Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand this comment..

139 replies

Oncloud · 10/10/2022 13:18

We have a very wealthy friend who has retired at 50 and will never need to work again.
We are very lucky in that whilst we are older than that, we both manage by working part time , live frugally with a modest house.
By the nature of being working people we sometimes discuss our jobs... and that they are ok , not ok etc.. part of life.
She often says , in this context.. oh but i dont have to work, and claps her hands.
She often says also its wonderful to be retired. In a shop last week she said, hows the job , to a woman we know, followed by, oh i never have to work again.its great. Big smile.
My dh finds this either
A. A bit insensitive
B. A bit lacking in emotional intelligence.
C.( if he is feeling a little grumpy)
.. gloating. But hopes it is not the latter .

This person has had a full on supporting job role in the past. It is not like its been life in a bubble
. It does grate a bit at times and you see the look on peoples faces ,but she doesnt seem notice or to get that
It is a little insensitive especially in the current climate.
I find that its a bit annoying but i am seeking to understand that it could be just her ( she has an actively cultivated attitude of positivity towards life) .. am trying to find out if anyone has a different perspective of what this could be?? The responses i mean.. as i want not to go down the iabu route and be a grumpy and judgy human./ making assumptions .

Hence the request for others views.!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThreeblackCats · 12/10/2022 20:53

Your friend is a twat!
no need to be so smug, twatish or inconsiderate. Jshe’s just a dick.
embarrassed for her, not!

ShinglesThinBonesWhiskersBunions · 12/10/2022 20:47

Your friend seconds smug and gloating.

I have a friend that was gifted a despite for a house in her very early 20s. They got a 100% mortgage and regularly loan money for holidays.

They seem to shoe horn that they bought their house for £33k and how much it is worth now. Lots of our friends live in smaller rented property.

Comments about her luck/good fortune are too much. I had a chat. When you said 'direct quote' it made me feel xyz (not bring other people into it). I have told them there behaviour makes me uncomfortable. I really do love her, I'm happy she is secure . If these type of comments don't stop, I won't see them as much or I'll leave. I really find it obnoxious and toxic.

M0rT · 12/10/2022 19:38

This could be her trying to be 100% positive about something that deep down she has niggles over.
Retirement, even very early retirement is the phase of life before you die.
This makes some people uncomfortable.

Hollybobs1 · 12/10/2022 19:25

She sounds like a narcissist

MumAsYouAre · 12/10/2022 19:03

What else does she say? (To a friend in a wheelchair) “I love walking, it’s great!”

She sounds like a massive bellend.

MossCoveredTree · 11/10/2022 10:48

I would actually see this as a remark made out of embarrassment and also trying to convince herself she has made the right decision to retire. She is very young to be retired. I would imagine this will stop at some point. Unless she tends to make other unpleasant remarks or is insensitive in a lot of other areas - I would put it down to her having worked so long she struggles to 'frame' herself outside of work.

In the meantime, if you do have the sort of relationship where you can banter with her - next time she does it I would say, laughing 'rub it in why don't you', 'it is alright for some isn't it', 'look at old money bags over here' 'spare a thought for us peasants still working to eek out a living' (in a light hearted way)

FayeGovan · 11/10/2022 10:15

People can be utter fuckwits.
When i was waitressing for minimum wage i had one guy telling me i should retire at 50 as that was what he did. I remember standing there with my heavy tray and thinking WTF...

billy1966 · 11/10/2022 09:55

Your husband sounds like he at least has the measure of her.

bingbummy · 11/10/2022 09:51

When you said she had jobs in the past I got it. I feel exactly the same. In fact I do this (privately) all the time because I never have to work again either, though I do.

It's like being released from prison. Full-time work you don't love robs life of all joy. I know, I've been there.

AtrociousCircumstance · 11/10/2022 09:28

He sounds fine and like he’s assessed things pretty accurately.

Doingprettywellthanks · 11/10/2022 08:57

My dh finds this either
A. A bit insensitive
B. A bit lacking in emotional intelligence.
C.( if he is feeling a little grumpy).. gloating. But hopes it is not the latter .

well doesn’t he just sound like a gem 🤔

Carlycat · 11/10/2022 00:20

She sounds unbearable. You have the patience of a saint putting up with her insensitive gloating, which is generally a cover for insecurity and low self esteem

FictionalCharacter · 10/10/2022 19:59

What @Rainbowshine said.
She’s insensitive and gloating whether or not she thinks she is. She’s been going on like this every time she sees you for a year??! How tedious.
The excessive talking about money is ridiculous and rather sad.
Would she say to someone struggling with money “oh I have plenty of money” and clap her hands like a toddler? Maybe she would! I wouldn’t want to spend much time with someone like her. She can get all the attention she needs from her self-congratulatory circle of retired friends.

cansu · 10/10/2022 19:34

Insensitive and gloating.
I have experienced this from a former colleague. I always thought she was lovely. Since she retired she makes many insufferable comments like this. I just avoid her really. I also can't help wondering if she is a bit bored. I can't really account for it otherwise.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 10/10/2022 19:21

I'd start telling her how it's becoming a real worry for the generation below you, how so many people in their 50s are becoming prematurely economically inactive. "I mean, as if they don't have it hard enough, with house prices being so unaffordable to them...." etc etc.

Oysterbabe · 10/10/2022 18:55

She sounds super annoying, but I will totally be like this if / when I retire. I won't be able to contain my excitement at leaving my horrible fucking job behind.

Doingprettywellthanks · 10/10/2022 18:53

BronwenFrideswide · 10/10/2022 18:48

Your friend is sounding more and more like one of those insufferable types who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

Clearly money obsessed and thinks that bestows status, the more you say about her the more the comments sound like looking down on others who are not in her position, a very ugly trait. The more you write the more obvious it is that she knows exactly what her comments are like, that she is bragging as she defends them by saying everyone's circumstances are different.

I wouldn't want to spend much time with someone so shallow.

She sounds like this because this is how the Op views her and presents her as such. Who knows whether accurate or not, but either way - clearly this isn’t someone the OP is particularly fond of so it’s a friendship on the decline I would say.

Gottagetthruthissss · 10/10/2022 18:53

TheEponymousGrub · Today 13:27

I'd reply, laughingly, "All, right, stop rubbing it in!"
And each time she said it, my laugh would get a leeetle bit smaller.

😂

Octomore · 10/10/2022 18:51

Your DH is spot on. Except its not either A, B or C - it's all three of them at once. She's an insensitive gloater.

BronwenFrideswide · 10/10/2022 18:48

Your friend is sounding more and more like one of those insufferable types who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

Clearly money obsessed and thinks that bestows status, the more you say about her the more the comments sound like looking down on others who are not in her position, a very ugly trait. The more you write the more obvious it is that she knows exactly what her comments are like, that she is bragging as she defends them by saying everyone's circumstances are different.

I wouldn't want to spend much time with someone so shallow.

Benjispruce4 · 10/10/2022 18:19

It’s called reading the room.

FleeUpFreeTime · 10/10/2022 18:00

If I didn’t have to work I’d be happy clappy too
why is she insensitive- because you have to work. Those are the cards we’ve been dealt. I wouldn’t begrudge her any seconds of utter happiness and I wouldn’t be offended by her

FistFullOfRegrets · 10/10/2022 17:55

nokidshere · 10/10/2022 14:44

The clapping her hands and being gleeful sounds childlike, maybe that's just her mannerisms.

I'm retired, my friends are not. I love being retired and they hate working, it is what it is. I empathise when they are moaning about work, tease them that they 'only' have 10 more years to go, they tell me to 'stop showing off' or moan about how lucky I am.

There's nothing wrong with enjoying the phase of your life you are in. I'm not going to stop telling them (and they wouldn't want me to) when I've had a lovely lazy day just because they are bogged down at work.

I've worked my 45yrs, it's not my fault that they are younger than me.

The hard thing for me was in a retired group of her and retired friends saying , isnt it wonderful to be retired and smile at each other. I said one of us isnt.

So no one is allowed to be happy they are retired because you aren't? That's just being silly. I would have replied to that comment 'yeah you lucky buggers'.

I think, to s degree, it's kind of 'ok' for that kind of banter, when you're significantly younger than you as long as you take the banter the other way. But it's no so great when you're the same age & have just been fortunate enough to be in a better financial position.

@Oncloud
There's always a social dance, some people are good at it, others aren't. It sounds like your friend is NOT. Your friend sounds lacking in social awareness, did you find this in any way before she retired?

it's hard to know what to say you could/should do without knowing her.

probably a few harmless quips?

'Well someone has to keep the wheels of progress turning'

'if we all retired at 50, who would run the world'

'🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

WisherWood · 10/10/2022 17:47

The more you say about her OP the more it sounds as if she's incredibly insecure and needs somebody around who she perceives as less successful than her in order to bolster her self-esteem and to gloat. And sadly, that person is you. You're perfect for this because you lack confidence and haven't done what the rest of us would have done, which is just to say 'oh, are you retired? I'd forgotten, you so rarely say so'.

Looked at in this light, you might find the generosity is just another way of lording it over someone. 'Look at me, I'm so marvellous, here I am, helping out the helpless peasants'. I'd be distancing myself. Few hundred miles and an ocean would do it.

TheHideAndSeekingHill · 10/10/2022 17:42

Is there anything in her life she's NOT happy with? given what you've said I think the only way to make her understand is how she'd feel if someone gloated over something she can't have e.g. "I'm so lucky to have such successful children!" or "I'm soooo lucky to be in good health" etc