Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Totally agree with Sturgeon re the tories

364 replies

FayeGovan · 09/10/2022 22:21

I destest them and their policies too

Good on her for telling it like it is

I know shes hated on mn, or rather on scotsnet. They prefer the tories there, christ knows why. Independence is a dirty word on scotsnet. So i know I'll be shot down, but i couldn't care less.

Good on you Nicola👍

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 10/10/2022 23:11

FayeGovan · 10/10/2022 22:40

Nice measured response here.

And @Clavinova has appeared with their long winded cut and paste posts, intended to stifle any independence debate.

Always makes me wonder why if Scotland is held in so much contempt, Westminster wont let us go? We must have something they want to keep, eh?

In your dreams.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 10/10/2022 23:09

😬

durgha · 10/10/2022 23:08

Oof. "No means no you moron" , from Ilikehot waterbottles. I'm late to the cause, you blabbermouth. People like you have got me off my arse. I"ll gently talk with people who have concerns about Scotland's future. It's a considered debate to be had, not some half arsed shouting match on mumsnet.

FayeGovan · 10/10/2022 22:40

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 10/10/2022 22:05

I found it hilarious that she said that. She is exactly like the Tories! How do none of the idiots who support her see it?!

The independence thing is ridiculous, Scotland has voted twice now, both times it was a no. Yet she says she will never ever give up. So is that just basically keep asking us until she gets her yes? That sounds so wrong... Plus if she gets a yes, since we keep voting or pretending we will everytime it's no, can we do another vote to see if it's a no the 4th/5th/6th time? Has she never heard of democracy?! No means no you moron!

Nice measured response here.

And @Clavinova has appeared with their long winded cut and paste posts, intended to stifle any independence debate.

Always makes me wonder why if Scotland is held in so much contempt, Westminster wont let us go? We must have something they want to keep, eh?

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 10/10/2022 22:05

I found it hilarious that she said that. She is exactly like the Tories! How do none of the idiots who support her see it?!

The independence thing is ridiculous, Scotland has voted twice now, both times it was a no. Yet she says she will never ever give up. So is that just basically keep asking us until she gets her yes? That sounds so wrong... Plus if she gets a yes, since we keep voting or pretending we will everytime it's no, can we do another vote to see if it's a no the 4th/5th/6th time? Has she never heard of democracy?! No means no you moron!

Clavinova · 10/10/2022 21:45

*Foreword

Clavinova · 10/10/2022 21:33

beachcitygirl
Whilst so many on here are criticising Nicola Sturgeon she just gave the most magnificent speech. She quoted the vile cruelty of Suella Braverman who said it was her “dream” to see an asylum flight take off for Rwanda.
Sturgeon added: “My dream is that we live in a world where those fleeing violence and oppression are shown compassion and treated like human beings, not shown the door.”

Somewhat ironic then that Nicola Sturgeon has chosen Denmark as one of the key comparator countries for her independent Scotland.

She wrote the Foreward to the research and analysis paper, Independence in the modern world. Wealthier, happier, fairer: why not Scotland? The paper tells us that "Denmark's 'flexicurity' labour market has often been held up as a model for Scotland and others to seek to replicate..." Apparently, Denmark provides "generous out-of-work benefits" and a "unique Danish tradition where solutions to major societal challenges are found in close cooperation..."

22 September 2022
Denmark closer to sending asylum seekers to Rwanda

www.infomigrants.net/en/post/43238/denmark-closer-to-sending-asylum-seekers-to-rwanda

September 2021
Denmark: Government proposes 37-hour work week for migrant women to qualify for social benefits.

ec.europa.eu/migrant-integration/news/denmark-government-proposes-37-hour-work-week-migrant-women-qualify-social-benefits_en

January 2021
Denmark aims for zero asylum seekers

www.infomigrants.net/en/post/29842/denmark-aims-for-zero-asylum-seekers

March 2020
How Denmark's 'ghetto list' is ripping apart migrant communities.
Copenhagen and other cities are planning mass housing evictions in a ‘social experiment’ to encourage integration.

www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/11/how-denmarks-ghetto-list-is-ripping-apart-migrant-communities

Kellie45 · 10/10/2022 21:22

For the past two years, Sturgeon has been asked about post-independence monetary policy with no response. So let’s just be clear, there is no plan.
Sturgeon’s vision of a financially independent Scotland is nothing more than a mirage.
But, as she told the conference today, she doesn’t care as long as she stays in power.
That desire to stay in power with no credible plan for delivering independence is why all she can do is spread anti-Tory hate and hope Scots are happy to put aside what a terrible job the SNP have done of governing.
As The Spectator’s Editor Fraser Nelson wrote: “How many politicians say they actually 'detest' their rivals? Why invoke hatred as a motivating political force? And isn’t it hard to do so if you pose as an inclusive, warm, smiling party?”

Kellie45 · 10/10/2022 21:21

For the past two years, Sturgeon has been asked about post-independence monetary policy with no response. So let’s just be clear, there is no plan.
Sturgeon’s vision of a financially independent Scotland is nothing more than a mirage.
But, as she told the conference today, she doesn’t care as long as she stays in power.
That desire to stay in power with no credible plan for delivering independence is why all she can do is spread anti-Tory hate and hope Scots are happy to put aside what a terrible job the SNP have done of governing.
As The Spectator’s Editor Fraser Nelson wrote: “How many politicians say they actually 'detest' their rivals? Why invoke hatred as a motivating political force? And isn’t it hard to do so if you pose as an inclusive, warm, smiling party?”

littlbrowndog · 10/10/2022 21:03

When somebody tells you Joanna cherry is a head case you know exactly what sort of person you are dealing with

Alexandra2001 · 10/10/2022 20:41

@DownNative You re coming out with stuff that simply isn't true.

The PSNI said its analysis of the link between the IRA and Sinn Féin remains the same as that laid out in a joint assessment conducted with MI5 in 2015. In that report, a number of definitive statements were made about the IRA including that its structures remained “in a much reduced form”, that it is not actively recruiting and that its leadership is committed to achieving a united Ireland through peaceful means
Crucially, it stated it was the view of IRA members that the army council oversees both the IRA and Sinn Féin “with an overarching strategy”. This strategy has “a wholly political focus”, it added

RhannionKPSS · 10/10/2022 20:32

beachcitygirl · 10/10/2022 15:16

🤣🤣 joanna cherry is a head case. Literally the only snp MP I don't respect.

So you don’t respect a woman with integrity, intelligence & guts then?

You admit that you respect Bawbag Bully Boy Blackford then? A man who , with his cronies , bullied Charles Kennedy to his grave.
You respect Mhairi Black who took a drag queen into a primary school to read to the children, and has called her own constituents “ Jeremy Hunts “

Rather dubious people to respect, but you do you.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 20:28

LookingAtYou · 10/10/2022 20:23

'Again, how is she supposed to do that, when that's exactly what was suggested last year and Alister Jack dismissed it out of hand?'

'Consumer rooms' dismissed as no evidence to support any effectiveness whatsoever. That doesn't mean they do nothing and as usual blame their failures on Westminster.

Well if it all has to be evidence based, what are people suggesting the SNP do? Bear in mind that they can't do anything that involves amending Reserved Law in any way, shape or form, as that's clearly not an avenue that London is willing to engage on.

So if there are other ideas coming forth from the organisations at the coalface, then yes, the SG should absolutely be listening to them, working with them, and trying to enact them if there's a perceived benefit.

Kellie45 · 10/10/2022 20:26

Sturgeon indulges in the worst forms of tribalism and hatred. She is good at playing the hate card I’ll say that for her. She is also very good at blaming Westminster for her totally inadequate government of Scotland. I hope she does good independence and gets off our back. Scotland is welcome to her and her awful party of hate.

LookingAtYou · 10/10/2022 20:23

'Again, how is she supposed to do that, when that's exactly what was suggested last year and Alister Jack dismissed it out of hand?'

'Consumer rooms' dismissed as no evidence to support any effectiveness whatsoever. That doesn't mean they do nothing and as usual blame their failures on Westminster.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 10/10/2022 20:22

it’s never going to happen. Even Nicola Sturgeon knows that.

Nicola will be ordering a deep clean of her overseas properties as we type. No way will she hang around in Scotland for the humiliation of a defeat. Her work is done and she doesn’t want to leave on a negative, it’s not good optics for the onward highly-paid position (and bidding war for the selective-memory memoirs).

Reminds me of another U.K. politician who limped on to the end with utter disregard for the day job, instead prioritised her own reputation, but thankfully it kickstarted the demise of her party in power and enabled Labour to boot them all out come 97.

Ludo19 · 10/10/2022 20:21

It's strange because the SNP are referred to as the tartan tories in some quarters.
Sturgeon should hang her head in shame over the NHS, the ferries and her financial discrepancies. She has two super injunctions for the press to mention neither her sexuality or the parties financial dealings.
She would much rather go on pride marches and give junkies an extra £50 a week benefit if they have a dog.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 20:17

Adieufattummy · 10/10/2022 20:10

Keep telling yourself that it’s just around the corner, just one last push! Cherry pick the rare polls that suit you. I guess it’s hard to accept when the dream is over.

it’s never going to happen. Even Nicola Sturgeon knows that.

Have you not noticed the several posts where I quite contendedly highlight the fact that I'm perfectly comfortable with it perhaps not being 'just around the corner'?

Sorry to burst your bubble and all.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 20:16

LookingAtYou · 10/10/2022 20:12

'Two entirely different scenario that require tailored approaches, which is where the fundamental problem lies because anglocentric Westminster Govt point blank refuses to acknowledge this crucial fact.'

Well, maybe if Nicola stopped dishing out free school meals and sanitary protection to kids who's parents can more than afford if and started 'tailoring her approach' to the drug problem she might make some headway?

Again, how is she supposed to do that, when that's exactly what was suggested last year and Alister Jack dismissed it out of hand?

Ask Alister Jack why that is. It's not for want of trying on the part of NS, the SG, Local Councils, NHS Scotland, Police Scotland, or drugs and health charities.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 20:14

You sound happy at the prospect of ongoing division and debate, beyond Oct 23, instead of ‘getting the job done’ to coin a phrase?

Well that's just a bizarre takeaway. It's not about being 'happy', it's about being realistic and pragmatic. Oct 23 Ref isn't happening even if it were to be legally approved because there simply isn't time to agree the format, schedule it, so on and so forth, thanks to the legal squabbling delaying the initial timetable. NS could hardly make a significant announcement along the lines of "I want to do X on X date, but by the time all the extraneous bullshit is dealt with it will more than likely be Y date". That's just not how these things are done anywhere, hence the hard and fast Oct '23 and sticking by it.

I'd love it to happen tomorrow, but that isn't remotely realistic either. I'm 'happy' enough to wait as long as it takes quite frankly, because as much as every day spent stuck in this awful union is a drag, I'm not about to freak out if it isn't dispensed with by 2024, or 2026, or 2030 or whatever. It takes as long as it takes. Pragmatic advocates of Indi have known this for decades and are perfectly at ease with it. The 'GET IT DONE NOW OR ELSE' brigade are not realistic. I empathise with the desire, but it is and always has been a case of slowly, slowly catchy monkey.

LookingAtYou · 10/10/2022 20:12

'Two entirely different scenario that require tailored approaches, which is where the fundamental problem lies because anglocentric Westminster Govt point blank refuses to acknowledge this crucial fact.'

Well, maybe if Nicola stopped dishing out free school meals and sanitary protection to kids who's parents can more than afford if and started 'tailoring her approach' to the drug problem she might make some headway?

Adieufattummy · 10/10/2022 20:10

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 18:47

Thank God Scottish independence will remain a fantasy for people like this. It's not going to happen. They had their chance in 2014 and they blew it. Since then poll after poll has shown that they will lose a referendum. Nicola Sturgeon knows that better than anyone, she just throws her rabid supporters scraps from time to time to keep them on side

This is so delusional it warms my soul

26% in 2007

35% in 2010

45% in 2014

now regularly polling over and above 50%

If you genuinely can't see the writing on the wall...

Just a matter of time, especially so since the old, traditional, conservative unionist is dying off, and they aren't being replaced as the younger generations are remaining firmly left/centre and pro-indi even as they age.

Tick Tock, as they say.

Keep telling yourself that it’s just around the corner, just one last push! Cherry pick the rare polls that suit you. I guess it’s hard to accept when the dream is over.

it’s never going to happen. Even Nicola Sturgeon knows that.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 20:05

Scottishskifun · 10/10/2022 19:58

Let's not pretend that drugs room are a magic cure thats why its been knocked back.
The best cure is properly funded residential rehab programmes and support for people not fix rooms!
You can't blame Westminster for the appalling record when England have the same laws and much much lower stats!

The Scottish govt need to get on with what they are already in charge of!

Well just as well absolute nobody pretended it was a 'magical cure' then, isn't it?

It's rich to complain about 'nothing being done' when the very first small step towards tacking the issue is rejected out of hand by people it doesn't affect, and in direct denial of the consensus wish of the people it absolutely does affect.

You can't blame Westminster for the appalling record when England have the same laws and much much lower stats!

England and Scotland are two totally different beasts when it comes to Class A problems. Sociologically, historically, economically, and pragmatically. The two are in no way comparable. You'd be as well holding up the drug situation in Outer Mongolia as a comparator for all the relevance England's situation has to Scotland's. Two entirely different scenario that require tailored approaches, which is where the fundamental problem lies because anglocentric Westminster Govt point blank refuses to acknowledge this crucial fact.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 10/10/2022 20:02

Folk who seem to think Indi is just going to 'go away' need to give themselves a reality check. It isn't going anywhere, it's just a matter of when exactly, or if, the ostriches pull their heads out of the sand and engage with it rather than it washing over them while they pretend it isn't happening.

Eh? when=next October
if=Supreme Court approval (it’s taking them two months to make a decision on it apparently, ffs what a waste of public money)

You sound happy at the prospect of ongoing division and debate, beyond Oct 23, instead of ‘getting the job done’ to coin a phrase?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/10/2022 19:59

As for yes losing last time but it still being great - if Brexit had not won that would have been it. I feel sorry for the No voters who are now faced with their 2014 vote being overruled

I can somewhat empathise with the point about 2014 'No' voters, but the SG has been absolutely clear all along. They are not seeking another Ref just for shits and giggles as some unionists seem to believe. It was always spelled out quite plainly that the mandate for a 2nd Ref would stem from a 'significant material change' to the 2014 'No' settlement.

I mean you could logically take that and suggest that in actual fact 'No' voters should themselves be absolutely outraged. They were promised that continuation of the UK would guarantee EU membership, yet within 2 years that is effectively out the window. Everyone who participated in the 2014 Indi Ref has been sold a lie, it isn't dependent on which way you voted.

You can't bind future legislators by current actions, so there's no basis for the oft repeated 'we can't have a Ref, we had one in 2014'. We had a General Election in 1979. Why have we bothered having any since? 1979 was surely the 'settled will of the people'. Politics change, opinions change, options change. It's good fundamental democracy to consult people once there has been a shift as large as Brexit.