Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked by this

191 replies

Vodkaany1 · 10/10/2022 23:07

Was walking through our local town tonight and there was a man outside one of the local mini supermarkets who was homeless and asked if I could spare some money, I said sorry, no as I didn't have any cash on me as I rarely carry cash these days. He was stood by the cashpoint outside and said "Maybe you could draw some money out" Being I was on my own and aware of potential distraction theft (fairly large town with fairly high crime rate) I said no, I wasn't prepared to take any money out, so he asked if I could perhaps buy him some food from the mini supermarket and as I'm not completely heartless I said yes that's fine. Went in with him to pick some food and then he asked me if I would buy him a small can of alcohol with mixer - think JD & coke in a can type thing - and a scratch card!! I was utterly gob smacked and my response was to tell him he was taking the piss and I'd buy him some food and a non alcohol drink and that was it or he could have nothing. Honestly couldn't believe it! AIBU to be shocked by the sheer cfery of him? It's really put me off helping anyone else in future

OP posts:
Softplayhooray · 11/10/2022 07:28

AmadeusBreathingWater · 10/10/2022 23:18

you’re right, he should have kissed your feet for offering to buy him a sandwich

🙄

I mean, the guy is homeless, sounds like his life has gone to compete shit and he's still ballsy enough to try his luck which is at least a positive. I'd be drinking too (or trying to) if I was destitute and homeless.

Was there piss taking? Yes. I can kind of understand it though.

Sunnyqueen · 11/10/2022 07:27

Oh and fwiw I have lost close relatives to alcoholism and still have other close relatives in the throes of it.

Sunnyqueen · 11/10/2022 07:24

I'd have got him them. I'd want a bloody drink if I was sleeping on the streets and it's only a weak can with mixer not a bottle of Glen's! And the scratchcard he might as well try his luck it's a pound of someone else's money that he could win more off.

dirtyasadustpanlid · 11/10/2022 07:22

I have often bought booze for a homeless person rightly or wrongly. Whatever gets you through the night. My father was a raging alcoholic and my childhood was pretty grim because of it. In my eyes a couple of cans would be a hell of a lot more welcome that. Tesco Sandwich especially when you are in the throes of addiction, of you don’t have to hussle anymore that night and it gives you some peace, well good. One small thing I can do then. Half of you will go home and crack open your nightly bottle of wine, but you have a home and the money to buy it. He asked for what he needed and that’s ok, you refused to buy it for him and that’s ok but don’t come on a judge a man for asking. You don’t ask, you don’t get and had he asked me, I would have given it and others too so it’s always worth the ask. For me, understanding alcoholism as I do from my childhood just makes me more aware and compassionate.

Bestcatmum · 11/10/2022 07:11

In the past I have been in a desperate situation with mental health where all I wanted to do was deaden the pain with alcohol or prescription drugs anyway I could. Don't judge.

Darbs76 · 11/10/2022 06:48

Some of the responses on here. Honestly why are do people suddenly become so judgmental and critical when hiding before a screen?

Anyway yes you’re not unreasonable to be shocked when he asked for the scratch card and alcoholic drink. And you’re definitely not unreasonable to not get them for him. I guess he has nothing to lose by asking

MrsMaxDeWinter · 11/10/2022 06:42

OP, I must say I laughed at this story because it is funny. You did a kind thing and got an amusing story out of it. I am not sure it is so gobsmacking that a homeless person who may not have talked to anyone that day thought he would try his luck. I would simply have laughed, told him he was cheeky, and moved on.
One of the things that homeless people say is that they often feel invisible and unseen. So it's really nice that you took a bit time to do him a small kindness.Think no more of it.

lannistunut · 11/10/2022 06:37

2ManyPjs · 11/10/2022 00:03

This.

What I'm gobsmacked at is that someone would go our their way to start a thread like this to judge some poor soul who's basically got fuck all.

I agree. Nasty thread, just designed to stir up anti-begging vitriol.

tranquiltortoise · 11/10/2022 06:26

There are two options when walking past a homeless person the way I see it:

  1. You engage with a homeless person and you accept however they are, e.g. if you give them money you accept that they may spend it on booze or drugs and that is their choice as an adult. Once you give it to them, it's theirs.

  2. You just don't engage, and/ or you donate to a charity instead.

There is literally no point in worrying about what they are spending money on or what they are doing with their evenings etc. - that's patronising and is like taking away their autonomy as adults. If they want to drink/ get stoned that's up to them and god knows they have more reasons to want that escape than most of us.

If you don't want money to be spent on those things, you give it to a charity.

Iwanttoholdyourham · 11/10/2022 06:25

Mummysharkdoodoodoodoodoodoo · 11/10/2022 06:01

Oh I HATE people with attitudes like yours. So what if he wanted a bloody mixed drink - it’s not like he was asking you to buy him a bag of heroin or a litre of vodka? That food and drink was probably the only comfort he got that day - if I was homeless I’d want a drink too! And even if you wouldn’t, who are you to judge? It wasn’t much more expensive than a non alcoholic drink. And how much is a scratch card - £1? £1 to give the poor guy some hope at a desperate time? You were cruel and judgemental and unkind.

@Vodkaany1 has stated that they have experienced alcoholism within their own family. A lot of people who haven't seen alcoholism or other addictions up close don't realise how devastating this can be. The UK minimises heavy drinking as normal culture, and this can be hellish for anyone trying to protect a loved one with a genuine drinking problem.

I don't think the OP is coming at this from a place of judgement, more a lack of knowledge about the issues facing homelessness, and a lot of personal lived experience of feeling helpless whilst a loved one drinks themselves to death, whilst those around minimise the problem.

The OP tried to help, it didn't go they way they expected. They've tried to help people dear to them before and it hasn't gone the way they hoped either. You can understand questioning the interaction, and wondering what they could have/should have done differently to get a better outcome.

As a lone person (I haven't assumed the OP is female, but the odds on this site are the OP is a woman), the request to take cash out would have immediately made them feel vulnerable, and that would have informed the rest of their interactions. When you don't feel safe yourself, you act on adrenaline and you're not entirely sure if you made the most logical decisions, because you weren't your usual self at the time; you were yourself on high alert.

The OP had the kindness to actually stop. A lot of people don't.

People are allowed to put boundaries around their kindness. In fact, I'd encourage it. If you have to do everything or nothing, most people will opt for nothing. When people are allowed to determine the level of support they give to strangers, they're more likely to do so, and the world is a less shitty place.

You might not be able to afford to or want to give £100k to Crisis. You might have the resources to stick 50p in a charity tin. Just because you can't do the big gesture doesn't mean you should skip the smaller gesture for not being as good. You do what you can, and what feels right to you. When you're kind within your own boundaries, you don't feel taken advantage of, and you are able to later repeat that kindness, because it feels safe.

Small, kind gestures all add up. Don't ignore their cumulative effect.

And I don't think it's kind to judge the OP, who tried their best. I hope they'll take on board my previous comments on Street Link, and learn from this encounter. Not because I think they're an awful person, but because I think the way they helped didn't make them feel safe, and when you're being kind, you deserve to feel safe. That's not something you should have to give up when helping.

tranquiltortoise · 11/10/2022 06:21

No, you should not be gobsmacked by it.

How a homeless person behaves is not something to be shocked by, they are in various complicated and difficult situations and are often desperate.

If you don't want to interact then you shouldn't have engaged with him. It's ridiculous to judge his actions/ behaviour.

Give a monthly donation to a local charity that supports homeless people.

RudsyFarmer · 11/10/2022 06:11

Good deeds never go unpunished which is why most people walk past homeless people and ignore the begging.

Beeinalily · 11/10/2022 06:10

OP you were kind. I wonder if the sanctimonious lot on here actually ever do anything for anyone, or if they just sit in judgment.

Fimofriend · 11/10/2022 06:09

Hilarious that so many posters are accusing OP of being judgemental while being judgemental of OP because she wouldn't just give him whatever he asked for.

I am sure booze and drugs makes it easier for someone to forget they are homeless but it also makes them more likely to be unpleasant or downright dangerous to innocent passers-by.

Luckily, where I live the local council makes a huge effort to keep people from becoming homeless. Usually politicians react if they get more than 300 letters about a subject so if just some of you would write to your local councils and ask them to ensure that places are opened to keep the homeless safe or at least during the cold months it would really help.

Mummysharkdoodoodoodoodoodoo · 11/10/2022 06:01

Oh I HATE people with attitudes like yours. So what if he wanted a bloody mixed drink - it’s not like he was asking you to buy him a bag of heroin or a litre of vodka? That food and drink was probably the only comfort he got that day - if I was homeless I’d want a drink too! And even if you wouldn’t, who are you to judge? It wasn’t much more expensive than a non alcoholic drink. And how much is a scratch card - £1? £1 to give the poor guy some hope at a desperate time? You were cruel and judgemental and unkind.

Redfrangipani · 11/10/2022 05:57

NightsByTheLake · 11/10/2022 00:15

And with the number of people carrying cash now being much lower, asking you to take money out your bank isn’t really as shocking as you think it is. Years ago lots of people would have given them the change in their pocket, now most people won’t have any. ‘Even’ homeless people have to move with the times to survive. Try to be less judgemental.

Really good point. I never have cash in my pocket anymore.

Yet Another problem/obstacle homeless people face.

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:54

Funkyblues101 · 11/10/2022 05:47

What if you'd bought him a scratch card and he'd won £50 000 on it? What then?

What do you mean what then? Would you want a cut of that because you bought the scratch card?

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:53

Iwanttoholdyourham · 11/10/2022 05:51

Not you, @Vodkaany1 , but @Wdib78 's comment on mobile phones is ridiculous.

Most people in the UK weren't born homeless, but fell into rough sleeping after their lives blew up. Often it's a breakdown with family, job loss and/or addiction. There are plenty of nice middle class men for example, who get divorced, can't afford to live on their own, and don't get treated as priority by the council because they're single men and supposed to take care of themselves, and they end up on the streets.

Women with kids struggle to get council accommodation as it is, because we have a shortage of housing stock. What do you think happens to all those men who don't get council housing? I can tell you, they don't magically find somewhere else to live.

Once you're on the streets, it becomes very difficult to get yourself off the streets. And some people end up with such poor mental ill health that they struggle to live inside again, given the choice. I've volunteered in shelters before where people have come in for practical support like food and showers, then slept back outside because they're so accustomed to the noise of the city. Fixing homelessness isn't always as simple as giving everyone somewhere to stay.

If you had a handset before you were sleeping rough, why wouldn't you cling on it when you were on the streets? It's hard enough not having a fixed address - can you imagine not being contactable by mobile and email either? If you don't have a phone, you can acquire one via a homeless charity. Getting people off the streets is the ultimate goal. There are lots of hoops to jump through in the meantime, and charities will try their best to provide support in that period, and that can include giving a PAYG handset to a rough sleeper and helping to keep it topped up so they can stay connected.

Depends on the location, but where I am, you can charge your phone on the bus (riding public transport is always a great way of staying warm and safe, and relatively cheap, so that's a bonus) or in shopping centres (again, nice and warm inside, and unlikely to be attacked given the number of people and cameras around).

When it comes to giving money or things to homeless people - sure, some do take the mick. Some aren't even genuine, and are just con artists. It can be difficult to read if the person in front of you is 'real' or not, if you don't have a lot of experience in speaking to rough sleepers. Some people just try their luck. Some are gang members and/or trafficked victims, forced to beg for what they can get. Although many people on the streets are genuine, there are unfortunately some people who take advantage of that by mimicking them and playing on your heartstrings.

If you are prepared to buy something for someone, remember, dignity is important. If you buy a bunch of food and drink and give to a homeless person, they might not be able to eat it. Anyone can be homeless. That can include vegetarians, for example, who would rather be hungry than eat meat. You can still be religious on the streets. You can still have allergies. You can still have a set of values that you refuse to compromise.

Not everyone has a substance abuse problem. But for those who do, it can mess with their tastebuds. A hot drink, for example, might need no sugar in it, or it might need 10 sugars in it to be palatable. If you tell people what you are prepared to do - e.g. offer them a hot drink and/or a sandwich - it's the kind thing to honour the choice within that boundary.

You're not wrong to refuse to do things outside your limits. If you're prepared to buy a soft drink but not a can of beer, you're OK to repeat you can't buy the beer, but they can have whatever soft drink they like. It's not CFery of them to see what they can get (you stopped to talk, how many other people did?) but it's also not wrong of you to reinforce that your kindness has boundaries.

If you're the type of person who ends up followed around a supermarket by a homeless person hoping you'll buy very specific things, I'd suggest you shouldn't be engaging. The last thing you want is to make a homeless person reliant on you, so every time they see you in the streets, they ask you for something you can't give them. Some people with very kind intentions do sometimes inadvertently put themselves at risk, because they find boundaries very difficult when they feel so guilty about being better off.

If you find these conversations too hard to manage, honestly, this isn't a fob off - the best way to support people on the streets is to make sure homeless charities know about them, so they can deliver the practical support instead, with experienced volunteers and staff having those interactions. You can, for example, flag a rough sleeper to Street Link here: www.streetlink.org.uk Give them as much information as you can, and they'll make sure an outreach worker checks up on them.

You can also donate money to homeless charities like Street Link, Shelter and Crisis. Or volunteer your time with one of them. Sometimes, the best way to support someone is to make sure someone with a different skillset to you takes the lead - and you support that person instead, whether financially or with time.

@Vodkaany1 , I'm sorry this interaction has left you feeling unsure if you did the right thing, and uncertain about how to handle yourself next time. But you know you meant well, so take comfort in your instincts for kindness, and don't feel obliged to stop next time if it doesn't feel right. Instead, report the location to Street Link and bob the charity the few quid you'd have been prepared to spend on a sandwich. You can feel more certain you've helped that way, without wondering if you've helped a genuine person, and without feeling personally unsafe.

Excellent comment! 👏👏

Iwanttoholdyourham · 11/10/2022 05:51

Not you, @Vodkaany1 , but @Wdib78 's comment on mobile phones is ridiculous.

Most people in the UK weren't born homeless, but fell into rough sleeping after their lives blew up. Often it's a breakdown with family, job loss and/or addiction. There are plenty of nice middle class men for example, who get divorced, can't afford to live on their own, and don't get treated as priority by the council because they're single men and supposed to take care of themselves, and they end up on the streets.

Women with kids struggle to get council accommodation as it is, because we have a shortage of housing stock. What do you think happens to all those men who don't get council housing? I can tell you, they don't magically find somewhere else to live.

Once you're on the streets, it becomes very difficult to get yourself off the streets. And some people end up with such poor mental ill health that they struggle to live inside again, given the choice. I've volunteered in shelters before where people have come in for practical support like food and showers, then slept back outside because they're so accustomed to the noise of the city. Fixing homelessness isn't always as simple as giving everyone somewhere to stay.

If you had a handset before you were sleeping rough, why wouldn't you cling on it when you were on the streets? It's hard enough not having a fixed address - can you imagine not being contactable by mobile and email either? If you don't have a phone, you can acquire one via a homeless charity. Getting people off the streets is the ultimate goal. There are lots of hoops to jump through in the meantime, and charities will try their best to provide support in that period, and that can include giving a PAYG handset to a rough sleeper and helping to keep it topped up so they can stay connected.

Depends on the location, but where I am, you can charge your phone on the bus (riding public transport is always a great way of staying warm and safe, and relatively cheap, so that's a bonus) or in shopping centres (again, nice and warm inside, and unlikely to be attacked given the number of people and cameras around).

When it comes to giving money or things to homeless people - sure, some do take the mick. Some aren't even genuine, and are just con artists. It can be difficult to read if the person in front of you is 'real' or not, if you don't have a lot of experience in speaking to rough sleepers. Some people just try their luck. Some are gang members and/or trafficked victims, forced to beg for what they can get. Although many people on the streets are genuine, there are unfortunately some people who take advantage of that by mimicking them and playing on your heartstrings.

If you are prepared to buy something for someone, remember, dignity is important. If you buy a bunch of food and drink and give to a homeless person, they might not be able to eat it. Anyone can be homeless. That can include vegetarians, for example, who would rather be hungry than eat meat. You can still be religious on the streets. You can still have allergies. You can still have a set of values that you refuse to compromise.

Not everyone has a substance abuse problem. But for those who do, it can mess with their tastebuds. A hot drink, for example, might need no sugar in it, or it might need 10 sugars in it to be palatable. If you tell people what you are prepared to do - e.g. offer them a hot drink and/or a sandwich - it's the kind thing to honour the choice within that boundary.

You're not wrong to refuse to do things outside your limits. If you're prepared to buy a soft drink but not a can of beer, you're OK to repeat you can't buy the beer, but they can have whatever soft drink they like. It's not CFery of them to see what they can get (you stopped to talk, how many other people did?) but it's also not wrong of you to reinforce that your kindness has boundaries.

If you're the type of person who ends up followed around a supermarket by a homeless person hoping you'll buy very specific things, I'd suggest you shouldn't be engaging. The last thing you want is to make a homeless person reliant on you, so every time they see you in the streets, they ask you for something you can't give them. Some people with very kind intentions do sometimes inadvertently put themselves at risk, because they find boundaries very difficult when they feel so guilty about being better off.

If you find these conversations too hard to manage, honestly, this isn't a fob off - the best way to support people on the streets is to make sure homeless charities know about them, so they can deliver the practical support instead, with experienced volunteers and staff having those interactions. You can, for example, flag a rough sleeper to Street Link here: www.streetlink.org.uk Give them as much information as you can, and they'll make sure an outreach worker checks up on them.

You can also donate money to homeless charities like Street Link, Shelter and Crisis. Or volunteer your time with one of them. Sometimes, the best way to support someone is to make sure someone with a different skillset to you takes the lead - and you support that person instead, whether financially or with time.

@Vodkaany1 , I'm sorry this interaction has left you feeling unsure if you did the right thing, and uncertain about how to handle yourself next time. But you know you meant well, so take comfort in your instincts for kindness, and don't feel obliged to stop next time if it doesn't feel right. Instead, report the location to Street Link and bob the charity the few quid you'd have been prepared to spend on a sandwich. You can feel more certain you've helped that way, without wondering if you've helped a genuine person, and without feeling personally unsafe.

Soubriquet · 11/10/2022 05:49

Funkyblues101 · 11/10/2022 05:47

What if you'd bought him a scratch card and he'd won £50 000 on it? What then?

Good for fucking him

I wouldn’t have hung around to see what he won anyway so I wouldn’t have known

Funkyblues101 · 11/10/2022 05:47

What if you'd bought him a scratch card and he'd won £50 000 on it? What then?

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:45

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 05:37

These day yes but not ten years ago.
Assuming he could charge it, he must have been getting enough too in donations to keep it topped up

Ten years ago you could charge your phone in a library, at a shelter, in a cafe. You just need a charger and plug.

wetpebbles · 11/10/2022 05:44

You were kind to him and he pushed his luck a bit.
I stupidly offered a cf a drink in the pub once and they asked for a double whisky when they had been drinking cheap lager all night

MayThe4th · 11/10/2022 05:40

I would have walked off the instant he asked me to draw money out of the cash point.

As for the people saying well if drugs is what gets him through the day…. What virtue signalling bollocks. You crack on then and support the drugs trade, the trafficking trade, everything else that it stands for, just as long as you can say you can say that it’s ok because “whatever gets him through the day.” And that’s assuming he’s genuine which there’s every chance he isn’t.

The fact that people are so gullible is the reason why begging has turned into an occupation for some. And why there are gangs sent out begging every day.

SnoozyLucy7 · 11/10/2022 05:40

Obki · 11/10/2022 05:33

And back in the real world, a strange man following me around a shop asking for alcohol and scratch cards would put me off for helping in this way again.

i completely understand that, as would I. But what I am saying is some people become indignant when a homeless person dares to want, to ask for something else that isn’t just a sandwich and coffee. They have nothing to lose by asking for something else like a scratch card or a Smirnoff ice. The person can say yes or no but it’s absolutely nothing to get gobsmacked out.