Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

State vs independent school open days

318 replies

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 08:57

Please tell me if I’m BU…

Looking at secondary schools. Have been to 3 independent school open mornings, 3 more to look at. Each school has sent an itinerary of the morning and a clear email so we know what to expect (really helpful when deciding if the children should come or not - not all tours have activities for younger siblings but some do).

Also trying to look at two state options but they have one fixed open evening and that’s it. No flexibility. No option for a smaller tour mid week, no option to speak to a member of staff outside that one evening.

The state schools are over subscribed and so I understand that they don’t massively need to “sell” themselves. But the independent schools are massively oversubscribed too and yet are happy to make time for children and parents to work out which school is the best fit.

Also, all the independent schools have their open days on Saturdays. Which means that most parents can actually make it with some notice.

Just a bit pissed off and needed a rant. I absolutely cannot choose a school based on a rushed evening visit without the chance to ask questions properly.

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:57

@celestialsphere “they don't probably don't particularly want children with SEN” That’s so horrible.

My dyslexic child currently has an academic scholarship to their prep school. They are very much “wanted” and welcome in their (very hard to get in to!) prep school currently!

OP posts:
Getoff · 10/10/2022 09:57

Maybe you should email your questions to the head (or whoever else might manage admissions) at each school?

passport123 · 10/10/2022 09:56

Just ask to speak to the SENCO outside of the open day

RedHelenB · 10/10/2022 09:55

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:11

I don’t want/need a brochure, a cappuccino or a bag with the school logo. I would like some time to hear a talk from the head and a chance to speak to a few key members of staff. I would like to speak to learning support about how they cope with children with dyslexia, I would like to speak to someone about GCSE options and I would like to speak to someone about pastoral care (assuming none of this is covered in detail by the main talk). I would like 15 minutes to ask questions without being rushed.

15 mins x possibly 200 + pupils. Not going to happen in a state school. Most talks allow parents to ask some questions don't they? I think you need to lower your expectations somewhat.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:55

@cantkeepawayforever really good points about what the open events are for. Thank you.

OP posts:
celestialsphere · 10/10/2022 09:54

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:48

Ok. Well thanks all. I know that the independent schools have budgets for open days etc. I get it.

What I’m surprised at is that any school isn’t open to a conversation with parents who can’t make the one open day available or who have a child with SEN and needs a more thorough chat about what provision might look like.

Please don’t explain budgets and privilege to me over and over. I’m an intelligent professional parent. I have children in state and private schools. I get it.

I am looking for a warm and friendly welcome to each school community so they can show me what their school is like and I can get a real feel for it. I really don’t need bells and whistles but I do need reassurance and to be able to understand if the school will be a good fit for each individual child.

I actually don’t think IABU to be able to speak to a prospective school about learning support. (And no, it’s not a SEN that would stop my child from getting into a highly selective academic school, but it is a SEN that requires support from school).

I think you're a bit delusional to expect them to work around you rather than the other way around. Realistically, they don't probably don't particularly want children with SEN as a presumably they may require extra resources for the extra support.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:53

@User135792468 oh please. So I can’t look at good independent schools and good state schools too? Really? I have an academic child who has dyslexia. I need to find the best fit for them. This includes working out where the best learning support provision might be within school.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 10/10/2022 09:52

I think it’s also worth considering what the open evening is ‘for’ in each case.

Private school parents have choices as to where they will spend a huge sum of money - and private school open days are designed to persuade them to spend that money with them.

State school parents, in reality, have very little choice, so what a state school open day is doing is giving its future parents - and also others who are likely not to be given a place - an opportunity to see the inside of the institution that their child will be allocated a place at. Local oversubscribed schools will welcome several thousands of parents to open evenings, so the experience is necessarily somewhat factory-like on a day when the staff will probably be working 12+ hours in school plus their normal extra at home in the evening. Even the largest primary school open day / evening is likely to involve only a few hundred parents.

That said, in terms of your specific questions - an e-mail directed to the school SENCo should elicit information about dyslexia, and there should be a GCSE options booklet or similar on the website.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 10/10/2022 09:51

It sounds like your issue is largely abound SEN provision. If you are genuinely interested in the state options and not just as a back up if your DC doesn't make the grade then you can always email them. This sort of info is freely available on most school websites.

Topgub · 10/10/2022 09:50

@user55875537986543

No.

I didnt. I dont know anyone who did.

Why would we? It makes no difference

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:50

@Talkwhilstyouwalk they do need to show the school in a good light of course, but they also let results and reputation speak for themselves too.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 10/10/2022 09:50

State school teachers can't be made to work on Saturdays (even if they offer extra pay for it), and there are limits on how much they can asked to be do in the evenings. It's not so much about whether they are paid for it, but whether it is part of the contract.

The majority of parents looking at state schools have rather less choice about where their child goes, and some will be rather less invested than those looking at private schools.

State schools get no say in which applicants they get (except grammars), so if they're over-subscribed, there's not much benefit in having more applicants. Arguably, what might benefit them is putting off the less-desirable applicants!

Having said that, I found the problem with the open evening at DD's school was that there was insufficient time to go round everything. You could easily have spent half an hour or more in the science labs, which half of us were directed to first. We managed to give our pupil guide the slip and move on to the subjects where we had specific questions, but I think some parents probably never did get to see the staff they really wanted to talk to. The neighbouring school was more free-flow, so you could prioritise more easily.

celestialsphere · 10/10/2022 09:49

If open days require teachers to work unpaid, and the school is oversubscribed why would state schools have an open day that is convenient for you? They probably couldn't care less if you tried to enrol your DC as they will be full anyway. The Independent schools are not in the same position as they probably don't just take the nearest pupils as comprehensive state schools have to (e.g. they may have entrance exams) so even if oversubscribed they probably want as many people to apply as possible so that they can be more fussy about the pupils.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:48

@Twizbe I can only imagine!

OP posts:
user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:48

Ok. Well thanks all. I know that the independent schools have budgets for open days etc. I get it.

What I’m surprised at is that any school isn’t open to a conversation with parents who can’t make the one open day available or who have a child with SEN and needs a more thorough chat about what provision might look like.

Please don’t explain budgets and privilege to me over and over. I’m an intelligent professional parent. I have children in state and private schools. I get it.

I am looking for a warm and friendly welcome to each school community so they can show me what their school is like and I can get a real feel for it. I really don’t need bells and whistles but I do need reassurance and to be able to understand if the school will be a good fit for each individual child.

I actually don’t think IABU to be able to speak to a prospective school about learning support. (And no, it’s not a SEN that would stop my child from getting into a highly selective academic school, but it is a SEN that requires support from school).

OP posts:
Talkwhilstyouwalk · 10/10/2022 09:47

Ok, well in that case they need to be very accommodating with open days and tours to make sure that they attract the top students and convince the cream of the crop to pick them.

HRTQueen · 10/10/2022 09:47

Many Independent schools are making a very nice earning just from applications. Then the exams. Oh and the tutorials for the exams

how many will get into the school well depends but for some it’s 20% of those applying but having been impressed by the school many parents will still be applying so handing over money before a child has even been accepted

Twizbe · 10/10/2022 09:44

You clearly didn't have to pick a school during covid.

I did have any open days when picking my son's school. Best we got were videos and zoom calls with presubmitted questions.

User135792468 · 10/10/2022 09:44

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:41

@Talkwhilstyouwalk they’re not “mildly” selective. They’re super selective and both schools we’re most keen on are top 20 in the country for results. They really don’t need to woo parents but equally they do want parents to understand the ethos of the school before they decide if it’s the right school for their child.

If you can afford a top 20 school, why are you even bothering with the state schools? It’s obvious which you will prefer, how can you not? They have much more money and are able to provide more as a result. Stop wasting peoples time and moaning about state schools open evenings. If this is already such a bone of contention, there will be numerous things over the years that will aggravate you.

Worthyornot · 10/10/2022 09:43

FiveMins · 10/10/2022 09:37

Independent schools need you as their customer. They are selling you a product. I live in a city where every state school is over subscribed and underfunded. They don't need to sell themselves so heavily.

I disagree. They really, really don't need you as a customer. I'm currently applying to schools that have 60 places and 300-350 applications. They do not need to beg for your custom, it's the other way around.

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:41

@Talkwhilstyouwalk they’re not “mildly” selective. They’re super selective and both schools we’re most keen on are top 20 in the country for results. They really don’t need to woo parents but equally they do want parents to understand the ethos of the school before they decide if it’s the right school for their child.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 10/10/2022 09:40

But what are you expecting

independent schools are a business they are pitching to you they have the means (money) and teachers and staff who are not so overworked and have the time to prepare for all of this.

State schools haven’t the money, over worked staff haven’t the time to organise such events

AnotherNewt · 10/10/2022 09:40

Bobblesock · 10/10/2022 09:05

If you do go for the independent option some of the fees you pay fund the PR and admin staff that make those events happen. Aswell as funding longer holidays for teaching staff.

It's not so much the fees in general, it's the application fees that prospective parents pay that allow them to run their admissions - ideally enough to be cost-neutral to the rest of the budget, but if not then obviously the shortfall is made up from general income (fees and investments)

There are usually biscuits and coffee/tea as well - all independent schools seem to have decent catering for all events to which parents are invited

Hollyhead · 10/10/2022 09:40

user55875537986543 · 10/10/2022 09:11

I don’t want/need a brochure, a cappuccino or a bag with the school logo. I would like some time to hear a talk from the head and a chance to speak to a few key members of staff. I would like to speak to learning support about how they cope with children with dyslexia, I would like to speak to someone about GCSE options and I would like to speak to someone about pastoral care (assuming none of this is covered in detail by the main talk). I would like 15 minutes to ask questions without being rushed.

All of that was included in the state comp open evening we went to. You shouldn’t generalise. I’m sure you could email your queries.

Getoff · 10/10/2022 09:40

You may also be surprised to hear the pope is Catholic

Here is QI explaining that the man with the official title pope is in fact not Catholic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread