Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer

259 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

OP posts:
Lockheart · 11/10/2022 14:27

I often have to walk along high Holborn in London and there are always some on there during rush hour, so high foot traffic. I get it, but there are a few who will wave and stand in front of you to try and block your path. By all means fundraise, but don't try to physically stop people in the street.

AnchorWHAT · 11/10/2022 14:20

PlumPudd · 10/10/2022 17:32

@RedToothBrush i didn’t say it was an excuse. Just that a) it works b) follow up studies have shown that the people it works on are usually happy they were approached and c) studies have also shown that if charities don’t make some sort of direct “ask” people don’t give, despite people also wanting charities to continue their work.

I think Water Aid did something along the lines of what you’re suggesting (got creative and tried a new approach) a few years ago. Instead of filming ads that showed the terrible consequences of people not having water (flies in eyes, poorly kids etc.) they shot one that showed a village after a well had been installed, and how happy and positive everyone was, farms thriving, kids no longer having to miss school to fetch water etc. People who were shown the advert loved it, and most said this was the sort of communication they wanted to see from charities and that it would motivate them to donate. But when it was rolled out people donated much less because they felt there was less need. It was quite a costly experiment and if charities spend money trying new approaches and training staff differently, they do have less money to go to the cause. So most will do what is proven to work. Not least because they are obligated to ensure that a certain percentage of their money goes to the causes and can only spend so much on staff, trying new approaches, admin etc.

Not saying any of this is good or okay, just explaining the reality of what happens.

Out of interest @RedToothBrush what kind of approach or campaign do you think would get you to donate that is different to a direct ask for funds?

I liked the one water aid did in pubs where they had something set up on the bar to balance a pound on a lemon or some such fun, loads of people after a beer got all competitive so imagine many pounds were donated for the fun of it.

dontyouwishyourgirlfriendwas · 11/10/2022 14:12

I’ve also had horrendous problems with Inside Success. As a pp said, my heart sinks when I see them in their blue jackets. Every tube station I ever go to be it Brixton, Oxford Circus, Goodge Street, Waterloo etc, I get harassed by them.

One time I really shouted at them because they wouldn’t leave me alone and they were being so intimidating (and it was the third separate time that day they’d spoken to me). I’m in my early 20s but I look very young so they see me as an ‘easy target’. I’m also a slow walker which means the always ‘get me’. Funnily enough I never get harassed when I’m with my male partner / father. And they don’t really get it on their own either. I wonder why that might be….

I would NEVER EVER donate to them. I only really tend to donate to homeless charities, women and children’s charities and food banks. You should definitely complain though if you feel like it because hopefully if more people complain they’ll actually do something about it.

TigerRag · 11/10/2022 13:38

We got a new front door and didn't get the no cold callers sign. Strangely, we've have less (or none that I know - my intercom is switched off unless I know someone will be calling) or no charity callers.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 11/10/2022 12:36

WatchoRulo · 11/10/2022 11:18

Chuggers will get a mandatory life sentence when I come to power.

It'll be hanging, drawing, quartering and an extra hanging to make sure they've learned their lesson when I'm running things!

In the meantime, a brisk "Fuck OFF" works wonders. Sometimes I've had them get shirty and say something like "Oh, don't you care about SICK CHILDREN then?" to which I have replied that no, actually, I don't, in the same way that I don't appreciate being harassed in the street by a cagoule full of idiot.

bellinisurge · 11/10/2022 11:44

No thank you is my first answer. Fuck off is my second. Unless there are kids around, in which case it's a firm No.

potniatheron · 11/10/2022 11:24

Methods I have used to make an aggressive chugger back off (all tried, tested and effective):

  • Get close up into their personal space and pull the weiredest / funniest face you can
  • Wheel round, clasp your hands over your head and hiss in a stage whisper: "DO YOU HEAR THEM"
  • Smile nicely and say "I'm sorry, I'm having the worst ever day, I really need to sort this out" and continue running past
  • Trot past and conspiratorially say "I'm in a rush, I really need a wee!"

These all work without having to be rude or snotty to the chugger.

WatchoRulo · 11/10/2022 11:18

Chuggers will get a mandatory life sentence when I come to power.

ChilliBandit · 11/10/2022 11:08

reigatecastle · 11/10/2022 10:48

I do my best to avoid eye contact. The other day they were hanging around outside my local Sainsburys, along with the local fake Big Issue seller (he's not homeless (and yes, I know that for a fact - it's well known locally and he gets moved on) and he uses fake Big Issue ID). It's so annoying trying to avoid the gauntlet of people demanding money.

They sometimes do follow you by the way!

I know someone who would ignore the no cold callers signs at the door sadly they don't apply to charity callers.

The fundraising regulator says no cold calling signs do include charities so they should take note of them. I have a sign saying we do not buy or sell at this door, this includes charities and religion. Miserable yes, but I don’t care. Some still ignore it and get directed to the sign as I close the door.

I seek out charities I want to support, they are mainly local and do great work. That’s what is needed to win me over, not a 20 something with a clipboard who probably has no idea about the work of the charity they are collecting for.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/10/2022 10:58

I just say no thanks and walk on, ignoring any follow up.

First one was ages ago in central London - a charity for the blind. I did sign up for a small monthly sum, but said I was not going to state my age (irrelevant and none of their business) or my phone number (unnecessary and I didn’t want them ringing me or passing it on.)

Some days later I had a letter from the charity, saying that they were ‘unable’ to process my ‘application’ without these two pieces of information!

Talk about CFery! The letter went in the bin, but needless to say, the money started coming out of my account anyway.

reigatecastle · 11/10/2022 10:52

very few people would proactively go out and find out about charities and make donations without a prompt or an ask

no but you find out in other ways, whether it be people asking for sponsorship, leaflets through the door, TV ads (that you can turn off or walk out the room from), social media posts etc. All of which are far less intrusive or abusive.

reigatecastle · 11/10/2022 10:51

They've gone downhill ever since, ironically - letting at least 2 of their properties (Clandon House was one) burn down through lack of precautions. I wonder if any heads rolled over that

to be fair I think that was probably the fault of the contractors they were using to do the work. It happened at the Glasgow School of Art twice as well. Builders seem to be very careless, that's not the charity's fault.

j712adrian · 11/10/2022 10:51

Yes, and GTFO would be my second answer. As preparation I also completely avoid and blank them.

reigatecastle · 11/10/2022 10:49

She looked at me with a smirk and said you obviously don’t care about sick kids

I'd just reply "not if they're not my own, no". Let them judge. Silly woman.

reigatecastle · 11/10/2022 10:48

I do my best to avoid eye contact. The other day they were hanging around outside my local Sainsburys, along with the local fake Big Issue seller (he's not homeless (and yes, I know that for a fact - it's well known locally and he gets moved on) and he uses fake Big Issue ID). It's so annoying trying to avoid the gauntlet of people demanding money.

They sometimes do follow you by the way!

I know someone who would ignore the no cold callers signs at the door sadly they don't apply to charity callers.

ChilliBandit · 11/10/2022 10:44

I hate them and think they should be banned. As others have said they are working for companies hired by the charity. It’s a very lucrative way for charities to fundraise but many charities take pride in not using this method.

I only had one approach me as I was in tears rushing to get to my car and get home. She wouldn’t let up and in the end I snapped “No, leave me alone!” She looked at me with a smirk and said you obviously don’t care about sick kids. I complained to the charity and got a letter back outlining that it was a very effective way for them to get donations and they wouldn’t stop. It was a Christian charity too 🙄.

I have also had them try and talk to me through my child “Mummy looks like a kind person doesn’t she?” I just reply along the lines of “looks can be deceiving” and walk off quickly. We often call going to town running the gauntlet of chuggers.

Luxurysleuth007 · 11/10/2022 10:36

They’re a menace. I don’t even reply anymore. With their pamphlets, logo’s waterproofs and freakish passive aggressive zesty nature - piss off.

Dotjones · 11/10/2022 10:16

I've found the key is to not stop walking. The OP's case of them following her to continue to harrassment is unusual in my experience. They have a specific place they're meant to be most of the time (usually coordinated with another charity mugger on the other side of the road).

If they try to engage me, I usually pick one of the following:
"Stop raping me!" (loudly, gets everyone looking and freaks them out)
"Sorry, I don't speak English" (usually leaves them confused, they're not the brightest people else they wouldn't be doing this "job")
"Fuck off you ugly/stupid/hideous cunt" (ideally make the insult more personal about something unique to them, their hair or their teeth for instance, something that they will remember - you have to get quite harsh with them because they have very thick skins.)

The important thing is to remember they don't deserve any respect. They're scum, trying to harass/intimidate/guilt-trip you into giving money, regardless of whether you can afford it. If they actually cared about the charity they'd be raising money for free - better still, working a proper job and donating their wages to the cause.

In the event that you do care about their charity, you still shouldn't give the charity mugger your money because most of it will go in commission to them and admin fees to their employer. Generally the charity will receive about 10% of what the chugger raises, sometimes less.

It's also worth noting that many chuggers are not representing a charity at all, with the whole thing being a scam. This is especially the case with ones who accept cash, but even ones who try to set up a DD or bank payment are also often out to scam you. Never was the phrase "charity begins at home" more true.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 11/10/2022 10:13

I agree. They're a nuisance. I know they are only doing a job blah blah blah, and I guess if someone has hit rock bottom that badly that they need to take a shitty job like this, you should probably not be nasty to them, but I have to say I do ignore them now.

I don't owe them anything, and I will NOT be intimidated into signing up for a charity, and giving my bloody bank details to a stranger in the street. When I am with DD, we get young men trailing after us, saying (to DD) 'hey luv, is that yer sister?' and 'hey gorgeous ladieeees.' I just think 'oh do fuck off.' Hmm

Sorry you felt intimidated by them @Parkingmoan1 Just try ignoring them next time.

NorthernSoul55 · 11/10/2022 10:04

If chuggers persist after a firm 'No thanks', I either offer cash (they can't take it, what a shame) or ask for their bank details for 'my' charity, same at the door . Sky, Virgin, AA etc who accost me in shopping centres are told I'm already a customer. Usually works.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 11/10/2022 09:53

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

@Parkingmoan1 "As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking."

There's your big mistake.

Mumoblue · 11/10/2022 09:47

Yeah, I have pretty severe social anxiety and it’s like these people KNOW. I always get targeted by people looking for money, which I don’t even have.

Where I used to work there used to be at least 3 people asking for money for this or that between me and the bus stop. Some days I just couldn’t face it and had to call my partner so I’d be on the phone while walking past them.
I’ve since had therapy and am better at saying no now but it’s still never nice.

Sunnysideup999 · 11/10/2022 09:42

Airpods are your friend here

CulturePigeon · 11/10/2022 09:27

Yes, they are often very aggressive. I feel sorry for charities - I used to do collections, in the days of people having cash, but I didn't even shake my tin. However deserving the cause, giving should be totally voluntary and not pressured.

I give to certain charities which I think are effective and use their funds wisely. I'm afraid I'm pretty cynical about some of the big ones though. They pay their CEOs etc huge amounts and often spend a big percentage of your pound on things most of us wouldn't be happy with. I was not impressed when the National Trust spent millions on a huge new HQ in Swindon. They've gone downhill ever since, ironically - letting at least 2 of their properties (Clandon House was one) burn down through lack of precautions. I wonder if any heads rolled over that?

I'm also influenced by how helpful these charities (which spend a lot on advertising and promotion) have been when I've actually gone to them. Sorry, but Age UK and RSPCA were totally hopeless at the point of use, so I'm reluctant to give to them. All about giving you leaflets but could I get any practical advice (that was all I wanted!) from Age UK - not a chance.

Mintyt · 11/10/2022 09:19

They should take no, and you should have carried on, on your way. I believe they can only take 1 step - I understand why you gave in but that's why they carry on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread