Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this comment..

139 replies

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 13:18

We have a very wealthy friend who has retired at 50 and will never need to work again.
We are very lucky in that whilst we are older than that, we both manage by working part time , live frugally with a modest house.
By the nature of being working people we sometimes discuss our jobs... and that they are ok , not ok etc.. part of life.
She often says , in this context.. oh but i dont have to work, and claps her hands.
She often says also its wonderful to be retired. In a shop last week she said, hows the job , to a woman we know, followed by, oh i never have to work again.its great. Big smile.
My dh finds this either
A. A bit insensitive
B. A bit lacking in emotional intelligence.
C.( if he is feeling a little grumpy)
.. gloating. But hopes it is not the latter .

This person has had a full on supporting job role in the past. It is not like its been life in a bubble
. It does grate a bit at times and you see the look on peoples faces ,but she doesnt seem notice or to get that
It is a little insensitive especially in the current climate.
I find that its a bit annoying but i am seeking to understand that it could be just her ( she has an actively cultivated attitude of positivity towards life) .. am trying to find out if anyone has a different perspective of what this could be?? The responses i mean.. as i want not to go down the iabu route and be a grumpy and judgy human./ making assumptions .

Hence the request for others views.!

OP posts:
Zofloraeverywhere · 10/10/2022 15:48

‘Nobody likes a braggart, dear’

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 15:48

LookItsMeAgain she is 100% sure wont have to work again . Her financial advisor has told her that for sure .

OP posts:
Choconut · 10/10/2022 15:47

Ok, latest post sounds like she is money obsessed and uses the fact she has a lot of it to patch up her low self esteem.

Choconut · 10/10/2022 15:45

If she's generally nice then I would just think she knows she's worked very hard before (and perhaps didn't like it too much) and is now feels so happy and lucky that she doesn't have to work.

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 15:45

Could it be just the perception of things and what is ok to discuss / say...
I was always brought up not really to say what things cost etc and also to be circumspect about others.
She also says things like oh where is the buikder I have 6k cash to give him, oh, yes i do like this part of the garden , happy to have paid 3/ 4 million so i can share it with people. Oh yes that art work did cost us a lot.
The thing i find hardest ( and its my crap)is the oh must divide some money up for the kids . Its good to be able to help them . Knowing that its a form of guilt for me as I cant help mine and ive been upset about it. Ive said I am glad for you, but hearing it makes me feel guilty in the past. She did say well, we all have different circumstances.
I feel like am drip feeding now unintentionally.Am not meaning to , its just that have started overthinking this.
I worry that if i ask her to consider others she may simply say well we all have different circumstance, and feel she will not get why it could sound goady, because she seems so free in talking about it ,and may see it as sour grapes in others / that rhe issue would be their jealosy, as opposed to a need to be circumspect at times.
I also think making a joke of it .. like yeah yeah dont go on would either be seen as jealousy or perhaps not hit home.

I appriciate the chance to explore this, and will work out an approach. I am aware it can look a bit of in the local shops etc also. I will re read thread later.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 10/10/2022 15:42

I'd actually tackle this from a different angle. She says that she'll "never have to work again". On that front I'd actually say "Well Doris, we never know what is around the corner for any one of us, so you say you'll never have to work again, but we just don't know. What if there was a huge bill you couldn't cover? I wouldn't count my chickens just yet. What with energy prices going up, some people are taking on second jobs so that they can both heat and eat. You're comments could be seen as upsetting to them, don't you think?"

This has been going on for a year now. I might even go with a sarcastically said "I know" if she said it again and then I'd try to change the subject to something more neutral like the weather.

chilliesandspices · 10/10/2022 15:42

I'm happy for people who have been able to retire. I don't enjoy work but I'm comfortable enough financially so it is what it is. I'm in my early 30s and there's a little part of me that worries I'll never get to the point of retiring comfortably so it's nice to see some people reach that point.

I think I'd only find her comments upsetting if I was working full-time and still struggling for money which I guess is a lot of people these days.

mam0918 · 10/10/2022 15:26

'Never have to work again' I would just view as ignorant because no one knows what the future holds, loads of people retire then have to return to work from changes in circumstance.

I also dont find it a 'proud' thing, as a disabled person and a carer not having an 'employed' job doesnt impress me because its been my reality and is for millions like me.

Blondewithredlips · 10/10/2022 15:17

She sounds vile I'm afraid. I have a friend that is similar and am in the process of gradually finishing the friendship because I cannot stomach this behavior or make excuses for it.

Ihavehadenoughalready · 10/10/2022 15:04

Say something like "while it's very nice for you and I'm happy for you, other people do still need to work to have adequate money coming in, and I think some people might think you are being a bit gloaty."

Does she do volunteering at all? She could still work, but just not get paid.

Also if more is mentioned about the big house, ask her if she's considered downsizing to solve her space "problem", otherwise perhaps you don't want to hear complaining when most people have the opposite problem. She can downsize and give the profit to charity if she's that wealthy.

I'm not sure why she is so tone-deaf, and it's almost like she's trying to make people jealous of her.

If she was born into wealth, you might casually mention that people born on third base don't get to claim a home run.

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:50

Also has said dont work too hard.
Up post is a poster who is retired and she ribs her mates about it in good jest , so maybe its me .. just not getting it .

OP posts:
Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:47

Its said
In their group
Its said to us ( workers)
Its said to people in shops .( who we know) .
Its said most times we meet.

OP posts:
Idontgiveashitanymore · 10/10/2022 14:44

I’d say something like . Enough is enough! Some people are really struggling right now!

nokidshere · 10/10/2022 14:44

The clapping her hands and being gleeful sounds childlike, maybe that's just her mannerisms.

I'm retired, my friends are not. I love being retired and they hate working, it is what it is. I empathise when they are moaning about work, tease them that they 'only' have 10 more years to go, they tell me to 'stop showing off' or moan about how lucky I am.

There's nothing wrong with enjoying the phase of your life you are in. I'm not going to stop telling them (and they wouldn't want me to) when I've had a lovely lazy day just because they are bogged down at work.

I've worked my 45yrs, it's not my fault that they are younger than me.

The hard thing for me was in a retired group of her and retired friends saying , isnt it wonderful to be retired and smile at each other. I said one of us isnt.

So no one is allowed to be happy they are retired because you aren't? That's just being silly. I would have replied to that comment 'yeah you lucky buggers'.

Andypandy799 · 10/10/2022 14:41

Yeah I think after a year it’s rubbing peoples faces in it. I would think for the honeymoon period acceptable but she sounds to have a lack of humility

Motnight · 10/10/2022 14:38

She's 50? She knows exactly what she is doing. And it's not nice.

DoingJustFine · 10/10/2022 14:36

I find the idea of it being smug upsetting. Not who I think she is .

Well, she is.

The hard thing for me was in a retired group of her and retired friends saying , isnt it wonderful to be retired and smile at each other. I said one of us isnt.

In this case, I think you were the out-of-step person. If she's with her retired friends, they're allowed to form a Smugness Collective, and you have to suck it up. But when she's with people IN THEIR WORKPLACES WHEN THEY ARE ACTUALLY WORKING then she has to shut up.

Otherwise it's like she's dancing through A&E singing, "I'm the picture of health!"

Hawkins001 · 10/10/2022 14:35

@Oncloud
both A and B

BlackberryCat · 10/10/2022 14:34

My parents are retired and I do think they are very happy not having to worry about work. I think it must be a great feeling putting all that behind you. I think your friend is just really happy but hasn’t thought about how her words might make others feel.

DoingJustFine · 10/10/2022 14:32

I'd honestly be tempted to say stuff like I read a study in Saga magazine that said early retirement is linked with Alzheimer's. Or brain tumours. Or saggy boobs.

Sparklfairy · 10/10/2022 14:32

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:25

Sparklfairy i did ask what she does with her time.
She does lots of art things .she says she does not know how she had time to work. Enjoys not having a clue what day it is as does not need to know.

The point I was badly making was that you could suggest she should 'share' her good luck, fortune and privilege by helping others through volunteer work. Give back, if you will. But say it really subtly rather than directly shaming her Wink

She won't do it, but she won't mention it (to you) again.

In the current climate it's kind of like splashing the cash (but not giving any out) around the homeless, you know? It's just tacky.

junebirthdaygirl · 10/10/2022 14:30

All my friends retired before me and went on and on about how wonderful retirement was. I found it a bit annoying as l loved my job and had no interest in retiring. Retirement isn't everything. She could have 40 yeas of this.
Maybe say: l love my job and l am delighted to be working.

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:27

I find the idea of it being smug upsetting. Not who I think she is .
The hard thing for me was in a retired group of her and retired friends saying , isnt it wonderful to be retired and smile at each other. I said one of us isnt.

OP posts:
Softplayhooray · 10/10/2022 14:25

AtrociousCircumstance · 10/10/2022 13:24

Insensitive on her part.

Equivalent to someone in a couple saying to their single friend, “So happy I’m not alone and lonely any more! Whoop!”

Spot on! But you'd never say it would you, because it's very obviously arshole-y. Doesn't stop her, though. I'd drop seeing her, personally, or if you really care about her, be honest with her that she's hurting people's feelings.

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:25

Sparklfairy i did ask what she does with her time.
She does lots of art things .she says she does not know how she had time to work. Enjoys not having a clue what day it is as does not need to know.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread