Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chuggers/fundraisers should take your first "no" for an answer

259 replies

Parkingmoan1 · 10/10/2022 14:48

I've just been walking through the town centre on my way to catch a bus and was caught by one of those fundraising groups who accost you in the street.

As soon as she started talking to me I politely said no thank you, I don't have the time to talk and carried on walking. Instead of taking that as my final answer she chose to walk alongside me saying "I'm a fast talker" and continued her speech.

I felt a bit intimidated to be honest, she was quite loud and bolshie whereas I don't like confrontation and hate things like this.

I said I don't have any spare money, she said if I didn't want to make the one off payment to the cause (£25 bloody quid) the magazine they're selling is "only" £5.

I ended up buying the magazine just so that she'd leave me alone.

AIBU to think they should have to take your first "no" as an answer and leave you be?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
reigatecastle · 28/08/2023 21:14

The whole charity sector needs reform in my view. Too many charities, too much corruption (see Oxfam), too much duplication.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/08/2023 20:40

They are also paid pretty well, that is money that should be used to do charity work.

Aside from all of the emotional blackmail, aggression and general annoyance they employ, this is why I consider it to be basically a blatant scam.

If I were to stand outside Tesco rattling a bucket with a charity's name on it and then took an hourly 'wage' or a generous percentage 'commission' out of it for myself before passing whatever was left to the named charity - if this were discovered, I would (rightly) be in very serious trouble.

Even if I tried to be 'transparent' and had a big placard saying "Please give generously - 50% of all donations will be given to X charity with the other 50% kept by me for my trouble," I would probably still be in hot water - and obviously wouldn't be given anything from anybody who had seen the sign anyway.

Whichever of these methods I tried, people would be horrified and would label me disgusting and a scammer - and I wouldn't disagree with them. Bear in mind that what the chuggers are doing is much worse than this, as in addition, they also actively approach people, use pressure and emotional manipulation, often tell lies, are seeking indefinite sign-ups and never tell anybody that lots of the donation will be kept by them or their company and never be seen by the named charity.

Why this isn't banned by law, I will never understand.

BashfulClam · 28/08/2023 20:20

I was rushing to get to the train station as my father had died when one a visited me. I was visibly upset and in a rush and said ‘No’ when some twat approached me. She kept trying to engage and talk at me so I screamed ‘will you just fuck off you stupid bitch!’ Not the best response but I wasn’t exactly I the best frame of mind. I now despise them and withdraw my support for any charity that uses them as I refuse to have my money sending them into my path.

They are also paid pretty well, that is money that should be used to do charity work. I withdrew my support from one charity who kept asking me to increase my donation and then sent a CD out in the post. How much must it have cost to produce and send fucking CD’s as well as twice weekly letters to increase my donation ?? Money that could have been used more wisely.

When they ask ‘don’t you care about xyz?’ I just say ‘no’ there is not much they can say to that.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/08/2023 18:30

but used the same tactic of "all your neighbours have donated," which I think adds pressure and makes you feel like an asshole if you don't

"Oh, well, obviously not everybody will be able to afford to give anything, but I'm really glad to hear that you've managed to raise so much support already. Well, bye!"

CleverLilViper · 28/08/2023 17:46

I had a run-in with a couple of charity cold callers/churglars recently.

The first one managed to get some money out of me-£10 exactly, and at the time, I was okay with this as I thought it was a one-off donation. Until I received a text half an hour later when I found out he'd set me up for a direct debit (but done it in a way that I'd never heard of before) to take the £10 every month. I quickly cancelled that and it left me with a sour taste in my mouth after what had seemed a nice interaction.

He was polite and friendly, and explained the charity well. He described how he'd been up and down the estate all day and how all the neighbours had donated £10/£20 and so I thought, oh, well, what's £10?

So, I donated.

The second one called a few weeks later, just as polite and friendly as the first, but used the same tactic of "all your neighbours have donated," which I think adds pressure and makes you feel like an asshole if you don't-and started to go on about it, "it's just £2 a week, who can't afford £2 a week? You couldn't get a cup of coffee for £2 nowadays."

Well, internally, I did the math and thought, actually, that's £104 per year and damn right you won't be able to get a cup of coffee if you're donating to everyone that knocks on the door! I promptly said no, that time and his attitude which had been chatty and polite and very friendly when he thought was getting money changed. He wasn't nasty or rude or anything-but his demeanour shifted and he just went "Ok, bye," and rushed off. Precisely what I wanted.

I feel like it's easier when they're on the street as you can just walk away. It's harder when they call at the door as it feels rude to slam it in their face, but with the second one, as soon as I saw him, I thought, "Why did I answer the door?"

On the one hand, I want to immediately say that I'm not interested, no thanks, but then on the other, it'd feel rude to do that because you haven't listened to them so throughout the interaction you're looking for a moment to go, "no, thanks." In some ways it's quite funny to keep them talking, knowing you're not giving them money and they're just wasting their time.

It's just annoying the tactics that they use to make you feel cheap if you say no. "It's only..." "couldn't buy a coffee for that," "all your neighbours have been really generous," (implication that you won't be generous if you refuse).

I'm now vowing to up my assertiveness game and say, "no thanks," right from the off and close the door before they continue.

I had one woman once who knocked on my door as I was in the middle of conference call-it didn't require my input and I was expecting a delivery so I answered-thinking I'd be one minute, oh, no, it wasn't my delivery. I tried to tell her I was busy and at work and didn't have time, and she got the immediate hump with me, and said she'd just come back later if I didn't deal with her then. I repeated I didn't have the time-she huffed off. Never came back, though. 😂

Nevermind31 · 28/08/2023 14:22

ask her… do you really think I will engage with you after I told you no, and you are harassing me? Good bye.

and then grow a thicker skin, it really doesn’t matter if they shout at you

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/08/2023 14:07

You lot are aware that these are actual human beings you are talking about? They wouldn’t be doing it for the fun of it, they just have bills to pay and mouths to feed like the rest of us. Some of you sound really self righteous and not very nice!

So are other scammers - in fact, many of them are based in very poor countries and see no other way to make enough money to feed their children other than by scamming westerners online or over the phone.

And yes, I do consider chuggers to be scammers. Unless, when they approach you, they make it very clear that they are a professional third-party being paid to solicit your bank details and that a large proportion of your donations will go straight into their back pocket - and that your agreeing to sign up for a direct debit will almost certainly lead to your being pressured to give more as time goes on. Which I highly doubt a single one of them has ever done.

I complained to my council numerous times about the ones in town basically making the high street unusable.

I feel so sorry for all of the shops and other businesses - paying very high business rates to that very same council - who happen to be located within the section where the council has allowed the chuggers to operate. I honestly think they should get a rebate on their business rates for all the days when the council makes their trading area a no-go zone.

I'm amazed at the big supermarkets who allow the chuggers in to hover by the entrance, to drive their customers away - but at least that's a decision that they've made for themselves (for whatever reason).

I highly doubt we ever will see it happen, but we really need to get away from the idea that anything labelled as 'charity' is automatically a worthy cause, run by altruistic people who actually care about the charity that is invoked.

In an ideal world (well, not one so ideal that there would be no need for charities to exist), I'd like to see two very clear categories for fundraising, with the operators forced to clearly state which one they fall under (like the hygiene ratings on food shop doors): one for people volunteering and one for people seeking to make money directly for themselves from the use of the charity's name.

Rocketpants50 · 28/08/2023 13:05

I hate it and puts me off donating to these big companies who fundraise in these ways. I am not sure why they I would hand over my bank details to a random person on the street. I did get so annoyed with one that who walked and hassled me down the high street, that if he would give me his bank details first then I might be inclined to give him mine. Strangely he said no.

BathingBeauty · 28/08/2023 12:42

I complained to my council numerous times about the ones in town basically making the high street unusable. It does seem to have improved. I would complain about their behaviour, the council gives them permission to be there.
i was late catching a train and they stood in front of me to try and stop me ‘get the next one’. I complained to the council and the charity.

I will never give money to a charity which uses these tactics, they’re on commission. My office is at the front of the house and I see them coming down the street, I don’t answer, no one does, so many people have ring doorbells now so they don’t have to.

Bagwyllydiart · 28/08/2023 12:27

WatchoRulo · 11/10/2022 11:18

Chuggers will get a mandatory life sentence when I come to power.

I’ll vote for you.

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/08/2023 12:25

I haven't read the full thread, but if someone kept pestering you in the street after saying 'no' I wonder if they'd think again if you got your phone out and started recording them? I imagine at least some of them won't like having their behaviour recorded.

RedToothBrush · 28/08/2023 12:12

WandaWonder · 28/08/2023 11:59

I am starting to say 'no!' to 'don't you care about children/fluffy bunnies/diseases' whatever if they don't take my polite 'no thank you' first time

I think we need to start saying 'actually I care about street harassment and high pressure sales tactics. Questions like that are emotional blackmail and I have issues with any charity who employs chuggers who use them'.

This type of behaviour - the example WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps details above is actually illegal I believe as it falls short of trading standards rules on high pressure sales tactics particularly if aimed at vulnerable (esp elderly) people and wouldn't be acceptable to the charity commission.

Remembering that councils also allocate slots for chuggers is also worth remembering.

Please take note of charity, names of individuals and report them. Don't just say 'no you don't care'. You need to be protecting vulnerable individuals from this exploitation.

TigerRag · 28/08/2023 12:06

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/08/2023 10:29

Quite - which is why the "Don't you care ..." lines irritate me. You'd think they'd come up with some better lines, but really there's not much they could say which would induce me to part with my bank details to some unknown in the street

Nor does it end there - a soft hearted pal once signed up for "just a fiver a month" for the RSPCA and was plagued to death by phone calls wanting an increase

Much easier to just say no in the first place and donate directly to whatever you wish

My dad stopped his donations to RSPCA because they kept asking for more money.

I remember being stopped years ago. I said no because I couldn't afford it and was told it was "only £10 a month". That is a lot when your only income is £50 a week (as it was back then) JSA. Even if I wanted to I couldn't sign up then as I didn't have my bank details (as NatWest don't print your account details on your card) he suggested that he take my number and he'll call me tonight and he'll get them then. I refused.

I've had some who because I walk past them and ignore then wave their hand in front of my face.

I donate to who I want - I've raised money for a small charity who i also collect money for via easyfundraising. (This doesn't cost me anything)

WandaWonder · 28/08/2023 11:59

I am starting to say 'no!' to 'don't you care about children/fluffy bunnies/diseases' whatever if they don't take my polite 'no thank you' first time

reigatecastle · 28/08/2023 11:53

Valeriekat · 28/08/2023 08:23

Unbelievable!

There are plenty of other jobs around, and their need to earn a living doesn't outweigh my right to go about my business without being harassed. It's also not a good look for young men to harass women in any context.

Valeriekat · 28/08/2023 08:23

TheFrustratedRedhead · 10/10/2022 16:18

You lot are aware that these are actual human beings you are talking about? They wouldn’t be doing it for the fun of it, they just have bills to pay and mouths to feed like the rest of us. Some of you sound really self righteous and not very nice!

Unbelievable!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/08/2023 00:11

"On the contrary; in fact, I care so much about X that I will be very careful to make my donation which may well be zero direct to the charity and not through a middle-man like yourself, who will take a large chunk of my donation away from the X that need every penny that people can give."

Curlygirl06 · 26/08/2023 19:24

We had some with a stall outside Greggs and a few of them were wandering about, with the main man stopping people as they were going in to Greggs or queuing outside. They were from the Cats Trust.
The big chap stopped me and was about to go into his spiel so I put my hand up, said I hated cats so don't bother. He got quite snotty about it and when I came out he was talking to the others and pointed me out. However, none of them stopped me after that so good result!

Mountainhowl · 26/08/2023 17:40

I done a month for one of these companies, it's all MLM, even had the big rave conferences where you have to whoop and cheer these random people who you've never heard of as if they're celebrities, and if you don't you've 'not got the winning mindset'. I made about £200 doing full time for 4 weeks, I can't do pushy!

They don't tell you when you go for the interview or anything that it's commission, it wasn't until after I'd been successful and was in training when that was made clear.

We were knocking doors, not in town centres, that seemed worse and I hated it, we would have to try doors 3 times over the course of the day to try and catch people. A man told me he'd give me X amount for something else and tried to pull me in his house, I was told off for not continuing on that street and going to find someone else from the group to work alongside instead.

Awful job and not something I'd ever do again, the party/upbeat vibe was nice at first until I realised that even the top level members of the team were skint too and everyone's just faking it

reigatecastle · 26/08/2023 17:09

Limosella · 26/08/2023 12:35

Learn to sign. It really throws them. I had a chugger in the week approach me and start his spiel. I signed, I can't hear you, to him and he was completely phased. He was chugging for a deaf children's charity. I am not deaf incidentally so much enjoyed his confusion

😂

Limosella · 26/08/2023 12:35

Learn to sign. It really throws them. I had a chugger in the week approach me and start his spiel. I signed, I can't hear you, to him and he was completely phased. He was chugging for a deaf children's charity. I am not deaf incidentally so much enjoyed his confusion

DelurkingLawyer · 25/08/2023 10:59

I always say “I don’t sign up to direct debits for people who knock at my door/approach me in the street.” I’ve found this highly effective as it brings the interaction to a dead halt. Still think it should be banned.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/08/2023 10:29

historyrepeatz · 23/08/2023 07:55

The chuggers don't give a shit about the charity they are promoting. They are sales people who likely work for a third party. They could be pushing an energy company one day and a charity the next.

Quite - which is why the "Don't you care ..." lines irritate me. You'd think they'd come up with some better lines, but really there's not much they could say which would induce me to part with my bank details to some unknown in the street

Nor does it end there - a soft hearted pal once signed up for "just a fiver a month" for the RSPCA and was plagued to death by phone calls wanting an increase

Much easier to just say no in the first place and donate directly to whatever you wish

GellerYeller · 25/08/2023 10:26

We had a spate of these locally plus those people who want to ‘save you money’ on utility bills, haranguing people in an alleyway from the car park to the shopping area where you can’t avoid them. When they wouldn’t take a polite no I said I had to donate any spare money to ‘the cult’.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 25/08/2023 10:07

100% agree @GasPanic

Swipe left for the next trending thread