Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked by this

191 replies

Vodkaany1 · 10/10/2022 23:07

Was walking through our local town tonight and there was a man outside one of the local mini supermarkets who was homeless and asked if I could spare some money, I said sorry, no as I didn't have any cash on me as I rarely carry cash these days. He was stood by the cashpoint outside and said "Maybe you could draw some money out" Being I was on my own and aware of potential distraction theft (fairly large town with fairly high crime rate) I said no, I wasn't prepared to take any money out, so he asked if I could perhaps buy him some food from the mini supermarket and as I'm not completely heartless I said yes that's fine. Went in with him to pick some food and then he asked me if I would buy him a small can of alcohol with mixer - think JD & coke in a can type thing - and a scratch card!! I was utterly gob smacked and my response was to tell him he was taking the piss and I'd buy him some food and a non alcohol drink and that was it or he could have nothing. Honestly couldn't believe it! AIBU to be shocked by the sheer cfery of him? It's really put me off helping anyone else in future

OP posts:
GelatoQueen · 11/10/2022 09:13

Where I live a lot of the 'homeless' women are run by gangs of men. They get bused around the city and strategic placed early morning and collected in the evening with their takings (which are all taken by the men). They also distribute dogs to some of the people who are 'homeless' as people are more likely to give money to feed their pets.
No way am I enabling any of this. Some people are really naive in my experience.

pimlicoanna · 11/10/2022 09:10

He didn't actually want food. He wanted alcohol. No homeless charity will advocate giving cash. Homeless people are given food. Most want money for drink and drugs. It's just a fact.

JennyJenny8675309 · 11/10/2022 09:10

I was in Las Vegas and saw a homeless man with a sign that said
“Not gonna lie, I need money for beer”. None of the “Will work for food” nonsense for that guy!

Glitterspy · 11/10/2022 09:10

LikeTearsInRain · 11/10/2022 08:52

I just ignore them now. Especially men because I think it makes a woman on her own very vulnerable to be helping unknown man with a penis who could have all sorts of addictions or mental health issues.

What the actual. The lack of empathy here is shocking. Are you for real? Check your humanity, @LikeTearsInRain

Noviembre · 11/10/2022 09:07

Don't fucking talk to people who are trying to get you to get cash from a cash machine. How bloody gullible are you? Christ almighty. People like you make the streets more dangerous for the rest of us, as thieves get bolder because more dimwits are so keen to virtue signal and whip their credit cards out they lose all common sense.

GelatoQueen · 11/10/2022 09:05

I never help the homeless directly because there are plenty organisations where I live that offer support, food, a bed etc. I will however talk to and I've got to know some of them quite well in the past. Quite a number (of men) are transient homeless - they live elsewhere during the summer months and get casual jobs, come back to my city in the autumn to beg. Almost all have addiction issues. I do tend to tell them about the support services and have in the past reported to SS when I've seen extremely vulnerable people on the street. But no - I never give money.

ThatCheeseIsMine · 11/10/2022 09:03

Because people are homeless, we mustn't take all autonomy away from them.

I agree with this so I give money along with if I've bought food. I absolutely understand spending it on alcohol and that plenty of non-homeless people do the same. However, giving someone their own money to make their own decisions is different from buying them alcohol. I don't want to have anything to do with someone possibly relapsing or being dangerously affected by alcohol so I wouldn't buy it.

No one has to buy anyone something just because they ask.

MorrisZapp · 11/10/2022 08:55

This happened to me, it was horrible. Young man begging tearfully for a bottle of water outside tescos. I said, sure, I'll get you some water. Money, money he said. Need food. I'll get you food I said, and went into tescos. He came with me saying money, money. When he realised I wasn't going to give him cash, he scanned the prices of the meat and took the most expensive box of chicken, then grabbed more bits by looking at the prices.

I felt really intimidated but I just wanted it over with so I went up to the checkout with him, he basically threw the food down in anger. The guy at the till clearly recognised him.

I paid up and the guy grabbed the stuff and stormed out. I was shaking as I walked away, it was a horrible experience and I couldn't work out what had just happened.

I walked back the same way an hour later and another guy was there with him, going through his takings and shouting angrily at him.

Clearly it was a script and the guy gives the money to a higher up guy. I don't make eye contact with them now.

GloriousGlory · 11/10/2022 08:53

LikeTearsInRain · 11/10/2022 08:52

I just ignore them now. Especially men because I think it makes a woman on her own very vulnerable to be helping unknown man with a penis who could have all sorts of addictions or mental health issues.

Do you give to homeless charities instead? If the only reason that you don't give us because you feel vulnerable?

Or is it just an area of society that you like to pretend doesn't exist?

LikeTearsInRain · 11/10/2022 08:52

I just ignore them now. Especially men because I think it makes a woman on her own very vulnerable to be helping unknown man with a penis who could have all sorts of addictions or mental health issues.

GloriousGlory · 11/10/2022 08:50

Petros9 · 11/10/2022 08:47

Crikey. Every now and then I read a thread and feel amazed at how contrary the majority of responses are.

Contrary? Pointing out another view?

GloriousGlory · 11/10/2022 08:50

LumpyandBumps · 11/10/2022 08:25

This thread is quite interesting in terms of voting.
Most comments indicate that OP is being unreasonable, whereas the poll shows a silent majority of voters think she is not unreasonable.
(28/72 at present)

I'm On the app I can't see that, but very interesting!

I think it's saying a lot of people see homelessness as meaning a "lower being", so it's ok for us lucky ones being joked that can say "I don't like fried eggs, I'll have scrambled" but homeless people should be grateful for anything and everything they're given.

Clearly, whilst voting that way, they can't vocalise that as they don't want to be corrected

Petros9 · 11/10/2022 08:47

Crikey. Every now and then I read a thread and feel amazed at how contrary the majority of responses are.

GloriousGlory · 11/10/2022 08:46

Can you imagine being homeless? You get bought food/drink that others deem "suitable".

The self righteous, I didn't buy him alcohol and. I didn't buy him coke, I get him a sandwich and water, aren't I great. I'm sure he'll stop being alcohol dependent now I've done that.

My DS works with the homeless and he says that is one thing that gets him, people giving food rather than cash and letting them decide what they want to buy that night.

No it may not be what you "want" them to have but if 10 cigarettes and a can of JD and coke do it, then great.

Because people are homeless, we mustn't take all autonomy away from them.

It's cold out there, we're all concerned about staying warm indoors currently, Imagine how they feel?

limitedperiodonly · 11/10/2022 08:43

if she has some deep held personal conviction that none of her money is used to provide alcohol or something then of course that's her prerogative. And if she just didn't want to do it and was slightly uncomfortable that he'd asked...whatever. But they've made a post saying she's 'gobsmacked' and calling the guy a cheeky fuck, saying how she might never help anyone again, because he had the temerity to ask for something he wanted?

@MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds there's a lot of drama over an everyday incident where most of us would say: "Sorry, no."

butterfliedtwo · 11/10/2022 08:39

Glitterspy · 11/10/2022 08:35

You weren’t unreasonable not to go to the cash point given the theft concern.

You we’re very unreasonable to judge his request and then post on here that you were gobsmacked by the cheek of him. I suppose you’d have been more comfortable if he’d asked for a dry crust of bread or some gruel, which is all you seem to think he would be entitled to as a homeless person.

Exactly this.

YABU and should count yourself lucky that you have the headspace for this to be gobsmacking.

Did you hope we would all say how awful he is?

Glitterspy · 11/10/2022 08:35

You weren’t unreasonable not to go to the cash point given the theft concern.

You we’re very unreasonable to judge his request and then post on here that you were gobsmacked by the cheek of him. I suppose you’d have been more comfortable if he’d asked for a dry crust of bread or some gruel, which is all you seem to think he would be entitled to as a homeless person.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 08:34

SleeplessInEngland · 11/10/2022 07:56

Nothing puritanical about saying alcohol has an escapist quality. If it didn’t hardly any of us would drink it. I know it’s not what I’d want if I had another night without a roof.

But that's not what I said. I said a can of JD and coke isn't escapism from the streets.
For what it's worth I don't drink, and yes of course alcohol offers escapism for some, but that's the problem here isn't it...a homeless guy asked for a can of JD and coke and it's ended up in a discussion about the evils of alcohol as a substance.
Other members of the public's drinking/shopping habits don't prompt this kind of talk. Think about how many people buy alcohol from Tesco in a day and how little thought is given to that.
The difference in OP situation is of course it's her money, and if she has some deep held personal conviction that none of her money is used to provide alcohol or something then of course that's her prerogative. And if she just didn't want to do it and was slightly uncomfortable that he'd asked...whatever. But they've made a post saying she's 'gobsmacked' and calling the guy a cheeky fuck, saying how she might never help anyone again, because he had the temerity to ask for something he wanted?
I'm genuinely taken aback by that. A request from a homeless guy for - a JD and coke and a scratchcard. I don't see anything awful about that 🤷‍♀️

LumpyandBumps · 11/10/2022 08:25

This thread is quite interesting in terms of voting.
Most comments indicate that OP is being unreasonable, whereas the poll shows a silent majority of voters think she is not unreasonable.
(28/72 at present)

Begoniasforever · 11/10/2022 08:17

Lovemusic33 · 11/10/2022 08:06

MN has gone crazy lately, people just seem to want to disagree with every OP written.

OP, he was a CF, he shouldn’t have pushed you to buy him things or give him cash, he made you feel uncomfortable and he knew this. Yes he’s homeless and desperate but that’s no excuse to make a women feel uncomfortable. I would have have told him to wait where he was and I would have bought him a sandwich and a drink and brought it out to him, I wouldn’t feel comfortable with someone following me into a supermarket and demanding items such as alcohol and scratch cards. It’s your money and your choice what you buy or don’t buy for him.

😱

limitedperiodonly · 11/10/2022 08:07

@Vodkaany1 meeting a man begging by a cashpoint outside a supermarket is a completely unremarkable encounter. Most of us do that at least once a day. You agreed to buy him a sandwich and were gobsmacked that he asked you for more. If you really were you shouldn't be allowed out on your own.

Lovemusic33 · 11/10/2022 08:06

MN has gone crazy lately, people just seem to want to disagree with every OP written.

OP, he was a CF, he shouldn’t have pushed you to buy him things or give him cash, he made you feel uncomfortable and he knew this. Yes he’s homeless and desperate but that’s no excuse to make a women feel uncomfortable. I would have have told him to wait where he was and I would have bought him a sandwich and a drink and brought it out to him, I wouldn’t feel comfortable with someone following me into a supermarket and demanding items such as alcohol and scratch cards. It’s your money and your choice what you buy or don’t buy for him.

IDontLikeMondays88 · 11/10/2022 08:05

Only on mumsnet would this be ok 😂

Begoniasforever · 11/10/2022 08:04

I can’t imagine making this kind of moralistic judgement. If I’d agreed to buy him something to eat and a drink then I’d not be moralistic if it was coke or jd and coke. People who live on the streets do so for many reasons and not one of them is good,

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 11/10/2022 08:04

@sst1234

Oh give over yourself. I hardly ever rise to stuff on this site but this is crazy! It's not peformative to be genuinely gobsmacked that someone would make a post about how a homeless man asking for a scratchcard is a cheeky fuck and she will never help anyone again!