Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this comment..

139 replies

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 13:18

We have a very wealthy friend who has retired at 50 and will never need to work again.
We are very lucky in that whilst we are older than that, we both manage by working part time , live frugally with a modest house.
By the nature of being working people we sometimes discuss our jobs... and that they are ok , not ok etc.. part of life.
She often says , in this context.. oh but i dont have to work, and claps her hands.
She often says also its wonderful to be retired. In a shop last week she said, hows the job , to a woman we know, followed by, oh i never have to work again.its great. Big smile.
My dh finds this either
A. A bit insensitive
B. A bit lacking in emotional intelligence.
C.( if he is feeling a little grumpy)
.. gloating. But hopes it is not the latter .

This person has had a full on supporting job role in the past. It is not like its been life in a bubble
. It does grate a bit at times and you see the look on peoples faces ,but she doesnt seem notice or to get that
It is a little insensitive especially in the current climate.
I find that its a bit annoying but i am seeking to understand that it could be just her ( she has an actively cultivated attitude of positivity towards life) .. am trying to find out if anyone has a different perspective of what this could be?? The responses i mean.. as i want not to go down the iabu route and be a grumpy and judgy human./ making assumptions .

Hence the request for others views.!

OP posts:
Bimblybomeyelash · 10/10/2022 17:38

Maybe she just sees it as acknowledging her good fortune, and being grateful for what she has, rather than taking it for granted.

I’d find it far more annoying if a well off fortunate friend spent their time moaning about early retirement.

ShellGrotto · 10/10/2022 17:37

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 17:32

TheHideAndSeekingHill think she realises she is lucky.
She often says that she is so lucky she does not have to work.
As said to me. Oh , I am so lucky I dont have to work.

OP, it's your attitude that is the puzzling thing on this thread -- your friend if clearly materialistic, and either insensitive or quite socially dimwitted or both, and whichever it is, she's a crashing bore.

But you seem weirdly resistant to acknowledging that and you keep tiptoeing around the situation. Are you afraid of her? What's stopping you saying what most people would feel able to say to a real friend, 'Dial it down, you've been banging on about not working for a full calendar year, and it gets a bit dull for the rest of us!'?

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 17:32

TheHideAndSeekingHill think she realises she is lucky.
She often says that she is so lucky she does not have to work.
As said to me. Oh , I am so lucky I dont have to work.

OP posts:
TwoWrightFeet · 10/10/2022 17:31

I have a very wealthy friend who hasn’t worked in over a decade. I can’t imagine her ever behaving like this.

BitOutOfPractice · 10/10/2022 17:31

She sounds vulgar. Ugh.

orbitalcrisis · 10/10/2022 17:21

Maybe you should suggest she gets herself a little job somewhere, does some volunteering or gets a hobby so she has something else to talk about.

catandcoffee · 10/10/2022 17:20

Your update about mentioning money all the time.......she's bragging and gloating.

It's like people who don't say my car....instead my BMW or range rover ect.

I detest braggers

Cosmos123 · 10/10/2022 17:17

Maybe she is just in her honeymoon period of retirement.

Unless she specifically rubs people's face in it with comments such as 'I am rich I don't need to work' etc I would just change subject.

I have experienced similar but it never bothers me. Their life their journey. This is mine and I don't let it get me down.

orbitalcrisis · 10/10/2022 17:16

Does she have anything else in her life, or is being rich her only thing? She sounds as dull as a rock.

MrsNobodyMM · 10/10/2022 17:11

I couldn't be friends with someone like that she sounds mean. No one neurotypical would actually speak like that and not think of it as horrifically rude and insensitive.

Plus - yes it's great to be financially secure, but shes 50 with no job. Some people really value their careers and I wouldn't like the sneery "I'm better than everyone" "no one wants to work if they don't have to like meeee" vibe. Some people enjoy making a contribution in life. We all have different circumstances, as she would say!

She sounds an unbearable, bragging bore. Sitting around smiling at other retired people? Seriously?

GoldenOmber · 10/10/2022 17:09

Well, if she's as nice and well-intentioned as you believe she is, then surely she'd be mortified to think she was coming across as smug, gloaty and dim all the time. So you'd be doing her a favour by encouraging her to have a bit of a think.

TheHideAndSeekingHill · 10/10/2022 17:08

"while it's very nice for you and I'm happy for you, other people do still need to work to have adequate money coming in, and I think some people might think you are being a bit gloaty." from one poster, or from another one "Look, friend, I am not sure if you’re aware but when you said that comment in the shop the other day, it clearly upset some people listening. I saw them sharing a bit of a look and I think it was a case of needing to read the room a bit better." are the right sort of lines to take I think.

She is clearly a huge show off but I don't suppose she wants EVERYONE to be saying she's a dickhead. If you can gently suggest to her that while it's great she's happy, talking about it is making other people think she's a bit self-centred and unaware of the hardships of others, she will probably come back saying "everyone has different circumstances", but then YOU have to be brave and say "well sometimes I do feel a bit like you're not aware of how lucky your circumstances are compared to others". That might give her pause for thought.

One of my friends responded to me telling him that we were finding money tight at the minute by telling me how much (a lot) he'd just earnt. I just went quiet for a bit (confused!) and then said "I think I just told you that we are in quite hard times and you replied saying how you've got x thousand pounds this month". He was aghast at himself when he heard it back. If your friend doesn't get it when you've put it to her, she probably is just a massively insensitive cow and I'd be backing away from the friendship and enjoying never hearing about her blooming retirement again.

Alternatively I'd say - but isn't it sad you had to work at all? 😁

Doingprettywellthanks · 10/10/2022 17:08

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 14:47

Its said
In their group
Its said to us ( workers)
Its said to people in shops .( who we know) .
Its said most times we meet.

How often do you actually get together?

Doingprettywellthanks · 10/10/2022 17:06

how close friends? How long have you known her? This aside, does your dh like her?

nokidshere · 10/10/2022 17:01

I'd be tempted to go all sympathetic about how bored she must be, what a shame. And maybe at a time when you're not talking specifically about retirement, find an excuse to say how it's a shame how some people get really quite dull when they retire if they constantly talk about it

Why would you do that though, this is a friend? Can people not talk to their friends anymore? Just tell her how she makes you feel, acknowledge that you have your own insecurities about the situation and tell her to stop going on about it.

If you really have to tiptoe round your friends then you need new ones.

nokidshere · 10/10/2022 16:56

She also says things like oh where is the buikder I have 6k cash to give him, oh, yes i do like this part of the garden , happy to have paid 3/ 4 million so i can share it with people. Oh yes that art work did cost us a lot.

Usually people who feel the need to tell everyone what they paid for everything are doing so from their own insecurities, like they have to 'prove' their success to others.

The thing i find hardest ( and its my crap)is the oh must divide some money up for the kids . Its good to be able to help them . Knowing that its a form of guilt for me as I cant help mine and ive been upset about it. Ive said I am glad for you, but hearing it makes me feel guilty in the past. She did say well, we all have different circumstances.

This is not her problem it's yours. What is the point in feeling guilty? Off the top off my head I'd bet there are a huge number of households that can't help their children financially. You have nothing to feel guilty about, and, even if you did, it would still be a wasted emotion. Your friend isn't responsible for your insecurities. Ignore and nod, tell her she's being an arse or get rid of her as a friend.

BusySittingDown · 10/10/2022 16:55

"Goodness me, I'd be soooo BORED not working!"

"It feels good to have a purpose."

(I actually hate it when people say this as I feel like it implies that people who don't work are brain dead).

Oliverfunyuns · 10/10/2022 16:53

She can be happy and joyful all she wants. Frequently gloating (yes, gloating) about it in front of people she knows aren't in the same position is just... rude! She's either clueless or intentionally rude, and it's difficult to see how she could fail to understand how it must come across to others. Does she not see their reactions? Unless she's generally lacking in emotional intelligence, I'd not feel inclined to be charitable in my estimation of her behaviour in this case.

That said, I doubt I'd raise it with her "formally". Some subtle, jokey reactions (urgh, please don't rub it in, etc.) might get the point across, or you could pretending you can't hear her gloating comments, giving no response at all. Tbh, she should already know that she's being annoying!

TeaTurtle · 10/10/2022 16:53

From all your posts, she sounds smug and gloating. She knows what she is doing.

Calandor · 10/10/2022 16:51

I think she feels awkward about it. And making the comments is kind of like picking at a scab. Like she feels she has to mention it because she feels a bit weird about everyone else still having to work.

Stiltonlover · 10/10/2022 16:51

She also says things like oh where is the buikder I have 6k cash to give him, oh, yes i do like this part of the garden , happy to have paid 3/ 4 million so i can share it with people. Oh yes that art work did cost us a lot.

She sounds absolutely awful!

I think if you consider more closely you'll see she's quite obsessed by money.

Why is she telling you she has to pay her builder? Let alone the amount?! Why is she talking about how much her garden cost?

She wants you to validate how well off she is, how well she's done for herself. Horrendous.

Try an experiment OP - next time, banish your (understandable) embarrassment and see how far she'll go.
"Gosh how did you retire so early?" "Really, how did you manage that?"
"Really, how much money do you have in your pension then?"
"Gosh how much was your annual salary to be able to save all that?"

If you do this every time, you'll either out-goad her and she'll stop doing it (hurrah!) or she'll continue and it will be crystal clear how money obsessed she really is.

Novum · 10/10/2022 16:50

I'd be tempted to go all sympathetic about how bored she must be, what a shame. And maybe at a time when you're not talking specifically about retirement, find an excuse to say how it's a shame how some people get really quite dull when they retire if they constantly talk about it

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 16:43

Psychonabike i am not defined by what dh thinks.. perhaps I didnt explain correctly.

I was trying to say these are his thoughts . Because.. at present I recognise that am struggling to form my own in this particular (confusing )instance. But that these are the ideas he has come up with for now .. and asking if any of his thoughts rang true to anyone..( alongside recognition of my own struggle to quite get in touch with my own thoughts as yet )

OP posts:
Mosaic123 · 10/10/2022 16:41

I'd think your friend was not very bright to be so inconsiderate of others' feelings.

Eatmycake3333 · 10/10/2022 16:39

she sounds like she’s full of her own self importance!

Swipe left for the next trending thread