Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Frustrated and let down by my friend

114 replies

LovingLifesHurdles · 09/10/2022 23:07

Please help me get my hormonal, pregnant emotions in check!

My friend, who used to be a nanny, now runs her own business doing a number of other things. I love that she has found her passion & have supported her emotionally and practically.

I work and need someone to pick up my DD from nursery a couple times a week and bring her home. My friend lives a short walk to me & the nursery. I asked my friend months in advance and made it clear I was looking for a professional commitment for 1 school year. I was clear that if she didn't have the time it was absolutely ok, I would find another alternative. She is more expensive than a childminder, but I was happy to pay. She agreed, seemed keen.

A month in, all seemingly going great. DD happy to be with my friend, friend seems happy too, no behaviour issues, I am on time for handover, pay on time. Got a message out of the blue saying she no longer wants to carry on with our arrangement as she has offer of more work through her business and doesn't have time for DD anymore.

I'm so frustrated and angry. She's basically left me in the shit because she received a better offer. Sorting out new childcare at 3 weeks notice in the middle of term is a nightmare here. We don't live in a big place so options are super limited and everyone recommended is now busy. It would have been no issue when I initially started looking.

Aibu to feel that if you make a professional commitment, or a commitment to a friend you don't just walk away because you don't fancy it anymore?? I know I am probably being somewhat unreasonable but I just feel so let down! Childcare during covid has been such a nightmare and every time I finally start to think it's sorted I'm back to square 1. I have a really full on job and I can't keep dropping out due to childcare if I intend to keep my job!

Please help me give my head a wobble! Would you be ok with this and carry on with the friendship as before? What do I say to her when I see her next week?

OP posts:
mumda · 10/10/2022 08:14

Move forward with your actual problem of finding a replacement.

Addicted2LoveIsland · 10/10/2022 08:12

Also - just because she didn't word it with "yes but only if my business doesn't pick up" doesn't mean she was being dishonest. Isn't that a given?? Even if she didn't want to do it just because she didn't doesn't matter. She gave you notice.

LuckyLil · 10/10/2022 08:10

LovingLifesHurdles · 09/10/2022 23:18

I know what you are saying about friendships and business but I honestly thought we could make it through 10 months without ruining our friendship or I would have never asked. I thought if I was just on my best behaviour, made sure DD was polite and kind etc we would have no issues. Clearly I was wrong!

Also I am not sure I would take a promotion at the cost of leaving my friend in the shit, unless perhaps it was super awful circumstances perhaps? (Also this isn't quite that, it's just an offer of more work)

Does the new work pay more than you are paying or less?

Addicted2LoveIsland · 10/10/2022 08:09

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 07:18

Thank you all for your comments. I am going to think about this more and try and give myself some more time before I react to my friend.

Those suggesting I blurred the lines are right I think. I just don't know how to sort my thinking out.

Those who wonder if I held my friend to a higher standard than a childminder - yes I did! Is that wrong to assume friends would treat you better than strangers?

For those saying I shouldn't expect her to turn down work - it's a tricky one to explain without being outing but she wouldn't actually have to turn any down. She has just decided that with the additional work she is now too busy. Of course it's within her rights to do so, I just feel very let down. We are talking a couple of hours a week which aren't at a time she has business commitments.

I think what it comes down to for me is that I repeatedly asked her if she was able to commit to this. Her answer should have been - yes but only if my main business doesn't pick up. I would have expected this level of honestly from my friend. Then I would have made a different decision myself.

But yes, I was naive, yes definitely lesson learnt (again!) not to mix business with friends/ family.

OP you say "with the additional work she will be too busy" and "a couple of hours a week when she isn't busy" - how do you know? You don't know when she will be busy or not; she is self employed so works the hours she chooses. For example, its 8am and I'm about to do invoicing for my business in a minute. Sometimes, I work at 2am because I have been doing other things during work hours. When self employed that's how it is - you don't get to dictate about her working hours. It doesn't matter if YOU feel the school run won't interfere with her work (even a couple of hours a week) - yet you yourself can't do it because of your job - this is a double standard and really bloody entitled.

mountaindewview · 10/10/2022 08:06

What does your contract with her say re notice?

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 08:01

DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/10/2022 07:51

Why should she pass up work in the short term just in case she gets busier in the long term?- no one operates like that- we have to live in our current circumstances which is all she’s done. You’ve expected far more from her than you’re entitled to- as a friend or an employer.

An expectation of honestly around her commitment levels is more than I am entitled to as a friend or employer? Is that really the case?

And I would have expected a face to face conversation, rather than an FYI text on a Sunday night. And an 'I'm sorry for dropping out so soon / dropping you in it ' wouldn't have hurt ...

Nowhere have I said I expected her to sit out the year. But I would have expected a longer notice, especially as it isn't directly impacting her business.

OP posts:
DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/10/2022 07:51

Why should she pass up work in the short term just in case she gets busier in the long term?- no one operates like that- we have to live in our current circumstances which is all she’s done. You’ve expected far more from her than you’re entitled to- as a friend or an employer.

IamnotSethRogan · 10/10/2022 07:28

YABU. The commitment was made when it worked for her. Now it no longer works for her and she's given you plenty of notice. Of course you're not being unreasonable to be disappointed but I wouldn't be cross at my friend.

TheHoover · 10/10/2022 07:27

After school provision is so tough to find. You have my sympathy.

I don’t think your friend is BU though. People’s livelihoods are more important than friendships. She should not feel obliged to carry on with an arrangement that doesn’t work for her just because it’s for a friend.

Time will tell what happens to the friendship.

mountaindewview · 10/10/2022 07:22

I'm sorry but I think you've effectively asked for an 8/9 month notice period and that's very unrealistic.

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 07:18

Thank you all for your comments. I am going to think about this more and try and give myself some more time before I react to my friend.

Those suggesting I blurred the lines are right I think. I just don't know how to sort my thinking out.

Those who wonder if I held my friend to a higher standard than a childminder - yes I did! Is that wrong to assume friends would treat you better than strangers?

For those saying I shouldn't expect her to turn down work - it's a tricky one to explain without being outing but she wouldn't actually have to turn any down. She has just decided that with the additional work she is now too busy. Of course it's within her rights to do so, I just feel very let down. We are talking a couple of hours a week which aren't at a time she has business commitments.

I think what it comes down to for me is that I repeatedly asked her if she was able to commit to this. Her answer should have been - yes but only if my main business doesn't pick up. I would have expected this level of honestly from my friend. Then I would have made a different decision myself.

But yes, I was naive, yes definitely lesson learnt (again!) not to mix business with friends/ family.

OP posts:
TellTheWolves · 10/10/2022 03:38

YABU. She’s had a better offer and given notice. Are you saying you’ve never left a job for a better offer and given your notice? Unlikely

TedMullins · 10/10/2022 03:35

YABU. She’s done nothing wrong. She’s given you notice in favour of a presumably more lucrative business offer which any sensible self employed person would do.

lannistunut · 10/10/2022 03:04

if you make a professional commitment, or a commitment to a friend you don't just walk away because you don't fancy it anymore??

I think four weeks' notice would have been all you could expect from a nanny and you are being unreasonable really. You are asking for a friend to feel obligated for a whole year, no one should be asked for that IMO. Your friend hasn't walked away because they 'don't fancy it anymore' they've got an opportunity to develop their main job in their own business.

You blurred the boundaries between friendship and business. You can't seriously ask your friend to put their business on hold for a year for this casual contract with you. If I were you I'd try to accept this graciously and learn from the experience.

FlipFlopBattle · 10/10/2022 02:56

As well as not mixing work/friends, I would add, based on personal experience, not to mix nannying and a new business!

First Nanny we hired was experienced, enthusiastic, wanted to cut down to after-school hours for a year so she could help her husband with the business he'd just started.

We agreed 4 weeks' notice on either side. First week of term, all was great. I was surprised that she asked on the first Sunday morning if I could pay for hours already done, as it was her who had suggested fortnightly payments, but no problem.

Sunday night, another message, saying thanks for the money and sorry for lack of notice but the business had won a massive bid that required both of them full-time immediately!

I learnt from that to be more observant about what someone's actual passion/next career goal is, as they often unconsciously give away where their priorities would lie. e.g. interviewed another experienced Nanny who was slightly reserved. I asked what she did in her spare time: eyes lit up, some sort of social media influencer thing that was going well and "already" covered half of the bills. Totally obvious (to me) that she'd basically just said she'd jack in the nannying immediately if the other gig increased. Didn't hire her...

user1471457751 · 10/10/2022 02:55

How many people here criticising the friend would think it reasonable for an employer to demand a 9 month notice period? Because that is essentially what the OP is wanting right now. She said she wanted this on professional terms not as a friend doing a favour. And professional terms is giving notice when you quit your job - for such a small job like this anything beyond 4 weeks would be madness.

The OP hired her friend on a fixed term contract. It's no surprise the friend has gone for a better position. I'm sure the usual advice on here to a woman employed on a ftc with a better job offer would be to quit as a 1 year contract provides no security whatsoever.

user1477249785 · 10/10/2022 02:28

I think the replies here are odd. You say you expected this to be a professional arrangement. I have employed nannies including part time and guess what? Life changes and sometimes they leave. It's a job, with a notice period. Not a commitment for life. I actually think you are blurring the professional and personal. In the former, this is ok and to be expected occasionally. You are cross because as a friend, you think she owes you more...

Moonshine5 · 10/10/2022 02:26

If she wasn't a 'friend' would you hold her to a higher or lower account- OP do you expect anybody to turn down a promotion ?

Addicted2LoveIsland · 10/10/2022 02:10

Addicted2LoveIsland · 10/10/2022 02:08

If she's only been doing it a month she doesn't even have to give you notice so I think 3 weeks is fine. It's frustrating but things like this happen all the time. If you didn't need her anymore you'd give her notice too. It works both ways.
Yes she did leave you for something better which she is well within her rights to do. She's perfectly entitled to better herself and berated business.
You don't own people because they work for you.
By your own admission you can't do pick ups because of your job. She now can't because of her job.
Your child = your problem.

That's meant to say "better her business"

Addicted2LoveIsland · 10/10/2022 02:08

If she's only been doing it a month she doesn't even have to give you notice so I think 3 weeks is fine. It's frustrating but things like this happen all the time. If you didn't need her anymore you'd give her notice too. It works both ways.
Yes she did leave you for something better which she is well within her rights to do. She's perfectly entitled to better herself and berated business.
You don't own people because they work for you.
By your own admission you can't do pick ups because of your job. She now can't because of her job.
Your child = your problem.

neighboursmustliveon · 10/10/2022 01:31

I briefly used a friend who was a childminder to mind my child. She let me down 3 times in 5 months, twice last minute ie the night before and one of those times was completely unavoidable she just chose to let me down (my child was her only all day care that day so she did all her pre and post school care but said she couldn't have my child to go hang out keeping someone company.

I stopped using her as I didn't have a job that was able to be so flexible and we switched to nursery who were never an issue in the 4 years we used them.

VeganSoulFood · 10/10/2022 01:09

I get why you’re annoyed, but honestly, I think mixing friendship with a professional commitment always has the potential for this kind of messiness, and I also think it was a little odd you asked her in the first place, given that she no longer works in childcare, but runs her own business. Obviously she could have said no, and with hindsight she should have, but the possibility of her being offered extra work that would be tempting to prioritise over this kind of very part-time arrangement was always there.

Cw112 · 10/10/2022 00:46

I kind of think times are tough at the moment and she's maybe in a position being self employed that she cannot turn down more work due to costs and covering her bills. Yes ideally she'd have given you more notice but equally if that bit more notice came at the expense of her being able to keep her business going then is that what you'd want for your friend? You said earlier "it's not a promotion its an offer of more work" if you're self employed promotion isn't exactly on the table but more steady work is self promotion in itself you sound like you don't massively understand or value what it takes to run a business. I'd speak to her, explain you were upset and felt that you should have got more notice from her because she knows it will leave you in the lurch and see what she says. I know childcare is a mare to sort out and no wonder it's got you stressed but with so many businesses closing their doors and winter electricity and heating bills going up I think you need to factor that into why she's maybe had to do it.

Changeee1546789 · 10/10/2022 00:28

You are completely right to feel angry OP and I would too.

I asked my friend months in advance and made it clear I was looking for a professional commitment for 1 school year. I was clear that if she didn't have the time it was absolutely ok, I would find another alternative. She is more expensive than a childminder, but I was happy to pay. She agreed, seemed keen

That is the long and short of it. I would not give two fucks if she has new business, she committed to something to help out a friend and has now bailed leaving only 3 weeks which is selfish and shit especially when DC is involved. I would struggle to continue on a friendship like this OP.

nannyquestion1 · 09/10/2022 23:54

saraclara · 09/10/2022 23:38

You can't expect anyone to commit to a very part time role for a year.
I get that it's frustrating, but I think you are naive to think that anyone growing a new business would pass over a much larger job for the sake of a few hours for her friend.

Yes you can if the person agreed to it!! Full job spec was upfront, nothing hidden.