Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State vs independent school open days

318 replies

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 08:57

Please tell me if I’m BU…

Looking at secondary schools. Have been to 3 independent school open mornings, 3 more to look at. Each school has sent an itinerary of the morning and a clear email so we know what to expect (really helpful when deciding if the children should come or not - not all tours have activities for younger siblings but some do).

Also trying to look at two state options but they have one fixed open evening and that’s it. No flexibility. No option for a smaller tour mid week, no option to speak to a member of staff outside that one evening.

The state schools are over subscribed and so I understand that they don’t massively need to “sell” themselves. But the independent schools are massively oversubscribed too and yet are happy to make time for children and parents to work out which school is the best fit.

Also, all the independent schools have their open days on Saturdays. Which means that most parents can actually make it with some notice.

Just a bit pissed off and needed a rant. I absolutely cannot choose a school based on a rushed evening visit without the chance to ask questions properly.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 10/10/2022 20:59

@user55875537986543 I totally get that, and I think your concerns are reasonable and valid. I'm not saying they're not.

The problem is, at an oversubscribed, large secondary school, there may be many families where there is some specific concern and parents/carers will want to speak to the school. There will likely be looked after children, there may well be other children who have lost a parent or a close relative, there will be children who are young carers, children who have mental health issues, children applying from out of area who know no-one, children who have other complex issues going on within their family. At this stage, the head of Y7, or the head of pastoral care could spend hours talking to parents who may not even apply to the school.

My experience of this is working at a large secondary school which was oversubscribed and in an area where parents had genuine school choice and some did go private (not London, though). The school had an intake of over 250 per year group, and they were oversubscribed every year- and of course there are parents who consider the school and then don't apply. If the school had allowed it, some pastoral staff could have spent 30+ hours talking to parents/carers who might apply and might get a place. But they didn't think that was a sensible use of staff time. At the moment you might disagree, but next year think how you'd feel if you couldn't speak to an important member of staff because they were busy dealing with prospective parents.

Equally, the last school I worked at was much smaller- the school had an intake of about 150 per year. It was the only school in a rural town, a very small number of children in the town went to private schools, and a small number went to the school in the next town. Pastoral staff and SEN staff were happy to spend a bit of time talking to prospective parents/carers, because a) it's most likely the child would end up coming to the school, and b) the number of parents who wanted to speak to the school outside of open evenings was a lot less.

I'm sure private schools may be in the situation of many, many parents wanting to speak to pastoral staff- but they are in a different position, and I imagine most private school staff see recruiting as part of their role- even if it's a very oversubscribed school. And the staff will probably have more time to spend on this.

Startagain51 · 10/10/2022 20:49

If you had posted 5 years ago, I'd have said definitely go for the state school, get involved, we need someone as intelligent and articulate as you on the governing body, fighting on our side.

Now? Please just send your kids to private schools. Teachers in state schools are beyond breaking point and can't give you what you need. One of my colleagues committed suicide recently. This is the reality that you say you fully understand. You're beyond privileged that you have a choice. Perhaps you could just support us in the forthcoming strike action, we would appreciate it.

Givenuptotally · 10/10/2022 20:31

Teachers in state schools don't get paid extra for open days

Neither do those in independents. Unfortunately, our jobs are dependent on bums on seats so that means the expectations of staff are going to be greater. Simple economics,

Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:29

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:26

@Plumbear2 secondary school is different? Again, wow! Thank you so much for your help.

You don't seem to realise this.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:27

@Plumbear2 83% think you’re annoying 🙄

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:26

@Plumbear2 secondary school is different? Again, wow! Thank you so much for your help.

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:26

Like I said 82%

Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:25

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:24

@Plumbear2 state school parent for the last 4 years. Stop bullying and patronising me.

In a primary school. High school is very different.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:25

@Plumbear2 and many people have explained that they have had fantastic, flexible and thorough open days and extra tours at state secondary schools. But you refuse to see this outside the narrow lens of your own experience.

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:24

82% day you are being unreasonable. Time to listen.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:24

@Plumbear2 state school parent for the last 4 years. Stop bullying and patronising me.

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:23

@Postapocalypticcowgirl Actually, the SENCO didn’t say I couldn’t communicate with her - I realise now it was the office staff. So maybe at the open evening I’ll find her to be much more open.

My children have also lost their father in the last couple of years so I also need to really be confident and comfortable with the pastoral care too.

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:22

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:19

@Plumbear2 Why so rude? I am nothing but supportive of my childrens schools and teachers. Wanting to attend a well run open morning is not “take take take.” Ffs.

Many people have explained to you why state schools carnt offer more yet you refuse to listen. Teachers have explained it to you. I agree state education is not for you for the teachers sake don't do it.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:19

@Plumbear2 Why so rude? I am nothing but supportive of my childrens schools and teachers. Wanting to attend a well run open morning is not “take take take.” Ffs.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 10/10/2022 20:18

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:09

@Postapocalypticcowgirl thank you for your post. I don’t think my expectations are unrealistic as many people seem to have had a brilliant experience with state school tours. I’m not expecting the earth but the school I’m
most interested in has a great reputation for SEN so it’s surprising that the school isn’t more keen to talk. I am going to make the last 2/3 of the open evening so hopefully I can ask all my questions then!

As I said, I do think it's a shame that the SENCO isn't able to make time to talk to you, and it is possibly not a great sign. Sometimes "great reputation for SEN" can lead to a lot of parents choosing that school for children with SEN, and that may leave the SENCO with an unmanageable workload. Or there may be other reasons as to why they aren't able to spare time to talk to prospective parents this term. It may also be that the volume of requests they've had is simply too high to accommodate- so to be fair to everyone they're speaking to no-one or prioritising by need.

In my experience as a teacher during state school open evenings, parents aren't rushed around, and we always offer time to talk. Pastoral leads and SEN staff are available to talk to as well. Hopefully you will find the experience better than you expect.

I do understand it's a big decision for you, and as you have a genuine choice, it's a different situation to parents who are basically just going to see the school their children will be going to. But state schools will always be limited in what they can offer in terms of staff time and parent contact compared to many independent schools, and I think that's something to be aware of going forwards. If that's really a deal breaker for you, then I think it's better to figure that out now, than two or three years down the line.

It is different to primary, simply due to the number of students each member of staff will teach, and the number of students the school has to accommodate as a whole.

Plumbear2 · 10/10/2022 20:14

FourEyesGood · 10/10/2022 18:53

I’m a secondary school teacher in a state school. We do one open evening for prospective Y7 students and their parents each year, and one for prospective Y12 students and their parents, plus one weekly after school meeting, 6 parents’ evenings and various extra-curricular clubs and trips, as well as doing all of the planning and assessment for our multiple classes each week - on top of the actual lessons we teach and the numerous phone calls and emails to parents we need to sort each each week.

We’re at breaking point. Just because some state schools offer additional open evenings, that doesn’t mean they should. And it definitely doesn’t mean we all should. Our workload is already unmanageable and teachers are leaving the profession in droves.

Couldn't agree more. You do a fantastic job. Its all take take take with some people.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:09

@Postapocalypticcowgirl thank you for your post. I don’t think my expectations are unrealistic as many people seem to have had a brilliant experience with state school tours. I’m not expecting the earth but the school I’m
most interested in has a great reputation for SEN so it’s surprising that the school isn’t more keen to talk. I am going to make the last 2/3 of the open evening so hopefully I can ask all my questions then!

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 20:06

@EmmaDilemma5 they’re funded differently?! 🫣

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 10/10/2022 19:51

One of the secondary schools I've worked in would have arranged an individual tour for you, and/or an appointment with the SENCO. Another one wouldn't have- due to their intake size and the demographic they served, you'd likely have as many as 500 parents wanting tours (not all of those students would get a place), and in a state school, it's simply not viable to organise this. At the other school, most parents were happy with the open evening (where we tried not to rush them and they could ask any questions they liked) and only around 20-30 parents would ask for separate tours, which is much more viable.

In the vast majority of state schools, teachers have a standard contract which limits the number of hours they can be directed to be in school- this includes any "trapped" time between when they finish teaching, and the start of events like open evening or parents evening. Logistically, there's often very little leeway once you've done an open evening for Y7, one for 6th form, maybe an options evening, plus parents evenings, and maybe one other evening event- e.g. a celebration evening (along with all the other things staff are directed to do, obviously). Most staff don't have the spare "directed time" to be asked to run tours after school, so the only people available to do this are usually those on the leadership pay scale (i.e. SLT), and realistically, they can only do so many tours.

In independent schools, staff contracts will likely specify x evenings, and x days of Saturday working etc, and their pay will be calculated accordingly. This may also be the case in FE in the state sector, too- usually FE lecturers aren't on a standard teacher contract.

It's also worth bearing in mind that state secondaries often struggle to recruit, especially in certain subjects, and teachers tend to value schools where not too many late evenings are required of them.

I do think it's a shame that the SENCOs won't at least arrange a phone call with you at this stage- and actually, that would make me wary- it suggests they're either overworked, or the schools aren't keen to recruit children with SEN. Or both.

I get the evening is inconvenient for you, and that's a real shame, and I understand that having other commitments makes things very difficult. But I do also think your expectations of the state sector are unrealistic, and this might be a bit of a sign that it's not right for you.

EmmaDilemma5 · 10/10/2022 19:41

piglet81 · 10/10/2022 09:01

Seems pretty simple to me - state schools are massively underresourced, whereas the independent schools are looking at you as a paying customer!

Exactly this.

OP - do you realise they are funded and resources very differently?!

MissHavershamReturns · 10/10/2022 19:34

There’s next to no info on Sen support on the website for most secondaries we are applying to

ancientgran · 10/10/2022 19:30

cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2022 17:07

I think it isn’t reasonable to expect a SENCo to speak to every prospective parent at the ‘considering the school’ stage, though.

On average, about 14-15% of pupils in mainstream state secondaries are on the SEN register. For a school with, say, 240 intake that has 10 considering the school per place, that’s about 360 children - as opposed to the 36 who will be in the cohort that gets places. 36 x 15 minutes is a not- unreasonable 9 hours - 360 x 15 minutes is a less reasonable 90 hours!

If you have enough spaces on the form, apply anyway, and discuss provision in detail with the SENCo if you get in. My advice would be different for a child with a full EGCP or complex needs, of course, as they can name schools in a different way.

Well done SENCOs on making the children at the school their priority rather than spending 90 hrs talking to people who might send their child to the school. Even more so at this time of year, children in their first half term at the school will presumably be keeping the SENCO fully occupied.

I'd have thought looking at the website would give lots of information on how things work at the school.

FatEaredFuck · 10/10/2022 19:28

A local school did an open morning which is a good addition to an open day.

FourEyesGood · 10/10/2022 18:53

I’m a secondary school teacher in a state school. We do one open evening for prospective Y7 students and their parents each year, and one for prospective Y12 students and their parents, plus one weekly after school meeting, 6 parents’ evenings and various extra-curricular clubs and trips, as well as doing all of the planning and assessment for our multiple classes each week - on top of the actual lessons we teach and the numerous phone calls and emails to parents we need to sort each each week.

We’re at breaking point. Just because some state schools offer additional open evenings, that doesn’t mean they should. And it definitely doesn’t mean we all should. Our workload is already unmanageable and teachers are leaving the profession in droves.

FatEaredFuck · 10/10/2022 18:53

I'd argue that if your child is disabled or has difficulty accessing education via a learning difficulty it is bloody reasonable to hope you can talk to SENCO to see if child would be accomodated/welcomed/tolerated/ignored.