Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH says I have the wrong personality to have DC

220 replies

Alphabey · 10/10/2022 15:12

DH and I have been together for many years and we had previously both agreed that we didn’t want any children. Since I’ve turned 30, all of that seems to have changed and I’ve been constantly feeling broody and longing for a child. It’s a sort of maternal ache I’ve never felt before.

When raising it with DH he was quite shocked and certainly didn’t seem keen. Ultimately he says he could be persuaded (financially we are in a great position to have a family) but his main concern is my personality, as to whether I’d cope with a baby and whether I’d regret the decision down the line.

I’m the first to admit that I’m naturally a worrier and over-thinker, whereas DH is very calm and chilled. If anything I’m highly strung. I do tend to be stressed easily and I don’t deal particularly well with challenges and stressful events. I also grew up as an only child and I’m still a bit selfish. AIBU in thinking I’d cope?

OP posts:
gannett · 10/10/2022 17:20

I don't think "you have the wrong personality to have children" is an insult, or cruel, or mean. I would say that about myself. DP would definitely say it about me. It's factually correct. That's why we're child-free.

From what I've observed in friends who've had children there's surprisingly little correlation between their personalities pre-kids and how easily they took to parenting. Some of the most highly-strung, chaotic ones have really chilled out as parents. And actually some of the ones who were always good with children and obviously always wanted them have struggled more.

upsiedaisy49593 · 10/10/2022 17:16

Your personality sounds just like mine. I worried about this before having my daughter and can say with confidence that she has changed me to become a lot more relaxed, which is absolutely a game changer because it dawned on me that there are simply situations where I have to let things be .

High5InALowRide · 10/10/2022 17:15

I'm a stressy worrier and having kids has made it worse. Even my laid back DH is now a shouter. It's not for everyone and my kids definitely replicate that behaviour so go into it with your eyes open! Ours was an accident and I'm an only child so I wanted to have a second. Hate having to put others first all the time so tbh it's a real struggle.

RedToothBrush · 10/10/2022 17:13

Angelinflipflops · 10/10/2022 15:17

Having a kid may be just the thing you need

This.

Whether its what you DH wants is another issue.

FWIW DH and I were/are exactly the same.

DS is awesome.

ffsnotagainandagain · 10/10/2022 17:13

Well he knows you better than us! I have met people who have had kids and said themselves they don't have that maternal instinct and it completely shows. Lack of awareness, compassion, selfishness. Obviously may not be you but broodiness effects us all from time to time but doesn't mean we have to act on it.

mydogisthebest · 10/10/2022 17:13

Not sure how anyone can have children and not get stressed and worried especially today with all the world problems.

Your husband knows you, none of us do, so you should listen to him.

Also if you have both always said you don't want children it's not very fair to change your mind now

Phoenixesrise · 10/10/2022 17:12

It seems like your husband isn't ready for having additional responsibility. Every parent worries about their child and that is the part and parcel of it all.

Can you get into some counseling for this, may be a few sessions as a couple? There things work best when an impartial person calls you out. I think he needs to hear this from someone (not you sorry) to me it seems more like a husband issue rather than your worries.

catandcoffee · 10/10/2022 17:12

How much time have you spent around babies, toddlers and teenagers ?

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 10/10/2022 17:12

wanker.

of course he's entitled to say he still doesn't want kids.

what he's NOT entitled to do is try to make you feel shit about being you

OR to say 'he could be persuaded! He's a) asking you to change/to
prove to him you'd be a good mum-fuck that, you're not auditioning!! And B) he's preparing his 'get out' clause 'YOU wanted a baby YOU do xyz & abc & def&ghi......

he'll take the fun bits & 'make'
YOU do everything he doesn't fancy doing because YOU wanted a baby, he never did and only went along with it to keep you happy

fuck that shit. Separate & meet someone who wants a family with you

BadNomad · 10/10/2022 17:11

Does he have a point? Are you likely to regret it? As soon as you have a child, your life is no longer your own. You have to put the child at the centre and every decision you make has to consider them first. Having children is not something you can "try" and if it doesn't work out "no harm done". A lot of harm is done if it's the wrong decision.

JaninaDuszejko · 10/10/2022 17:10

I think it's a really mean thing for your DH to say. They say it takes a village to raise a child, that's because none of us have all the skills required to parent every age effectively. We need the help of our partners and parents and siblings and cousins and friends and childcare professions and teachers and doctors and nurses and TV presentors and actors and volunteers at all the various clubs our children will do etc etc to effectively raise our children. So if you get anxious and worry a bit and he's laid back then I bet he'll be the one who loses your children at a fair and you'll be the one who finds them. You will complement each other.

But I'd be more concerned about him saying something so mean and unnecessary. If he doesn't want to have kids he needs to own that and not make it your fault .

whumpthereitis · 10/10/2022 17:10

he may very well think a child wouldn’t fit easily into your family.

not least because it seems apparent that he doesn’t want one. Sadly, you’re no longer on the same page as one another. He doesn’t want a child, he would only consider having one to keep you. That isn’t a good thing for any of you.

You have a decision to make as to what you want more.

AuntSalli · 10/10/2022 17:09

One of my DC should never have children based on her personality it would be an absolute disaster. She wouldn’t enjoy it. the child wouldn’t enjoy it. I hope we never get to test the theory

Folklore9074 · 10/10/2022 17:09

No one here can tell you if you have the right personality and there is no way of knowing until you have the baby. Having a child is a gamble, you either go for it knowing the risks/benefits or you don’t.

AnApparitionQuipped · 10/10/2022 17:07

When raising it with DH he was quite shocked and certainly didn’t seem keen. Ultimately he says he could be persuaded

It seems to be your DH who has the wrong personality for having children. If he has to be 'persuaded' it's not a good idea.

You got together on the basis you wouldn't be having children, it isn't fair to try to pressure him into having them against his judgement.

Bumpsadaisie · 10/10/2022 17:06

Hmm.

Having a child can stir up and bring out all sorts of things that you didn't know you had/were/felt.

Your DH might feel chilled and relaxed. In a way it is quite easy to be chilled and relaxed when one is only responsible for oneself! He could find the responsibility, stress and burden of fatherhood a real shock.

Likewise, it could turn out you could take to motherhood like a duck to water.

I do know many people who were rather surprised at the kind of parents they became. A relative who was/is extremely creative and artistic went full Gina Ford with her two. And the opposite way around.

FabFitFifties · 10/10/2022 17:04

I could not have a child with someone who said that to me. You want a child - he doesn't. He also seems to have a pretty low opinion of your personalty - either that, or he's cruel enough to say these things, just to put you off.

BretonBlue · 10/10/2022 17:04

I don’t think this has anything to do with your personality. He doesn’t want children and he thought you were both on the same page about this. You’re just as entitled to change your mind as he is entitled not to. You have some big decisions to make about the future of your relationship.

alwaysscared · 10/10/2022 17:04

My husband said this to me only the other day. Problem is, our DS is 9! He has ASC and I am his full time carer as he currently can't attend school. I am not great at this as I, like you, are a constant worrier. I will say that my mental health problems have got so much worse since having DS and I have developed treatment resistant OCD since having him. Think long and hard before making a decision

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 17:03

Aquamarine1029 · 10/10/2022 16:41

Doesn't want to admit it? He already has! They agreed years ago to not have children.

This - and not wanting children isn’t a character flaw.

Piffle11 · 10/10/2022 17:02

You and your DH sounds very much like me and my DH. I am a highly stressed and anxious person, he is very chilled. I was hoping that his great qualities would cancel out mine… Unfortunately, that's not how it works! We have two children: one has low functioning autism, non-verbal and very much stressful to deal with, and the other one it's just like me: anxious, worries about everything. I always found it difficult in social situations, and obviously once you have children, this increases. Play dates, school events,… I have found it incredibly difficult. I absolutely adore my children and they are the loves of my life, but my life has become increasingly difficult since becoming a mother. The thing with having children is you never know what you are getting.

Fedupwithmondays · 10/10/2022 16:59

I could of wrote this post OP. I was the same as you before I had my 3 DC's. I am a worrier and over thinker but my DH is very laid back/chilled. We work very well together.
I had my DD when I was 35, followed by two more DC's and I love every minute of being a mum. I am now 50 and a completely different person to who I was. They are my world and I hope you have your DC in the future.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 10/10/2022 16:58

I'm torn because it might make you less like that or it might make you more like that.

My son is autistic it's absolutely exhausting and relentless and I have to be hugely selfless and cope with very high stress (him running in road, eating stones, hitting me). If you had a child like this you would really struggle and that's the truth...

PyongyangKipperbang · 10/10/2022 16:58

Well I would say that you have a huge positive personality trait....you are self aware.

Many people are not and blithely gloss over (or simply do not/will not see) their own imperfections. Being aware of negatives in ones emotional make up is a great gift to have.

You can look at those issues and see how to overcome or minimise them and their effects.

My biggest concern is that your DH says he could be persuaded, while at the same time trying to convince you that you would be a shit mother......this doesnt bode well. A child needs parents who actively want and embrace parenthood, one parent who does that alone is far better than a couple where only one is fully committed and frankly most marriages dont survive the "I will let you have a kid but......" arrangement that this sounds like it would end up being.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/10/2022 16:55

I'd assume I'd got the wrong husband, not the wrong personality.

So you over think a bit and worry more than him. You're hardly pulling the legs off spiders for kicks.

No one really knows what kind of parent they'll be until they are one. You certainly don't have to be perfect like your husband believes he is, you just have to be open to change.