Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State vs independent school open days

318 replies

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 08:57

Please tell me if I’m BU…

Looking at secondary schools. Have been to 3 independent school open mornings, 3 more to look at. Each school has sent an itinerary of the morning and a clear email so we know what to expect (really helpful when deciding if the children should come or not - not all tours have activities for younger siblings but some do).

Also trying to look at two state options but they have one fixed open evening and that’s it. No flexibility. No option for a smaller tour mid week, no option to speak to a member of staff outside that one evening.

The state schools are over subscribed and so I understand that they don’t massively need to “sell” themselves. But the independent schools are massively oversubscribed too and yet are happy to make time for children and parents to work out which school is the best fit.

Also, all the independent schools have their open days on Saturdays. Which means that most parents can actually make it with some notice.

Just a bit pissed off and needed a rant. I absolutely cannot choose a school based on a rushed evening visit without the chance to ask questions properly.

OP posts:
MsMarch · 10/10/2022 11:59

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:54

@Plumbear2 @ancientgran @MsTSwift
other posters have shared very different experiences with state schools. I don’t expect the school to put on an extra open evening for me. I am disappointed that there is one 3 hour window per year for the school to show prospective parents and children around.

While the difference between accessibility for state and independent is significant, you appear to have particularly inaccessible state schools if you can't get any time with the SENCO and there's only one open day.

DS' school has had one open evening and at least 2 open mornings this term alone (he keeps coming home to tell me who he saw from his primary school today!) and last year was the same. I also had a private conversation with the SENCO of both local schools while I was assessing which one would be best for him and I seem to recall the other state school had similar amounts of accessibility. Certainly, we spent an evening at each of them in addition to my private conversations with the SENCOs.

His school also does a virtual open evening which is available via their website - although it's recorded, not live - so quite helpful to review in advance.

So perhaps in your case, the independents are the way to go.

ancientgran · 10/10/2022 11:57

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:54

@Plumbear2 @ancientgran @MsTSwift
other posters have shared very different experiences with state schools. I don’t expect the school to put on an extra open evening for me. I am disappointed that there is one 3 hour window per year for the school to show prospective parents and children around.

You do realise that not all schools have the same challenges? Well of course you do or you wouldn't need to visit them. Schools in some areas have staff shortages, supply teacher shortages and staff run ragged.

You are commenting on these open evenings and you haven't even been to one.

ancientgran · 10/10/2022 11:55

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:19

@southlondoner02 the school I really do want to see most of all offers one open evening a year. That’s it. Just seems so limiting.

You could have gone last year, I did that as it helped with working out if we would do 11 plus. Shame you didn't plan ahead.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:54

@Plumbear2 @ancientgran @MsTSwift
other posters have shared very different experiences with state schools. I don’t expect the school to put on an extra open evening for me. I am disappointed that there is one 3 hour window per year for the school to show prospective parents and children around.

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 10/10/2022 11:51

I had a friend that was forever ringing the primary head and got upset that the school communication wasn’t great. She went private which for them was absolutely the right call - if you as a parent need that level of service you have to pay for it sadly.

ancientgran · 10/10/2022 11:48

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:39

@ittakes2 ok, but I am also a current parent in independent and state schools. Both schools are really as flexible and accommodating for parents as they can be. One open evening and nothing else seems pretty unimpressive.

My DD teaches in a state secondary school, she regularly is in school from 8 am to 5.30 or 6 pm. On parents evenings, new student inductions and open evenings (one for year 7 and one for sixth form) she is there from 8 am to 9 pm. She has one of these evenings at least once a month. She also has work to do at home.

I'm not sure how much more you think she should be doing or how much her students would suffer is she is expected to do anymore and ends up collapsing with exhaustion.

Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 11:34

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:19

@southlondoner02 the school I really do want to see most of all offers one open evening a year. That’s it. Just seems so limiting.

It takes alot of hard work, planning and time to have that one open evening. Schools have multiple other things do aswell open evenings for other events for children already in the school. After school sporting events, choirs, bands. All of which stop for open evenings. They also have to arrange for pupils to be available in the evening to show parents around. Alot a work goes into this, and you expect them to arrange another just because you carnt organise the time?

ihatesteve · 10/10/2022 11:31

In my city there are a couple of very good state schools that are lottery based. Ex independents. They have full on open evenings which are not dissimilar to the independents promo events. Although open to all (if your name is pulled out of the hat) they clearly want children of interested parents that don't just automatically send to their local school. To appeal to that demographic they have to put on open days.

The good over subscribed state in my area holds one open evening and if you don't book months in advance it is full and you can't go. There wasn't much in the way of display.

My children's over subscribed indi shuts for the afternoon on open evening to prepare and most kids are roped in to show people around / put on exhibitions.

I think the majority of state schools just don't need to showcase themselves in this way so don't bother. Its a shame they don't though as i think children learn a lot of soft skills showing others around and it generates pride in their community.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:19

@southlondoner02 the school I really do want to see most of all offers one open evening a year. That’s it. Just seems so limiting.

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:18

@ReadyForPumpkins am definitely listening to what local friends and colleagues have to say too

OP posts:
southlondoner02 · 10/10/2022 11:18

If one of your children is in state school could you talk to them about their opinion of the school regarding sen support? I found primary was a font of knowledge about different secondaries, having transitioned lots of kids over the years.

Sorry if I missed it but do they not also do any open mornings? There were a few we couldn't get to in the evening so I took some annual leave to go to a morning session. Much quieter and more space to ask questions

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 11:17

@Collienova except the post above your from @zippygeorgebungle shows that state schools can and do offer excellent help with open days

OP posts:
ReadyForPumpkins · 10/10/2022 11:11

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:06

But tell me. How can I choose a school based on one open evening with hundreds of other parents so I can’t have more than a hurried chat with anyone? That’s crackers.

This is very simple. Ask the parents in your children's primary school who has siblings in the secondaries. Almost all state primaries will have many children in the local state secondaries. These are independent reviews, similar to what you get in tripadvisor and air bnb. Is that not good enough?

Collienova · 10/10/2022 11:10

As many have said already, you really are expecting private sector treatment in a state environment. Not going to happen.

You do come across as entitled even if you insist you aren’t. You have very specific questions regarding the SENCO provision. Contact them to ask them outside the open day. If they’re not happy to accommodate you, then that’s an answer right there, isn’t it?

or just go independent; it sounds like you need the contact time they can offer.

zippygeorgebungle · 10/10/2022 11:08

I do understand OP difficulty as I'm a lone parent to kids ranging from nursery age to year 6 and work full time in a busy profession. But I have found where I've had a specific question of the state schools I've visited (4 of them and off to 2 primaries next month...) they have emailed me back straight away. Eg I asked about them continuing two modern foreign languages they were studying at primary into year 7. I went to a private school open day and bursary evening and both were a bit less welcoming actually, and the open day had a full school in session which had some advantages but also felt a lot busier than the four hour state Saturday open morning which was purely there to show all departments eg a bit of cooking, a bit of a scary science experiment. The pupils got to do a bit of a task in every single department and there was a quiz treasure hunt thing which my younger ones loved.

Dixiechickonhols · 10/10/2022 10:56

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 10:50

@Dixiechickonhols no, I appreciate your thoughts. The issue on that night is one child has an away match for school (compulsory) so can’t be collected until 6pm. So the parent friends who would always help me out will be in the thick of evening things with their own children. Homework can be forgotten for a night, yes. It’s more logistics. If I can move my meeting ( I’m speaking so it’s hard to move but I’m trying!) then I’ll just scoop up the children and take them all with me.

If you can move meeting I’d not hesitate to ask another mum as a one off I’d certainly help another mum in the situation. Best wishes.

zippygeorgebungle · 10/10/2022 10:56

Our local state schools both had their open day on a Saturday actually. I was really impressed at the staff and so many students going in and to show us round and hear the head talk. In some ways it made it harder as I had the little ones with me as nursery as closed on Saturdays of course but I've been to two other evening ones and a private school one. All have been the same level of rushed (a bit, they have to be) but also the same format. It is hard.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 10:50

@Dixiechickonhols no, I appreciate your thoughts. The issue on that night is one child has an away match for school (compulsory) so can’t be collected until 6pm. So the parent friends who would always help me out will be in the thick of evening things with their own children. Homework can be forgotten for a night, yes. It’s more logistics. If I can move my meeting ( I’m speaking so it’s hard to move but I’m trying!) then I’ll just scoop up the children and take them all with me.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 10/10/2022 10:46

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 10:12

@Dixiechickonhols it’s something I’m trying to work out. I’d need someone to collect children from two schools and take them home for supper and homework etc though and I’d need to move a meeting that I’m not sure it’s possible for me to move. I will try my best though!

As a one off would another mum take your others or I have seen younger children at open nights. So pick up everyone early, go to open day then McDonalds after. Younger miss homework as a one off.
Not being patronising just hard to see wood for trees sometimes.
I’ll also add than the senco at DD’s school was very uninspiring when I spoke to her at open night but the actual support where needed was fine. I had a more lengthy conversation with her when dc got a place in March.

PurpleIsTheNewPink · 10/10/2022 10:45

Have you called them? My dd's primary school office was very happy to take questions (and would have probably passed them on to the head teacher if required). Also, another primary that we considered we missed their open day and they were happy to arrange another tour for us and a few other parents.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 10:44

@MissHavershamReturns oh yeah, I’m wise to that. Have already been put off one school for serious cherry picking. Another Saturday morning school tour had a much more realistic bunch of children and almost every member of staff!

OP posts:
MissHavershamReturns · 10/10/2022 10:40

My kids are currently in prep. Be very sceptical of Saturday open days op - handpicked kids and teachers. Much better to see the school on a working day.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 10:38

@CrochetIsCool I have a child in a state school. “I am sure most parents would prioritise time for this in the week” I DO!! I would! Just once there is an open evening that I’m going to struggle to get to. I prioritise my children over everything and can almost always juggle things during school hours.

OP posts:
CrochetIsCool · 10/10/2022 10:35

Maybe attend a state Open Evening and then you can comment on what was actually on offer rather than just making assumptions. I have attended 2 secondary ones recently - lots of input from pupils about their experiences, briefing from the Headteacher about the school philosophy, plans and exam results, further education and career pathways of previous pupils etc. Subject staff were available in all classrooms and more than happy to talk to parents/children - many parents didn't take this up so no queues Lots of work examples available to look at and pupils demonstrating science, design technology and science activities, plenty of interactive things to engage the children too. SENCO and Learning Support staff were available in the library/learning zone respectively so a quiet space for parents to speak to them. Both schools offered the opportunity for parents to book a separate appointment tour during the school day if wanted/needed. Neither offered Saturdays but to be honest I am sure most parents would prioritise time for this in the week if they felt it was important to inform their school choice.

Snugglemonkey · 10/10/2022 10:33

If you can afford independent and are happier with your interactions, then go independent. We get more than 15 minutes at parent's evenings. We also can request a meeting anytime and it is accomodated. We got a private tour of the school, during class time so we could see what was going on with teaching. That was a choice we were able to make. The facilities are all there and all questions are answered. Yes, we pay for the privilege but we feel it is worth it. If you want a lot of interaction, maybe it is worth it for you too.