Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you got no help, how do you now feel about helping elderly relatives?

157 replies

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 08:50

I'm interested to see if the way I am feeling is just me, or others feel a similar way.

My mum died many years ago, and my dad remarried. He then spent all his time with her, and her DC. They have babysat GC, given money to her DC for things they needed, and been on annual holidays with them. They have done none of this for me or my siblings. They have not babysat for me once. My DC have near to zero relationship with them.

PIL have also not done anything for us. They babysat twice. The second time was 15 years ago when my DH was best man at a friends wedding and MIL started playing mind games with us saying right up until the morning that she hadn't decided if she wanted to help us out yet, and so I never asked her again. My PIL have pleaded poverty for decades and never once helped out my DH with anything. However, when it comes to his sibling, they have been given massive amounts of help both financially and practically. For example, PIL were too broke to donate anything to our wedding, but gave sibling £20K.

If you ask my DC, who are all now in their teens, they aren't fussed about either set of GP's which is sad, but it is what it is. As mine get older I feel a sense of relief that I no longer have to beg, borrow and steal when I need a bit of help. And, I have needed help at times. My DH has been great, but he works long hours and I have to do all the childcare.

Fast forward to now and both sides of the GP's are late 70's. The family and my SM direct my dad to me with any ailment or upset he has. Apparently SM is not able to deal with him. If he has a bug, apparently I should drive over to stay and look after him, as its too much for SM. I'm not good enough to spend Christmas with, but when it comes to being a carer, it's my duty. When I pushed back on this once, I was told that I was burning my bridges with the family. The thing is, those bridges don't exist in the first place. If I need a bridge, they aren't going to lower it for me to walk over.

On the other side my MIL seems to have this attitude that if you are elderly you are deserving in massive respect on the level of an ageing monarch, and we should be spending as much time with them as possible, and sympathising with every ailment they have. I was asked to drive them to an international airport recently as it is too much for them, and I said no as I was too busy. They have also asked us to go on holidays with them and I have told my DH, who would have agreed out of FOG, that I am not going.

I know that the above sounds a bit heartless but I just don't see myself doing lots of things for them. I used to invite them and include them in things. I asked my dad every Christmas for 22 years and he has not accepted one. My PIL only come here for Christmas if there is no better offer. I see both sets of GP every few months, which is what they set years ago, not me. However, now I/we get called up and told they never see anyone, no one comes near them, no one visits their house and this annoys me and I feel a bit guilty. I think that it is only going to get more demanding as well.

Once my DC are older, I will have more free time and I want to enjoy it. I am looking forward to it. I have already started to add things into my life that I have not been able to do in the past. I have lots of great friends. I am happy with the level of contact I have with GP's but from their side, it is not enough. I guess what I am trying to say is that I don't feel that I owe them anything and I am not prepared to spend more than a bit of my time doing things for them.

Is this U and does anyone else who has had similar feel like this? I reflect on what I have written and I think, jeez, what a cow.

OP posts:
Kissingfrogs25 · 12/10/2022 07:23

It is absolutely incredible how men can be so accommodating with someone else's time and energy, but when it is asked of them - they find their assertiveness pretty quickly.

It is a shame that the underlying perception must be that the man's time is far more valuable than that of their wives and partners. This level of sexism is rife even today. It is entirely depressing to read.
Despite most women having full time jobs these days and they have children to consider in the mix. Somehow women are expected to take this on as well, it is unsustainable, and many elderly parents still imagine it is the 1960s and women are at home making jam and soup and have ample time to attend to their sometimes relentless needs.

Anyone wishing to make serious money in the future should consider opening a business catering for elderly care, that is going to be a growth market as people start to realise that old age is not always about travelling the world and a place in Provence, but demanding health issues, serious need for help and assistance and their adult children can not be expected to fulfil this need when they are already flat out keeping a roof over their heads. I thought covid would be a reset, but it has proved to be a rest in the wrong direction as far as I can see.

billy1966 · 11/10/2022 22:23

@Kissingfrogs25 my nurse friends are such kind women. That particular woman was thankful she avoided feeling guilty by living far enough away to be well out of it.

I agree with your advice to@Cokeandaslice to give some serious thought to how much you wish to be involved. Do not get sucked into helping someone beyond what is healthy for you and your MH.

Feeling forced to help someone you do not like, not to mind love, is hugely stressful.

@CaronPoivre I think a general tolerance/investment for someone from a distance is vastly different to daily/weekly care and appointments.
Vastly different.

OP, do not allow your husband to foist his FOG on you, dragging you into any of his parents care.
Not your responsibility.
Be very firm.

Men are very adept at roping in the women in their lives to help out.

I wrote recently of how a very calm friend of mine had a rare loud row with her husband when, she, newly retired from nursing was volunteered by her BIL for hospital appointment duties for her inlaws!

Her husband had often worked away and she had never seen her inlaws for dust, even when she was on occasion really stuck (her friends stepped in).

Her BIL and his wife were the favourites and had free childcare for many years.

That her BIL had the cheek to ring her husband to tell him, that his wife, my friend, needed to do X on Y date for the inlaws absolutely infuriated her with the sheer CFery of it.

She told her husband to take time off HIS work and to never ever involve her in his parents care.
She had juggled all their childcare for years and she had NO intention of being imposed upon by HIS family.
That was a couple of years ago and she has stuck to it rigidly.
Funnily enough her husbands FOG cleared quickly when his brother tried to impose on him too much.....funny that🙄

EurovisionshouldgotoChippingNorton · 11/10/2022 21:51

I support my very elderly mum and supported my dad until he died. It is hard physically and emotionally and impacts on my leisure time as my mum is lonely. I do it because it feels right as they were loving, good parents and amazing grandparents. Even so, I admit I sometime feel resentful at the impact on my own life as it has been years now so I definitely wouldn't do it in your circumstances. I wouldn't feel guilty either but enjoy the times with your husband and children and if you have any siblings who you have a good relationship that is valuable. I think very low contact, on your terms might be easier than none. Look after yourself first and foremost!

Supersimkin2 · 11/10/2022 21:46

Of course you don’t owe them and of course the Golden Children have fled.

Of course DF and DSM will lie their heads off now they want something.

But. You’re much nicer than they are. Live that.

If you’re worried they’ll be bad/distressing for DC, keep DC away. You don’t sacrifice children to the old. (Right now society does that too much already.)

Have they left you anything? Don’t count on it. I’m pretty tolerant of awful relations, but to me that’s the deal breaker.

Whatever you do for DF and DSM that’s nice, remember you won’t get thanked.

Or loved.

If you can handle that, be nice to them.

Kissingfrogs25 · 11/10/2022 21:26

CaronPoivre · 11/10/2022 20:21

@Kissing frogs25
It is interesting that you say your MIL is an unkind person due to her own teenage years. I had an extremely difficult time - and nearly lost my life in teen years and yet I have turned into a kind, caring and loving person. I wonder if it is in your interest to find an excuse for her poor behaviour?

She did suffer incredible trauma in her teens. Worse, I imagine, than nearly dying yourself. Certainly harder to come to terms with. Of course it’s in my interests to tolerate her presence, if not her behaviours. She’s my husband’s mother and my children's grandmother. Now she’s very elderly and quite vulnerable. I don’t need to do battle or make it difficult for my husband to see his mother. She lives far enough away for me to show kindness when we see her, to make arrangements for medical issues or sort household problems from afar. Why would I hang on to Ill feeling and bitterness that is more damaging to me than anyone else?

You have no idea what happened to any poster on here, so I don’t think you are in a position to judge or compare firstly.

Secondly sorting out a few affairs from ‘afar’ and fixing a smile for the odd visit is VERY different from daily care, or two or three hospital runs a week/household help or for some 247 assistance that is the reality for many thousands of families.

I wouldn’t even classify your input as remotely ‘care giving’ so perhaps that’s why it is so easy for you to be ‘kind’ you aren’t actually doing very much if anything of substance, and what is being done is remote and from afar.

I don’t think anyone mentioned bitterness - that’s a you thing, the fact you are working so hard not to feel that way speaks volumes….

CaronPoivre · 11/10/2022 20:21

@Kissing frogs25
It is interesting that you say your MIL is an unkind person due to her own teenage years. I had an extremely difficult time - and nearly lost my life in teen years and yet I have turned into a kind, caring and loving person. I wonder if it is in your interest to find an excuse for her poor behaviour?

She did suffer incredible trauma in her teens. Worse, I imagine, than nearly dying yourself. Certainly harder to come to terms with. Of course it’s in my interests to tolerate her presence, if not her behaviours. She’s my husband’s mother and my children's grandmother. Now she’s very elderly and quite vulnerable. I don’t need to do battle or make it difficult for my husband to see his mother. She lives far enough away for me to show kindness when we see her, to make arrangements for medical issues or sort household problems from afar. Why would I hang on to Ill feeling and bitterness that is more damaging to me than anyone else?

hattie43 · 11/10/2022 19:06

I totally agree with you OP. It's amazing the number of people who disregard you when young and then suddenly want to reconnect when they are old and everyone else has vanished .
I don't think you should be guilt tripped in doing anything you don't want to , you mention you have things to do when your DC are older and I'd say go and enjoy them .
I am in a similar situation in that my mother was very absent when I was younger preferring to chase men than be with her children . She is also late 70's now and I won't be giving up my precious retirement years to be a caterer . I've always want to extensively travel and that's what I'll be doing .

isadoradancing123 · 11/10/2022 18:51

No, they put nothing into the relationship so now they deserve very little back

Kissingfrogs25 · 11/10/2022 18:47

billy1966 · 11/10/2022 17:42

OP,

You sound lovely and have made great efforts over the years, despite being rebuffed.
In your place there is no relationship and I would mute the phone.
They have chosen the type of relationship you have.
Protect yourself and your family.

This has been a consistent theme in my circle over the past 20 years and has always boiled down to the interest shown in the grandchildren.

If no interest has been shown in them, not necessarily childcare, but just interest, then my friends have not gotten very involved in eldercare on either side.

They did/do the very bare minimum and encourage them to spend their money.
This can be very painful for some to countenance!

Several of my friends are nurses and the expectations of family that they would automatically step in is extraordinary.

One gentle friend of mine had two golden brothers BIL that could do no wrong, nor could their children and her husband was an afterthought in all things throughouthis life and marriage.

They were quietly excluded in a suble way and were not included in family business.

They weren't invited to Christmas lunch but my friend never cared as her parents were delighted to share the day with them.

Anyway a house came up 30 minutes from where they lived and 5 minutes from
her parents

They never said a word as they hadn't met with his family in months, as usual, and simply text the weekend that they had moved.

Well! The outrage that they had moved closer to her parents and wouldn't be available for future care was hilarious.

The selfishness of it!

My friend was genuinely shocked that they had absolutely assumed that her sole purpose would be to step in if needed.
They hadn't called to their house in years despite being 5 miles away.

In the last 15 years, many is the time over vino she has said what it was such a bullet dodged that they did move, as his parents have required a lot of help and bar the occasional visit she isn't involved with them at all.

Her children never established much of a bond, so by the time they left in their very early teens, they were largely ambivalent about seeing them.

Her husband as the least "successful" of their 3 sons, is now well able to bat away his favoured brothers and their occasional complaints.

They all had their parents undivided attention for years and it is the least they can do.

Other friends have steadfastly refused to be sucked into the "hospital appointments merry-go-round" for parents and in laws that they too never saw from one end of the year to the other.

Several have mentioned how resistant to bothering "the golden one's" in their lives.

"Favourites" is a huge thing simmering in some families.

Expecting teens and children in their 20's to want to spend time with elderly relatives that they have no real bond or shared history with, is both unreasonable and unrealistic.

I was devoted to both my darling grandmothers right up to their deaths because whilst they had never provided childcare for me, they had always shown a great interest in me and my siblings right into my 20's.

This is so insightful.

I too have been on the receiving end of a huge backlash because we were pencilled in as the elderly care (much to our surprise!) when we lived very close to them they didn't visit us from one month to the next, and never even helped even in a medical emergency.
So I had very little time for the theatrics when we finally moved a few hours away. It is still mentioned now and the grudge and resentment sits there at the centre of everything. We moved eleven years ago - and we still have to listen to this on a loop and how they will 'never get over it'. They know golden child has no interest despite the lavish time, money and effort they have directed at him, and he didn't as much as drop of a tin of beans for the whole of the pandemic whilst they were isolating despite wfh every day and living under half an hour away.

It is so true that some families are stuck in the stereotypes of expecting the dd to step in and mop up the elderly care. It also true that some families think they can treat their dc in any way they wish and still expect to be waited on into old age. Op, let the stress go, it stopped being your job a long time ago - and indeed he could not bring himself to prioritise you at any point, now he can rely on the people that he has chosen to spend his life with. I would do the bare minimum as billy said if you want to, and if you have time and capacity. Otherwise I would send the name and number of the nearest care agency and tell them to start interviewing.

magma32 · 11/10/2022 18:42

@mam0918 👏100% this sort of speak is toxic itself under ‘be kind’ ‘be patient’ ‘be the bigger person’

billy1966 · 11/10/2022 17:42

OP,

You sound lovely and have made great efforts over the years, despite being rebuffed.
In your place there is no relationship and I would mute the phone.
They have chosen the type of relationship you have.
Protect yourself and your family.

This has been a consistent theme in my circle over the past 20 years and has always boiled down to the interest shown in the grandchildren.

If no interest has been shown in them, not necessarily childcare, but just interest, then my friends have not gotten very involved in eldercare on either side.

They did/do the very bare minimum and encourage them to spend their money.
This can be very painful for some to countenance!

Several of my friends are nurses and the expectations of family that they would automatically step in is extraordinary.

One gentle friend of mine had two golden brothers BIL that could do no wrong, nor could their children and her husband was an afterthought in all things throughouthis life and marriage.

They were quietly excluded in a suble way and were not included in family business.

They weren't invited to Christmas lunch but my friend never cared as her parents were delighted to share the day with them.

Anyway a house came up 30 minutes from where they lived and 5 minutes from
her parents

They never said a word as they hadn't met with his family in months, as usual, and simply text the weekend that they had moved.

Well! The outrage that they had moved closer to her parents and wouldn't be available for future care was hilarious.

The selfishness of it!

My friend was genuinely shocked that they had absolutely assumed that her sole purpose would be to step in if needed.
They hadn't called to their house in years despite being 5 miles away.

In the last 15 years, many is the time over vino she has said what it was such a bullet dodged that they did move, as his parents have required a lot of help and bar the occasional visit she isn't involved with them at all.

Her children never established much of a bond, so by the time they left in their very early teens, they were largely ambivalent about seeing them.

Her husband as the least "successful" of their 3 sons, is now well able to bat away his favoured brothers and their occasional complaints.

They all had their parents undivided attention for years and it is the least they can do.

Other friends have steadfastly refused to be sucked into the "hospital appointments merry-go-round" for parents and in laws that they too never saw from one end of the year to the other.

Several have mentioned how resistant to bothering "the golden one's" in their lives.

"Favourites" is a huge thing simmering in some families.

Expecting teens and children in their 20's to want to spend time with elderly relatives that they have no real bond or shared history with, is both unreasonable and unrealistic.

I was devoted to both my darling grandmothers right up to their deaths because whilst they had never provided childcare for me, they had always shown a great interest in me and my siblings right into my 20's.

OoooohMatron · 11/10/2022 16:38

pompomdaisy · 11/10/2022 16:04

I didn't receive help financially or physically from my mother or any elder my side of the family. I still helped them because that was expected. It seems to be all the rage these days to expect parents to raise both you and the grandchildren!

It's actually the complete opposite. Back in the day it was extremely common for grandparents to provide childcare on a regular basis, often while parents were at work. It's a lot less common now and more of an occasional thing for many, certainly not expected.

VatofTea · 11/10/2022 16:37

YANBU....at all.

My Ex-MIL never calls me for anything, that s fine by me, but my exH is her only son and they do rely on him. Ex MIL is re-married to ex Step FIL. They were never interested in the grandchildren as they were desperately hanging onto their youth. Ex Step FIL is younger than Ex-MIL by 5 years, they engaged in a firm fight so that 50 was the new 30 and they were too young to be grandparents, even though ex MIl was in fact at least mid 50s becoming a grandparent, she had zero interest.

They were almost averse to toddlers. Roll on 15 years, and they are obviously aging etc. I bumped into Ex Step FIL on the street, and he waxed lyrical to me about how his father had done the same sport as my sons, all his life, and how proud he would be now, looking down from heaven, knowing he had great-grandsons competing in xxx sport.

Whaaaat.....dead step great grandfather looking down from heaven!!! This is a step FIL, no blood relation, no interest when kids were high intensity toddlers. Never treated them or us to a meal out or a coffee or a cake or babysitting or emotional support. they were incredibly mean with time and money. My ex-husband called to their house one Sunday (late) morning, and ex FIL called him from inside the house and said they weren't there.

Now they are sucking up to the two grandsons, as they are their only grandchildren!! So annoying, so hard to explain to my kids how useless they were, when we could have benefited from some help.

NO - I will not be helping them, they know that. Ex -DH probably will help them, he shouldn't, but he will.

ASimpleLampoon · 11/10/2022 16:20

You owe them nothing. Go NC . Burn the Bridges. You deserve to enjoy your emptynestyears. you have earned it.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 11/10/2022 16:16

my MIL seems to have this attitude that if you are elderly you are deserving in massive respect on the level of an ageing monarch

My late mother also had this attitude. She always put her mother's and MIL's needs first - not just above her own, but also above those of my father and me - and never missed an opportunity to remind me that in the fullness of time she would expect me to do the same for her. In the event, that question didn't arise (she died when she was still quite young), but it definitely soured our relationship whilst she was alive.

Naunet · 11/10/2022 16:11

I don’t blame you at all OP. My dad abused me when I was little, so he won’t be getting any care at all from me. I haven’t seen him in over 20 years, but he sent me a Christmas card last year, possibly the first time ever, so I sense that he may be starting to think about care. He can keep dreaming.

My mum either turned a blind eye to the abuse or was so detached from me that she didn’t even notice that I wasn’t ok. She never told me she loved me, was never there for me emotionally, but she was good in a practical way, we were always fed and clothed. She’s spent her years pandering to my dickhead brother, despite being a complete arsehole, he’s the golden child, so whilst I’ll make sure she goes into a good home, if she wants family care, she can ask mr golden balls.

pompomdaisy · 11/10/2022 16:04

I didn't receive help financially or physically from my mother or any elder my side of the family. I still helped them because that was expected. It seems to be all the rage these days to expect parents to raise both you and the grandchildren!

Crucible · 11/10/2022 15:44

My two pence; they look to you now because they don't value your time. Those that they have lavished money and time upon have been burnished gold by the attention, and in their minds they are 'worth more than you.' Your time is less valuable so they can call on it when they please, expect you to be at their beck and call.

I think it really comes down to making decisions about how you choose to use your time and being ok with others not approving of your decisions.

Flowersintheattic57 · 11/10/2022 15:44

Relationships are like fires; if you don’t put any wood on, they go out.

Aconitum · 11/10/2022 15:36

You owe them nothing, absolutely nothing.
I would be telling them so and why, but you sound far too nice for that😁

Derbee · 11/10/2022 15:36

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 09:36

Allthegood,

Yes, they have behaved as they wished, but I don't think they see it as that. The last time I was on the phone to my Dad, he was having a massive rant about how his children don't invite him over for Sunday lunch or make sure they are OK at the weekends. We have been asking him for years and years. He actually used to drive past one of our streets to go to SM's relatives and not once did he call in to say hello. According to him, it is us DC who are at fault.

It is the same for PIL. MIL will never see herself as at fault. There is one funny thing though WRT her. A while ago she told DH that "she thinks we are not very nice people, doesn't she?". Apparently it upsets her, that I don't think she is a decent human being.

I wouldn’t be on the phone with him ranting about my failures etc. Just hang up or tell him you don’t have time.

You don’t owe anyone anything.

BalmyBalmes · 11/10/2022 15:33

Allthestarsabovemyhead · 11/10/2022 15:15

Have you actually told them why you won’t help out? I would tell them that they were never here for you and never helped when you asked. Also what about his step children, can they not help?.

This^
Let them know you had to struggle on with no family support when your kids were young so you will not be providing any support for them now. You will need to make it very clear this is the reason as support works both ways

mam0918 · 11/10/2022 15:29

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 11/10/2022 08:54

I think it depends on how you set your own ethical code in life.

My dad is pretty rubbish. Not very present. Doesn't seem to care a lot. But I am not like that as a person. I do care. So I don't behave as he behaves, I behave as I believe is right. I'm not religious but I do something think, if someone was looking at my actions, would I be deemed a good person? I always try my best to act in a way I believe is ethical. How other people behave is up to them.

Sorry that's a bit abstract.

My father abused and neglected me before fucking off and completely abandoning me and telling me he wished I was dead.

I have ZERO plans to care for him and frankly I am better than him regardless because Im just not caring for 'a stranger', if I was like him I would abuse and torture him like he did to me.

You reap what you sew in life and he is reaping a very lonely life and thats not my fault or responsability.

No one should put up with being a doormat to toxicity under the guise of being 'the better person'... thats really dangerous.

Allthestarsabovemyhead · 11/10/2022 15:15

Have you actually told them why you won’t help out? I would tell them that they were never here for you and never helped when you asked. Also what about his step children, can they not help?.

cptartapp · 11/10/2022 15:10

I'm a big believer in sourcing external help and not tying family. So DH and I spent thousands on nursery and childcare fees over the years. My parents are dead, but PIL are well off and I would fully expect them to buy in help and care as needed rather than look to busy DH and I with jobs and families of their own.
Isn't that what we save for all our lives?
Having said that, SIL did very much better than us in terms of financial and practical help. Another reason I won't be encouraging DH to jump to.