd help out anyway. Having a child is a shock to their finances. It doesn't have to be new stuff but they'll need it anyway. I would want to help my child if I could afford it.

MightyOaks · 11/10/2022 22:30

Bobbins36 · 11/10/2022 16:59

Why the hell are two students having a child when they can’t even afford rent for themselves 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

You do realise that despite contraception sometimes it happens anyway? Or are you pretending to not be aware of this?

MightyOaks · 11/10/2022 22:28

Valeriekat · 11/10/2022 15:50

Why are they even having a child? They sound incredibly irresponsible.

Erm how dare you?! You have zero clue what they're studying or how this has happened! What a horrible, nasty thing to say based on two facts - they're students & they're expecting a baby! Ffs.

Some of us found ourselves pregnant whilst on the contraceptive implant AND using a condom! Luckily I was with the father but these things happen to women no matter what protection is used!

You're a nasty piece of work!

Lotusmonster · 11/10/2022 22:25

Get second hand and clean it up. Better for the environment, better for your pocket. It’s a no brainer for items that are essentially short term use.