Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer

259 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

OP posts:
DelurkingLawyer · 12/10/2022 12:48

As to the question about accepting the offer - it is a matter for the executors who they sell to provided they act in accordance w their duties as executors to maximise the estate - that isn’t purely a matter of selling to the apparent “highest bidder” as your example shows. You can in principle sue the executors as a beneficiary but I think in that scenario it would be hopeless. The more common scenario is a sale at an undervalue to someone who turns out to be a relative of the executor!

DelurkingLawyer · 12/10/2022 12:43

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:23

It just sounds worse and worse!

I suppose, being fair about it, if they have been left a bequest in a will, then it prevents them from being denied it if the executor should just try to pocket it themselves or delay passing it on for years - so I can sort of see why such a service would have a place.

I think the main thing would be how they use that information - do they mark it on a 'future income' balance sheet and wait patiently for a reasonable amount of time until everything has gone through and the executors can pass it on to them; or do they pounce on it and immediately start harassing the executors - who are likely also grieving family members - with their hands out?

Yes this is the situation that my posts re my MIL are about.

They didn’t necessarily know she had made a bequest during her life. But once probate was granted their enquiry agents found out and they harassed constantly to get the cash. There was no house to sell because FIL was alive so it was a case of transferring her ISA to him and getting the cash out. And of course it was some time after she’d died as a grant of probate takes a while.

You are also bang on about not giving them a % of anything. Say you leave them 50% of your house and your kids 50%. They will claim that a house worth £500k is worth £600k. If the property is sold they get their half whatever it is, but if the family wants to keep the house so there is no actual sale price to go on, the charity will push and push to get bought out at “half” that’s far too high. Rather than take it to court many families will pay the £50k.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/10/2022 12:41

When I reluctantly agreed to buy the magazine she then tried to strong arm me into buying two for £10

Of course she did - and if you'd been foolish enough to sign their direct debit you'd have been hounded with calls for an increase

If it's not your charity of choice, the only thing really is to go on saying no, and if they still persist to ask them calmly to stop harassing you

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:58

In my experience (former auditor) they don’t wait around. They have teams that deal with this and they are relentless. It’s not marked as future income as they technically become entitled on the person’s death. It’s a debtor from the minute they find out an approximate amount.

But, whether they like it or not, if you've been left X% of the proceeds of the sale of a house, the house has to actually be sold before the proceeds come through - and house sales can take a considerable time from marketing to completion.

I totally get them wanting to be kept in the loop and updated along the line, but how can it be considered reasonable to start harassing grieving relatives to rush everything through, just so that they can get their money ASAP?

Do they also have a say as to which buyer's offer is accepted? Say you have an offer of £300,000 from somebody who seems like a shifty chancer with no realistic means of ever being able to pay that much, and an offer of £290,000 from a genuine proceedable buyer with all the documents and loan agreements ready and all stacking up - would the charity be able to insist that you waste your time by going with the cowboy, before they inevitably delay forever and then expect to beat you right down - all because they (theoretically) would stand to get an extra £100 (based on 1%), against all the (very obvious) odds?

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 11:56

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:45

Not that it makes it any better but I assume the value of 10 months of direct debit is what the company is paid per “victim” so the charity wouldn’t disclose it like any other supplier it gets services from. Still gross though.

When we say 'the first ten months of your donations', do they actually get it diverted to them monthly, assuming that the money does come in - or do they get given a lump sum by the charity as soon as they sign you up? If somebody agreed to £5 a month to get rid of an aggressive and intimidating chugger and then immediately cancelled the direct debit, does that mean the charity would just hand them £50 as a reward for harassing you, meaning that their mugging would have cost the charity £50, rather than supporting them? If that's the case, they really are incentivised to be as bullish and unrelenting as possible, aren't they?

I’d like to know this, none of the charities I ever audited used chuggers so I’ve not seen it in practice.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:45

Not that it makes it any better but I assume the value of 10 months of direct debit is what the company is paid per “victim” so the charity wouldn’t disclose it like any other supplier it gets services from. Still gross though.

When we say 'the first ten months of your donations', do they actually get it diverted to them monthly, assuming that the money does come in - or do they get given a lump sum by the charity as soon as they sign you up? If somebody agreed to £5 a month to get rid of an aggressive and intimidating chugger and then immediately cancelled the direct debit, does that mean the charity would just hand them £50 as a reward for harassing you, meaning that their mugging would have cost the charity £50, rather than supporting them? If that's the case, they really are incentivised to be as bullish and unrelenting as possible, aren't they?

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 11:36

Smee and Ford is the big name in this area. Direct from their website:

Our experienced reporting team read over 5,000 Wills per week in order to identify and report charitable bequests and ultimately notify organisations of these gifts.

Smee & Ford’s notification services provide:

Timely and accurate information on forthcoming legacies
Notification of named legacies within weeks of probate
Advanced notification of discretionary legacies
Information on any new charitable trusts or additional funding
We offer three different notification services; Named Legacy Reports, Discretionary Services and a Charitable Trust Service. Read on for more information on what is covered by each service.

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 11:35

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:23

It just sounds worse and worse!

I suppose, being fair about it, if they have been left a bequest in a will, then it prevents them from being denied it if the executor should just try to pocket it themselves or delay passing it on for years - so I can sort of see why such a service would have a place.

I think the main thing would be how they use that information - do they mark it on a 'future income' balance sheet and wait patiently for a reasonable amount of time until everything has gone through and the executors can pass it on to them; or do they pounce on it and immediately start harassing the executors - who are likely also grieving family members - with their hands out?

In my experience (former auditor) they don’t wait around. They have teams that deal with this and they are relentless. It’s not marked as future income as they technically become entitled on the person’s death. It’s a debtor from the minute they find out an approximate amount.

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 11:32

mjf981 · 12/10/2022 11:22

No it wasn't made clear at all. It wasn't even made clear to those of us working for the company...I only found out by accident after my drunken boss let it slip. The whole thing felt like a giant scam and I left. Met some very interesting people on the streets though, and really learned how to talk to people. Would never ever do it again though.

Not that it makes it any better but I assume the value of 10 months of direct debit is what the company is paid per “victim” so the charity wouldn’t disclose it like any other supplier it gets services from. Still gross though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:27

The whole thing felt like a giant scam and I left.

Hmm, I can imagine why it felt like that....

They probably factor in the people with a conscience like you, who leave them when they get wind of what they're up to, and just rely on the hardline, ruthless ones to see what's in it for them, do handsomely well for themselves and the agency, and stuff any semblance of ethical behaviour.

sandytooth · 12/10/2022 11:25

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:23

It just sounds worse and worse!

I suppose, being fair about it, if they have been left a bequest in a will, then it prevents them from being denied it if the executor should just try to pocket it themselves or delay passing it on for years - so I can sort of see why such a service would have a place.

I think the main thing would be how they use that information - do they mark it on a 'future income' balance sheet and wait patiently for a reasonable amount of time until everything has gone through and the executors can pass it on to them; or do they pounce on it and immediately start harassing the executors - who are likely also grieving family members - with their hands out?

Yes that's a point. I'm redoing my will so it's lots to think about.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:23

It just sounds worse and worse!

I suppose, being fair about it, if they have been left a bequest in a will, then it prevents them from being denied it if the executor should just try to pocket it themselves or delay passing it on for years - so I can sort of see why such a service would have a place.

I think the main thing would be how they use that information - do they mark it on a 'future income' balance sheet and wait patiently for a reasonable amount of time until everything has gone through and the executors can pass it on to them; or do they pounce on it and immediately start harassing the executors - who are likely also grieving family members - with their hands out?

mjf981 · 12/10/2022 11:22

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 07:48

We signed up people to make monthly donations through their bank accounts, and were told that the first 10 months of donations went to my company, as it was their 'fee' for signing the person up!!

Is this made explicitly clear to the donor? If not, I wonder why it isn't a legal requirement to do so? If the normal charity collectors, standing on the high street with a tin, just kept the first big chunk of all they were given for themselves before passing some of it on to the charity they were collecting for, everybody would rightly be utterly disgusted and call them thieves and frauds; even if they had a small sign up saying "£2 of every £10 collected will be passed to the charity and the other £8 taken by me as an admin fee", there would be fury - so why is it allowed for chuggers?

Considering how many people will sign up under the pressure and then cancel before they've even paid 10 months' worth - it really is invoking the name of the charity under false pretences and, imho, nothing but fraud. I think people often see the phrase 'charity muggers' as a bit of light-hearted hyperbole, but I don't think it's really very far from the truth at all.

No it wasn't made clear at all. It wasn't even made clear to those of us working for the company...I only found out by accident after my drunken boss let it slip. The whole thing felt like a giant scam and I left. Met some very interesting people on the streets though, and really learned how to talk to people. Would never ever do it again though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:17

Unfortunately not telling them in advance won’t help. There are paid for services that sit in the probate courts and inform the charities of bequests to them. Most of the big/medium charities subscribe.

Ah, I didn't know that - interesting. We recently executed a relative's will and found it quite difficult to get in touch with the local charity she'd left a bequest to - they never answered the phone or got back to us - and they then took ages to cash the cheque!

I suppose, if it's 'only' after probate, at least they can't be actively sizing you and your estate up for years before you die - having your name and DoB on a database that uses algorithms to predict when they might hope to get their hands on your cash.

sandytooth · 12/10/2022 11:13

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 10:56

Alternatively, put it in your will, to instruct your executors, but still, don't let the charity know in advance.

Unfortunately not telling them in advance won’t help. There are paid for services that sit in the probate courts and inform the charities of bequests to them. Most of the big/medium charities subscribe.

It just sounds worse and worse!

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 10:56

Alternatively, put it in your will, to instruct your executors, but still, don't let the charity know in advance.

Unfortunately not telling them in advance won’t help. There are paid for services that sit in the probate courts and inform the charities of bequests to them. Most of the big/medium charities subscribe.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 10:41

Also, if you do want to give money to a charity(ies) after you die, at the very least give a set amount and not a percentage of your estate/proceeds of your house. They will vehemently rail against you doing this (if they know about your intentions), as they know that a £1,000 bequest made when you're 30 will be worth a tiny fraction of that in real terms when you die at 90.

By contrast, if your estate includes a house that you eventually owned outright, they know that their bequest will keep on going up and up over the years - far more than just inflation - hence their keenness for a percentage.

By far the best way, assuming that you trust your children/beneficiaries, is to give them clear instructions that you want them to pass on an amount/percentage of your estate to your chosen charity - but it's ultimately in their control - and don't let the charity know about it until they receive the gift. Alternatively, put it in your will, to instruct your executors, but still, don't let the charity know in advance.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 10:31

Its not an exaggeration, they are muggers.

Charity Muggers hence chuggers.

It's true: not all muggers will hold you at gun-point; a lot will use 'confidence trickery' in the same way that these people do.

To be honest, at least a 'standard' mugger will be upfront that they want your money because they clearly want to keep it for themselves, and won't make any bones about doing it to be benevolent; I find it even more disgraceful when people will claim to be doing it 'for charity' when they know full-well that, at best, the charity won't see any of the money donated for most of the first year, and at worst, loads of people (who were coerced into signing up in the first place) will cancel before the charity ever sees a penny.

The charities endlessly hassling for their share of my MIL’s estate were large “respectable” charities like MacMillan. A bit fucking ironic when she had died of cancer that they were sending letters every month demanding their money.

I think a lot of them want the best of both worlds: they expect to be turning over a lot of money as their right, like a regular business; but unlike a business, they don't have to provide goods or a service in return and expect to emotionally blackmail you into keeping on giving.

If you contact, say, Sky, when your contract is up, and say you want to cancel, they will do everything they can to persuade you to stay, as they clearly want to keep your business, but everybody knows the score and what each other gets from the business relationship: they won't threaten that children will die or sick puppies go untreated if you go ahead and cancel.

DelurkingLawyer · 12/10/2022 09:49

The charities endlessly hassling for their share of my MIL’s estate were large “respectable” charities like MacMillan. A bit fucking ironic when she had died of cancer that they were sending letters every month demanding their money.

Make one off donations during your life and do not allow them to contact you, especially not by phone. The last thing you want as you get older and more vulnerable is charity phone chuggers pursuing you in your house.

Or make a donation to a much smaller charity and one that doesn’t use chuggers. I donate to the Rabbit Welfare Association who send about 1 email every 3 months in a very unassuming way. I feel that donations make more impact to small charities and that they are actually focussed on the work they do rather than becoming “about” the CEOs and machinery that a huge charity needs to sustain itself.

BamBamBilla · 12/10/2022 09:27

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 18:23

OK OK being mugged is an exaggeration but there was a point in there somewhere 😄

I do need to work on being more assertive.

Its not an exaggeration, they are muggers.

Charity Muggers hence chuggers.

myusernamewastakenbyme · 12/10/2022 08:55

My house and any money is going to be split between my 3 children...charity begins at home.

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 08:50

DelurkingLawyer · 12/10/2022 07:54

No worries :)

And no, I don’t think they give a toss.

A piece of advice for anyone thinking of leaving a charity money in your will: don’t. They employ people to comb through wills once made public after the grant of probate, and the charity will then hound the executors relentlessly for the money. When MIL died some years ago we had this, and our sols had to write and tell them to piss off until the assets had all been liquidated so they could get their bequest.

My husband has also litigated several disputes where the extent of what the charity got was unclear, and they are unbelievably aggressive and will pursue litigation to the nth degree. They would say that it is their duty as trustees to get as much money in as possible. But they are terrifying opponents. Huge amounts of money to litigate and no ability or desire to compromise. Don’t under any circumstances put your surviving relatives in a situation where they might have to fight a charity for their bequest.

I second this. I’ve seen charities drag families through the courts until there is nothing left. I know they have a duty to get as much money for the charity as possible but they really have no limits. Our will goes through about every person I can think of and if there is no one left it’s left to three charities to fight it out amongst themselves.

garlictwist · 12/10/2022 08:31

I hate these chugger people! It doesn't seem as bad as it used be but a few years ago going into town felt like running in the gauntlet - there were just so many and it made walking through the city centre incredibly unpleasant.

I refuse to give to any charity that employs these kind of methods.

GermanFrench22 · 12/10/2022 08:30

Surely any decent charity should not use chuggers. It seems to me that the charities that use them are the ones to blame and don't deserve our money.
Is there a list of the culprits? It loses the whole sector so much goodwill.

Such a waste of society's resources as well when there is a shortage of workers in hospitality and care etc.

zinfanfan · 12/10/2022 08:28

I was way too polite and tolerant of these people in the past. Generally now I just avoid eye contact, ignore and keep walking. If they shout something I pretend I didn't hear and keep walking.

If they approach me I just smile benignly, stare through them in a dazed/confused way and keep walking.

The key thing is to keep walking briskly and not speak at all. They'll give up eventually.

If they phone me or knock on the door I don't let them get through their initial speech or answer any questions, I just say "no thank you" and close the door or hang up.

You owe them nothing and I disagree with their tactics and behaviour so I don't feel bad about doing this.