Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you got no help, how do you now feel about helping elderly relatives?

157 replies

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 08:50

I'm interested to see if the way I am feeling is just me, or others feel a similar way.

My mum died many years ago, and my dad remarried. He then spent all his time with her, and her DC. They have babysat GC, given money to her DC for things they needed, and been on annual holidays with them. They have done none of this for me or my siblings. They have not babysat for me once. My DC have near to zero relationship with them.

PIL have also not done anything for us. They babysat twice. The second time was 15 years ago when my DH was best man at a friends wedding and MIL started playing mind games with us saying right up until the morning that she hadn't decided if she wanted to help us out yet, and so I never asked her again. My PIL have pleaded poverty for decades and never once helped out my DH with anything. However, when it comes to his sibling, they have been given massive amounts of help both financially and practically. For example, PIL were too broke to donate anything to our wedding, but gave sibling £20K.

If you ask my DC, who are all now in their teens, they aren't fussed about either set of GP's which is sad, but it is what it is. As mine get older I feel a sense of relief that I no longer have to beg, borrow and steal when I need a bit of help. And, I have needed help at times. My DH has been great, but he works long hours and I have to do all the childcare.

Fast forward to now and both sides of the GP's are late 70's. The family and my SM direct my dad to me with any ailment or upset he has. Apparently SM is not able to deal with him. If he has a bug, apparently I should drive over to stay and look after him, as its too much for SM. I'm not good enough to spend Christmas with, but when it comes to being a carer, it's my duty. When I pushed back on this once, I was told that I was burning my bridges with the family. The thing is, those bridges don't exist in the first place. If I need a bridge, they aren't going to lower it for me to walk over.

On the other side my MIL seems to have this attitude that if you are elderly you are deserving in massive respect on the level of an ageing monarch, and we should be spending as much time with them as possible, and sympathising with every ailment they have. I was asked to drive them to an international airport recently as it is too much for them, and I said no as I was too busy. They have also asked us to go on holidays with them and I have told my DH, who would have agreed out of FOG, that I am not going.

I know that the above sounds a bit heartless but I just don't see myself doing lots of things for them. I used to invite them and include them in things. I asked my dad every Christmas for 22 years and he has not accepted one. My PIL only come here for Christmas if there is no better offer. I see both sets of GP every few months, which is what they set years ago, not me. However, now I/we get called up and told they never see anyone, no one comes near them, no one visits their house and this annoys me and I feel a bit guilty. I think that it is only going to get more demanding as well.

Once my DC are older, I will have more free time and I want to enjoy it. I am looking forward to it. I have already started to add things into my life that I have not been able to do in the past. I have lots of great friends. I am happy with the level of contact I have with GP's but from their side, it is not enough. I guess what I am trying to say is that I don't feel that I owe them anything and I am not prepared to spend more than a bit of my time doing things for them.

Is this U and does anyone else who has had similar feel like this? I reflect on what I have written and I think, jeez, what a cow.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 11/10/2022 10:56

I would prioritise your own DC and invest in your relationship with them.

Growing up, my parents belonged to the 'sandwich' generation providing care and support to elderly relatives and trying to care for us children as well. It cut down on the practical and emotional resources they had for their children, and meant that often we'd have to fit around visiting and caring for elderly relatives or our parents didn't have any time for us because they were too stressed working full-time and trying to organise care and support from a distance. Nothing was ever enough in the later days.

It was sometimes annoying as a teen to spend large chunks of our holidays visiting elderly relatives and essentially running around after them (and having our parents taken over by them), but I didn't begrudge it particularly since our grandparents were absolutely present for us as young children, did so many things with us, lavished gifts on us and we had a very, very loving relationship with them. They put so much effort into building the relationship, and it was that relationship (and the love involved) which sustained us through the quite tough times which came later and when the demands made were often quite onerous.

Since you don't have that existing loving relationship with them which might enable you to tolerate their demands with affection and good humour, I'd be shutting them down pretty quickly. Don't take time from your own children to spend with people who have never valued you.

Freedomfromguilt · 11/10/2022 10:55

My MIL has recently started telling me all about the wonderful DIL's her brothers and sisters have. They cook, they clean and the sun shines out of their rear ends, she is making it clear that this is what I should be doing to be a good DIL. This is something she should have been thinking about 20 years ago instead of being a bitch. She did nothing for her own MIL but expects me to be at her beck and call.
My parents on the other hand took care of their parents and set a brilliant example to their children who will, when the time comes, rally around.
I always wanted a good relationship with my IL's but they have made it impossible and it completely goes against how I was raised to say 'sod them' but other than the odd visit to check that they haven't died in their armchairs, I'm done.

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 10:49

you made our lives harder

It did. I had no one to call up when I was having a bad day, no parent or PIL to get advice from. I had no one to share my terror when my baby was really sick. Just the other day I had to beg 2 hours off at the end of work so I can take my DC to a medical appointment.

I'm not saying that a GP should be doing childcare for me. I am talking about an emergency, helping me out a bit, a couple of times a month max. Babysit for me once in a blue moon so DH and I could go out together. These are the things I want to do for my DC.

It is OK now though. Pretty soon I won't need any help. My DC are older. I will have free time. I just don't want to swap the role of mum for the role of elderly carer.

OP posts:
maryberryslayers · 11/10/2022 10:48

When pregnant MIL (local and both retired) told me that they would not be helping with childcare, I laughed and told her I'd never ask, and it's a good job as we won't be helping with elderly care.
She often used to offer to give me a hand for an hour when DS was tiny then turn up late or not at all. We get on well but I've stuck to what I said. They have enough money to pay for care if they want to but prefer not to. We have lives and small children plus DH works long hours. SIL made noises about DH giving up time to care for MIL each weekend so FIL could have a break, I shut it down immediately as I wasn't willing for our kids to miss out on clubs/family time or me be solo parent at weekends as well as in the week.
My parent on the other hand (not local and self employed) helps me when ever I ask, travelling over an hour at the drop of a hat and has helped us out with anything we need over the years and is my biggest support. I would do what ever I could for them no matter what.
I think you reap what you sow in relationships and no one 'owes' anyone anything.

Cuppasoupmonster · 11/10/2022 10:46

Further to my comment above, I don’t see eye to eye with my in laws (boomer Brexit types with far right opinions) but they love DD and go out of their way for her - they collect her from nursery for dinner once a week, and usually have her for a few hours at the weekend so I can get things done. Nothing massive but it shows they care, so I will be more than happy to help in their old-old age.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 11/10/2022 10:45

@TheDailyCarbunkle
Yes this is exactly what I meant thank you for expanding

OperaStation · 11/10/2022 10:45

Georgeskitchen · 11/10/2022 09:15

You owe them nothing. Let the ones who benefitted from all the financial and practical help look after them. It would be interesting to know who gets all the money when they snuff it, if there's anything left!

This. You don’t owe them anything. If I were you I wouldn’t lift a finger to help them. They have treated you very badly.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 11/10/2022 10:44

You seem to be creating a potential drama out of nothing. Either respond with what you have said here or don't respond at all.

Cuppasoupmonster · 11/10/2022 10:44

echt · 11/10/2022 10:42

You do you, but don't piss and moan when you're cut out of the Will. It's the correlative to what you are suggesting.

I fucking hate the narrative that you only look after your parents because they do things for you. Do you look after your children for the payback?

You seem to be missing the point that kids don’t ask to be born so caring for them isn’t a ‘favour’. You wouldn’t let yourself into someone’s house, Hoover it unasked then say that they owe you.

echt · 11/10/2022 10:42

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 08:50

I'm interested to see if the way I am feeling is just me, or others feel a similar way.

My mum died many years ago, and my dad remarried. He then spent all his time with her, and her DC. They have babysat GC, given money to her DC for things they needed, and been on annual holidays with them. They have done none of this for me or my siblings. They have not babysat for me once. My DC have near to zero relationship with them.

PIL have also not done anything for us. They babysat twice. The second time was 15 years ago when my DH was best man at a friends wedding and MIL started playing mind games with us saying right up until the morning that she hadn't decided if she wanted to help us out yet, and so I never asked her again. My PIL have pleaded poverty for decades and never once helped out my DH with anything. However, when it comes to his sibling, they have been given massive amounts of help both financially and practically. For example, PIL were too broke to donate anything to our wedding, but gave sibling £20K.

If you ask my DC, who are all now in their teens, they aren't fussed about either set of GP's which is sad, but it is what it is. As mine get older I feel a sense of relief that I no longer have to beg, borrow and steal when I need a bit of help. And, I have needed help at times. My DH has been great, but he works long hours and I have to do all the childcare.

Fast forward to now and both sides of the GP's are late 70's. The family and my SM direct my dad to me with any ailment or upset he has. Apparently SM is not able to deal with him. If he has a bug, apparently I should drive over to stay and look after him, as its too much for SM. I'm not good enough to spend Christmas with, but when it comes to being a carer, it's my duty. When I pushed back on this once, I was told that I was burning my bridges with the family. The thing is, those bridges don't exist in the first place. If I need a bridge, they aren't going to lower it for me to walk over.

On the other side my MIL seems to have this attitude that if you are elderly you are deserving in massive respect on the level of an ageing monarch, and we should be spending as much time with them as possible, and sympathising with every ailment they have. I was asked to drive them to an international airport recently as it is too much for them, and I said no as I was too busy. They have also asked us to go on holidays with them and I have told my DH, who would have agreed out of FOG, that I am not going.

I know that the above sounds a bit heartless but I just don't see myself doing lots of things for them. I used to invite them and include them in things. I asked my dad every Christmas for 22 years and he has not accepted one. My PIL only come here for Christmas if there is no better offer. I see both sets of GP every few months, which is what they set years ago, not me. However, now I/we get called up and told they never see anyone, no one comes near them, no one visits their house and this annoys me and I feel a bit guilty. I think that it is only going to get more demanding as well.

Once my DC are older, I will have more free time and I want to enjoy it. I am looking forward to it. I have already started to add things into my life that I have not been able to do in the past. I have lots of great friends. I am happy with the level of contact I have with GP's but from their side, it is not enough. I guess what I am trying to say is that I don't feel that I owe them anything and I am not prepared to spend more than a bit of my time doing things for them.

Is this U and does anyone else who has had similar feel like this? I reflect on what I have written and I think, jeez, what a cow.

You do you, but don't piss and moan when you're cut out of the Will. It's the correlative to what you are suggesting.

I fucking hate the narrative that you only look after your parents because they do things for you. Do you look after your children for the payback?

Untitledsquatboulder · 11/10/2022 10:41

Wouldn't touch them with a 20' bargepole, let alone make a big effort to include them in my life or facitate theirs if I were you OP.

Ironically we do most for my dad who was by far the least helpful and lovely of our 4 parents - but he did love me and the kids and would have done anything for us within the constraints of his personality. I would trot over hot coals for my mum or my inlaws though.

Cuppasoupmonster · 11/10/2022 10:40

YANBU.

My dad was very reliant on my grandparents when I was growing up - emotional/financial support, babysitting, the works.

When they reached their 90s and his first grandchildren were born, he buggered off abroad with my stepmum and now barely speaks to us. When we do speak to him he’s half pissed and making barbed remarks about our mum who left him, or how we ‘never go to see him’ despite the fact he’s retired and it would be infinitely easier for him to come to us rather than us taking time off work to fly small babies and toddlers out to him. He also left us as responsible for his parents, which was been hugely stressful - one has died and the other has significant health issues.

So yeah, if he’s expecting to fly back to us for care in his old age he can bugger off.

Itsnotaboutthepasta · 11/10/2022 10:38

I don't think you are being unreasonable. Similar with us my in laws are useless, we didn't even get a happy birthday message for our little one this year yet DSIL was having them babysit a 1 year old for two weeks whilst they went away.

My side I am NC with my dad but super close to my mum (they are separated) and she does so much for us. I mentioned to my DH the other day it's quite a relief that we have only one parent to look after in old age as the rest of them can go to hell for all I care.

No way will I be helping them when they treat myself, DH and DC so poorly. You are entitled to say no and not feel guilty about it and do what's best for your family OP.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/10/2022 10:37

As the old saying goes, ‘As you sow, so you reap.’

I certainly wouldn’t feel obliged to lift a finger for them. Let the ‘golden ones’ step up - but from all I’ve ever heard, after too many years on a forum for carers of people with dementia, all too often the ‘golden ones’ are ‘far too busy’.

Weemummykay · 11/10/2022 10:36

Tealpoppy · 11/10/2022 09:15

My family did nothing for me growing up/had my own kids
my brothers got it all-money,support,favours,lifts-the lot
they had college paid for,lived rent free,had cars-after having their lessons and tests paid for-money for their weddings-everything
i got laughed at for asking for help
but in their heads,they did everything for me-I couldn’t wipe my own arse without their help
i was expected to be their nurse,carer and bottle washer when they got old-just because I’m a female
nah,fuck that-to their surprise,I went nc and I will refuse to do anything for them when the time comes
let the golden children get their hands dirty

This 👌🏾

CallTheMobWife · 11/10/2022 10:36

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 09:14

Yes, of course you are right about it not being reciprocal help, but the relationship.

It has been hard to watch others being favoured, and my DC not being as important as step DC and us not being as important as DH's siblings. It was what I have had to listen to, that has really got me to the mindset I am at now, not they didn't give me this or that. I have cried so many tears over this in the past. At some point, years into it, I just decided to concentrate on my own little family, and we did, and it is lovely.

I'd tell them exactly that, if I were you. I would tell them; you've ignored us for years, you've favoured everyone else, you never helped or took any interest,you made our lives harder. Why would I come running now you need something? Where were you for the last 20 years whenever I needed anything? Somewhere else. Which is where I'm going to be. Toodle-oo.

Catonamountain · 11/10/2022 10:35

Its the guilt and obligation which tests you, try and resist it

Davros · 11/10/2022 10:31

As thedailycarbuncle says, behave in a way true to yourself but do not become a doormat. My mum was a terrible, neglectful mother and she did nothing for her own mother. She also cut me out of her will to favour the golden child (who did nothing for her, not even a hospital visit) which she wanted to keep secret to exploit me. I continued to visit, make sure she was ok and support my nice sister who lived nearer and did the most. However, neither of us got involved in giving her "care", we made sure it was arranged and continued to visit and bring her extras iyswim. Social services tried to put us in the care plan and we refused

Sistanotcista · 11/10/2022 10:25

C8H10N4O2 · 11/10/2022 09:38

If he has a bug, apparently I should drive over to stay and look after him, as its too much for SM

Your SM of 22 years who lives with him seriously expects you to go and care for DF when he is ill? Is she insane?

Help between the generations is rarely reciprocal at any one point in time but relationships generally do survive on a degree of being reciprocal over time.
We have no obligation to adults who largely cut us out of their lives, even if they are family.

Exactly this. Relationships survive on a degree of being reciprocal over time, whether this is labour (babysitting and elderly care) or love and affection. We get back what we put in. They have made no effort to put any love, care or support into you and your family, and thus none has been built up over time. You have no obligation whatsoever to assist them now, especially if it's not convenient for you.

OoooohMatron · 11/10/2022 10:20

You reap what you sow. I'd be directing them to their other children who have received help from them in the past.

Sloth66 · 11/10/2022 10:15

They’ve chosen to prioritise and favor other family members in a hurtful way for decades. What’s the saying - you reap what you sow.
you don’t have any goodwill from them to draw on. As long as you’re comfortable with your decision, I’d keep your distance

Redqueenheart · 11/10/2022 10:14

I don't think that anyone can demand love, support and respect simply because you are related to someone. It has to be earned.

If you have a very distant relationship with a relative and they have never been that involved in your life it is unrealistic for them to now expect help after years of not really bothering with you...

This is even more relevant if the person is toxic, manipulative and generally unpleasant.

Also I never understand why women are expected to just give up their life to care for elderly relatives.

The longer this guilt-tripping carries the less likely we are to finally sort out the wider issue of social and elderly care and make sure there is a proper provision for supporting people as we get older.

Would I care for my elderly mother? never. I have no love for her and she failed to care for me as a child and a teen and I owe her nothing. I fought hard to rebuild my life after years of misery inflicted by my parents and they will no steal another minute of my life from me.

ParentallyUnprepared · 11/10/2022 10:10

Just keep saying no and feel no guilt about it.

Acheyknees · 11/10/2022 10:09

I had my kids fairly late on in life and my DH's parents had retired early. They wanted to travel, play golf and generally have fun. No problem there. But they also said they wouldn't be around to do childcare as they wanted to travel so we wouldn't be able to ask them. So we didn't, the children grew up with very infrequent visits to his parents, no Christmas together or holidays.
Now they are too old to travel and complain they don't ever see us. My children are now at work and university, they have never had a close relationship with his parents so don't want to start one now. We have been fairly blunt with his parents, we all have our busy lives now. You reap what you sow.

HermioneWeasley · 11/10/2022 10:08

My sibling and my DP’s sibling had all the help when we had young families - free childcare, living with them rent free, endless babysitting so they could have nights out and short breaks. I regard any care they need as they get older entirely their responsibilitiy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread