Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some random bloke just started an argument with me. 

113 replies

FeelingMoreFreeWithEveryYear · 10/10/2022 14:44

I was just out running with my dog in the countryside near my house. I was absolutely minding my own business as I was determined to run 5K without stopping. My dog runs off lead, until I see another dog, which is rare, and I call him to heel or put on lead depending on situation. My dog doesn't like big dogs coming up to him and a while ago he was attacked by a pack of dogs and I thought he was toast! My dog totally minds his own business.

So, we were going along and these 3 dogs come round the corner without anyone with them. 2 large and 1 medium, so I put my dog on the lead and carry on running. No bother. I'm expecting owner to appear and call dogs back, but they don't. All 3 dogs start circling mine and sniffing his butt and one was in his face. I just carried on running. However, as I ran past the man started making comments to me very loudly, not sure for whose benefit in the middle of a field, about how "isn't it funny how people with dogs are the worst, and hate other dogs" and other comments. So, I stopped and said something about his dogs circling mine and he doesn't like it. Then he made some more comments and by this time I was enraged by this guy who I doubt would be saying all this if I was a man. So I told him I didn't think he was setting his DC a very good example making comments to a woman out on her own. Then he made some more comments, I can't even remember what, so I called him a F* Arsehole and jogged on with him shouting something as I left.

I'm not proud of using this language in front of DC, but I am SICK of men who think they can make comments and just carry on without being pulled up on it. I'm SICK OF IT. If I had been with my DH, I doubt very much he would have said anything.

I know IABU for using bad language in front of DC, but AIBU for how I handle my dog when out, or is he?

OP posts:
Noteverybodylives · 10/10/2022 18:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WannabeKittens · 10/10/2022 17:59

DirectionToPerfection · 10/10/2022 17:52

@Noteverybodylives

What is actually wrong with you?

Well, they’re almost certainly a man for starters, perhaps even the man in question….

Have reported their post.

mycatisannoying · 10/10/2022 17:54

Your words will no doubt stay with those kids, and it's not their fault. I wouldn't have used that language for that reason, and I think you're every bit as bad as him.

DirectionToPerfection · 10/10/2022 17:52

@Noteverybodylives

What is actually wrong with you?

tartytowers · 10/10/2022 17:50

Well done for saying something back to him. Men that make nasty uncalled for comments to women need telling to fuck off!

MayThe4th · 10/10/2022 17:50

I would absolutely bet that the man wouldn’t have acted the way he did if the OP was a man.

Last weekend I was on a bus when a man got right up in my face and started having a go because I was sitting on the seat behind him and he felt I should be somewhere else. I absolutely stood up to him, but when another male passenger told him to stop he suddenly got up and moved. Twat.

And it’s not all dogs off lead which are a problem. My dog’s recall is perfect, he will come straight back and I can either put him on a lead or move in a different direction if there are other dogs around. He has never jumped up at anyone in his life.

But at usual these threads bring out the <yawn> anti dog arseholes.

Noteverybodylives · 10/10/2022 17:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/10/2022 17:47

It doesn't happen quite so much when you're walking but it also happens when you are swimming or using the weights in the gym that you have bought and paid for but some think should be a lady-free zone. It's frightening to realise how many many men feel threatened by women trying to be fit and strong and want to scare them back indoors.

It's true. Swimming SERIOUSLY fucking annoys them. Water patriarchy chicken makes them incandescent with rage. I've had at least three men try to give me impromptu swimming lessons since joining my particular gym; inquired of the bloke who asked me last time that if he was wasted in his current occupation, he could apply for a job as an instructor and get paid for what he was offering me for free.

These days, I just keep my swimmers' earplugs in, and if I'm approached point to them and shake my head.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/10/2022 17:44

Women should have dignity and walk on by in silence. Men, meanwhile, have free rein to do what they so often do and insult/harass lone women in public. Such is the wearisomely predictable tone of some of the responses in this thread.

The only way in which I'd have exercised caution here is in risk-assessing. A woman who backchats a man could easily end up in a ditch. We all know this isn't catastrophizing; it happens with far too alarming a regularity.

I'm pleased you challenged his behaviour, OP, and also glad you came out of that situation unscathed.

I too am sick of it.

limitedperiodonly · 10/10/2022 17:38

we have people saying they were assaulted and it's a huge mess with loads of hassle and money being wasted (for the police) because people generally can't keep it shut.

Oh @Burgoo how dreadful for you. No wonder you stopped working as a police officer. I hope you've found employment more to your liking.

Are there any other things people who are going about their lawful business can do to avoid troubling the police?

limitedperiodonly · 10/10/2022 17:30

This is why women don't run alone. There is something about running that makes some men (a lot of men) very angry. It doesn't happen quite so much when you're walking but it also happens when you are swimming or using the weights in the gym that you have bought and paid for but some think should be a lady-free zone. It's frightening to realise how many many men feel threatened by women trying to be fit and strong and want to scare them back indoors.

Even my husband didn't believe me until the day he stopped to tie his shoelace and I got foul abuse from two wankers in seconds. One of them said: "Sorry mate. I thought she was on her own."

OP i'd continue to take your dog or run with someone else if the route is lonely. Don't feel bad about swearing in front of his children. He can explain that the lady said a naughty words and Daddy was being a creepy dick. Ignore the soppy cows saying you did anything wrong. They always come out on threads like this.

DirectionToPerfection · 10/10/2022 17:03

Yes, we must all put up with random strangers having a go at us over nothing, and must meekly shuffle away before some accuses us of causing a scene. 🙄

Fuck that.

Burgoo · 10/10/2022 17:00

I personally wouldn't have gotten into the confrontation. There really is absolutely no point and it just makes life harder. If it was someone you knew then that's one thing, but a random stranger? I have much more important things to worry about TBH.

That said, I wish people wouldn't start arguing withs strangers in public places. I used to work as a police officer and the number of calls we would get from people (mainly women but also some men too, it's not a gendered issue) was astounding. They victim would get someone gobbing off, they would get enraged and retaliate and start screaming/swearing and the person would then smack them. Next thing you know we have people saying they were assaulted and it's a huge mess with loads of hassle and money being wasted (for the police) because people generally can't keep it shut.

As a guy I would be extremely reluctant to start gobbing back at someone who clearly has either a bad attitude/problem with their emotions or is just a bad person. Anyone who starts squaring up to me in the street likely means business, I am too old and have experienced enough to know it's simply not worth the misery.

The question I always ask is, what is it you are trying to achieve by getting into an argument with someone you don't know? If it's getting knocked flat, go ahead because the chances are someone will (or worse in today's climate). If it is to "win" the debate, it's useless because these types don't want to be corrected, they want a fight.

I do NOT condone shitty behaviour from anyone, and that guy needs a good telling off (and it will happen at some point, he will come a cropper when he starts on the wrong person). At the same time, the moment you start escalating your behaviour, you are now inviting a confrontation and that also isn't a bright idea. I did years in the job, and I very rarely had anyone start with me unless I was dealing with drug/alcohol users. My starting position is "what can I do to DE-escalate this situation?" and "what is actually going on here?" I do see though that a man acting in that way is intimidating to ANYONE (I am not getting into the gender issue here, I think it's a major red herring). In those situations we can easily move to fight/flight and we do or say things we later probably think better of doing.

CaptainMyCaptain · 10/10/2022 16:58

Threadkillacilla · 10/10/2022 14:47

Sounds like he was being a gobshite and you didn't just run past but escalated it.

Yes. I would have ignored him and kept on running.

Anonymous48 · 10/10/2022 16:57

Spanielsarepainless · 10/10/2022 16:18

A bloke wouldn't care about using 'language' in front of children. When I ran I walked past other dogs.

What are you talking about? Maybe the men you know. But my husband wouldn't have been at all happy about someone using bad language in front of our children when they were young. It's inappropriate.

BatteryPoweredMammy · 10/10/2022 16:55

Endosaurus · 10/10/2022 14:53

He was wrong to make digs, but you were wrong to run at his dogs without giving him time to recall and put them on leads too.

Most dogs will see another dog/person running towards them and naturally be curious and approach.

Bollocks to that. His dogs were not on a lead…end of story.
If you want to wander around with your dog(s) off lead, you take the consequences.

Fairislefandango · 10/10/2022 16:52

You did nothing wrong wrt how you dealt with your dog and the other dogs, you were well within your rights to make the comment about his dogs circling yours, given that he'd already started the conversation with you. However, I would have definitely left it at that. Yes he was a total arse and no, I don't suppose he would have talked the same way to a man. But there was no need for you to escalate things and swear at him in front of your dc. You gained nothing ftom doing so, and you'd already expressed your disapproval of how he let his dogs behave.

OfficerArrestThatRuffian · 10/10/2022 16:45

Sorry, am I understanding this correctly: this all began because random man was offended by the fact you kept running with your dog (on a lead) as opposed to, what, bending down and scratching his dogs' ears or something? Hence his initial passive aggressive comment about dog owners not liking other dogs?

I've heard of men thinking they're permanently entitled to women's time but I didn't realise the massive entitlement also extended to their pets!

The only reason I would advise you not to say something back is for your own safety. Otherwise there is absolutely no reason on earth that women should meekly put up with this sort of passive aggressive, slack-jawed idiocy from strange men.

lovelypidgeon · 10/10/2022 16:26

I have a reactive rescue dog who is always on a lead in public places, and wears a muzzle which most sensible people see as a clue that he might not be keen on being approached. I have lost count of the number of people who have allowed their off-lead dogs to run at my dog face on (whilst I am clearly trying to distract mine/get him out of the way) and then made passive aggressive comments (to no one in particular) about how some dogs shouldn't be out in public etc etc when he growls at them. Every time I have made any comment back they have become aggressive and I have frequently been told that I should walk him at night or have him put to sleep. My DH has never had these comments made to him- which I'm sure must be coincidence and nothing to do with him being a rather big gruff looking bloke whereas I am a small middle aged woman.

So no, OP YANBU. FWIW, I have never had nasty comments from owners with well controlled off-lead dogs, or who put them on a lead when they see us coming.

courgettigreensadwater · 10/10/2022 16:22

@ZeroFuchsGiven my dog is often off the lead and wouldn't have any interest whatsoever in sniffing or jumping up at you.

Spanielsarepainless · 10/10/2022 16:18

A bloke wouldn't care about using 'language' in front of children. When I ran I walked past other dogs.

Whattaweapon · 10/10/2022 16:09

Good on you OP, I have had a few of these types of incidents myself. Seems some men just can't resist an opportunity to have a pop at a woman.

purpleboy · 10/10/2022 16:01

Endosaurus · 10/10/2022 14:53

He was wrong to make digs, but you were wrong to run at his dogs without giving him time to recall and put them on leads too.

Most dogs will see another dog/person running towards them and naturally be curious and approach.

Yes op you must make sure you stop running so the poor idiot with no recall can get his dogs back! God forbid people actually take responsibility for their own dogs.

If your dog goes up to people or other dogs without being invited then you are also a twatty dog owner.

You did nothing wrong op ignore this poster who is clearly having a shit day and desperately trying to pull you down to their level!

Rosehugger · 10/10/2022 15:58

And if he was any sort of a dog owner, he'd know that three dogs v one can always be an issue, no matter how chilled the dogs all are. I bet his wife walks the dog most of the time and he hasn't a clue.

Chlobo89 · 10/10/2022 15:56

Good for you! People are weird on here about dogs but you did the right thing with yours. Of course dogs should be allowed to run off lead as long as they come back when called it’s not a problem.
The man was a twat, probably because he knew he was in the wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread