Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is going to offend some people, but...

108 replies

chandaliere · 11/10/2022 08:36

To think that people who have left their country of birth and possibly family behind, to make a better life for themselves in a different place and have made a success of it, deserve a lot of respect ?

I think it takes a lot to make something of yourself elsewhere and can't help but have masses of respect for people who've managed to do that.

OP posts:
OneTC · 11/10/2022 10:53

Discovereads · 11/10/2022 09:08

I mean it’s all migration innit? Even Brits going to Australia.
The OP didn’t specify refugees only. Literally said “anyone”

Most immigration/emigration you don’t have nothing. It costs a lot to move countries what with visas, moving your furniture & stuff, probably a break in employment, etc.

So I don’t see how the comment was tone deaf unless you’re illogically applying it to refugees…..

The stay there and make your country a better place comment is certainly hinting at being a refugee. Runs with people's perceptions that many refugees from war torn countries are fighting age men

j712adrian · 11/10/2022 10:46

Yes.

You'll find the people who object to it also hate people who have worked abroad.

echt · 11/10/2022 10:44

Dotjones · 11/10/2022 08:50

I don't find it offensive but I think it's wrong. It takes greater courage to remain where you're born and make the place better rather than take the easy option of running away to a better country.

Is that what you'd say to asylum seekers?

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/10/2022 10:42

Totally agree and I would scratch my head at anyone who found this remotely offensive.

I have known a few people who have migrated here from poorer countries in search of a better life and its bloody hard. Relentlessly hard and isolating, even if things go your way, which is far from a given. The prejudice, the constant feeling of being an outsider, the way the odds are stacked against you in terms of employment, the fact you have to work four times as hard as a native person to be taken seriously at a job when you do get one. It never ends.

People who pull it off deserve massive respect IMHO.

Rosesandstars · 11/10/2022 10:36

They are brave and courageous - yes. ,
Is it always best to leave your family behind in order to earn more money? no, not always, sometimes it takes more bravery and is better for yourself and family to stay!.
Are all migrants more courageous than literally anyone else? No.

oakleaffy · 11/10/2022 10:20

PurpleIsTheNewPink · 11/10/2022 09:32

Thank you girlmom. I appreciate that. It happened a long time ago. ( When I was a child visiting my uncle who had moved to the UK with his family). I'd never experienced that level of aggression before or since so it's left quite an impression. I'll never forget how ashamed I felt of myself and my family.

That must have been really unpleasant, and frightening for a child, and of course deeply unpleasant for an adult to experience as well {Your Uncle and his family at that time probably suffered the same nasty comments}.

I wonder if these gobby men {Who are the ones who should feel ashamed} would have the same attitude if their Surgeon or Specialist was from India or Pakistan?

Hopefully things have got a lot better now.

bingbummy · 11/10/2022 10:18

Yeah screw your family you leave behind, let them fend for themselves.

FourTeaFallOut · 11/10/2022 10:06

FourTeaFallOut · 11/10/2022 10:01

Well yes. My point was only alongside the other which laid out the -presumed- qualities of migrants which highlighted veneered personality qualities.

But yes, a completely different migrant is one who is moves on the sheer will to survive alone. The bulk of my family shifted to England in the same famine migration, chirpy they were not.

Veneered - Revered! I have a head cold which is scrambling my brain, and letters!

TankFlyBossW4lk · 11/10/2022 10:05

Dotjones · Today 08:50

I don't find it offensive but I think it's wrong. It takes greater courage to remain where you're born and make the place better rather than take the easy option of running away to a better country

Yeah, well I bet you don't think that about the Irish potato famine, when people emigrated to the US.

Smileeriley · 11/10/2022 10:04

I agree op.

I left UK, best thing I ever did. Hated the place.

FourTeaFallOut · 11/10/2022 10:01

VeganSoulFood · 11/10/2022 09:53

Well, or just desperate. A lot of my family emigrated to the US after the Famine. I don’t think they would have been particularly robust or proactive, and they knew the journey and initial conditions would be hideous, but they had no other options. And they’d seen a lot of death.

Well yes. My point was only alongside the other which laid out the -presumed- qualities of migrants which highlighted veneered personality qualities.

But yes, a completely different migrant is one who is moves on the sheer will to survive alone. The bulk of my family shifted to England in the same famine migration, chirpy they were not.

Cornettoninja · 11/10/2022 09:58

chandaliere · 11/10/2022 09:39

I actually think people who move away from their home and make a new life have a superior quality to people who don't. I think you can tell they have a different outlook on life. That's obviously a massive generalisation and I think it's an offensive opinion I hold.

I just think they're better than the ones that live and die where they were born and never properly venture out.

I think that's offensive. I should have said it from the beginning, but I pressed send before I wrote the rest of my post.

Twice? Maybe you’re just a bit shit at communicating?

it’s not offensive to admire something. It is offensive to place yourself as an expert judge as other peoples worthiness.

what you actually are is narrow minded and failing to recognise achievements of people who don’t do something you personally admire. Lots of very successful business people, health care professionals, charity workers, scientists, teachers etc. achieve amazing things without migrating but not necessarily having an ‘easy’ time.

You’ve made the mistake of thinking that things that you personally find admirable means anyone outside that category is ‘less’. It’s not your opinion that’s offensive it’s your small mindedness.

VeganSoulFood · 11/10/2022 09:53

FourTeaFallOut · 11/10/2022 09:47

yes because if you are willing to leave everything you know to start a new life you are probably proactive, positive, smart and hardworking....Not to mention physically healthy with robust mental health to consider such a big change alone and unencumbered by caring responsibilities - these are the ace cards in the pack.

Well, or just desperate. A lot of my family emigrated to the US after the Famine. I don’t think they would have been particularly robust or proactive, and they knew the journey and initial conditions would be hideous, but they had no other options. And they’d seen a lot of death.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/10/2022 09:50

chandaliere · 11/10/2022 09:39

I actually think people who move away from their home and make a new life have a superior quality to people who don't. I think you can tell they have a different outlook on life. That's obviously a massive generalisation and I think it's an offensive opinion I hold.

I just think they're better than the ones that live and die where they were born and never properly venture out.

I think that's offensive. I should have said it from the beginning, but I pressed send before I wrote the rest of my post.

I missed your little gem in your second paragraph.

I knew of or knew lots of people who'd never ventured out of where they lived, for many, many reasons. You don't have to travel to gain a broader outlook on life.

oakleaffy · 11/10/2022 09:48

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 11/10/2022 09:46

OK, I'll bite.

Why don't YOU go and live in France then?

I am sure life will be soooooooooooo much better for you there. 🙄

Awaits the paper thin and flimsy 'reasons' why you cannot go.

I own part of a house there, but my loved ones are here, but it's a definite consideration.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/10/2022 09:47

chandaliere · 11/10/2022 09:39

I actually think people who move away from their home and make a new life have a superior quality to people who don't. I think you can tell they have a different outlook on life. That's obviously a massive generalisation and I think it's an offensive opinion I hold.

I just think they're better than the ones that live and die where they were born and never properly venture out.

I think that's offensive. I should have said it from the beginning, but I pressed send before I wrote the rest of my post.

You're talking out of your behind here re that.

My great grandmother (German) moved here before the start of WW2 to live with her son (dual national German/English) because her husband was in a hard labour camp in Germany and she'd already lost her home twice over due to the Nazis in Germany and Luxembourg. She didn't want to come to England but didn't have or thought she had a superior quality of life. In fact in a local shop they refused to serve her as she had a German accent. Her outlook on life was mostly survival but also thinking about her 'boys' (German army) fighting English army in England and having to see that. She also knew that she wouldn't return home, and she would have liked to have done that.

phishy · 11/10/2022 09:47

Dotjones · 11/10/2022 08:50

I don't find it offensive but I think it's wrong. It takes greater courage to remain where you're born and make the place better rather than take the easy option of running away to a better country.

Unless you're posting from somewhere like Syria or Palestine or Ukraine, I doubt you know the meaning of making your war torn country better than running to a 'better country'.

You are in your country due to an accident of birth, not because you are worth more.

FourTeaFallOut · 11/10/2022 09:47

yes because if you are willing to leave everything you know to start a new life you are probably proactive, positive, smart and hardworking....Not to mention physically healthy with robust mental health to consider such a big change alone and unencumbered by caring responsibilities - these are the ace cards in the pack.

FatKyle · 11/10/2022 09:46

Thats pretty offensive. Nothing like a sweeping generalisation on all sorts of people who move from many circumstances and for different reasons. Some might be brave. Others are not. It doesn't make them better or worse than those who don't move.

Nice new name change to go with 'first' post though

EmmaH2022 · 11/10/2022 09:46

girlmom21 · 11/10/2022 09:42

I just think they're better than the ones that live and die where they were born and never properly venture out.

Well now you've completely changed the tone of your thread and sound like a bit of a dick.

Yup. I'm probably going to die in London on account of having stayed to care for my immigrant parents in their old age, whom OP thinks are marvellous. What does "properly venture out" mean OP?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 11/10/2022 09:46

oakleaffy · 11/10/2022 09:43

I thought this was indeed one of these silly posts.

I envy my old Lodger for buying a house in France {His Mum and brother live there too...The property prices are a fraction of ours, and it's a far better life.
They squeaked in just before the disastrous Brexit vote.

Well done them.

OK, I'll bite.

Why don't YOU go and live in France then?

I am sure life will be soooooooooooo much better for you there. 🙄

Awaits the paper thin and flimsy 'reasons' why you cannot go.

Rinatinabina · 11/10/2022 09:45

Child of immigrants now an expat from the UK. i would say it depends where you are coming from and your resources and when really. Someone immigrating to the UK 40 years a go from a tiny village with no money is going to be different from a middle class person clutching an MBA coming for a nice desk job tbh from the same country

When my parents immigrated flying was too expensive so many people didn’t see family for years, letters were sent via airmail most jobs available to immigrants were limited. These days people are facetiming each other all the time and visiting each other on a much more regular basis. I think global inequality was much starker a few decades ago. It’s not great now but it’s substantially better so people moving from one place to another are not necessarily experiencing the level technological etc difference that they may once have. So on-line banking using apps is common in most countries in africa and was more widespread than in the UK because access to a laptop was harder to obtain.

I appreciate the sentiment, it is daunting moving country but tbh it wasn’t that bad. I think its a very different experience if you are fleeing with what you can carry. That must be bloody terrifying.

donttellmehesalive · 11/10/2022 09:44

I agree. I have a family member who complains about immigrants taking all the jobs. I think, yes because if you are willing to leave everything you know to start a new life you are probably proactive, positive, smart and hardworking.

TheStoop · 11/10/2022 09:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Twigfen · 11/10/2022 09:43

Depends who you are talking about, if you are speaking about 100's and 1000's of fit an able men. Who leave their country with women and children for economic reasons than staying and help improve the conditions for those they leave behind. Then he'll no.