Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emergency rent freeze laws passed !!??

264 replies

happyfishcoco · 10/10/2022 12:51

Emergency rent freeze laws passed in Scotland
and Welsh maybe follow.

YABU = vote agree to rent freeze
YANBU = vote for not agree to rent freeze

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-63164850.amp

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-63131075.amp

OP posts:
Notimetothink · 10/10/2022 19:31

Just wait till they bring in the planned legislation to prevent any house being sold with less than a D energy certificate. The days of a fixer upper will be over, and people will find it even harder to buy their own homes as it will push up prices. I can see many properties lying empty.

Grumpycatsmum · 10/10/2022 19:18

NicolaSixSix · 10/10/2022 17:11

@Bumpitybumper how is it the tenant’s problem that the landlord has an interest only mortgage so has opted not to pay towards the asset? Seems like a bad decision or worse on the part of the LL

It's not about whether it's the tenant's problem. Or whether the landlord has made a bad decision.
Most landlords (like every other type of investor) will only hold an asset if it is likely to make money in the short or long term. If it's going to lose money they will eventually sell and that will mean les properties available to rent unless (i) more public house for rent is constructed (ii) landlords who are cash buyers enter the market - and they tend to prefer small flats not family properties or (iii) houses become more affordable for former tenants - not likely at the moment because of increased interest rates, even if house prices fall.

Buggsilla · 10/10/2022 18:54

Hankunamatata · 10/10/2022 12:55

We need rent control around the country with regional set rates to allow affordable housing for everyone

Historically when rents have been controlled, the amount of stock available to rent has declined. Think about that.

Badnewsoracle · 10/10/2022 18:49

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 18:24

Can’t give tenants more legal protections as landlords will sell up.

Can't freeze rents because landlords will sell up.

Can’t do X Y or Z for tenants because landlords will sell up.

Urgh.

Well that's true. BUT there are things that the government could do which would help out renters without penalising the landlord. But make being a landlord unprofitable and yes, they'll sell up. If those properties were being replaced by social housing it'd be ok, but it isn't. And there's an enormous swathe of people who will never be able to, or want to buy.

justasking111 · 10/10/2022 18:44

justasking111 · 10/10/2022 18:38

Had a look at our council property to let 3 beds in a bad, bad area. That's daylight robbery round here. That's our council for you 🙈

Sorry £900 pcm. I'm that mad my brains fried

justasking111 · 10/10/2022 18:38

Had a look at our council property to let 3 beds in a bad, bad area. That's daylight robbery round here. That's our council for you 🙈

GaladrielHiggins · 10/10/2022 18:37

We need more council or HA housing providing decent accommodation at a fair price. That’s what the govt should be concentrating on. That’s the only way people will have secure, long term, homes. Letting people buy their council houses is fine as long as they keep the supply of council houses at a high enough level.

AuntSalli · 10/10/2022 18:36

@Eeksteek The issue in times gone by has always been with 100% mortgages they are aimed at precisely the kind of people who should never have a mortgage. As with everything when the risk increases for the lender as does the rate, it’s rarely the case the people are better off with those mortgages than renting, at best they might not be worse off but then of course something happens. The something might be losing their job, it might be major repairs to the house, it might be a relationship breakdown. And because there’s no skin in the game as such only the money that they’ve paid off by making the repayments people think they can walk away. Amongst my school friendship group in the late 90s 2000s we saw quite a few of them either remortgage and spunk the equity away on cars and holidays.
Or one of the above happened and they literally just handed the keys back having spent years spending two or £300 more than they would have on rent,l and the home maintenance etc. additionally you used to get clobbered with 12 years for the banks to recover the debt of believe they’ve now reduced that to 6 though.

it’s also not widely known but if you get a property repossessed no High Street lenders going to touch you with the bargepole for a long time. And it’s quite likely the groups will share information so if you are repossessed by anyone in the bank of Scotland‘s group for example they will never lend to you again.

It can work for some people and in fact it did work for me right back in 1998 that’s how I got on the ladder but I bought the house for literally two times my annual income so working in a bar I could cover that mortgage it was absolute buttons.

Manekinek0 · 10/10/2022 18:32

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 18:24

Can’t give tenants more legal protections as landlords will sell up.

Can't freeze rents because landlords will sell up.

Can’t do X Y or Z for tenants because landlords will sell up.

Urgh.

But you would expect any other business to run at a loss?

Cyw2018 · 10/10/2022 18:30

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 18:24

Can’t give tenants more legal protections as landlords will sell up.

Can't freeze rents because landlords will sell up.

Can’t do X Y or Z for tenants because landlords will sell up.

Urgh.

The answer is to build more houses, in order to control the supply and demand related house price rises, and to build copious amounts of social housing, as any good government should do, so that government can have an impact on rental controls through competition.

The reality is that the government is just creating a situation that forces LL to sell into a housing market that is so bouyant that the prices still maintain even with the extra properties.

Then the government make the LL the villans when in fact it is their incompetence.

Bad LL who rent unsafe properties should be banned from being LL. But we still desperately need good LL. Not this current situation.

justasking111 · 10/10/2022 18:29

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 18:24

Can’t give tenants more legal protections as landlords will sell up.

Can't freeze rents because landlords will sell up.

Can’t do X Y or Z for tenants because landlords will sell up.

Urgh.

The big boys hide behind shell companies based abroad. Our council spent 15 years chasing one. They'd just start up new companies dodging and diving. They were never caught shadow selling to themselves again and again

WhatsAVideo · 10/10/2022 18:24

Can’t give tenants more legal protections as landlords will sell up.

Can't freeze rents because landlords will sell up.

Can’t do X Y or Z for tenants because landlords will sell up.

Urgh.

HRTQueen · 10/10/2022 18:24

Agree

i have already been contacted by a number of estate agents telling me now is a great time to get the best from the rental market

I’ve never increased rent while I have had good tenants in

justasking111 · 10/10/2022 18:22

Cyw2018 · 10/10/2022 18:03

Most LL do have a back up business plan, it's just not very palatable.

Section 21 and sell!

DIL friend works in a big solicitor practice. They're flat out issuing eviction notices. Just seen on the news 90k homeless in Wales that's going to rise

IncessantNameChanger · 10/10/2022 18:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/10/2022 18:00

Easy, the landlord will have accounted for increased costs while creating their business plan and will have both the capital and a system in place to deal with unexpected rises in costs, maybe at a reduction in profits until things settle down.

What? Many landlords don’t have a cash reserve or business plan in place? Many overextended themselves when taking out a btl mortgage and can’t cope with a slight increase in their business costs? Well, sounds like those landlords should never have been allowed to become landlords and it probably isn’t a bad thing to be getting them out of the sector once and for all.

Of course most LL have a business plan. But when you think about 10% interest rates it's more of a "shit I hope that doesn't happen again" I could do 10% in theory , but do you know what? Now I have more kids and slmist two decades in this behind me, I wouldn't want to, when it comes to it being a possible reality with rent freezes and ever increasing energy restrictions, and removal of section 21s. Then the whole package means its too much. If they introduce the new energy ratings as law, I don't have the 10k sitting in the bank. On top of increasing interest rates.

If I was to sell I think it's far more likely an investor will buy my house then it being sold for under 100k. I just can't see a glut of 40k houses flooding the market. My house was bought for 135k. It's 300k now. How low would it need to go for a renter with no deposit to buy?

JustAnotherManicMomday · 10/10/2022 18:18

Personally unless they freeze mortgages its unfair to freeze rent. Many home owners are feeling the pinch as well. I'm talking about those who only own one property.

AuntSalli · 10/10/2022 18:18

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/10/2022 18:00

Easy, the landlord will have accounted for increased costs while creating their business plan and will have both the capital and a system in place to deal with unexpected rises in costs, maybe at a reduction in profits until things settle down.

What? Many landlords don’t have a cash reserve or business plan in place? Many overextended themselves when taking out a btl mortgage and can’t cope with a slight increase in their business costs? Well, sounds like those landlords should never have been allowed to become landlords and it probably isn’t a bad thing to be getting them out of the sector once and for all.

Actually most landlords don’t have a mortgage. And that’s the fly in the little house price crash ointment isn’t it ?

Grumpycatsmum · 10/10/2022 18:17

StillNotWarm · 10/10/2022 13:30

Lack of rental properties is already an issue, and this is just going to make more landlords sell up. It is only viable after a prolonged period of building and maintaining social housing.

This ☝️

Figmentofmyimagination · 10/10/2022 18:16

In Glasgow this September, the university was recommending to students part way through their degree that they either defer or give up because of the absence of student housing. This is a direct result of landlord reaction to the threatened rent freeze. Around 250,000 rental homes have been withdrawn from the market. Be careful what you wish for. Don’t invite students from outside Scotland if you can’t house them. Just be honest and tell them this is now a ‘commuter-only’ university, for Scottish students who live with their parents.

Badnewsoracle · 10/10/2022 18:08

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/10/2022 18:00

Easy, the landlord will have accounted for increased costs while creating their business plan and will have both the capital and a system in place to deal with unexpected rises in costs, maybe at a reduction in profits until things settle down.

What? Many landlords don’t have a cash reserve or business plan in place? Many overextended themselves when taking out a btl mortgage and can’t cope with a slight increase in their business costs? Well, sounds like those landlords should never have been allowed to become landlords and it probably isn’t a bad thing to be getting them out of the sector once and for all.

Most of those landlords DONT have a buy to let mortgage. They have residential mortgages with consent to let. Usually given because they have struggled to sell or such. Those mortgage deals have expired and they are now paying a variable rate. And can't now get BTL mortgages as the yield is too small. Which is why loads have and are selling up.

Cyw2018 · 10/10/2022 18:03

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/10/2022 18:00

Easy, the landlord will have accounted for increased costs while creating their business plan and will have both the capital and a system in place to deal with unexpected rises in costs, maybe at a reduction in profits until things settle down.

What? Many landlords don’t have a cash reserve or business plan in place? Many overextended themselves when taking out a btl mortgage and can’t cope with a slight increase in their business costs? Well, sounds like those landlords should never have been allowed to become landlords and it probably isn’t a bad thing to be getting them out of the sector once and for all.

Most LL do have a back up business plan, it's just not very palatable.

Section 21 and sell!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/10/2022 18:00

MintJulia · 10/10/2022 13:40

So, how would it work?

Interest rate rises. Landlord's btl mortgage goes up. Landlord is unable to pay increase on btl mortgage. Landlord is forced to sell to avoid bankruptcy. Tenant ends up homeless because new owner wants to live in their house.

How does that help the tenant?

Easy, the landlord will have accounted for increased costs while creating their business plan and will have both the capital and a system in place to deal with unexpected rises in costs, maybe at a reduction in profits until things settle down.

What? Many landlords don’t have a cash reserve or business plan in place? Many overextended themselves when taking out a btl mortgage and can’t cope with a slight increase in their business costs? Well, sounds like those landlords should never have been allowed to become landlords and it probably isn’t a bad thing to be getting them out of the sector once and for all.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 10/10/2022 17:54

LizzieMacQueen · 10/10/2022 15:50

Sorry HRTFT do someone upthread may have mentioned this, but the law in Scotland ( to end of March only ) still has a get out clause - landlords whose expenses such as mortgage have increased them, the law simply doesn't apply to them.

That's not correct.

Landlords can ask for rent to be increased by 50% of increased interest rates but cannot exceed 3% of the previous rent.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 10/10/2022 17:50

antelopevalley · 10/10/2022 15:46

@Jjones8 Good. We need buy to let landlords to leave the market. Buy to let was responsible for pushing house prices up amazingly high. Before the invention of these mortgages, house prices had to remain at the level that first time buyers could afford.

I don't know about England but buy to let landlords are only a small proportion of the Scottish private rented market.

Eeksteek · 10/10/2022 17:49

AuntSalli · 10/10/2022 16:58

Goes back to my original point 100% percent mortgages are on their way.

For some people that will work out really well and for other people who lead chaotic lives it will end in absolute disaster but it keeps the money merry-go-round going around.

The absolute last thing the government wants is people being able to retire on unearned income. And far too many people in their mid to late 50s have done that in the last two years so any obstacles that they can put in their place they will.

@AuntSalli I’m wondering if 100% mortgages wouldn’t be a good thing? It would mean a lot of things that renters want - long term stability, ‘ownership’ over homes, benefit from low interest rates (if we ever see them again) no bastard landlord (except the bank). You’d build equity really slowly, but you’d own a home. Well, effectively you’d have a lifetime tenancy with the bank. The different between landlords and mortgage lenders is only the practical bit, really. Most of being landlord is letting a tenant borrow the cost of your deposit, as well as pay the mortgage (and repairs and regulatory stuff). It would cut out a lot of middlemen.

I think it would have worked when people bought a house and lived in it for fifty years. But people don’t do that now.

Tons (more) of landlords are going to sell up. If interest rates go up, that means you can put the equity in savings and get a decent return. That hasn’t been the case for decades. Who wants to be reviled and have to deal with tenants, when you could just the cash sit in the bank, instead? For many years there hadn’t been much of an alternative for small landlords.