Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being friends with a girl half his age

136 replies

PleaseBeHonest · 10/10/2022 07:16

DH is 47 and this girl is in her twenties. She used to work for him, he was her manager. At the time, things weren’t great between DH and I. He was coming home every day in a foul mood, not even acknowledging me most nights. He’d then blame the stress of work. However, he then talked about how much fun he had at work and that they “spent the whole day laughing”. He mentioned a few colleagues but this one (the girl) he mentioned more than most. I actually lost my temper with him because he was mentioning her so much.

Then she found another job and left the company about 6 months ago. I thought that would be the end of it.

Then at the weekend DH showed me his phone and I could see that there was a conversation between the two of them. Basically she was asking him if he was going to someone’s leaving do and he said he wasn’t. All innocent enough, but why are they still in contact? Especially as I had raised concerns about her in the past.

DH said they were friends 🙄. AIBU to have an issue with a 47 year old MARRIED man being friends with a girl in her twenties?

Just for background, I have NEVER had an issue with anyone else DH has worked with ever. Just this one girl.

OP posts:
IsThePopeCatholic · 10/10/2022 20:11

Zingy123 · 10/10/2022 10:01

Yes there's always one who uses the correct terminology.

Agree. ‘Girl’ is so demeaning.

Begoniasforever · 10/10/2022 19:49

She’s a grown ass woman op.

look you clearly think he fancies her and are jealous and insecure. What’s your question, it’s reasonable not to like your husband being in touch with a woman you think he fancies and prefers to you. But you can’t dictate his friends. So it’s either trust him or don’t. Because arguing and trying to force him not to be in contact isn’t going to work for you.

AloysiusBear · 10/10/2022 19:48

When i was in my twenties i had mates at work who were men (and women) twice my age. After i stopped working with one friend (he was about 15 years older than me) we met for a pint a couple of times. I was planning my wedding, he chatted about his two daughters and a holiday he was planning with his wife, we gossiped about our old colleagues. Why would a woman in her twenties want a bloke in his forties? I didn't fancy my balding colleague in the least, i had my 29 year old boyfriend at home!!

HeckyPeck · 10/10/2022 19:43

PleaseBeHonest · 10/10/2022 09:23

@Shiningstarr he’s deleted all the previous messages. And his Friends list is not visible on Facebook.

The only people I've know do this with the friends list and deleting messages have been cheating unfortunately.

I can't think of an innocent reason unless he deletes everyone's previous messages?

StupidSmallFruit · 10/10/2022 19:38

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 10/10/2022 10:18

I've read the OP, and a miserable husband taking out his stress and anger on her is her problem, not the fact that he has a friendship with a woman.

Hell, her entire evidence of his transgressions is that he's brushed this woman off when she's invited him on a works night out. They surely must be shagging!

Did you miss the part where he was coming home in a foul mood every day, and is deleting all the texts between them? Or did that just not suit your narrative?

My DH has lots of women friends - lots of really close friends he’s known for years.

This - like your friendship with a woman - has literally nothing to do with the OP’s situation.

bakehimawaytoys · 10/10/2022 19:21

Not a sad world thanks @Kite22 just the voice of long experience. The fact that you and your DH have friends of all ages (congrats) has nothing to do with OP's husband treating her like shit while claiming to have "laughed all day" with this much younger woman during a rough patch in their marriage and to now be deleting their apparently innocent messages so that OP can't read them.

I would be mortified if my DH was messaging a 20-something woman he used to manage as "friends". There is a complete power imbalance here that makes it creepy and disrespectful.

Unglamorousgranny · 10/10/2022 17:51

@TwoWrightFeet read pp. The girl v woman debate has already been talked about & put to bed further upthread. Pointless attempt at being goady from you.... 🙄

Afterfire · 10/10/2022 17:07

I wouldn’t like this at all. Mentionitis. Deleting messages. Hiding friends lists. No thanks. Fuck that for a game of soldiers. She has NO reason to stay in touch. It’s inappropriate in these particular circumstances.

slashlover · 10/10/2022 17:05

I've deleted old conversations with people who I worked with and assume I will never see again, but I'm one of those people who hates a cluttered messenger/email.

cantbelieveheletmedown · 10/10/2022 17:01

This was exactly how my marriage ended. My DH become obsessed by some woman 15 years his junior. He became glued to his phone, leaving for work earlier, arriving home later and his behaviour towards me was shitty and unforgivable! I'm now on my own, putting the pieces of my life back together whilst he has moved her in!
Hoping karma will firmly land on his doorstep soon!!

Kite22 · 10/10/2022 16:48

There's only one reason a 47-year-old man is friends with a girl half his age and it's not because he's interested in her personality.

Maybe in your sad world, but many of us are capable of being friends with all sorts of people in a platonic way.
Through hobbies as well as work both dh and I have friends where there is considerable age gap (both older and younger as it happens) and both have friends that are male and friends that are female. As do our adult dc.

OP there seems to me to be nothing strange in an ex colleague asking someone who still works there if they are going to someone's leaving do. Your dh even showed you the message. He also isn't going. Not sure what you are concerned about here.

MRSE20 · 10/10/2022 15:12

I started my first job at 15 and left at 25
I became friends with colleagues who are double and triple my age
One of my close friends is a 70 year old woman and I remain friends with a couple of the guys there who are 50/60 year old married men (message, speak every so often) and I invited them to my wedding with their wives and children
Most workplaces are very age diverse

My partner is 30 and his closest work mate is 18/19 (they go out pub every so often etc and text a lot outside of work)

I go out with old work friends for drinks every so often who are double my age and we always have a great time

I think you are overthinking this
There is a big difference between your husband flirting and secretly messaging a 20 year old or just having general platonic chat

ObviouslyHeGetsFed · 10/10/2022 14:51

In my first job as a late teen while at uni I got on really well with my male married manager. He was late 30s/early 40s. Never anything in it, not even harmless flirting. His girlfriend (now wife) worked away so he came on nights out with us and to student gigs. I moved home after university and we now live 6hrs drive away but we are still social media friends and we have a chat a few times a year or often send memes or memories. Ive never actually met his wife and was not invited to their wedding or met their kids. Unsure if she even knows I exist. I dont think its odd, we are friends.

DHProblem · 10/10/2022 11:19

My DP is in his early-50s and has been friends for a while with a girl in her mid-20s, we are all in the same area of work but for different companies. He's always said there's nothing in it (for him at least) but she is flirty with him when we are all at work events and occasionally I will spot a social media post from her with them 'having fun' together at an event where I haven't been able to make it and it really pisses me off. She's absolutely beautiful and he obviously enjoys the attention. He thinks of himself as being very 'young at heart' (I'm several years younger than him myself) so maybe he doesn't see the age gap as much as outsiders do. She's a smart, funny girl, I actually like her as a person, but she has told me several times that she likes much older men, without mentioning him in particular. I trust him (99%, anyway...) and I really don't think anything is going on but it's hugely irritating and I am always on edge when she's around. I think both the younger woman and older man in these scenarios both get a frisson out of their friendship and I don't actually think it always leads to anything, but the fact you are pissed off (and, most importantly, that he's a bit of a shit to you at home) should be enough for him to show some respect and back off considerably.

ihatesteve · 10/10/2022 11:17

Im in my 40's and work with someone in his 20's. We are work friends becuase we work with each other. I dont message him out of work and would be horrified if he messaged me. I'm superior to him. Totally inappropriate on a number of levels.

That said some young people keep in touch with literally everyone they have ever met - a text only takes secobds to send - its your dh's response to it that is worrying.

missmamiecuddleduck · 10/10/2022 11:14

OverTheRubicon · 10/10/2022 10:53

There are so many women posting here about how in their 20s and 30s they have (/had) male work friends who were 20+ years older, who gave them great advice, took them for lunch, nothing more than friends.

That may have been how you felt. I used to feel the same. Then I got older and saw it from the other side, and think absolutely no way.

Even the men that wouldn't want to actually cheat are usually loving the feeling of that close relationship with a younger woman, and/or the ego boost of being sought for advice and seen in public together. As these same women grow older, and also as they get more senior, somehow they seem a lot less worthy of these close work friendships than colleagues half their age.

Doesn't mean you can't keep these relationships up, if you're both enjoying it and getting along so long as you have your eyes open to what they generally mean.

Spot on.
Ask men and they'll have very different views about it.

Anon778833 · 10/10/2022 10:55

OverTheRubicon · 10/10/2022 10:53

There are so many women posting here about how in their 20s and 30s they have (/had) male work friends who were 20+ years older, who gave them great advice, took them for lunch, nothing more than friends.

That may have been how you felt. I used to feel the same. Then I got older and saw it from the other side, and think absolutely no way.

Even the men that wouldn't want to actually cheat are usually loving the feeling of that close relationship with a younger woman, and/or the ego boost of being sought for advice and seen in public together. As these same women grow older, and also as they get more senior, somehow they seem a lot less worthy of these close work friendships than colleagues half their age.

Doesn't mean you can't keep these relationships up, if you're both enjoying it and getting along so long as you have your eyes open to what they generally mean.

Exactly right ^^

OverTheRubicon · 10/10/2022 10:53

There are so many women posting here about how in their 20s and 30s they have (/had) male work friends who were 20+ years older, who gave them great advice, took them for lunch, nothing more than friends.

That may have been how you felt. I used to feel the same. Then I got older and saw it from the other side, and think absolutely no way.

Even the men that wouldn't want to actually cheat are usually loving the feeling of that close relationship with a younger woman, and/or the ego boost of being sought for advice and seen in public together. As these same women grow older, and also as they get more senior, somehow they seem a lot less worthy of these close work friendships than colleagues half their age.

Doesn't mean you can't keep these relationships up, if you're both enjoying it and getting along so long as you have your eyes open to what they generally mean.

BorisisaLune · 10/10/2022 10:46

Are you kidding @QuizzlyBears ? There's only one reason a 47-year-old man is friends with a girl half his age and it's not because he's interested in her personality

Very true as i learnt to my cost.

My OH struck up a friendship with a (very attractive) woman in her mid 20s (he was mid 50s at the time)

I thought this a little odd and my antennae went up, turns out you were correct, he wasn't interested in her personality at all but in her Dog, a breed he'd always wanted as a child and was taking it for walks (on his own) when she was WFH - we ended up with her living with us FT, the dog not the woman!

Anon778833 · 10/10/2022 10:45

YANBU. Id be surprised if he doesn’t have some sort of interest in her. What could they possibly have in common for a genuine friendship? Some people kid themselves about this sort of thing because they don’t want to see the truth. So it’s good that you see it for what it is.

PugInTheHouse · 10/10/2022 10:41

The age if her is irrelevant, work colleagues ages vary hugely so that wouldn't be odd to me, it's whether there is something more to their relationship that's the issue. When I was 22 I left my first job, one of my closest colleagues was a 50 yo male. He was married with kids (definitely not a player) and we would still meet for lunch etc after I left. Never anything in it whatsoever.

Arenanewbie · 10/10/2022 10:38

Was it a one off contact about leaving do? If so, I wouldn’t think too much about this. However I wouldn’t like them being in contact as friends it would look very odd to me.
My DH is on friendly terms with people of different ages through work, they often keep in touch after leaving but all their communications are strictly related to work: they share info about vacancies, events etc. There will be an element of how are you/ how is life but it will be secondary.

oakleaffy · 10/10/2022 10:33

''Mentionitis'' is a red flag from me, too.

As is the ''We spend the day laughing''

He may well fancy her like mad, hopefully it won't be reciprocated.

My ex H had mentionitis and did end up marrying the 'Mentioned' one after a very painful divorce.

The mentioned was a significantly older woman, I wasn't suspicious because of this... more fool me!

The second marriage didn't last, but even so... beware of mentionitis.

Shiningstarr · 10/10/2022 10:27

Hell, her entire evidence of his transgressions is that he's brushed this woman off when she's invited him on a works night out. They surely must be shagging!

But he has deleted all of their previous conversations aswell. I think there's probably a lot more to it than just being friendly.

girlmom21 · 10/10/2022 10:23

I was going to tell you you're overreacting because IME the receptionist is the person you go and chat to and have a laugh with when you need to get away from your desk for 10 minutes but he's deleted all their previous conversations so now I'm suspicious.