Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked by this

191 replies

Vodkaany1 · 10/10/2022 23:07

Was walking through our local town tonight and there was a man outside one of the local mini supermarkets who was homeless and asked if I could spare some money, I said sorry, no as I didn't have any cash on me as I rarely carry cash these days. He was stood by the cashpoint outside and said "Maybe you could draw some money out" Being I was on my own and aware of potential distraction theft (fairly large town with fairly high crime rate) I said no, I wasn't prepared to take any money out, so he asked if I could perhaps buy him some food from the mini supermarket and as I'm not completely heartless I said yes that's fine. Went in with him to pick some food and then he asked me if I would buy him a small can of alcohol with mixer - think JD & coke in a can type thing - and a scratch card!! I was utterly gob smacked and my response was to tell him he was taking the piss and I'd buy him some food and a non alcohol drink and that was it or he could have nothing. Honestly couldn't believe it! AIBU to be shocked by the sheer cfery of him? It's really put me off helping anyone else in future

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 11/10/2022 08:01

They are very persistent and intimidating. I don't want to encourage begging so I have regular donation set up to a homeless charity and if I'm in a different area I donate to a local charity via my phone.

I think you did a good thing helping him but don't let it put you off helping others.

Vodkaany1 · 11/10/2022 07:59

I didn't mention the costs last night as it's irrelevant to me but for those saying that the can of drink would be not much more then a can of coke and only £1 for a scratchcard, the can of drink he wanted specifically was £2.90 and the scratchcard he wanted was, again, a specific one that was £3 as that was "the only one he does".

To the person who said I was accusing him of being a professional begger, I didn't say that - I said he may not have been genuinely homeless, he could be a drug addict with a home but begging on the street for money for his next fix. I didn't see any belongings with him as he wasn't sat outside the shop, just hanging around the door but he could've kept them elsewhere. His clothes were not clean and i believe there's a high chance he was but as I said, I'll never know for sure.

Some of you may not have agreed with my decision, which is fine, but some of you have been downright nasty. Judging me despite telling me not to judge and calling me names. How does that make you any better? It doesn't because sure as hell you wouldn't say it to my face, it's just easier to be nasty when you're behind a screen. Keep telling me I'm wrong for being outraged - please tell me where I said I was outraged? I was shocked and taken a back at the extra requests and thought it was cheeky never said I was outraged at all.
I've explained several times why I wouldn't buy booze, I don't buy it for myself either. Just because you have been in similar childhood situation to me and would still buy it, doesn't make me wrong!

OP posts:
EatYourVegetables · 11/10/2022 07:59

A middle class mum who had a hard day because her kids are misbehaving and her job is demanding “deserves” wine-o-clock, but a homeless person doesn’t?

SleeplessInEngland · 11/10/2022 07:57

*I know it is what I’d want!

Sparklfairy · 11/10/2022 07:57

gamerchick · 10/10/2022 23:32

When I was homeless, getting off my head was more preferable than food. Makes walking the streets bearable.

He didn't have anything to lose by chancing his arm OP. If you haven't done it, try to squash the outrage.

This. And he was hardly going to end up passed put in the gutter from a can of mixed drink.

Don't forget the majority of people ignore him, so of course he wants to get what he can get while he can, he doesn't know when someone will stop for him again.

mrsparsnip · 11/10/2022 07:57

My eldest son is very vulnerable. He was asked for money by a man standing by a cash machine. The man said he was homeless. My son told him that he only had three pounds.

He gave this to the man, who then started to 'cry' and told my son that he had a baby and a dog to feed (or something similar) and asked my son if he could withdraw some money from the cash machine. My son went to the machine and the man stood close to him (my son is autistic, so this made him really uncomfortable). He told my son to draw out as much as he could. My son withdrew £400, which is the maximum he could withdraw. The money was his rent for the month. The man did not 'threaten' my son, he was just really close and really coercive.

My son told me about what had happened the next day, and although the police checked the CCTV, around the area, my son could not identify anyone. He was, and still is scared of going to that area of town. We helped him to change his PIN just in case this had been seen, and to help my son feel safer. His support staff have given him extra advice about how to respond to this sort of coercion.

So, whilst the incident described in this thread is amusing at one level, there is a more worrying side to this type of behaviour.

SleeplessInEngland · 11/10/2022 07:56

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 07:44

Escapism from a can of JD and coke 😂

What puritanical nonsense

Nothing puritanical about saying alcohol has an escapist quality. If it didn’t hardly any of us would drink it. I know it’s not what I’d want if I had another night without a roof.

limitedperiodonly · 11/10/2022 07:55

Why is everyone who asks you to do something you don't particularly want to do a cheeky fucker on Mumsnet? They're not holding a knife to your throat. Just say you'd rather not.

limitedperiodonly · 11/10/2022 07:52

He asked, you said no eventually.

Dreamer14 · 11/10/2022 07:52

Probably an alcoholic. I would not have purchased alcohol for an alcoholic. Some filling healthy warning food yes but no to alcohol

Wdib78 · 11/10/2022 07:50

sst1234 · 11/10/2022 07:45

This is MN OP. Some batshit posters will tell you that you are devoid of any mouthy unless you buy him some crack and a joint too.

🤣
I've bought plenty of food and blankets, without being asked for people begging on the streets of my hometown, however never money due to the many reports that there are "fake" homeless in our town.
That's my entire point, you just don't know!

ThatCheeseIsMine · 11/10/2022 07:48

I’ve been in this situation and it made me really uncomfortable. Not the alcohol but offering to get them something from the shop and they got up and came in with me to choose - I don’t want someone going round the shop with me and that’s not what I offered. The man was then angry with me that I wouldn’t buy more so I learned a lesson never to agree to this. I will still offer and get someone a sandwich, fruit or a coffee etc. they ask for but not a shopping trip.

Round here they can sometimes be aggressive and one shouts at you if you don’t say yes. One time I said “sorry, I don’t have any change today” and now he mocks me and repeats that back to me when he sees me. But OTOH a lot of the homeless in our area seem to have MH problems. Even without that I can understand it must be awful.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 11/10/2022 07:48

I’m honestly not sure what you wanted from this thread? Anyone who disagrees with you, you argue with. Accounts from real life people who’ve been homeless, they’re still wrong and you’re still right.

Do you just want us to fawn at your good deed by buying a person some food and the lecture about enabling his alcoholism?

Well done OP. You’re a queen. He will be off the streets clean and sober tomorrow because he didn’t have that 1 can in his belly and no money from you to buy any more. Bravooooooo

sst1234 · 11/10/2022 07:47

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 07:40

Jesus I'd have bought him a scratchcard! For Christ sake he's homeless!
He's not a CF.
Give the guy a bit of respect and let him have some autonomy. He doesn't have the means to have anything he likes, imagine never being able to choose for yourself and always being given only what other people deign to give away/pre-approve for you. I'd have had a chat about the alcohol but even that was a mixed drink in a can not a 3L bottle!
You'd give a toddler more say in what they were given than that.
Honestly I'm gobsmacked that you were so outraged about an adult in a shitty situation asking for some small comforts that you've posted about it online!

Give over with the performative outrage. It’s a bit silly.

Lunar270 · 11/10/2022 07:46

AIBU to be shocked by the sheer cfery of him? It's really put me off helping anyone else in future

I appreciate you've tried to explain yourself OP but I voted YABU for this because it wasn't cfery. The guy is homeless and social norms go out of the window. It's not difficult to put yourself in his shoes and ask what you'd do if 99% of people ignored or said, "no", or treated you like scum.

And while you claim not to be judging, you are really if you thought he was a CF, whichever way you explain it.

And why would it put you off helping others in future? Are you tarring the homeless with the same brush or has the prospect of dealing with unreasonable requests been too distasteful?

BitOutOfPractice · 11/10/2022 07:46

So @Vodkaany1 (interesting name for someone so uptight about alcohol!) what would you have done if to us bought him a scratch card (or he’d bought one with a pound coin you’d found) and he won big? That’s a much more interesting moral dilemma!

sst1234 · 11/10/2022 07:45

This is MN OP. Some batshit posters will tell you that you are devoid of any mouthy unless you buy him some crack and a joint too.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 07:44

Escapism from a can of JD and coke 😂

What puritanical nonsense

SleeplessInEngland · 11/10/2022 07:43

I saw a documentary on the homeless and they hate being constantly given sandwiches. It sounds so counterintuitive and you weren’t wrong to offer but I can understand when living on the streets all you really want is a moment of escapism.

Riverlee · 11/10/2022 07:43

I would be gobsmacked as well, and would only buy food, not alcohol or a scratch card.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 07:40

Jesus I'd have bought him a scratchcard! For Christ sake he's homeless!
He's not a CF.
Give the guy a bit of respect and let him have some autonomy. He doesn't have the means to have anything he likes, imagine never being able to choose for yourself and always being given only what other people deign to give away/pre-approve for you. I'd have had a chat about the alcohol but even that was a mixed drink in a can not a 3L bottle!
You'd give a toddler more say in what they were given than that.
Honestly I'm gobsmacked that you were so outraged about an adult in a shitty situation asking for some small comforts that you've posted about it online!

Softplayhooray · 11/10/2022 07:39

I do find it weird that anyone says buying a weak can of mixed alcohol for the guy encourages alcohol abuse.

As adults, probably most of us know someone already who has suffered from alcoholism or binge drinking or drugs or whatever, but when is the last time your mate asked you to buy them a weakly mixed alcoholic drink down the pub and you said no because I don't want to encourage you to have an alcohol abuse problem?

Vodkaany1 · 11/10/2022 07:33

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 11/10/2022 02:27

You offered not having cash up as an excuse - he took that to mean that if you had cash on you, you would give him some, so he offered a solution to the problem. If you just didn't want to give him money, you could've just said 'no'.

I've already explained why I wasn't happy to take money out of the cash point. It wasn't that I didn't want to give him money - I was a lone female at night in a town that has a high volume of distraction thefts. I wasn't going to take my purse out of my handbag when there was barely anyone to help if it turned out to be a that case

OP posts:
BitOutOfPractice · 11/10/2022 07:30

I wonder what the op would’ve done if she’d bought the scratch card and he’d won big?

BitOutOfPractice · 11/10/2022 07:29

Vodkaany1 · 10/10/2022 23:24

It wasn't the cost of it that bothered me and maybe CF isn't the right phrase, I was just shocked when he'd asked for food and then added on the other things, especially after asking me to draw money out of the cashpoint. I think he said something along the lines of "maybe you could take £20 out". I wouldn't support buying alcohol and I'm wary of giving money if I suspect there maybe an alcohol/substance abuse problem. While I understand there maybe a "need" for some escapism if living on the streets, it feels wrong to enable it.

You sound incredibly naive and priggish op.