Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer

259 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

OP posts:
chilliesandspices · 10/10/2022 16:25

Maybe respond with "I'm sorry but I can barely afford to pay my bills right now".

Ponderingwindow · 10/10/2022 16:25

I pulled up to go into a shop that had some standing outside the other day. Where this was located, they could only be there with store permission. I just turned my car back on and left. I just didn’t feel like dealing with them even though my standard policy is to just ignore the hired ones. I will be polite to real volunteers, but more often these days you can tell these are just people hired to stump up donations. Either way, I don’t donate in the street. It’s a poor way of making charitable giving decisions . At most I will take the name of the charity and do more research.

TheFrustratedRedhead · 10/10/2022 16:21

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 16:20

This organisation has teenage kids out on the streets doing it, the vast vast majority will still be living with their parents / guardians.

Then it’s the organisation you should be angry with, the ‘teenage kids’ are victims as much as anybody else…

KimberleyClark · 10/10/2022 16:21

If one knocks on my door I I tell them I already donate to whatever charity it is.

My small local Co op used to let chuggers stand just inside the door. It was so intimidating because there was no way to avoid them.

Magenta82 · 10/10/2022 16:21

TheFrustratedRedhead · 10/10/2022 16:18

You lot are aware that these are actual human beings you are talking about? They wouldn’t be doing it for the fun of it, they just have bills to pay and mouths to feed like the rest of us. Some of you sound really self righteous and not very nice!

They have a choice, anyone with enough confidence to stop strangers on the street and try to get them to sign up to charity donations will be capable of getting a different job.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 10/10/2022 16:21

A young bloke came to my door and asked me if I had heard of Marie Cure, I said yes thanks and shut the door. He rang again and when I answered he said I was very rude. I said that's right, off you fuck and he did.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/10/2022 16:21

If i get sucked in then I apologise and say "so sorry for wasting your time but that I already give £x to that charity every month and I really can't afford to increase it' they seem to find it hard to argue through that.

Why ever would you apologise?! If anything, I'd claim I was upset that my regular giving wasn't appreciated, so I might as well cancel it altogether - and ask for their full name, so that I could tell the charity which of 'their' people's actions had led me to cancel. Whether you do then cancel or not is up to you, of course.

We were told in training that asking 3 times has been shown to get the most donations.

That is appalling - it sounds like a scammer's tactic rather than that of a supposedly-reputable charity. Criminals have probably also discovered the ways to get the most money in - raise your voice, target lone women and the elderly, threaten that you have a weapon etc. Just because something might happen to work in no way means that it's remotely acceptable.

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 16:20

TheFrustratedRedhead · 10/10/2022 16:18

You lot are aware that these are actual human beings you are talking about? They wouldn’t be doing it for the fun of it, they just have bills to pay and mouths to feed like the rest of us. Some of you sound really self righteous and not very nice!

This organisation has teenage kids out on the streets doing it, the vast vast majority will still be living with their parents / guardians.

OP posts:
whatkatydid2013 · 10/10/2022 16:19

I (often truthfully as it happens) say “it sounds like a great charity I’ll ask if my work would consider adding them to their list of causes. I never gift anything outside my work scheme as they match my donations”. A couple of times people have persisted but if they do I figure I’m fine to be a bit rude as they clearly aren’t fussed about the charity

TheFrustratedRedhead · 10/10/2022 16:18

You lot are aware that these are actual human beings you are talking about? They wouldn’t be doing it for the fun of it, they just have bills to pay and mouths to feed like the rest of us. Some of you sound really self righteous and not very nice!

RaRaRaspoutine · 10/10/2022 16:17

Ooooof chuggers make my blood boil. When I was a student, a much larger male chugger walked alongside me for a bit after I said no thanks, I don't have time, I'm going for the bus - then waved his hand in front of my face going "Hellooooooooo!". I nearly had a panic attack right there.

89redballoons · 10/10/2022 16:15

Many years ago, as a student I got a holiday job working in a call centre doing charity fundraising. I only lasted a few weeks. We were calling on behalf of various national charities, we weren't paid commission but if we didn't hit our targets in terms of number of people called and number of donations received we'd be let go.

We had a very rigid script that we had to stick to and a key part of that was making sure we asked for donations three times every call - first a monthly donation, then a lower or less frequent regular donation and then a one-off donation. We were told in training that asking 3 times has been shown to get the most donations.

I'm sure that's true, I'm also sure it pisses a lot of people off and intimidates others and I'm not sure how much good it does the charities' reputations in the long term. That said this was more than 15 years ago and the fundraising agencies are obviously still taking the same approach.

Rowthe · 10/10/2022 16:14

Also I'm sure the rules changed.

I thought they weren't allowed to approach people any more, or chase them down the road?

Scarecrowrowboat · 10/10/2022 16:11

If i get sucked in then I apologise and say "so sorry for wasting your time but that I already give £x to that charity every month and I really can't afford to increase it' they seem to find it hard to argue through that.

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 16:09

It worked yes because I felt intimidated.

It should be illegal to bully/harass somebody into giving you money. There are people more vulnerable than me that may well have paid the £25 and not just the £5 for the magazine. Its wrong.

OP posts:
Rowthe · 10/10/2022 16:09

JoBrodie · 10/10/2022 15:28

Was it "Inside Success"? They're not a charity but are a social enterprise / CIC that raises awareness and funds for people affected by knife crime. I've seen lots of very positive tweets about them and also lots of very negative ones. They are now on my radar as a thing to learn more about.

I think they might be subject to different fundraising rules from those that govern 'chuggers' (charity 'muggers'). Maybe worth letting the council know if their staff are intimidating people though.

While a firm 'no' and keeping walking should lose them it's not always that easy. As others suggest it can be useful to have a few prepared polite-but-firm phrases / objections to hand: - that you don't do direct debit, that you'd need to do your due diligence on the breakdown of how they use their funds, that you're recovering from an illness and want to keep moving, that your hearing / tinnitus [etc] is really bad at the moment, that you'd need to check with partner / parents / sibling / financial advisor before considering making any payments, that you're late for a train or meeting, you have no wish to have a conversation now etc etc.

Personally I quite like "I'm not at liberty to discuss the matter" ;)

Did you pay with cash or card for the magazine?

Jo

The best is not slowing down at all.
" No thanks".

And just keep on walking.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/10/2022 16:08

I do agree, though, that - like badly behaved children who are routinely ignored by their parents - they see any attention as positive.

They know you aren't going to welcome them, or leave them with a warm glow in your heart because of how much they're brightened up their day, so they probably see that they've got nothing to lose: annoy you and get nothing or annoy you until you buy a magazine off them, to get rid of them. Like wasps at a picnic once they smell your delicious sweet lemonade.

Ellyfinsmum · 10/10/2022 16:07

I had one the other day just as I was getting home from the school run, trying to get my 5 year old and toddler in the house, lugging the pram up 3 steps to get into the house containing a red faced angry screaming baby who needed feeding. He saw all of this and still decided now might be a good time to give me his whole charity spiel. When I said now is not a good time sorry he said ‘oh don’t you care about children then?!’ Um think I need to look after my actual children instead of standing here listening to you. It makes me so mad that they often try to make you feel guilty for not donating to them when they probably don’t even care about the charity themselves.

Purplecatshopaholic · 10/10/2022 16:07

Well her tactic worked as you bought something! Just keep walking next time!

ofwarren · 10/10/2022 16:06

cooliebrown · 10/10/2022 15:47

Chuggers get you in the street; the ones that come to your house are churglars

Churglers!!
I'm going to use that from now on

Noviembre · 10/10/2022 16:05

Don't even look at them. If they speak, hold up a hand and keep going. Not difficult. They prey on politeness.

Rowthe · 10/10/2022 16:04

It still worked though didnt it?

You paid her.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/10/2022 16:02

Also when they are stationed in shops/ petrol stations that you want to use so you have to get by them.

It baffles me as to why shops agree to this. I don't know if they think it makes them look kind and community-minded, or if they just get browbeaten by the charities refusing to take No for an answer. I don't mind somebody standing to the side, waiting to be approached by interested people; but that's never how it happens. Somebody will rattle a tin under your nose and say something like "Help children with cancer?" and know that most people will feel to ashamed to ignore them.

Our local Co-op used to have a different charity every week - sometimes they would approach me whilst I was clearly actively shopping (looking at goods and comparing prices). It really put me off using that shop and I would often go elsewhere in preference.

I also hate it when you get local groups - Guides, Scouts or whatever - who immediately start packing your bags without asking, clearly for a donation. I'm fussy about how I pack and I don't want a child throwing tins on top of eggs or salad. I don't object to supporting them with a quid (still feels a bit pressured, though), but I'll pack my own shopping, thanks!

Best suggestion I can think of, once they've deliberately ignored your declension, is to sing 2 Unlimited at them loudly, without stopping. "No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no thank you!" That song is irritating enough just as a song, so hopefully they'll get the message. If not, ramp up the volume with a "Techno, techno, techno nonsense!" If nothing else, they'll assume you're crazy and steer well clear Grin

Somebody should develop a simple website - something like CharityCollectorDueDilligenceCheck.com - with questions that you can require them to complete before you will look at their form:
What is the charity number?
How long have they been working for the charity?
How much do they personally give to the charity each month?
What first attracted them to the charity and its causes?
Can you guarantee that any money I give/agree to give today will be handed straight to the charity, without any commission?
If no, and they are expecting to take commission, why wouldn't I be better giving directly to the charity, so that they get all of it directly?
Note: I will not accept 'we take our commission out of the gift aid, so all of your giving goes straight to the charity' - as that gift aid is also my taxes that I can choose to reallocate to the charity on top of my giving, so that they get the maximum amount.

If they won't fill in your form, how could they possibly expect you to fill in theirs? Get THEM having to keep saying No (or just go away, preferably).

Oliverfunyuns · 10/10/2022 15:58

And yet (some) people on MN mock anyone who refuses to answer the door to people they don't know/haven't invited/aren't clearly there for a legitimate business purpose.

Out on the street, it's more difficult, but at least then you can keep walking and get away from them that way! People aggressively trying to part me from my hard-earned money anger me, which makes it easier to not give a crap if I'm rude for ignoring them, or saying "Not today!" and leaving it at that.

daffodilandtulip · 10/10/2022 15:56

I hate them. They are relentless and aggressive.

Don't go to town much anymore though but I feel the ones knocking on doors have subsequently increased. I said no thank you, and closed the door straightaway the other day - he shouted through my window "how rude"!