Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer

259 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

OP posts:
GasPanic · 25/08/2023 09:56

They wouldn't be chuggers though if they were nice and took no for an answer.

The whole word implies unpleasant behaviour associated with charity collection.

I do think aggressive collection tactics undermine charities, as they make more people angry than get positive collection results.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 25/08/2023 09:52

@reigatecastle

I agree with @MrsSkylerWhite- if they said "you look like a nice person" I'd just say 'I'm not.' And as for 'do you want people to die,' I might say 'yes, to decrease the world's surplus population!!'

'......do you want people to die???' Shock

WOW, I haven't had anyone say this to me... (do you want people to die?!) That is dreadful. But I can believe someone would have said it. Some guy approached me and DH once (about 4 years ago,) trying to raise money for an animal charity, and he said 'morning people! Do you like animals?' (FFS Who doesn't like animals? Hmm )

DH was in a bad mood that morning (not with me but just a bit salty in general,) and he said 'mmm yeah I do. Labrador on toast is particularly delicious!' and gave the man this look >>>Hmm The man said 'oh ha ha very funny.' And gave him the look back... Hmm Prick.

As a pp said (@historyrepeatz ) these people don't give a shit about what they're promoting, it could be a charity one day and an energy company the next. They're just doing it for the money. A friend of DD's had a short stint working as a chugger some 5 years ago, when she was at uni, as she needed the money. Only lasted 3 weeks as she HATED it, and the horrible manipulative tactics they used.

But also, she said she got paid £75 for every person she signed up!!! £75! They don't want one-off donations like they USED to want/ask for ... The whole idea, is for them to get peoples bank details so they can push more stuff on them to pay up for, and just take it out of their bank account, as per my post way back in the thread... Nasty manipulative behaviour.

Page 9 at 13.20 on 12/10/2022

Page 9 | Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer | Mumsnet

And whilst me, and DH, and most people on this thread won't tolerate it, and will notice anything extra coming out of their bank account, some people are much more shy and nervous and awkward and are afraid to say no, and some may not notice extra bits and bobs coming out of their bank account...

As has been said, these chuggers are DREADFUL and need banning.

LlynTegid · 23/08/2023 08:24

What I would do is make it illegal to ask for any bank details in the street, or agree to anything other than a one-off donation, you could argue GDPR etc as a reason.

Someone has a tin or bucket asking for donations is acceptable to me.

reigatecastle · 23/08/2023 08:22

twoshedsjackson · 22/08/2023 19:22

All that chuggers inspire in me is a steely determination to have nothing to do with the cause they are promoting, and I have told chuggers as much; they seem unfazed but leave me alone after that.
Perhaps if more people had the time or inclination to contact charities, telling them what a poor impression was being made in their name, it might deter them.

Agreed. I also agree with @MrsSkylerWhite - if they said "you look like a nice person" I'd just say I'm not (and if they tried the "do you want people to die" I might channel my inner scrooge and say "yes, and decrease the surplus population".

I'm pretty good at noticing them and not making eye contact but as I said above, it can be more difficult at railway stations if you have a bit of a wait for your train and they don't tell you your platform until the last minute, you are a sitting duck on the concourse (I am thinking of Waterloo station but I imagine any other terminus station is similar).

historyrepeatz · 23/08/2023 07:55

The chuggers don't give a shit about the charity they are promoting. They are sales people who likely work for a third party. They could be pushing an energy company one day and a charity the next.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 22/08/2023 22:01

twoshedsjackson · 22/08/2023 19:22

All that chuggers inspire in me is a steely determination to have nothing to do with the cause they are promoting, and I have told chuggers as much; they seem unfazed but leave me alone after that.
Perhaps if more people had the time or inclination to contact charities, telling them what a poor impression was being made in their name, it might deter them.

Agree @twoshedsjackson ^

twoshedsjackson · 22/08/2023 19:22

All that chuggers inspire in me is a steely determination to have nothing to do with the cause they are promoting, and I have told chuggers as much; they seem unfazed but leave me alone after that.
Perhaps if more people had the time or inclination to contact charities, telling them what a poor impression was being made in their name, it might deter them.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 22/08/2023 19:12

Me and DH were walking through a big outside shopping area today, and DH (aged 60-ish,) was getting a bit tired and was nearly ready to go home. I wanted to look in a clothes shop and try a couple of things on. So my DH sat on a bench and waited for me... I said 'I'll only be 10 minutes.' A particular charity - I won't name and shame them - had set up camp some 70-75 feet (25-ish yards) away from him.

He was looking at his phone and eating some crisps, and a man aged around 35 walked right over to him from where their 'stall' was, and said 'good morning young man!' (fucking patronising that is, calling someone YOUNG MAN or YOUNG LADY when they're clearly over 60.) Hmm DH said 'er hi...' The man said 'how would you like to sign up to donate to our charity???' (Not 'giz a fiver mate...' They wanted DH to sign up and give his bank account details, so he could pay by direct debit - £10 a month!)

DH said (truthfully,) 'sorry mate, I don't have anything on me. No wallet, no money no cards.' (I had the debit card and cash. We have a joint bank account and everything comes out of the same one. He has his own card, but when we're together, it's usually me who has the card and money.)

The man said 'you have NOTHING on you? How are you paying for anything today?' DH said 'I don't need anything - I have just come out for a walk... (He never mentioned he was waiting for his wife... ) The man said 'you can still sign up, we just need your bank account details.' DH said 'I don't know them off by heart.' The man said 'well what bank are you with, you can go ask your bank for a print off of your account to get the account number... I can come with you if you like.' DH was like Confused The man continued... 'Or maybe you can bring up your bank details on your phone and we can set it up now.'

DH was getting pissed off by then... He said 'my wife controls the finances. I wouldn't be able to set it up without her say-so...' (Not true, I don't stop him spending anything, but he said this to try and get the man to piss off!) The man continued...... 'and where is your missus? She can give us the bank details yes?' (urgh missus!Hmm I hate that too!) DH said 'yeah wait there, I'll go and get her...' Then he walked down the alleyway to the side door of the shop I was in, didn't go back, and managed to lose the man!

The charity's behaviour was SO rude and inappropriate. Trying to bully my DH into parting with ten pounds a month. And trying to get his bank details, and demanding to know how he is paying for anything with no money and no debit card. Then saying he can go to the bank to get the details, or set it up on his phone - right there! Right in the high street! That's so manipulative and horrible. SOME people would have ended up signing up, as they'd be too nervous/shy/embarrassed to say no!

Horrible practice. Horrible people. Angry As pps have said, these vile chuggers need banning.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/08/2023 10:38

One said to me “you look like a nice person” a couple of weeks ago. “I’m not” and a hard stare did the trick.
They ought to be banned.

DelurkingLawyer · 22/08/2023 10:36

Pushkinia · 22/08/2023 08:50

I had one of these a few days ago. I stopped his long spiel politely and said I already have charities I donate to regularly. He immediately asked me aggressively which charities they were. I stopped being polite at this point, told him to mind his own business and shut the door on him.

Unbelievably rude. A friend of mine was once approached by a chugger seeking sign ups for Amnesty. Friend said “I’m already a member.” The chugger said “yeah right.” My friend got out his membership card. He was absolutely furious and cancelled his membership. Told them why.

MaybeOneAndDone · 22/08/2023 08:50

"No, sorry, I am in a rush" I use it every time, and I do not stop walking. They can't argue with it, because I am not going to be late for a hypothetical appointment to chat to a random chugger.

Pushkinia · 22/08/2023 08:50

Musti · 10/10/2022 14:53

I agree. And I hate people coming to my door even more. The other week I was busy and had to answer the door and they told me about their cause. Which I empathise with, but I already have the charities that I donate to regularly and can’t donate to them all. I don’t want to be made to feel like a bitch by some strangers in my own home. Most charities have merit but you have to choose.

I had one of these a few days ago. I stopped his long spiel politely and said I already have charities I donate to regularly. He immediately asked me aggressively which charities they were. I stopped being polite at this point, told him to mind his own business and shut the door on him.

selphie · 22/08/2023 08:46

I think the best policy is just to ignore these people and blank them out. Same with the overly pushy street vendors and beggars who you encounter at tourist destinations. A lot of them will take any interaction, even a "no thanks" as a sign to keep pressuring you. You don't owe them your time.

reigatecastle · 22/08/2023 08:22

Sausagelove · 12/10/2022 13:23

Anyone who has unpleasant experiences with these chuggers should complain to the council. Chuggers have to apply for a licence and there are clear rules about their conduct. Complain to the council every single time.

I wonder why they are allowed at railway stations actually - presumably there's no financial benefit to Network Rail or the railway companies so just tell them no. There's no need to create extra stress for passengers when they are waiting for trains.

Poppy sellers are fine because they don't hassle you.

JoBrodie · 21/08/2023 23:19

I am re-animating this zombie thread to share a recent ITV News story about Inside Success aka Inside Success Union CIC (the 'chuggers' that OP encountered). The Fundraising Regulator has asked them to tone things down quite a bit.

• Anti-knife crime group Inside Success Union accused of harassing public to raise cash (1 August 2023) ITV News
https://www.itv.com/news/london/2023-08-01/anti-knife-crime-group-accused-of-intimidating-public-to-raise-cash - with a video which includes an interview with former employees and someone from the Fundraising Regulator.

The Regulator actually published its report earlier this year in March https://www.fundraisingregulator.org.uk/more-from-us/resources/inside-success-union-cic-march-2023

Apparently they received "more than a dozen complaints over two years", I'm surprised it wasn't more. As they're not a charity then technically they're not supposed to be fundraising and should just be selling the magazine, however the nature of the complaints made it pretty clear that some of the staff were hassling people for donations: "None of the complainants indicated they had been pressured to buy a magazine or sign up to a subscription; only to donate.^"

More stories, including Daily Mail, via Google https://www.google.com/search?q=fundraising+regulator+inside+success

I had an encounter with them a couple of weeks ago at Mile End station and they did actually accept my 'no thanks' on first go.

Jo
^they're a social enterprise, or a CIC = community interest company

BloodAndFire · 12/10/2022 21:35

Yes, thank you for the information about how charities behave wrt legacies. I should have known this, based on how big charities operate generally, but I'd never joined the dots before. Awful

I give lots to charity but I specifically choose local charities, international charities with low to no overheads and very specific, documented outcomes, women's refuges, etc.

I would never give a penny to a charity that employs chuggers, and particularly I would never ever give a penny to oxfam,who are especially appalling even among a dodgy bunch.

JoBrodie · 12/10/2022 20:36

I was in Stratford (London) today at Westfield Shopping Horror Centre and walked past some Inside Success people (and also a couple of people with clipboards wanting to survey how to make Stratford better) at the bus station and they all completely ignored me. The only difference I can think of is that I was wearing a mask.

After Stratford I went to Holborn where someone (I didn't spot from which organisation) did try and engage me when I wasn't wearing my mask. I said 'no thank you' and they backed off immediately.

I'm tentatively concluding that a mask repels chuggers ;)

The charity-wills stuff that people have shared is astounding, I had no idea.

Jo

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 14:36

I am agog at the charity just putting through the additional cash!

No sense at all that this is fraud.

I think an awful lot of 'charity' behaviour skates very close to what most people would consider unethical, but does sometimes veer into illegal territory. How is it really any different from a scammer demanding that you need to pay them £X to 'fix' your Windows 'problems', even when you've made it clear that you're not interested? Those vouchers sounded of very low inherent value - just like any old magazine coupon promotion - and were almost certainly given free of charge to the charity.

We used to have a man who brought an apparent charity magazine (only about 12-16 A5 pages) to our door every so often (when he felt like it, it seemed - often with 'double' issues that were no bigger but were nevertheless twice the price). Family Life Club, I think it was called. It was so clearly marketed as being 'supporting' children with liver cancer (iirc), with pictures of children in hospital on the cover, two or three very basic, generic articles and a couple of wordsearch-type puzzles. A load of boring rubbish, obviously - just a way of making your donation regularly.

We just assumed that it was the kids' cancer charity who produced the magazine and guessed that the man was either a kindly volunteer who gave up his time for free or possibly for his expenses and/or a small commission. It turned out, when we read the very tiny print, that it was basically an independent business that gave something like 2% of their profits to the charity and pocketed the rest!

I think it should be illegal to exploit a genuine charity and get donations or sympathy purchases - that nobody would ever give/make if it weren't for the charity angle - when less than, say, 85% of the money actually goes to the charity. Which is worse: asking for money honestly for me and keeping all that I get, or asking for money 'for charity' and keeping 95% of it for myself, knowing that I will end up with far more than if I hadn't exploited the charity's name?

Then again, loads of big High Street names are in on it with things like charity Christmas cards - that sell for a premium, but only a few pence from each one is actually seen by the charity. I'm amazed that it isn't illegal, frankly - especially considering that there are (a few) normal, commercial businesses out there, run by ethically-minded people, that quietly give more of their profits to charity without ever mentioning it to customers than do the ones selling things 'for charity'.

DelurkingLawyer · 12/10/2022 13:47

I am agog at the charity just putting through the additional cash!

No sense at all that this is fraud.

Sausagelove · 12/10/2022 13:23

Anyone who has unpleasant experiences with these chuggers should complain to the council. Chuggers have to apply for a licence and there are clear rules about their conduct. Complain to the council every single time.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 12/10/2022 13:20

NeedWineNow · 11/10/2022 23:09

When I worked in London I had to run the gauntlet of chuggers as soon as I walked out of the office - I worked near St Paul's so it was a prime area for them to hassle unsuspecting tourists. I usually stalked past with a very strong 'NO' if anyone tried to engage, however one made the mistake of berating me saying that it was people like me who were the reason the planet was in the state it is. I turned round and said, very loudly, 'sorry I think you're mistaking me for someone who gives a fuck' and left him standing.

Brilliant. Grin

As a pp said, once they have you hooked in they don't stop. I have a similar story...

I once signed up with a monthly magazine some years ago - 2009-ish (they had reps standing in the shopping centre trying get people to sign up.) I quite fancied the magazine, so I signed up and paid £18 for the year. (£1.50 per issue instead of £2.25 or something like that.) The £18 came out of my bank account 2 weeks later. No problem. Got my first magazine the following week. Great!

About a month later, I got my second magazine. THEN shortly after, I got a phone call from the head office of this magazine asking if I would like to sign up to this special offer.... For just £50 pounds they will send me £125 worth of high street vouchers. I was like, 'what? That sounds amazing. Explain more.'

She said 'so.... It's vouchers for Debenhams, Marks and Spencers, House of Fraser, John Lewis, Harrods, Waitrose, Zara, Body Shop, blah blah blah blah blah. You will get £125.00 worth of vouchers for around 15 shops and stores.' BUT - as she went on it turns out it was £5 off this at House of Fraser, £5 off that at Marks and Spencer, £3, off off this at Waitrose, and £7.50 off that at Harrods blah blah blah. And a £10 off voucher if you spend more than £100 in 'Next.'

I then realised it was just a bunch of £5 off here, £2.50 off there and £7.50 off here vouchers on 90% of shops I NEVER go into. So I declined. 'No thanks I will just leave it. I'd never make any use of the vouchers,' I said. ' Oh, okay,' she said. End of call.

About a week later I was looking through my internet banking, just checking a few transactions. And I looked at my direct debits. There was a message there saying 50 pounds was due to go out of my account (to this magazine) the next day. So the bloody woman had actually gone and done it anyway. I cancelled the direct debit immediately and it didn't go out.

Hilariously, the 125 pounds worth of vouchers came to my house a few days later. After a few days, I started to get phone call after phone call. (I never answered they left messages,) demanding the 50 pounds - or the vouchers back. I picked up the phone after the 5th or 6th time, and told the man that I had actually refused and declined these vouchers, and didn't want them, and they should never have tried to take the money out of my account.

I said go listen back to that phone call. I said 'no, I don't want these vouchers, I will never make use of them!' And the woman said 'Okay then.' The man on the phone said 'you need to send back the vouchers.' I said 'I never asked for them, indeed I REFUSED them, and you still sent them, so YOU come get them if you want them' and then I hung up and blocked their number.

They sent me a letter threatening legal action if I didn't return the vouchers. I wrote back and said 'knock yourself out, see you in court. I didn't spend them. I haven't asked for them. I didn't want them. I wasn't interested in them.' After my letter saying 'see you in court,' I never heard from them again. Weirdly though, I did get the other 10 copies of the magazine, which were automatically set up to come out - and I had paid for them!

Also, the vouchers only had a 3-4 month deadline on them anyway! A few months later I just shredded them!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/10/2022 13:03

After I said no thanks to one, for a major charity, the bloke said maybe I wasn’t fully aware of what the charity did.

Er, yes I am, thanks - and probably a great deal more than you are, since a dd has worked for them for over 10 years, including in post-tsunami/post earthquake disaster zones.
That shut him up!

ChilliBandit · 12/10/2022 12:56

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2022 11:58

In my experience (former auditor) they don’t wait around. They have teams that deal with this and they are relentless. It’s not marked as future income as they technically become entitled on the person’s death. It’s a debtor from the minute they find out an approximate amount.

But, whether they like it or not, if you've been left X% of the proceeds of the sale of a house, the house has to actually be sold before the proceeds come through - and house sales can take a considerable time from marketing to completion.

I totally get them wanting to be kept in the loop and updated along the line, but how can it be considered reasonable to start harassing grieving relatives to rush everything through, just so that they can get their money ASAP?

Do they also have a say as to which buyer's offer is accepted? Say you have an offer of £300,000 from somebody who seems like a shifty chancer with no realistic means of ever being able to pay that much, and an offer of £290,000 from a genuine proceedable buyer with all the documents and loan agreements ready and all stacking up - would the charity be able to insist that you waste your time by going with the cowboy, before they inevitably delay forever and then expect to beat you right down - all because they (theoretically) would stand to get an extra £100 (based on 1%), against all the (very obvious) odds?

I completely agree with you, I am just commenting on what I observed. Where the % is unknown they recognise the most likely amount and then chase and chase. I do wonder how much is spent employing the chasers vs how much extra value they get over just waiting. I’ve seen wills contested by charities where their % has been lowered just before the person’s death too.

Bestcatmum · 12/10/2022 12:54

The blue cross pissed me off they just kept ringing me endlessly for donations during my working hours, I work in a busy NHS clinic doing dressings and I can't keep answering the phone. I had to get really shitty with them in the end and say no more calls.

CrustyFlake · 12/10/2022 12:48

If you have trouble being assertive, a good tactic is to just completely ignore them. Look away, and don't respond to anything they say to you.

If they knock on your door, just close it without saying a word.