Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Frustrated and let down by my friend

114 replies

LovingLifesHurdles · 09/10/2022 23:07

Please help me get my hormonal, pregnant emotions in check!

My friend, who used to be a nanny, now runs her own business doing a number of other things. I love that she has found her passion & have supported her emotionally and practically.

I work and need someone to pick up my DD from nursery a couple times a week and bring her home. My friend lives a short walk to me & the nursery. I asked my friend months in advance and made it clear I was looking for a professional commitment for 1 school year. I was clear that if she didn't have the time it was absolutely ok, I would find another alternative. She is more expensive than a childminder, but I was happy to pay. She agreed, seemed keen.

A month in, all seemingly going great. DD happy to be with my friend, friend seems happy too, no behaviour issues, I am on time for handover, pay on time. Got a message out of the blue saying she no longer wants to carry on with our arrangement as she has offer of more work through her business and doesn't have time for DD anymore.

I'm so frustrated and angry. She's basically left me in the shit because she received a better offer. Sorting out new childcare at 3 weeks notice in the middle of term is a nightmare here. We don't live in a big place so options are super limited and everyone recommended is now busy. It would have been no issue when I initially started looking.

Aibu to feel that if you make a professional commitment, or a commitment to a friend you don't just walk away because you don't fancy it anymore?? I know I am probably being somewhat unreasonable but I just feel so let down! Childcare during covid has been such a nightmare and every time I finally start to think it's sorted I'm back to square 1. I have a really full on job and I can't keep dropping out due to childcare if I intend to keep my job!

Please help me give my head a wobble! Would you be ok with this and carry on with the friendship as before? What do I say to her when I see her next week?

OP posts:
Vapeyvapevape · 10/10/2022 13:39

I think as a friend, I would have expected a bit more than a message, at least a phone call. The fact that she hasn't called makes me think she just doesn't want to do it anymore and doesn't want to get into the details as to why.

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 13:38

LeningradSymphony · 10/10/2022 13:11

I'm the same OP. A commitment is a commitment. If she had come to you to talk it over and try and figure something out then I'm sure you'd feel differently. For example broached it and told you the situation, apologised for letting you down and ask if you can find someone else and agreed to remain in the position until you've got another person. But to just commit to a year and then drop out out of the blue is really awful and says a lot about her.

It's a bit different to people talking about fixed term contracts, in my experience when you get a fixed term contract the onus is on the employer to employ you for that time period but not necessarily on the employee to agree to stay for that long. Whereas here quite obviously you emphasised you would need her for a year!

Obviously it's a lesson learned to not mix friends and business, and to ensure you have a contract if this ever came up in the future. At least setting out a notice period so you're not stuck trying to find someone else at such short notice.

Totally understand why you're so unhappy and yes, it would affect the friendship if it were me.

This sums up how I am feeling really well, thank you.

But I accept this seems to be a minority approach and apparently people don't care about commitments to/ from friends or employers. I will have to reset my expectations a bit.

Yes business with friends/family is a disaster. One I will not be repeating.

OP posts:
Kissingfrogs25 · 10/10/2022 13:13

You are being unreasonable. She is allowed to change her mind about what works for her, and additionally to earn more money doing something else! She is not obliged to continue in any shape or form, and I am surprised you are so annoyed. You have ages to source an alternative arrangement.

We are experiencing a crunch, of course she has to prioritise her bills.
Be gracious and accepting, and you can continue as before with a normal friendship.

LeningradSymphony · 10/10/2022 13:11

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 12:40

If we are talking about my real job, yes absolutely I would not walk out after a few weeks with the excuse that I had a better offer - it's against my morals but if nothing else my professional reputation would be trashed. In the corporate world these kinds of things always come out and it never ends well.

Talking in this particular situation in my friends shoes I may have made the same decision (I don't know her finances, or how much better this may or may not be paid) but definitely not with such short notice and not handling it in the way she has. And I would certainly have expected her to be upset with me and done everything I could to fix the situation.

I'm the same OP. A commitment is a commitment. If she had come to you to talk it over and try and figure something out then I'm sure you'd feel differently. For example broached it and told you the situation, apologised for letting you down and ask if you can find someone else and agreed to remain in the position until you've got another person. But to just commit to a year and then drop out out of the blue is really awful and says a lot about her.

It's a bit different to people talking about fixed term contracts, in my experience when you get a fixed term contract the onus is on the employer to employ you for that time period but not necessarily on the employee to agree to stay for that long. Whereas here quite obviously you emphasised you would need her for a year!

Obviously it's a lesson learned to not mix friends and business, and to ensure you have a contract if this ever came up in the future. At least setting out a notice period so you're not stuck trying to find someone else at such short notice.

Totally understand why you're so unhappy and yes, it would affect the friendship if it were me.

TedMullins · 10/10/2022 13:03

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 12:40

If we are talking about my real job, yes absolutely I would not walk out after a few weeks with the excuse that I had a better offer - it's against my morals but if nothing else my professional reputation would be trashed. In the corporate world these kinds of things always come out and it never ends well.

Talking in this particular situation in my friends shoes I may have made the same decision (I don't know her finances, or how much better this may or may not be paid) but definitely not with such short notice and not handling it in the way she has. And I would certainly have expected her to be upset with me and done everything I could to fix the situation.

Well then I think you are in a minority. I’d absolutely bail on a job for a better offer. Everyone is expendable to an employer so it’s foolish to have any loyalty to them imo. When friendship is involved it’s a bit more complicated as there is loyalty but from many people’s point of view here she did give you sufficient notice. And whatever other issues you might have with childcare aren’t her problem. It sounds like you expect her to bow under the pressure and expectations of a friendship without actually thinking about what’s best for her.

DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/10/2022 12:46

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 11:37

You've read my posts and come to the conclusion that I think I am more important than my friend? Or that my job is more important than hers? Wow that's really sad for me to hear.

A little bit, yes- you seemed annoyed that she doesn’t want to carry on doing something she doesn’t want to and doesn’t suit her, as it’d be best for you if she does. To me that says you think your needs are more important than hers.
I know it’s frustrating but imo she’s done nothing wrong other than not showing that bit of empathy and acknowledging its a pain for you to find a new arrangement. Her actions are fine- she’s found a better way to make money for herself which she’s entitled to do.

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 12:40

TedMullins · 10/10/2022 12:31

Using your example of getting a year’s work contract - are you really saying if you were offered something better and more lucrative a few weeks in you wouldn’t take it? If that’s the case I think you’re in a minority.

If we are talking about my real job, yes absolutely I would not walk out after a few weeks with the excuse that I had a better offer - it's against my morals but if nothing else my professional reputation would be trashed. In the corporate world these kinds of things always come out and it never ends well.

Talking in this particular situation in my friends shoes I may have made the same decision (I don't know her finances, or how much better this may or may not be paid) but definitely not with such short notice and not handling it in the way she has. And I would certainly have expected her to be upset with me and done everything I could to fix the situation.

OP posts:
TedMullins · 10/10/2022 12:31

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 08:31

Yes I understand that I am blurring the lines but I'm really struggling to sort through my thoughts on this.

I treated it as a business transaction - in what way? As in I didn't ask for it as a favour and made sure I paid her a decent rate? I would have thought that would have been a good thing? That I made sure to ask a few times if it definitely did work for her?

I actually would have expected a professional response back (I think). Dropping out of a work commitment less than a month in, at short notice is poor business behaviour I think. I wouldn't get away with dropping out of a project at work a few weeks into a 1 year project because it didn't work for me anymore. It is unprofessional I think. But people seem to disagree.

From a friend perspective all I expected would have been an honest conversation up front about not being able to commit, probably to be told in person and perhaps some sort of apology for not honouring a commitment.

Using your example of getting a year’s work contract - are you really saying if you were offered something better and more lucrative a few weeks in you wouldn’t take it? If that’s the case I think you’re in a minority.

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 11:37

DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/10/2022 10:35

If you’re now viewing this as a business transaction then usually a probationary period would apply where only one weeks notice is required for a childcare role.

You can’t have the best of both- a years commitment for a very part time and low paying role as she’s a friend to you, and then the disappointment that she’s let you down with “insufficient” notice that’s actually a lot longer than you’d ordinarily be entitled to.

I know sorting out childcare is an absolute nightmare- I’ve been there. But it’s just one of those things, and in the meantime both parents regardless of how high flying and important their day jobs are just have to suck it up, juggle like mad and find an alternative. Her life isn’t less important than yours because you’ve got a big career and she’s made the choice that suits her and her family best from a routine/financial point of view. I do think that in her shoes I would have apologised that the arrangement hadn’t worked out and shown a bit of empathy for your situation but I probably wouldn’t have actually acted differently with the 3 weeks notice.

You've read my posts and come to the conclusion that I think I am more important than my friend? Or that my job is more important than hers? Wow that's really sad for me to hear.

OP posts:
LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 11:35

ThighMistress · 10/10/2022 11:00

The friend is not an indentured servant - they are entitled for whatever reason to end the arrangement. It may be for career reasons or even because she wants a snooze in front of Countdown at 3.30 instead of trudging to school and back.

I should think the reason why most people don’t choose to do paid school pick-ups (if they don’t have their own child) is because it’s a huge tie for little return. Perhaps the friend has realised that having to be available every single weekday at 3pm (racing back from somewhere, no holidays etc) is too much of an ask.

Even friends are allowed to back out of arrangements - I think asking her to commit to a whole year was way too ambitious. A term at a time, maybe, but the friend probably saw the whole year stretching before her and realised it’s an awful lot of afternoons buggered.

Just 2 afternoons a week, obviously just in term time and I made it clear if she has wanted time off it wouldn't have been an issue. And by the way, all the reasons you mentioned for not wanting to do it is why I repeatedly checked if she definitely wanted to.

Yes absolutely you are right on the idea that asking for the year was obviously too much, but I really wish she would have said so.

In future the idea of a term at a time seems more feasible, but honestly I don't know how you are supposed to stay that flexible regarding childcare. How do other working parents do it? How do you keep finding new childcare? How are young kids supposed to cope with having a new caregiver introduced every few weeks? My DD is pretty confident and friendly for her age but I can see it's not easy for her having to keep adjusting. I have utterly lost count of how many times in the last 2 years I have had to ask for flexibility from my manager (thank god she is so utterly lovely and understanding, but she can't keep covering for me forever). I honestly just thought I finally had it sorted for the year 😥

OP posts:
Oneandone · 10/10/2022 11:02

I voted YANBU just because 3 weeks isn't a lot of notice for someone to figure out childcare. She's not in the wrong for breaking your agreement completely, people can quit jobs for a better offer. But it's just not enough notice imo and she should know that as someone who has worked in childcare.

ThighMistress · 10/10/2022 11:00

The friend is not an indentured servant - they are entitled for whatever reason to end the arrangement. It may be for career reasons or even because she wants a snooze in front of Countdown at 3.30 instead of trudging to school and back.

I should think the reason why most people don’t choose to do paid school pick-ups (if they don’t have their own child) is because it’s a huge tie for little return. Perhaps the friend has realised that having to be available every single weekday at 3pm (racing back from somewhere, no holidays etc) is too much of an ask.

Even friends are allowed to back out of arrangements - I think asking her to commit to a whole year was way too ambitious. A term at a time, maybe, but the friend probably saw the whole year stretching before her and realised it’s an awful lot of afternoons buggered.

MrsJamieDornan · 10/10/2022 10:45

user1477249785 · 10/10/2022 02:28

I think the replies here are odd. You say you expected this to be a professional arrangement. I have employed nannies including part time and guess what? Life changes and sometimes they leave. It's a job, with a notice period. Not a commitment for life. I actually think you are blurring the professional and personal. In the former, this is ok and to be expected occasionally. You are cross because as a friend, you think she owes you more...

This.

I think you're blurring lines. If it was a professional relationship 3 weeks notice after a month seems ok. I get it's frustrating and problematic for you but you can't expect her to put her work on hold for what sounds very short but intrusive hours.

DailyEnergyCrisis · 10/10/2022 10:35

If you’re now viewing this as a business transaction then usually a probationary period would apply where only one weeks notice is required for a childcare role.

You can’t have the best of both- a years commitment for a very part time and low paying role as she’s a friend to you, and then the disappointment that she’s let you down with “insufficient” notice that’s actually a lot longer than you’d ordinarily be entitled to.

I know sorting out childcare is an absolute nightmare- I’ve been there. But it’s just one of those things, and in the meantime both parents regardless of how high flying and important their day jobs are just have to suck it up, juggle like mad and find an alternative. Her life isn’t less important than yours because you’ve got a big career and she’s made the choice that suits her and her family best from a routine/financial point of view. I do think that in her shoes I would have apologised that the arrangement hadn’t worked out and shown a bit of empathy for your situation but I probably wouldn’t have actually acted differently with the 3 weeks notice.

pantsville · 10/10/2022 10:27

Friend has the right to end the arrangement. OP has the right to be frustrated by the situation she’s now in as a result and hurt by lack of apology. Both of these things can be true at the same time.

The fact you will have to continue to see each other socially will make it more awkward if you don’t talk about it. I find the lack of apology probably the worst part. Oblivious to how much it’s impacting you? Trying to be blasé about it in the hopes you will be too?

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 10:20

Darkplaces · 10/10/2022 10:13

You are allowed to feel let down and disappointed.
But at the same time, your friend didn't do anything wrong.
Do you often find that friends don't live up to your expectations?

No I really don't. That's why I am struggling so much. I have picked up friends from all walks of life and have had no issues maintaining friendships over 20 years.

Actually you really have a point. As a rule I try to set expectations low and where possible focus on weathering the storms together. My only expectation is treating friends with kindness.

But I do have high expectations of people I do business with. Actually this has really clarified where I've gone wrong with this mentally, thank you. I expected a business interaction with a friend, but instead my friend seems to have approached this more as a side hussle that suited her at the time but no longer does. Fair enough, still disappointed though.

OP posts:
NotLactoseFree · 10/10/2022 10:17

I don't really understand. It's a professional relationship - anyone can cancel a professional relationship, with notice, at any time. Which she has done. I do completely understand why you are frustrated and upset, but she isn't doing anything wrong. She has the right to find work that pays more, as long as she doesn't screw you.

Darkplaces · 10/10/2022 10:13

You are allowed to feel let down and disappointed.
But at the same time, your friend didn't do anything wrong.
Do you often find that friends don't live up to your expectations?

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 10:10

Blowthemandown · 10/10/2022 09:25

@LovingLifesHurdles I think I’d ask if she can continue a bit longer while you sort an alternative. At that point explain you had thought you had a commitment and you had given her plenty of options to say no and you now wish she had said no to begin with. See how she responds and take it from there. Otherwise things will just fester.

Yes maybe you are right. Especially as it's going to be hard to avoid her where I live. Our friendship circles overlap and we do end up at a lot of social events. But I am not sure what exactly I can say as loads of people seem to think 3 weeks notice over text is perfectly reasonable in this situation. I definitely wish she had said no!

But I don't think I will ask her to extend, I don't want her dropping out last minute.

OP posts:
butterfliedtwo · 10/10/2022 10:09

Yes, it's odd to expect friends to turn down a promotion, especially in this economy. She gave you notice without having a contract.

LovingLifesHurdles · 10/10/2022 10:00

saraclara · 10/10/2022 09:48

Also I am not sure I would take a promotion at the cost of leaving my friend in the shit,

Even if the job you were doing for your friend was only for two hours a week, as in this case?

As I said in the original response, it's not a good analogy. She isn't having to turn down a promotion. She has just decided because her business is now more busy she doesn't have time for DD pickup anymore. It's not one or the other, she could do both, but choses not to. That's her choice. But it was not entirely unpredictable that she might have more work come in (think custom goods artist/ seller making something hand made), which is why I checked quite a few times that she definitely wanted to do this and could commit to it.

But also yes, I stand by my statement that my friends are more important to me than a promotion. Is that really so odd? And if I really did need to take the promotion I would do my absolute best to help my friend out of the situation I put them in, and I would have the courtesy to apologize.

OP posts:
pantsville · 10/10/2022 09:50

I think you can be honest with her when you speak to her. Explain how you made it as clear as possible you needed a 1 year commitment. By going back on the agreement she’s put you in a difficult situation as you will have missed out on other childcare options. You’re now in the position of having to scramble around trying to find something else at short notice.

I wouldn’t expect her to change her mind at this point - it could well just be an excuse as she’s not keen on doing it any more. But I wouldn’t be pretending to be happy about it. She is the one who’s made the poor decisions here I think.

saraclara · 10/10/2022 09:48

Also I am not sure I would take a promotion at the cost of leaving my friend in the shit,

Even if the job you were doing for your friend was only for two hours a week, as in this case?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 10/10/2022 09:36

YANBU for feeling disappointed.

But I think holding her to standards different than any other childminder, regarding the notice period, is BU.

lickenchugget · 10/10/2022 09:27

Also I am not sure I would take a promotion at the cost of leaving my friend in the shit, unless perhaps it was super awful circumstances perhaps? (Also this isn't quite that, it's just an offer of more work)

This is really unfair. I would absolutely expect anyone to move for a promotion in any role, friend or professional (especially in the current financial climate). She’s given you notice; I’m not sure what else you expect. Anyone can leave any job at any time, it’s no different because you are friends. As others have said, this is the issue with mixing friend and business, your expectations of her have not matched with hers