Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Totally agree with Sturgeon re the tories

364 replies

FayeGovan · 09/10/2022 22:21

I destest them and their policies too

Good on her for telling it like it is

I know shes hated on mn, or rather on scotsnet. They prefer the tories there, christ knows why. Independence is a dirty word on scotsnet. So i know I'll be shot down, but i couldn't care less.

Good on you Nicola👍

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 15:11

worriedatthistime · 10/10/2022 15:09

Also has she not learnt anything about use of language from mp's and what this can cause
Disgusting

On a minor point of pedantry, Nicola Sturgeon is not an MP.

But please elaborate?

worriedatthistime · 10/10/2022 15:09

Also has she not learnt anything about use of language from mp's and what this can cause
Disgusting

worriedatthistime · 10/10/2022 15:04

@Honeysuckle16 you don't have to have it written in black and white to show when someone dislikes someone
Also her policies show what she thinks of women and womens rights

Pugdogmom · 10/10/2022 15:03

English born ,living in Scotland and I support Scottish Independence. The anti English stuff was by a particular rabid Scottish Independence supporter who is nothing to do with the SNP and I believe is banned from ever joining them. Pretty nasty individual. Turned up at an SNP conference, with his stupid banner and was challenged by English Scots for Independence. Yes they are a very active group, so get fed up with people stating that everyone who supports Independence is anti English 🙄.
And according to people on here, the only country that couldn't survive on their own is Scotland, despite many countries in Europe being formed in the last 30 years , and goodness knows how many more countries that have survived splitting from the UK .
I'm a bit puzzled as to why that RUK ( I mean the Westminster government), is so desperate to keep us if we are such a drain on their resources. 🤷‍♀️. You'd think they'd want shot of us.
Personally I think NS is completely correct about the Tories, and I don't agree with everything she says, but some absolutely vile stuff has been said about her on this thread. You don't have to like her, but some of the comments here from supposedly grown adults is pretty disgusting.
I don't like Liz Truss, but I would never resort to the vile name calling that's displayed on here.

worriedatthistime · 10/10/2022 15:03

@OnaBegonia its not irony england has a much much bigger population and she is not well liked as she is very anti english and shows it , you wouldn't have a welsh or english MP allowed to act
They are part of the uk so do fall under westminster but have a lot if say in how scotland is run and its not in a great place under the snp either
You have to have more policies than independence

derxa · 10/10/2022 15:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh my God! 😆 I've been posting here for years. I'm a sheep farmer in the Borders.
I would report your post calling me a troll but best that it stands

worriedatthistime · 10/10/2022 14:59

Well she can have an opinion but doesn't look like she is doing that great a job either

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 14:55

sst1234 · 10/10/2022 14:21

You’d have to politically illiterate to think Nicola Sturgeon does a good job. SNP’s record in office is disastrous. Even worse than the Tories.

And if you have children, you will be sorry as her policies actively put children in harm’s way.

What is your yardstick for measuring SNP performance v's Westminster Tory?

If you are going to make a highly questionable claim, it's only proper that you qualify it and lend some credence to it, or it doesn't merit any notice whatsoever.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 14:45

You’re bonkers! Scotland would have exited the EU guaranteed if it had got independence in 2014. The no vote was the only thing that stopped that. Fact!

This simply is not true. Pointlessly exclaiming 'Fact!' does not make it any less untrue, but 'yes' did not do a good enough job of explaining exactly why, which enabled 'Better Together' to play up on EU Nationals' fears of being booted out in the event of 'Yes', despite there being absolutely no requirement for that to be the case nor there being any actual proposal to do it.

The deliberately misleading part of the retrospective unionist take on this, is they presupposed that as soon as Scotland tallied up the votes, the next day the EU would simply go 'right, that's you oot', when that isn't the case at all. There was 18 months between the date of the vote and the proposed date for Indi, and as Scotland was fully EU compliant at the time, the EU have confirmed since that there should have been no significant hurdle to ratifying contiguous EU membership.

It's yet another unionist myth that Scotland would have been 'booted out' of the EU as soon as we tallied up 50%+1 'yes' votes. Our Eu membership was not going to end the instant we voted 'yes'.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 14:34

ie If Labour win does that change votes for those who say they despise Tories

I know this wasn't directed specifically at me, but I can answer on behalf of myself, and the committed pro-independence people I know.

Attitudes to this prospect were pretty much explained concisely by the FM yesterday morning. The worst possible scenario is the reprehensible shower in UK government right now, and while a Labour Westminster administration would be preferable to that, it's like asking if you want a shit sandwich or a shit sandwich with chocolate sprinkles.

Labour is still ardently pro-union, and many of their policy approaches that matter to Indi-minded Scots are indistinguishable from the Tories themselves. The Labour party has moved so far away from what they used to be when they genuinely were the party of consensus in Scotland that most Scots just don't recognise them any more, so they don't even carry any sort of romantic 'hark back to the old days' sentiment either. They're a centre/centre right party under Starmer no matter how much they kid on otherwise, and their Scots counterparts are still nothing more than a completely inconsequential branch office.

In short, yes, Labour in Westminster is preferable to Tory, if for no other reason than to be spared the most egregious excesses, and established incompetence of the Tory party, but Labour still offers nothing at all to sate a desire for Independence. It's not even a matter that revolves around that one issue. Labour has made it abundantly clear that they are a hard Brexit party now, and that is also fundamentally at odds with the view of the vast majority of Scots pro-indi voters.

I've no doubt that the prospect of Westminster Labour genuinely winning a UK election would entice a few more Scots to vote that way to hurry it along, we see that already in elections in Scotland with the unionist vote flopping either labour/conservative (baffling, but there you go) where there is a chance to stop a pro-indi party, but the idea that Labour in government in westminster would lead to a Labour resurgence in Scotland is wishful thinking. It was Labour in governance in Westminster that finally woke Scots up to the fact that it doesn't make the blindest bit of difference who is governing from there, Labour or Tory, they are still first and foremost a party entirely preoccupied and concerned with England, they have to be for the sake of electability, hence why that traditional vote completely collapsed and the SNP stepped into the void.

derxa · 10/10/2022 14:33

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:29

@derxa "You know nothing about agriculture in Scotland that's for sure" 🤣🤣

Aye ok mrs wiki 😆🤦🏻‍♀️💀 pure riddy for you.

Well I'm waiting for your evidence for your claims. I come from a long line of Scottish farmers. Some tenants and then land owners. If you had gone on about the Highland Clearances and sheep you might have had a point. But Aberdeen Angus nah!

Alexandra2001 · 10/10/2022 14:29

You’re bonkers! Scotland would have exited the EU guaranteed if it had got independence in 2014. The no vote was the only thing that stopped that. Fact!
the fact that the UK left the EU afterwards is neither here nor there!

Scotland may well of carried its through its EU membership, you don't know it wouldn't have, a YES vote would have taken many years to implement, plenty of time for them to negotiate remaining in the EU... its an unknown.

Now of course, they would have apply as a new member.... with a very uncertain outcome.

Brexit is a material change to Scotlands status, they should be given the chance to vote again.

I agree with a PP, a Labour Govt, may well change how Scotland would vote in any referendum.

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:29

@derxa "You know nothing about agriculture in Scotland that's for sure" 🤣🤣

Aye ok mrs wiki 😆🤦🏻‍♀️💀 pure riddy for you.

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:27

@Roomytrouser not adverse to that as long as it bears zero resemblance to the ermine coated never voted gluttonous greed of the lords.

Filled with ordinary folk who've led exemplary lives or given to their country or sports or charities etc 🙌🏻 I'd back that.

derxa · 10/10/2022 14:26

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:05

@derxa

I can't baby you through this I'm sorry. Of course the breed is scottish. However the vast majority of land was owned by English landlord's & farmed by scottish tenants with little/no rights.
Aberdeen Angus were in huge demand worldwide particularly in southern USA
It made economic sense to the English landlords to use their land to grow crops to feed and house (for want of a better word ) cattle rather than food for the scottish people living & working on the land. A huge amount of these same landlords held swathes of fruit laden orchards and lands in England. Feeding their tenants with sugar high white breads & jams changed the scottish diet from a wheat, barley, oats & seafood & protein diet to a sugar based one had huge political & social & health impact that remains to this day.

Poor (aka greed) decisions of the landowners has cast long shadows on scottish health & diet & poverty. Old sons cast long shadows.

I notice you didn't comment on the Elgin marbles. 🤨

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_McCombie
The main breeder of Aberdeen Angus. Not an English landlord at all. Aberdeenshire is famous for its cattle and sheep breeding and this continues to this day. You know nothing about agriculture in Scotland that's for sure.

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:26

First they ignore you
Then they laugh at you
Then they fight you
Then you win.

Indy is coming.
Democracy will out.

I feel sorry for those so wrapped up & warped in your vitriol that you can't see that. But hey ho. It is what it is & the snp keep winning.
Namaste.

Thanks to the interesting thoughtful posters. Genuinely.

Laters.

CapMarvel · 10/10/2022 14:25

sst1234 · 10/10/2022 14:21

You’d have to politically illiterate to think Nicola Sturgeon does a good job. SNP’s record in office is disastrous. Even worse than the Tories.

And if you have children, you will be sorry as her policies actively put children in harm’s way.

If you think the SNP's record is worse than the tories over the last 12 years I would request you leave that rock you seem to be living under.

Roomytrouser · 10/10/2022 14:25

I’d like a second chamber in Scottish politics.

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:22

@Fieldsofhay in your opinion. Not in the opinion of the scottish voting public who keep returning pro indy politicians in every single election.

Sorry that democracy is inconvenient for you.

RhannionKPSS · 10/10/2022 14:22

Honeysuckle16 · 10/10/2022 02:04

Thank you FayeGovan, and others for your posts with which I strongly agree.

There is so much mistaken information on this thread. For example:

  • that NS hates English people and England
  • that NS hates women and children
  • that NS works to the detriment of Scottish services.

These are not recognisable to many Scots including those who have voted in the SNP to government for the last 15 years.

NS has never said or written that she hates England. However, this is stated so often in the media and sites like MN that people have come to believe it’s true.

A gender-neutral cabinet, preference given to women candidates, NS’s support for care-experienced children which gives rights enshrined in Scottish law, free childcare for over 3 year olds, free bus travel for 12-18 year olds, the Scottish Child Payment of £20 weekly for each eligible child under 6 years old. It will increase to £25 per week and become available to all children up to the age of 16 on 14 November 2022. The Poverty Alliance reported this money was making a real difference to lifting Scottish families out of poverty.

Heard of any of these? They are scarcely, if at all, quoted in the media but are hard-fought steps taken by NS.

On Scottish services, it was reported earlier this week that Scotland had missed its targets for NHS waiting times, with much criticism following that. A few days later, results for England, Wales and NI were released, showing Scotland had done much better than other parts of the U.K. This was given virtually no attention in the media.

I’m not saying the SNP or NS are perfect, of course there is work to do. NS is making a positive difference to the lives of Scots and that’s why she is voted in.

Is that you Nicola?

sst1234 · 10/10/2022 14:21

You’d have to politically illiterate to think Nicola Sturgeon does a good job. SNP’s record in office is disastrous. Even worse than the Tories.

And if you have children, you will be sorry as her policies actively put children in harm’s way.

Fieldsofhay · 10/10/2022 14:19

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:16

Thanks @MarshaBradyo

Yup too late for me. And scottish Labour is a different breed from uk Labour (sadly) for example I think Zarah Sultana MP marvellous & I adore mick lynch.

I hear you re accepting a vote, but as I said further up, there has been huge material differences since the 2014 referendum. Not least brexit. Scottish voters were told categorically to vote no to stay in EU and so on.
The pound is worthless and no one (I know) believes in the strong shoulders of the UK anymore.

Also at that time a lot of elderly people believed that the tories were the safe economic choice (remember all the "can we keep the pound Chat"

Much like brexit - & their big red bus. Lies were told & some folk not so clued up were fooled.

My daughter was 10 at last referendum now 18 - a new crop of voters want a say.

I'm not adverse to there being discussions around how long it would have to be before any other vote could take place. Or perhaps a second vote once details were hammered out etc

But democracy changes, its an ever moving sea. & the only thing we can go on is that the voting scottish public keep voting in a pro -independence government & councils & MP's.

Thatcher 🤮 herself said if scotland wants independence all they need do is return a majority of pro-indy MPs

A union should really be one in which all 4 are held in equal status & voices as noteworthy as others, otherwise it's not a union at all, but an occupation.
With the uk Prime Minister Vowing to ignore our elected FM. There's no way this can go on, I'm afraid.
Wales won't be far behind I'm sure.

On a lighter note have you heard Martin sheen on Welsh independence- Marvellous.

twitter.com/owswills/status/1386986004482072579?s=46&t=2obFwQKt7PqY-scZbrIQBA

You’re bonkers! Scotland would have exited the EU guaranteed if it had got independence in 2014. The no vote was the only thing that stopped that. Fact!

the fact that the UK left the EU afterwards is neither here nor there!

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 14:16

Thanks @MarshaBradyo

Yup too late for me. And scottish Labour is a different breed from uk Labour (sadly) for example I think Zarah Sultana MP marvellous & I adore mick lynch.

I hear you re accepting a vote, but as I said further up, there has been huge material differences since the 2014 referendum. Not least brexit. Scottish voters were told categorically to vote no to stay in EU and so on.
The pound is worthless and no one (I know) believes in the strong shoulders of the UK anymore.

Also at that time a lot of elderly people believed that the tories were the safe economic choice (remember all the "can we keep the pound Chat"

Much like brexit - & their big red bus. Lies were told & some folk not so clued up were fooled.

My daughter was 10 at last referendum now 18 - a new crop of voters want a say.

I'm not adverse to there being discussions around how long it would have to be before any other vote could take place. Or perhaps a second vote once details were hammered out etc

But democracy changes, its an ever moving sea. & the only thing we can go on is that the voting scottish public keep voting in a pro -independence government & councils & MP's.

Thatcher 🤮 herself said if scotland wants independence all they need do is return a majority of pro-indy MPs

A union should really be one in which all 4 are held in equal status & voices as noteworthy as others, otherwise it's not a union at all, but an occupation.
With the uk Prime Minister Vowing to ignore our elected FM. There's no way this can go on, I'm afraid.
Wales won't be far behind I'm sure.

On a lighter note have you heard Martin sheen on Welsh independence- Marvellous.

twitter.com/owswills/status/1386986004482072579?s=46&t=2obFwQKt7PqY-scZbrIQBA

Fieldsofhay · 10/10/2022 14:13

And the Elgin marbles should go back to Greece, obviously.

Swipe left for the next trending thread