Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you got no help, how do you now feel about helping elderly relatives?

157 replies

RadioHeadstand · 11/10/2022 08:50

I'm interested to see if the way I am feeling is just me, or others feel a similar way.

My mum died many years ago, and my dad remarried. He then spent all his time with her, and her DC. They have babysat GC, given money to her DC for things they needed, and been on annual holidays with them. They have done none of this for me or my siblings. They have not babysat for me once. My DC have near to zero relationship with them.

PIL have also not done anything for us. They babysat twice. The second time was 15 years ago when my DH was best man at a friends wedding and MIL started playing mind games with us saying right up until the morning that she hadn't decided if she wanted to help us out yet, and so I never asked her again. My PIL have pleaded poverty for decades and never once helped out my DH with anything. However, when it comes to his sibling, they have been given massive amounts of help both financially and practically. For example, PIL were too broke to donate anything to our wedding, but gave sibling £20K.

If you ask my DC, who are all now in their teens, they aren't fussed about either set of GP's which is sad, but it is what it is. As mine get older I feel a sense of relief that I no longer have to beg, borrow and steal when I need a bit of help. And, I have needed help at times. My DH has been great, but he works long hours and I have to do all the childcare.

Fast forward to now and both sides of the GP's are late 70's. The family and my SM direct my dad to me with any ailment or upset he has. Apparently SM is not able to deal with him. If he has a bug, apparently I should drive over to stay and look after him, as its too much for SM. I'm not good enough to spend Christmas with, but when it comes to being a carer, it's my duty. When I pushed back on this once, I was told that I was burning my bridges with the family. The thing is, those bridges don't exist in the first place. If I need a bridge, they aren't going to lower it for me to walk over.

On the other side my MIL seems to have this attitude that if you are elderly you are deserving in massive respect on the level of an ageing monarch, and we should be spending as much time with them as possible, and sympathising with every ailment they have. I was asked to drive them to an international airport recently as it is too much for them, and I said no as I was too busy. They have also asked us to go on holidays with them and I have told my DH, who would have agreed out of FOG, that I am not going.

I know that the above sounds a bit heartless but I just don't see myself doing lots of things for them. I used to invite them and include them in things. I asked my dad every Christmas for 22 years and he has not accepted one. My PIL only come here for Christmas if there is no better offer. I see both sets of GP every few months, which is what they set years ago, not me. However, now I/we get called up and told they never see anyone, no one comes near them, no one visits their house and this annoys me and I feel a bit guilty. I think that it is only going to get more demanding as well.

Once my DC are older, I will have more free time and I want to enjoy it. I am looking forward to it. I have already started to add things into my life that I have not been able to do in the past. I have lots of great friends. I am happy with the level of contact I have with GP's but from their side, it is not enough. I guess what I am trying to say is that I don't feel that I owe them anything and I am not prepared to spend more than a bit of my time doing things for them.

Is this U and does anyone else who has had similar feel like this? I reflect on what I have written and I think, jeez, what a cow.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Papershade5 · 13/10/2022 09:14

I think if you are feeling up to it you could respond with, well Dad we used to invite you a lot but you seemed to prefer x's family,if you don't feel up to it then just be unreliable and unavailable and dont answer the calls

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 12/10/2022 21:12

Tell them to fuck off is my vote.

I'm low contact with my family and most of DHs family have passed away. My family did fuck all for us when our kids were small so I will be doing fuck all for them when they get older.

Overandunderit · 12/10/2022 21:02

YANBU. You don't owe them anything.

But YABU to not actually tell him exactly how you feel whilst they are still here and then go NC. Fuck them.

Focus on your family and put energy there.

Quincythequince · 12/10/2022 20:59

Supersimkin2 · 12/10/2022 20:54

We’ve had two generations of dementees in our family, both alive and needing care simultaneously.

It’s really nasty. The saddest thing is that by the time Gen 2 dies they’ll have drained every penny of the family assets so there’s no money left for Gen 3, who care for them.

Gen 3 are stuck renting - no house to sell for care, no inheritance, earning capacity slashed by years of unpaid care shifts.

Why are they doing unpaid care shifts to the extent that it affecting their ability to earn and improve their own situations.

That is not ok, and should surely not be expected.

Supersimkin2 · 12/10/2022 20:54

We’ve had two generations of dementees in our family, both alive and needing care simultaneously.

It’s really nasty. The saddest thing is that by the time Gen 2 dies they’ll have drained every penny of the family assets so there’s no money left for Gen 3, who care for them.

Gen 3 are stuck renting - no house to sell for care, no inheritance, earning capacity slashed by years of unpaid care shifts.

Cokeandaslice · 12/10/2022 19:44

@Kissingfrogs25 Thank you yes I need to be clear about what I can manage and what is acceptable. It's just a tough situation and I'm not sure if my parents realise how distant they've been although deep down they must, right?

Sorry you are going through this OP. It doesn't feel fair.

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/10/2022 19:07

CallTheMobWife · 12/10/2022 18:21

The post I replied to was about "retired people", not the very elderly in need of care,so no, we were not at that point.

I think 60s to mid 70s is very different from what lies after that. All the 60 and 70 somethings I know have great social lives and busy schedules. The 80 and 90 somethings are totally different, and seem very frail. The deterioration is very sudden, so a lot of them make the mistake of thinking ‘I feel fine now so will for years yet’. It usually takes one accident or medical condition for them to go downhill.

Kissingfrogs25 · 12/10/2022 19:01

CallTheMobWife · 12/10/2022 17:15

That's not my experience at all. All the newly retired people I know, and long retired too, are living their best lives. Travelling, nights out, clubs, societies...they have more money than we do,more time, more flexibility.

My MIL and her friends have a better social life than my 21 year old and her friends, and far more money to have it with.

Hopefully they won’t burn through the family money leaving nothing for their care….

CallTheMobWife · 12/10/2022 18:21

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/10/2022 17:50

We’re talking about the ones in need of care - 80s and 90s

The post I replied to was about "retired people", not the very elderly in need of care,so no, we were not at that point.

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/10/2022 17:50

CallTheMobWife · 12/10/2022 17:15

That's not my experience at all. All the newly retired people I know, and long retired too, are living their best lives. Travelling, nights out, clubs, societies...they have more money than we do,more time, more flexibility.

My MIL and her friends have a better social life than my 21 year old and her friends, and far more money to have it with.

We’re talking about the ones in need of care - 80s and 90s

LuffleGro · 12/10/2022 17:23

I'm in a very similar situation OP. I feel that those siblings/step-siblings who have benefitted from the help and support from the parents/PIL should be the ones to step up and offer that help in return. I would arrange a care home if needed but I'm not going to give up my life to care for people who were not prepared to do the same for me. I hope we are much more present for our children when they are adults.

CallTheMobWife · 12/10/2022 17:15

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/10/2022 16:51

I also think part of the problem is the culture in the U.K. for the retired to venture further out of society, rather than into it.

They tend to move to semi rural or village locations, with poor transport connections and no nearby services, then just retreat into themselves and spend all day sat watching TV because there’s nothing to do. They then age rapidly and end up in an unsuitable house in an unsuitable location where their adults kids have to drive to them, drive them about to appointments, are their only company etc

That's not my experience at all. All the newly retired people I know, and long retired too, are living their best lives. Travelling, nights out, clubs, societies...they have more money than we do,more time, more flexibility.

My MIL and her friends have a better social life than my 21 year old and her friends, and far more money to have it with.

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/10/2022 16:51

I also think part of the problem is the culture in the U.K. for the retired to venture further out of society, rather than into it.

They tend to move to semi rural or village locations, with poor transport connections and no nearby services, then just retreat into themselves and spend all day sat watching TV because there’s nothing to do. They then age rapidly and end up in an unsuitable house in an unsuitable location where their adults kids have to drive to them, drive them about to appointments, are their only company etc

ProfessionalWeirdo · 12/10/2022 16:24

It is a shame that the underlying perception must be that the man's time is far more valuable than that of their wives and partners. This level of sexism is rife even today.

I remember my mother once saying to me: "Weirdo, don't ever marry an only child." It was said slightly tongue-in-cheek and I didn't fully understand it at the time, but it wasn't until decades later that I realised what she meant - that any woman who marries an only child will end up having to look after his mother as well as her own. My mother and my aunt both married only children, and this is precisely what happened to them.

ProfessionalWeirdo · 12/10/2022 16:17

Remember, invest in your descendants - not your ancestors.

Wise words indeed.

OhCobblers · 12/10/2022 12:28

@RadioHeadstand
I think we'd all agree that none of them sound nice or kind.

Based purely on that, without the favouritism that has blatantly been shown on both sides towards siblings (financial or other), you are well within reason to walk away and have nothing to do with any of them.

I'd stop Xmas invites too frankly. Bet you'd feel a huge sense of relief knowing that you were enjoying the day solely with your own family unit.

They deserve nothing from you at all.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/10/2022 11:12

Dh and I have always willingly done whatever we can to help (now adult) dds, but having had to cope for far too many years with dementia in both my FiL and my DM, the last thing I ever want is for dds to have to do any elderly care for us.

We've told them very firmly as much, and have made it very clear in our Powers of Attorney that if we get to the stage of being both unable to care for ourselves, and speak (with full mental capacity) for ourselves, then we want absolutely no ‘striving to keep alive’, nor any life-prolonging treatment.

Thankfully there should be enough cash to pay for help, if needed.

boredOf · 12/10/2022 10:38

These grandparents are terrible. You owe them nothing. Say no. Go no contact but he firm now.

Kissingfrogs25 · 12/10/2022 10:38

billy1966 · 12/10/2022 08:44

I agree with you.
Nursing can be very tough with the hours and nights, and my friend did it with a husband who travelled.

She was in paediatrics and worked with very sick children so hugely invested.

But SHE organised the children all those years while her husbands job wasn't impacted.
Sadly her beloved parents died before she had children.

I can tell you he got 20 years of home truths with that row and pure fury at the cheek of BIL and HIM repeating it back to her.

He was a very quiet man for a long time afterwards.
The hometruths did him NO harm at all.🙄

She is enjoying her retirement after 30 years and savouring HER time.

The same woman is so kind to a couple of neighbours, because that is who she is.

Her in laws complete lack of interest in her children is the reason she could care less what happens to them, and that is the bottom line in all of this.

If you have zero interest in people for many years, you really are deluded if you think they are going to spend any time or interest in your care when you decide it is convenient to you.

IMO a lot of women are very much pushing back on the assumption that all care giving is down to them.....in my circle anyway.

Working FT and raising a family, my friends really aren't interested in the role and won't accept any husband foisting it on them.

Maybe we will eventually overturn this long held perception with enough strength in numbers to ensure people plan for their own retirement and ill health responsibly and not expect the nearest female relative to pick up the slack - we are in the process of planning now, as to not inflict this kind of burden on our own children.

If the relationship is warm and loving, most adult children will enjoy being with their parents and family but for us that does not stretch to bottom scrubbing!! Ever. My mother pretty much martyred herself doing so for her (emotionally checked out) parents with a bitterness and resentment I can't easily put into words. It turns out many people are very interested in doing the elderly care to preserve the inheritance, but resent what is involved and the number of years required. Which is the other side of the coin. I sometimes feel sorry for older people put in that position, especially if there is vulnerability or serious illness.

I am glad your friend held firm, for her own dignity as well as principle. After a life time of caring for others in all ways she deserves to have a somewhat carefree life now.

Wayk · 12/10/2022 08:54

Put yourself first. My counsellor has been telling me this for years and I did not take her advise and kept getting hurt. Last year was an awful year and people I helped financially, moved mountains for in time if difficulty did not even pick up the phone to me. I was so lonely. I eventually took the advise and spending money on myself and my sister who is very good to me.

billy1966 · 12/10/2022 08:44

Kissingfrogs25 · 12/10/2022 07:23

It is absolutely incredible how men can be so accommodating with someone else's time and energy, but when it is asked of them - they find their assertiveness pretty quickly.

It is a shame that the underlying perception must be that the man's time is far more valuable than that of their wives and partners. This level of sexism is rife even today. It is entirely depressing to read.
Despite most women having full time jobs these days and they have children to consider in the mix. Somehow women are expected to take this on as well, it is unsustainable, and many elderly parents still imagine it is the 1960s and women are at home making jam and soup and have ample time to attend to their sometimes relentless needs.

Anyone wishing to make serious money in the future should consider opening a business catering for elderly care, that is going to be a growth market as people start to realise that old age is not always about travelling the world and a place in Provence, but demanding health issues, serious need for help and assistance and their adult children can not be expected to fulfil this need when they are already flat out keeping a roof over their heads. I thought covid would be a reset, but it has proved to be a rest in the wrong direction as far as I can see.

I agree with you.
Nursing can be very tough with the hours and nights, and my friend did it with a husband who travelled.

She was in paediatrics and worked with very sick children so hugely invested.

But SHE organised the children all those years while her husbands job wasn't impacted.
Sadly her beloved parents died before she had children.

I can tell you he got 20 years of home truths with that row and pure fury at the cheek of BIL and HIM repeating it back to her.

He was a very quiet man for a long time afterwards.
The hometruths did him NO harm at all.🙄

She is enjoying her retirement after 30 years and savouring HER time.

The same woman is so kind to a couple of neighbours, because that is who she is.

Her in laws complete lack of interest in her children is the reason she could care less what happens to them, and that is the bottom line in all of this.

If you have zero interest in people for many years, you really are deluded if you think they are going to spend any time or interest in your care when you decide it is convenient to you.

IMO a lot of women are very much pushing back on the assumption that all care giving is down to them.....in my circle anyway.

Working FT and raising a family, my friends really aren't interested in the role and won't accept any husband foisting it on them.

Bramblejoos · 12/10/2022 08:36

sometimes relentless needs

This is what can happen. The elderly person becomes housebound - so you are the only person they see apart from carers, they need many loooong visits to doc and hospital, need shopping, gardening etc etc.
Just be careful, popping in to do one thing can grow and grow.
Not really the elderly person's fault - just how ageing happens.

Quincythequince · 12/10/2022 07:36

Invest in your descendants OP, not your ancestors.

They now reap what they have sown and have firmly been the architects of their own
sorry future.

Why are the step DC helping your dad at all?

Have you actually pointed out their shitty behaviour to them saying - just because you remember it differently, it doesn’t meant it didn’t happen the way I’m telling you it did.

At most, I would invite them round for a cup of tea every couple of months, no more.

I’m sorry this happened to you.

Remember, invest in your descendants - not your ancestors.

DomesticShortHair · 12/10/2022 07:32

I don’t believe in karma, but I do believe that a lot of time in life we grow our own luck. By that, if you’re decent towards others around you, then when the time comes that you need help, you’ll have built the relationships and goodwill that you can fall back on, so that help will usually come.

This is a good example. You don’t owe them anything, and they find themselves in the situation they’re in, entirely because of their attitude and behaviour. So be it. As my Mam used to say ‘if you make your bed, then you lie in it’.

Kissingfrogs25 · 12/10/2022 07:23

reset