Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State vs independent school open days

318 replies

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 08:57

Please tell me if I’m BU…

Looking at secondary schools. Have been to 3 independent school open mornings, 3 more to look at. Each school has sent an itinerary of the morning and a clear email so we know what to expect (really helpful when deciding if the children should come or not - not all tours have activities for younger siblings but some do).

Also trying to look at two state options but they have one fixed open evening and that’s it. No flexibility. No option for a smaller tour mid week, no option to speak to a member of staff outside that one evening.

The state schools are over subscribed and so I understand that they don’t massively need to “sell” themselves. But the independent schools are massively oversubscribed too and yet are happy to make time for children and parents to work out which school is the best fit.

Also, all the independent schools have their open days on Saturdays. Which means that most parents can actually make it with some notice.

Just a bit pissed off and needed a rant. I absolutely cannot choose a school based on a rushed evening visit without the chance to ask questions properly.

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 18:38

@Dishwashersaurous of course. But we also have a state secondary that we are geographically in catchment for so we do have a “choice” of two state schools. Plus the independent schools which only have a catchment area of how far I’m prepared to travel (and entrance exams of course!)

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 10/10/2022 18:35

But it's still a criteria . There's no real choice . Either you meet the criteria or you dont

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 18:33

@Dishwashersaurous it’s a faith school so children come from a fairly wide area.

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 18:30

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:51

@youcantry I expect state schools to offer more than a 2-3 hour open evening once a year. I’d like at least one 30-60 minute tours/meetings in smaller groups each term. I’d also like the SENCO to be available to speak to a prospective parent for 10 minutes on the phone before school offers come out.

With the best will in the world schools do not have the time or resources to do this for every single parent.

Dishwashersaurous · 10/10/2022 18:24

For the vast, vast majority of secondary state schools there is no choice. There is the illusion of choice but in reality there are catchment areas for schools. If you live in the catchment area for the school then you go there. Otherwise you go to the school in the next catchment area over.

In a very few areas there might be two options but this is more rare.

Therefore for oversubscribed state schools there is a catchment area, and people living there will go to the school.

You are in an unusual position because you are choosing between state and private. Most people attending the school won't have a choice.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 17:40

@cantkeepawayforever yes!!! Ha! My brain has shut down clearly.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2022 17:29

Elusive, I think!

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 17:24

Illusive!!

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 17:24

@flumposie thank you. The illusory Saturday morning open mornings do exist 😁

OP posts:
flumposie · 10/10/2022 17:14

Where I live we ( state school) do open mornings. I spent last Saturday in school from 9.30 until 1pm. No extra pay or time in lieu. Part of directed time. ( 21st year at this school, always done open days apart from 2020)

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 17:10

@cantkeepawayforever really fair point

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2022 17:07

I think it isn’t reasonable to expect a SENCo to speak to every prospective parent at the ‘considering the school’ stage, though.

On average, about 14-15% of pupils in mainstream state secondaries are on the SEN register. For a school with, say, 240 intake that has 10 considering the school per place, that’s about 360 children - as opposed to the 36 who will be in the cohort that gets places. 36 x 15 minutes is a not- unreasonable 9 hours - 360 x 15 minutes is a less reasonable 90 hours!

If you have enough spaces on the form, apply anyway, and discuss provision in detail with the SENCo if you get in. My advice would be different for a child with a full EGCP or complex needs, of course, as they can name schools in a different way.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:58

We got amazing school branded huge and beautiful teddy bears from one school once. My children both disliked their taster day there and I was also underwhelmed. The teddies were lovely though!

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2022 16:54

I think , if you attend a number of state school open evenings, you can get a feel for them in relation to one another. Which, in the context if a single event, are welcoming and helpful and well-run, and which are careless and off hand.

Equally, attending private school open events will enable internal comparisons within that sector.

Where it gets tricky is cross-sector comparison because, for lots of reasons including the underlying purpose of open events, the events are apples and oranges.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:53

@youcantry I’m a state and an independent school parent. I am a veteran of independent school open days. Some of the flashiest open days have been at schools that I have discounted because I wasn’t convinced they were the best schools for our family. And not because the jute bags weren’t the right size (although they are often slightly too small to be any real use 🤣)

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:51

@youcantry I expect state schools to offer more than a 2-3 hour open evening once a year. I’d like at least one 30-60 minute tours/meetings in smaller groups each term. I’d also like the SENCO to be available to speak to a prospective parent for 10 minutes on the phone before school offers come out.

OP posts:
youcantry · 10/10/2022 16:49

Oh and the promotional bags with the most desirable content, essentially branded to promote the school.
Look at the school, not the marketing - independents spend a fortune on marketing which state schools do not have the luxury of.

youcantry · 10/10/2022 16:47

I've worked in both.
The independents will go all out to get you to apply, taster sessions, several open events - there's no guarantee that your child will be given a place!
What do you expect from state run schools?

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:46

Sorry for the sarcasm but I have explained I’m not interested in the quality of the refreshments etc. I’m interested in the school ethos and dynamic and how they choose to present that. I really, really care that I understand the learning support but also the pastoral care systems at the school and the academic systems (options, sets etc)

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:44

@zingally you’re right. You’ve clearly read my posts. Whoever can offer me sushi and a good choice of wines can educate my child. Quite right.

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 16:43

@zezzez not west London but similar dynamic 🤓

OP posts:
zingally · 10/10/2022 16:41

borntobequiet · 10/10/2022 09:07

Massively more expensive option offers a more attractive pre-purchase package, hardly a surprise to anyone with real life experience.

EXACTLY.

The independent schools are businesses. They need to drum up business to stay open. And one of the ways they do that is through offering an attractive pre-enrollment package to "grab" potential customers.

The state schools are going to keep operating and getting kids in the doors whether they advertise or not.

It sounds like "being wined and dined" is attractive to you - you want the personal touch. So just go for the independent school.

zezzez · 10/10/2022 16:25

What I've found in my experience of three different independent schools, is that the more academic the school, the more advanced, targeted and dynamic the SEN support is. For instance, in the top London schools, they don't view dyslexia or autism as a "problem to deal with," they simply talk about SEN as a "different learning style" that other students can learn from and benefit from. Having said this, the odds if a place at 11 plus are like 1 in 12, but the schools definitely attract the best Ed Psychs and understand that some of the most gifted children can have "spiky educational profiles."

Popgoestheweaselagain · 10/10/2022 16:19

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 14:12

@Popgoestheweaselagain I suppose what I’m really asking is why some state schools are not being as warm and welcoming as most independent schools. Obvs paying fees plays a part. But generally there seems to be a much greater effort to find the right school for each child. I appreciate for lots of people they don’t have a choice of state schools and it’s their catchment school or nothing. In which case open evenings really are just a chance for children and parents to see what’s next, rather than a chance to decide if that’s the school they want to apply for.

Well, it could mean a couple of things. If a school in my area was oversubscribed and their attitude to admissions was 'We've got one open evening, take it or leave it', I'd think that was probably a high achieving school that everyone wanted to get into. However, if I had a SEN kid and was looking for a more nurturing, individual approach, I'd be worried that their 'you're lucky to get in here' attitude wouldn't be right for our family. If their coasting on their reputation, they might not be really puting the effort in that you want. With SEN you really need to do your homework and not follow the crowd. I certainly understand why you would be worried about plumping for a school without even having attended an open day.

zezzez · 10/10/2022 16:18

Are the schools in West London by any chance OP. I may know them quite well if so.