Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked by this

191 replies

Vodkaany1 · 10/10/2022 23:07

Was walking through our local town tonight and there was a man outside one of the local mini supermarkets who was homeless and asked if I could spare some money, I said sorry, no as I didn't have any cash on me as I rarely carry cash these days. He was stood by the cashpoint outside and said "Maybe you could draw some money out" Being I was on my own and aware of potential distraction theft (fairly large town with fairly high crime rate) I said no, I wasn't prepared to take any money out, so he asked if I could perhaps buy him some food from the mini supermarket and as I'm not completely heartless I said yes that's fine. Went in with him to pick some food and then he asked me if I would buy him a small can of alcohol with mixer - think JD & coke in a can type thing - and a scratch card!! I was utterly gob smacked and my response was to tell him he was taking the piss and I'd buy him some food and a non alcohol drink and that was it or he could have nothing. Honestly couldn't believe it! AIBU to be shocked by the sheer cfery of him? It's really put me off helping anyone else in future

OP posts:
Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 05:37

These day yes but not ten years ago.
Assuming he could charge it, he must have been getting enough too in donations to keep it topped up

Obki · 11/10/2022 05:33

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:29

Why gobsmacked? Why the judgement? The man has nothing. Society has already failed him.He’s been left to fend for himself. Sounds like he has only himself to look out for. He has nothing to lose by asking for those things. Of course it’s up to you to give or not give but there’s nothing to be gobsmacked about.

And back in the real world, a strange man following me around a shop asking for alcohol and scratch cards would put me off for helping in this way again.

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:33

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 04:47

I once saw a woman ask a "homeless " man outside a supermarket if he would like a hot meal in the cafe, she let him gather his things while she went to order inside. He then gets out a mobile phone and starts texting someone.
Where does a homeless person charge a phone?
It really makes me wonder how many of these people are genuine

What?. These days you can charge your phone in most places - in McDonalds, on the bus, in a supermarket and million other places for free. So many, unfortunately, are very genuine.

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 11/10/2022 05:32

Ive bought alcohol for a homeless guy previously, a few cans of lager, I figure that if it helps spend another night on the cold streets who am I to judge. You sound kind, OP, I’m not criticising.

I can’t blv the guy didn’t thank you though. And before anyone falls over themselves to say why should he fall at your feet in gratitude, a quick thank you wouldn’t have hurt him. Being homeless doesn’t mean having no decency. The majority of homeless I have encountered have been thoroughly good people.

However, I do recall one day when I lived in Notting Hill, asked the guy who always sits outside Tesco if he needed anything, he said ‘yeah, I’ll have a coffee, but not from here, from Waitrose’… I got him his Waitrose coffee!

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:29

Why gobsmacked? Why the judgement? The man has nothing. Society has already failed him.He’s been left to fend for himself. Sounds like he has only himself to look out for. He has nothing to lose by asking for those things. Of course it’s up to you to give or not give but there’s nothing to be gobsmacked about.

Obki · 11/10/2022 05:17

So much sanctimony in this thread.

OP, you were very nice. A bit too nice, when he came into the shop with you you should have asked him to give you space. I think you were vulnerable in that situation.

I went to buy £2 snack from KFC and a homeless man asked for something too but wanted a full
meal. My limit was £2 as that was what I was spending on myself. I just have him the £2 in the end as he said he wanted a doughnut.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 11/10/2022 05:12

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 04:47

I once saw a woman ask a "homeless " man outside a supermarket if he would like a hot meal in the cafe, she let him gather his things while she went to order inside. He then gets out a mobile phone and starts texting someone.
Where does a homeless person charge a phone?
It really makes me wonder how many of these people are genuine

There are numerous charities and community services offering practical support to homeless people. Just not, unfortunately, a roof over their heads or enough money to live on.

ChampagneCamping · 11/10/2022 05:08

You handled it very well, you were boundaried but supportive

Soubriquet · 11/10/2022 05:05

LikeTearsInRain · 11/10/2022 01:00

I had a woman do similar to me. Said she needed money at first to cover rent for her child. When offered to buy something from the shop instead she wanted a can of cider, chocolate bar and 20 fags

She wanted money for rent…you buying food isn’t going to do that is it.

Maybe, once she had paid rent, she would have bought that stuff with what was left over.

You was just taking out the middle man

Soubriquet · 11/10/2022 05:02

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 04:47

I once saw a woman ask a "homeless " man outside a supermarket if he would like a hot meal in the cafe, she let him gather his things while she went to order inside. He then gets out a mobile phone and starts texting someone.
Where does a homeless person charge a phone?
It really makes me wonder how many of these people are genuine

Easy..

the library, a cafe…

Soubriquet · 11/10/2022 05:01

Look, I’m one who hates alcohol. I was brought up by alcoholic parents and as a child I used to have to spend every weekend in the bloody pub.

But I wouldn’t begrudge the poor man a can of premix and a scratch card.

It would take the edge off the cold and you never know, he could have won £5 to keep him going over the next few days.

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 04:47

I once saw a woman ask a "homeless " man outside a supermarket if he would like a hot meal in the cafe, she let him gather his things while she went to order inside. He then gets out a mobile phone and starts texting someone.
Where does a homeless person charge a phone?
It really makes me wonder how many of these people are genuine

youlightupmyday · 11/10/2022 04:44

My philosophy in giving money to beggars is, if I want to I will. If they want to spend it on booze or drugs, who cares, I prob would in the same sitch.

Maduixa · 11/10/2022 02:47

I lived for many years in a very rich city (by international standards) that has a crazy amount of homeless people (San Francisco). It is not at all strange to me, and in fact it is completely normal and commonplace, that someone asked you for alcohol or for a scratch card. But I don't know where you live; maybe it is still unusual there.

So let me give you some advice for the future which is - unfortunately, but likely - coming, where your city will be teeming with homeless and desperate people too. You say yes to what you can do and are are willing to do, and a very firm no to what you can't/won't. And yes, people you engage with on the street WILL give you shit(e) if you say no. They're desperate. No one can tell you how much you want to or should engage and what you can or cannot give. But figure it out, because no matter where you live, life is getting harsher and you're going to be asked for help more and more.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 11/10/2022 02:37

Summerfun54321 · 11/10/2022 02:14

I always offer to take beggars to go and buy food instead if they ask me for money. Only 2 people have ever taken me up on it. People are naive if you think others don’t beg for drug money, some aren’t even homeless.

Look, it's your choice to give money or not, and it's completely OK not to. But don't be a patronising dick about it.

Beggars and homeless people are still people - adults with agency. If they want to be given food they'll ask for food. If they are given money, it's their decision on how best to spend it to make their lives better at that moment. That might be a bus ticket, or a cheap hostel, or socks, or a big bag of meth to numb the pain.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 11/10/2022 02:27

Vodkaany1 · 11/10/2022 00:03

Can I just point out for those having a go that it's just a drink/scratchcard - I probably wouldn't have batted an eyelid had he not already asked me to take money out of my bank when I said I had no cash on me. It's not just the things he asked for in the shop, he actually asked me to withdraw money from the ATM!

You offered not having cash up as an excuse - he took that to mean that if you had cash on you, you would give him some, so he offered a solution to the problem. If you just didn't want to give him money, you could've just said 'no'.

xiaoxo · 11/10/2022 02:24

Lovely MN piling on OP for not buying a stranger alcohol ffs. You could give your life savings and bloody home away to the man and you’d still be the arsehole here. YANBU, i’d walk soon as he pushed me into using the ATM, would love to see all these others in the same situation Confused it’s the pure cheek of taking advantage of kindness and pushing his luck, I wouldn’t care if he’s got nothing to lose or not, there’s a moral compass between providing a meal or buying alcohol/fags.

Summerfun54321 · 11/10/2022 02:14

I always offer to take beggars to go and buy food instead if they ask me for money. Only 2 people have ever taken me up on it. People are naive if you think others don’t beg for drug money, some aren’t even homeless.

catell01 · 11/10/2022 01:29

OP i don't think you're U for being a little taken aback at being asked to withdraw money - I guess he chose to stand next to an ATM strategically. But I guess he's learned that nobody carried cash around and wants to maximise the odds.

I don't think you're U for being a little taken aback that he accompanied you around the store. But at least he was getting what he actually wanted rather than assuming a complete stranger would know what he would/could eat. Yes, I know a lot of you will think he should be grateful for anything, but he might have allergies etc.

I don't think you're U for thinking he's cheeky for adding the scratchcard. Totally unreasonable request, IMO.

I don't even think you're U for not wanting to buy him an alcoholic drink (you have your reasons and that's fine, nobody else's business) BUT why do you automatically assume he's an alcoholic? At one point you suggest that he might even have been a professional beggar, so was he really acting drunk, look like a drunk, smell like a drunk, was he reeling all over the place? One shitty mixed drink does not an alcoholic make. It's not like he was asking for a quart, half or bottle of cheap whisky or vodka.

Now you have a plan to always have cash with you to hand out to the homeless, are you going to dictate to them what they're allowed to spend that money on? You could still be 'enabling' addicts but is that OK as long as you're not personally purchasing the drugs or alcohol?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 11/10/2022 01:12

What would you rather a street sleeper died of? freezing to death? Malnutrition? being pissed on daily and beaten up by thugs? When you are on the streets, frankly any distraction be that coke, meth or alcohol is welcomed. Its not the same as giving alcohol to a dependent partner, parent or child....they have much better choices they can make. Homelessness gives you practically no choices at all so I can fully understand the desire to get pissed.....and I am a tee totaler.

Well said. It's easy for those of us with a home, warm blankets and food to judge. The same people who gobble anti-depressants and anti-anxiety meds or have their welcome half-bottle of wine at night put their nose in the air at the notion of buying some poor sod on the street a little relief.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 11/10/2022 01:08

bloodywhitecat · 10/10/2022 23:15

Cheeky but I guess the scratch card gives him a fleeting glimpse of hope.

Agree.

Same with the booze. I look upon it as I'm not buying them drink, I'm buying them a little bit of time free from anxiety.

mauveskies · 11/10/2022 01:08

The correct MN response would have been to have given him your home.

Vecna · 11/10/2022 01:00

Ignore the usual mn twats. You can't even give to the homeless without being told you're an arsehole here.

You were very kind and he was blatantly trying to take advantage of your kindness. His life is probably so shit that he deemed pushing for more worth a go, but of course it was unpleasant for you.

LikeTearsInRain · 11/10/2022 01:00

I had a woman do similar to me. Said she needed money at first to cover rent for her child. When offered to buy something from the shop instead she wanted a can of cider, chocolate bar and 20 fags

PinkFrogss · 11/10/2022 00:59

Another idea for the non cash carriers - gift vouchers, doesn’t have to be much, just £5 for a cafe, greggs, Tesco etc