Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does my partner owe me cash for injuring me ?

137 replies

Namehasbeenchangedtoprotecttheinnocent · 10/10/2022 12:47

Partner and I had a fight a year ago. It got physical and my finger got broken. Never been physical before or since. Both of us very ashamed. Basically- I’d been drinking & he was sober. Big argument kicked off. I went to bed as could see where it was heading ( big argument I mean-
not physical fight) I told him to sleep in other room but he followed me in and continued arguing. Tried to take duvet off bed. I was shouting at him and holding onto duvet. He slapped me ( only time ever happened) and there was scuffle. Finger obviously broken and confirmed by ED. So this were gets complicated. Turns out I have benign tumour in finger which why broke so easily.
Had hellish year of operations/ bone grafts / infections which has cost me a fortune and all my sick pay. I’m angry as if he hadn’t assaulted me in first place this wouldn’t be happening ( but probably would have at some point ) but yes not his fault I had tumour which means it broke so easily / isn’t healing. So AIBU to expect him to pay for operations or generally feel responsible
for what happened or do I suck it up?

This not about how dysfunctional it was to have this fight in the first place- that’s a WHOLE other post! Genuinely interested in peoples thoughts

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Noteverybodylives · 11/10/2022 06:00

What an odd relationship.

Namehasbeenchangedtoprotecttheinnocent · 10/10/2022 21:24

Again it’s a benign tumour. No danger of it spreading or cancer. Also there’s no question of me suing him. Just as someone said “does he have a moral obligation to help with the financial fallout”. We don’t have shared finances at all due to various non relevant reasons - mostly me though as had rough divorce - (no not rough like that ) and like to have total control of my money and how it is used. Ergo my frustration at medical bills I feel I didn’t deserve or contribute to the cause of. BUT about 97% of people disagree with me so glad I asked as don’t want to make what is / was a shitty situation worse.

OP posts:
Noteverybodylives · 10/10/2022 17:33

No your ex doesn’t owe you any money.

ZiriForEver · 10/10/2022 17:27

I don't think the OP is after legal advice here.

Demonstrating different legal approaches can be useful as it explains the reasoning, but no one is sueing anyone now.

I understand the question as asking for support for/warning against opening this topic with her partner.

The obvious answers are that a real partner is person who would offer, or at least where she wouldn't feel bad about discussing it.
When discussing, I see it as a result of common action, so I 'd expect common remedy.

Upsidedownagain · 10/10/2022 17:00

Don't partners share costs and help each other out? If he's not doing that, he's not much of a partner.

girlmom21 · 10/10/2022 16:58

Novum · 10/10/2022 16:55

OP, you might do better posting in the legal section. It's extraordinary how people who have no clue about the relevant legal principles always post with such confidence on issues like this on threads like AIBU and Chat, and in fact it's really quite dangerous.

Considering she hasn't actually said where in the world she is, she won't necessarily get good legal advice, but if you're going to take your partner to court for payment you may as well end the relationship now.

CallTheMobWife · 10/10/2022 16:57

Novum · 10/10/2022 16:55

OP, you might do better posting in the legal section. It's extraordinary how people who have no clue about the relevant legal principles always post with such confidence on issues like this on threads like AIBU and Chat, and in fact it's really quite dangerous.

OP is not in the UK and could be anywhere in the world, with any legal system. Nobody, here or in Legal, can give her any useful legal advcie at all.

Novum · 10/10/2022 16:55

OP, you might do better posting in the legal section. It's extraordinary how people who have no clue about the relevant legal principles always post with such confidence on issues like this on threads like AIBU and Chat, and in fact it's really quite dangerous.

Novum · 10/10/2022 16:52

Crazykatie · 10/10/2022 16:42

If you were a visitor in his house yes, domestic third party insurance would cover it, generally members of the same “household” can’t sue each other, but I’m sure there are exceptions.

In your case you were drunk, the weakness in the finger was unknown and injury was not foreseeable, you would not win anyway. He was wrong slapping you but that’s a criminal offence nothing to do with compensation.

Completely untrue. There is nothing saying that people in the same household cannot sue each other, and this is potentially a civil wrong as well as a criminal offence.

Crazykatie · 10/10/2022 16:42

If you were a visitor in his house yes, domestic third party insurance would cover it, generally members of the same “household” can’t sue each other, but I’m sure there are exceptions.

In your case you were drunk, the weakness in the finger was unknown and injury was not foreseeable, you would not win anyway. He was wrong slapping you but that’s a criminal offence nothing to do with compensation.

ohidoliketobe · 10/10/2022 16:42

Directory for my local hospital.
Oh look at that - Accident and Emergency.

OP. Tricky one. I must say I think you are misdirecting your anger at his behaviourcausing you financial difficulties. Has this incident and the aftermath been discussed at your therapy sessions?

Does my partner owe me cash for injuring me ?
Needwine999 · 10/10/2022 16:32

Sorry but why are you still with this violent man?

Ponderingwindow · 10/10/2022 16:29

If he was truly your partner in life, you wouldn’t be facing medical bills and lost wages alone, regardless of how the injury happened. That your boyfriend is watching you struggle with the fallout from this “isolated” incident really doesn’t bode well for the long term viability of the relationship.

EndlessMagpies · 10/10/2022 16:28

Legally - I have no idea.

Morally - Yes, he darn well should. A decent person would think it was the right thing to pay at least some of your bills. But then he doesn't appear to be a decent person, seeing as it was he who assaulted you in the first place.

EvilRingahBitch · 10/10/2022 16:23

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 10/10/2022 15:31

In general, compensation is due if entity (person or company) A either took an action, or by negligence failed to take an action, which led to person B being injured and where it was reasonable that A should have forseen that such an injury (whether to B or to any unlucky person) might be expected as a potential outcome of their action or failure of action, and that they took no steps to warn or mitigate against that. Which is why you get warned "careful, it's hot" when you buy a coffee. If person A hits person B hard enough that B loses their balance, B may be uninjured or may fall at an awkward angle against something sharp and get seriously damaged, and A is liable for that because falling against something dangerous is a readily predictable potential consequence - so was this readily predictable?

If you were to sue your bf, the case would hinge on how much he could have expected his action to have caused you injury if he had thought about it for a moment. Of course he didn't know about the tumor, so the big question would be whether the injury would have still happened to a normally healthy finger that hadn't been weakened by the tumor. Obviously that has to be a guess, we can't know exactly.

In the UK at least (I don't know if this is the same in your country) civil cases like this go on the "balance of probabilities" rather than "beyond reasonable doubt" but on the basis of what you have posted, I would say that the balance of probabilities is that for a normal healthy finger, it would be so much less likely that a significant injury would be caused that he couldn't possibly have known what the consequence would be, and therefore he shouldn't be held liable.

As long as some form of injury is forseeable then the eggshell skull principle applies if the victim happens to be unusually vulnerable, both in civil and criminal law....in England.

InstaHun88 · 10/10/2022 16:21

When you get to the point of having to consider compensation for physical injury your relationship is over.

This. You cannot just have therapy and move on together. End it.

NumberTheory · 10/10/2022 16:17

I don’t know that you are being unreasonable. It depends a bit on the how the fight went down. But legally, losses from injuries caused by an assault are something you would have civil redress for in most jurisdictions.

ancientgran · 10/10/2022 15:49

If he's your partner I'd expect you to be sharing the costs regardless of fault.

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/10/2022 15:34

Noviembre · 10/10/2022 15:31

Jesus. What a life some people lead.

Indeed . . .

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/10/2022 15:33

You are as bad as each other!
But instead of complaining that your finger broke too soon, why not just be grateful that it has been discovered when it has and get it sorted?

It could have been horribly far advanced if this hadn't happened.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 10/10/2022 15:31

In general, compensation is due if entity (person or company) A either took an action, or by negligence failed to take an action, which led to person B being injured and where it was reasonable that A should have forseen that such an injury (whether to B or to any unlucky person) might be expected as a potential outcome of their action or failure of action, and that they took no steps to warn or mitigate against that. Which is why you get warned "careful, it's hot" when you buy a coffee. If person A hits person B hard enough that B loses their balance, B may be uninjured or may fall at an awkward angle against something sharp and get seriously damaged, and A is liable for that because falling against something dangerous is a readily predictable potential consequence - so was this readily predictable?

If you were to sue your bf, the case would hinge on how much he could have expected his action to have caused you injury if he had thought about it for a moment. Of course he didn't know about the tumor, so the big question would be whether the injury would have still happened to a normally healthy finger that hadn't been weakened by the tumor. Obviously that has to be a guess, we can't know exactly.

In the UK at least (I don't know if this is the same in your country) civil cases like this go on the "balance of probabilities" rather than "beyond reasonable doubt" but on the basis of what you have posted, I would say that the balance of probabilities is that for a normal healthy finger, it would be so much less likely that a significant injury would be caused that he couldn't possibly have known what the consequence would be, and therefore he shouldn't be held liable.

Noviembre · 10/10/2022 15:31

Jesus. What a life some people lead.

IncompleteSenten · 10/10/2022 15:21

Legally I would imagine the fact you've stayed with him would go against you. Morally yes he should meet the medical costs of an injury he caused.

Anonymous48 · 10/10/2022 15:13

Putting aside everything else - you had an argument that became physical that you don't seem to see as a problem, etc. - the fact that you are asking if your partner owe you cash shows that this is not a normal healthy relationship or "partnership". My friends and I sometimes owe each other cash, as do my siblings and I. My husband and I never owe each other cash, because we are a partnership.

Buggsilla · 10/10/2022 15:06

Leaving aside the fact you were drunk which was entirely your own doing. The tumor is nothing to do with him. It would've surfaced at some point and you'd have had the same bills. It would be nice if he was in a position to help with the bills & willing to do so, but he has no obligation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread