Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Totally agree with Sturgeon re the tories

364 replies

FayeGovan · 09/10/2022 22:21

I destest them and their policies too

Good on her for telling it like it is

I know shes hated on mn, or rather on scotsnet. They prefer the tories there, christ knows why. Independence is a dirty word on scotsnet. So i know I'll be shot down, but i couldn't care less.

Good on you Nicola👍

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 09:47

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 09:34

In the context of where we are now, yes it is irrelevant. Indyref2 was in the manifesto of the parties that now govern Scotland. This is how representative democracy works.

The no campaign's principle argument was that a "no" vote was the only way for Scotland to remain in the EU. How did that work out, hmm?

Well it technically was. You have no idea if the EU will let you in or not if Scotland applies as an independent country. There's other countries waiting on the list, and you will be starting from scratch on meeting their requirements, something others waiting are not. And there's certain countries not happy about letting Scotland join.

Staying with the UK was a more certain way of staying in the EU. But a referendum was then held as the rest of the UK wanted to, and as a democracy we voted to leave. That's how democracy works, it's the majority that win. As I say, we haven't done a best out of 3 for Brexit, is that the plan for independence? Or just keep wasting millions each time rather than spend the money on fixing problems?

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 09:44

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:04

'Why don't we just abolish elections if you believe that voting once or twice settles the matter?'

Well why did the nats keep wanging on about it being a 'once in a generation' vote if they really meant to keep on holding refs willy nilly until they got the result they wanted??

Except they didn't. It was a slogan.
"Dead in a ditch" anyone "Oven- ready" "education, education, education" from the man who made Iraq war his priority in gvmt

A slogan.

A stupid slogan used by firstly & primarily one person no longer in the party.

It was NEVER part of the Edinburgh agreement or white paper.

It had no official meaning.

But god it's convenient for anti-democracy types to drag out again & again.

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 09:34

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:25

'What may and may not has been said in the past is irrelevant.'

Well I can see it's inconvenient but it isn't irrelevant. If they lie about 'once in a lifetime only!' What else are they talking bollocks about hmm?

In the context of where we are now, yes it is irrelevant. Indyref2 was in the manifesto of the parties that now govern Scotland. This is how representative democracy works.

The no campaign's principle argument was that a "no" vote was the only way for Scotland to remain in the EU. How did that work out, hmm?

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 09:28

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:25

'What may and may not has been said in the past is irrelevant.'

Well I can see it's inconvenient but it isn't irrelevant. If they lie about 'once in a lifetime only!' What else are they talking bollocks about hmm?

A lot, like the money they keep 'losing'. Probably conveniently in their bank accounts.

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:25

'What may and may not has been said in the past is irrelevant.'

Well I can see it's inconvenient but it isn't irrelevant. If they lie about 'once in a lifetime only!' What else are they talking bollocks about hmm?

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 09:20

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:04

'Why don't we just abolish elections if you believe that voting once or twice settles the matter?'

Well why did the nats keep wanging on about it being a 'once in a generation' vote if they really meant to keep on holding refs willy nilly until they got the result they wanted??

The SNP stood on a manifesto that had indyref2 front and centre and they absolutely strolled the election. What may and may not has been said in the past is irrelevant.

Like it or not, they absolutely have a mandate to persue a second vote.

CapMarvel · 11/10/2022 09:17

balalake · 11/10/2022 07:15

I detest Tory policies. However, I would not have expressed this in the manner that Nicola Sturgeon did, were I in her shoes.

The SNP in general and their record in government in Scotland is poor, indeed I say it is the best argument against Scottish independence.

Well, it's not, given the point is independence from Westminster, not a perpetual SNP government.

It's highly likely that if Scotland were to become indy that the SNP's stranglehold over scottish politics would diminish, given that a large % of voters vote for them purely on this one issue.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 09:08

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:04

'Why don't we just abolish elections if you believe that voting once or twice settles the matter?'

Well why did the nats keep wanging on about it being a 'once in a generation' vote if they really meant to keep on holding refs willy nilly until they got the result they wanted??

This. You lot did keep banging on saying it's once in a lifetime. Suddenly changed to once every year it seems, or at least that's what she's threatened. She knows it will be a no again hence why it's not happened.

But can't expect SNP to stick to what they say. Last time it was oil this and oil that, we will get all our money from oil. Now the oil industry has been abandoned and it's all renewable energy now. Apparently we are a leading country, that's a fucking laugh. And we are told to take public transport to save the planet, then she cuts it in half above Perth. Great idea again.

If a referendum can keep happening again and again, then why can't we do the Brexit one again? And like I say, if it's yes next time, do we vote again to check? Best out of 3? Or 5? It all seems a bit childish to be honest, accept you lost like we had to for Brexit, get over it and stop running the country into the ground.

walkingonsunshinekat · 11/10/2022 09:04

How do all the the other EU non EU borders work?

They'd be normal passport control, customs, the existing FTA with the UK/EU would apply (or whatever replaces it) so we are left with whatever immigration controls both sides wish to have.

There isn't the historical political issues that there is with NI.

Its not the border, it would be the lack of financial institutions and a currency, that would take a long time to solve.

The Union is a grouping of free nations, if Scotland wishes to go it alone, its not for England to strong arm them into staying & denying a vote on the issue, i think Scotland, with all its natural resources, could be a real success and have as a pp said, charge UK for Trident to stay in Rosyth, England has no choice, no where else could go with huge expense/opposition which we don't have.

LookingAtYou · 11/10/2022 09:04

'Why don't we just abolish elections if you believe that voting once or twice settles the matter?'

Well why did the nats keep wanging on about it being a 'once in a generation' vote if they really meant to keep on holding refs willy nilly until they got the result they wanted??

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 08:50

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 10/10/2022 22:05

I found it hilarious that she said that. She is exactly like the Tories! How do none of the idiots who support her see it?!

The independence thing is ridiculous, Scotland has voted twice now, both times it was a no. Yet she says she will never ever give up. So is that just basically keep asking us until she gets her yes? That sounds so wrong... Plus if she gets a yes, since we keep voting or pretending we will everytime it's no, can we do another vote to see if it's a no the 4th/5th/6th time? Has she never heard of democracy?! No means no you moron!

Why don't we just abolish elections if you believe that voting once or twice settles the matter?

Don't be a silly Billy.

MarshaBradyo · 11/10/2022 08:49

walkingonsunshinekat · 11/10/2022 08:13

Why would the border be such a problem? the EU has a string of borders with non EU countries.
Plus its a non issue as any independent would be years away from joining the EU.

The Tories electoral success and hence Brexit, was built on a tidal wave of nationalism and we are repeatedly told by the Government there are zero issues with the border/exports/imports, indeed its sold as a distinct advantage for the UK (which around half of us believe) - surely we would want all these advantages to flow to Scotland too?

Ok how do you envisage get border working? What type of controls do you see put in place

People are sold a line as with Brexit but the dull questions are avoided at our cost - as we’ve found out

So how do you see it working

beachcitygirl · 11/10/2022 08:49

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/10/2022 23:17

I'd vote Tory any day of the week if it would oust the SNP and Sturgeon

Nationalism is far worse than the Tories.

What do you mean by nationalism and why do you associate it with the snp?

Nationalism in the sense you are suggesting is abhorrent. That has nothing to do with the strive for independence from a union that no longer works.

The name is Scottish National Party (not nationalist ) no matter how many times people deliberately say it wrongly.

A country running its own affairs is the norm.

A union where one part does not want to be in the union is abhorrent.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/10/2022 08:48

balalake · 11/10/2022 07:15

I detest Tory policies. However, I would not have expressed this in the manner that Nicola Sturgeon did, were I in her shoes.

The SNP in general and their record in government in Scotland is poor, indeed I say it is the best argument against Scottish independence.

Another good reason for not liking SNP. All that idiot has done is drag Scotland through the mud. If she actually decided to focus on Scotland for a change and fix the problems, she may actually get more votes. I would if she could prove she was competent, but she's about as competent as my cat. So it's a no from me and won't vote SNP at all.

She is pretending to now, with the mental health problems, but the plans are so vague and shit it won't work. She's made alcoholism worse with the price system. We pay more tax in Scotland than the English do, 21% instead of 20. NHS is shit, police budget just got cut again, schools are shit and falling down. And all she cares about is independence and ruining women's rights. Great women there..

walkingonsunshinekat · 11/10/2022 08:13

MarshaBradyo · 11/10/2022 07:07

Last pp make good points

Nationalism built on a combination of a promised utopia and hate is powerful but reminds me of that nationalism poem re appearing like a friend at first

It also is strong enough to make people wave away obvious issues around borders - which by now people should have learnt from Brexit don’t just disappear.

Why would the border be such a problem? the EU has a string of borders with non EU countries.
Plus its a non issue as any independent would be years away from joining the EU.

The Tories electoral success and hence Brexit, was built on a tidal wave of nationalism and we are repeatedly told by the Government there are zero issues with the border/exports/imports, indeed its sold as a distinct advantage for the UK (which around half of us believe) - surely we would want all these advantages to flow to Scotland too?

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 11/10/2022 07:57

it reminds me of the speeches made by miss world candidates back in the 80s. Anyone for a donkey sanctuary?

yes, this. Posturing for the media and those outside Scotland who really don’t understand the layers of failure by the SNP over 14y, they only see NS’s media sound bites. It’s always just words and no successful action. Unless of course, you count the baby box? As long as you’re not waiting on your baby box being delivered via a ferry

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/10/2022 07:43

The independence thing is ridiculous, Scotland has voted twice now, both times it was a no.

Firstly, the 1979 vote (which wasn’t an independence referendum but one on devolution) was actually won by the yes camp 52% to 48% (sounds familiar) but the outcome was rejected because a turn out in the mid 60s% meant that technically only 33% of the electorate voted yes, below the required 40% threshold
(I wonder why that condition was removed from recent referendums?).

The second devolution referendum in 1997 (precedent here for multiple referendums on the same issue) was also won by the yes camp, this time 74% to 36%, which was enough to get beyond the threshold.

The 2014 independence referendum was indeed a no, although in my opinion that result was swayed massively by outright lies told by the no camp but the result stands. So far it’s 2-1 in favour of the yes camp when it comes to referendums on Scotland’s governance.

Even the most ardent unionist cannot argue that there have been fundamental and material changes to the union since the last vote and so a second referendum on the matter is absolutely justified.

On a more general point, the SNPs record in power has nothing to do with the Scotlands ability to rule itself and be independent, nor would the SNP be guaranteed a seat in power in a independent Scotland. The people of Scotland could elect the Scottish Tories if the so chose but at least it would finally be our choice.

If you think we should be denied a vote on our own future because we voted no* once or because you don’t like the way the SNP rule I hope you are also campaigning to abolish future general elections and referendums too? After all England voted for the Tories so why should you get another chance to change it?

balalake · 11/10/2022 07:15

I detest Tory policies. However, I would not have expressed this in the manner that Nicola Sturgeon did, were I in her shoes.

The SNP in general and their record in government in Scotland is poor, indeed I say it is the best argument against Scottish independence.

MarshaBradyo · 11/10/2022 07:07

Last pp make good points

Nationalism built on a combination of a promised utopia and hate is powerful but reminds me of that nationalism poem re appearing like a friend at first

It also is strong enough to make people wave away obvious issues around borders - which by now people should have learnt from Brexit don’t just disappear.

TightDiamondShoes · 11/10/2022 07:06

That’s so sweet that our FM wants to end war and violence and offer shelter for anyone living in fear.

it reminds me of the speeches made by miss world candidates back in the 80s. Anyone for a donkey sanctuary?

very few on this planet surely are grinning whilst chanting “more violence, more, more?” - but it doesn’t take a genius to understand that we cannot give shelter to every single person worldwide dealing with a sticky wicket. The population of Rwanda alone is 13 million. That’s before we deal with Eritrea (small pop). How about Mauritania with approximately 5 million living as slaves?

well that’s 3 countries handled and an increase in population of 10+ million.

ideology has to stand up to realism and literally be counted.

anyway, can we still vote for Ruth Davidson? What a woman!

Fieldsofhay · 11/10/2022 01:29

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/10/2022 23:17

I'd vote Tory any day of the week if it would oust the SNP and Sturgeon

Nationalism is far worse than the Tories.

Agree. My ONLY consideration when voting is who keeps the SNP out. It would be nice to be able to take other policies into consideration but nationalism is so vile we have to do all we can to stop it.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/10/2022 23:21

Also think it's a pretty awful state of affairs when the First Minister announces she despises 20-25% of the nation's citizens.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/10/2022 23:17

I'd vote Tory any day of the week if it would oust the SNP and Sturgeon

Nationalism is far worse than the Tories.

LetMeSpeak · 10/10/2022 23:15

She didn’t go far enough my opinion. I’m not going to say my thoughts on the tories in fear of getting banned. To put it extremely mildly they are a disgrace.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 10/10/2022 23:13

Kellie45 · 10/10/2022 21:21

For the past two years, Sturgeon has been asked about post-independence monetary policy with no response. So let’s just be clear, there is no plan.
Sturgeon’s vision of a financially independent Scotland is nothing more than a mirage.
But, as she told the conference today, she doesn’t care as long as she stays in power.
That desire to stay in power with no credible plan for delivering independence is why all she can do is spread anti-Tory hate and hope Scots are happy to put aside what a terrible job the SNP have done of governing.
As The Spectator’s Editor Fraser Nelson wrote: “How many politicians say they actually 'detest' their rivals? Why invoke hatred as a motivating political force? And isn’t it hard to do so if you pose as an inclusive, warm, smiling party?”

She's like a dog with a bone when it comes to whining about 'Scottish Independence!' How embarrassing. To think SHE is the face of Scotland. '😂